To ask the Scottish Government what representations it has made to the United Kingdom Government about equalising the minimum wage regardless of age, given the impact on youth employment. (S4O-03427)
Official Report · Chamber
Minimum Wage
Portfolio Question Time Training, Youth and Women’s Employment
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Angela Constance SNP 5
- Elaine Smith Lab 5
- John Finnie Ind 2
- Neil Findlay Lab 2
The record
14 contributions
The Scottish Government believes that work should be fairly rewarded. With independence we would ensure that the minimum wage would rise by at least inflation and establish a fair work commission, which, along with assessing the minimum wage, would be asked to consider the appropriate minimum wage for young people and apprentices.
The Low Pay Commission’s call for evidence for the 2015 minimum wage rate asks specifically for information on the minimum wage for young people, and the Scottish Government welcomes views on that issue, prior to submitting our response.
In response to the call for evidence in 2014, the Minister for Energy, Enterprise and Tourism raised the importance of the national minimum wage for apprentices and called for it to be continuously assessed to ensure that it keeps pace with the rising costs that are faced by our young workforce.
I call Neil Findlay. Briefly, please.
Why does the minister not support using the powers—
I am sorry; I meant to call Mr Finnie.
I thank the minister for her response, although it sounded as though she was saying that we have made no representations. I encourage her to make representations.
In 1998, the UK Government made the national minimum wage law in order to ensure that employees in the UK are provided with
“decent minimum standards and fairness in the workplace”.
Any discrimination, including age discrimination, is unwelcome and I would encourage the minister to make those representations and to make a commitment to eradicating such discrimination in an independent Scotland.
I encourage Mr Finnie to read the Official Report of today’s session.
In principle, people who are doing the same job should get the same rate of pay. That is an important principle. I believe that, in an independent Scotland, Mr Finnie and I will be on the same side and the fair work commission will have an important role. I am on record as supporting the Scottish Youth Parliament’s one fair wage campaign.
Although I recognise that employers expect to pay people who are in training a different rate from those employees who are time served or fully qualified, we have a lot to learn from the European experience. In some European countries those differentials are not too great, while in others they are quite stark. I believe firmly that people should get the same rate of pay for the same job.
And now, briefly, Neil Findlay.
Why does the minister not use the powers that she has at the moment and support, for example, the increase to the living wage, especially through the procurement process? She has the powers, so why is she not doing that?
As Mr Findlay well knows, this Government, unlike the previous Labour Scottish Executive, has led by example on the living wage and done everything—[Interruption.]
Order, please.
—everything within its power—[Interruption.]
Order.
—within the current European Union rules.
I had hoped that Mr Findlay would have the grace to acknowledge that statutory guidance addressing issues such as terms and conditions and pay is a very important step forward. However, I, of course, want to make a bigger step forward and have a fair work commission because the big scandal is that, since 2008, the national minimum wage has not kept pace with the cost of living. That happened under Mr Findlay’s watch, not the watch of this Government. I believe firmly that this Parliament should have the economic powers to address issues such as low pay and in-work poverty.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 6 Aug 2014 →- Training, Youth and Women’s Employment Questions · 1
- Employment Tribunal Fees (Youth and Women’s Employment) Questions · 6
- Health Visitors (Training) Questions · 6
- Training Women Aged Over 25 (Skills Development Scotland) Questions · 4
- Women’s Unemployment Questions · 6
- Women’s Employment Questions · 12
- Youth Employment Scotland Scheme Questions · 6
- Minimum Wage Questions · 14
- Commonwealth Games Legacy Questions · 4
- Commonwealth Games Legacy Questions · 5
- Commonwealth Games Legacy (Remote Areas) Questions · 11
- Commonwealth Games 2018 Questions · 4
- State Pensions (Independence) Questions · 7
- State Pension Age Questions · 4
- UK Sport Funding (Independence) Questions · 7
- Pride House Legacy Questions · 4
- Trident Debate · 136
- Business Motion Business motions · 1
- Decision Time Decision time · 9
- Persecuted Christians Members’ business · 11
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.