Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 12 December 2013 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 14 contributions · 3 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

14 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link


1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01754)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Engagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
In 2007, the Scottish National Party pledged to ensure that children in primaries 1 to 3 would be in classes of 18 pupils or fewer. When he was asked in 2007 whether he could guarantee that that would be achieved in one parliamentary session, the First Minister told the chamber, “Yes, I can.”

Nearly seven years on, is the First Minister closer to or further away from reaching that goal than he was when he took office?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I remind Johann Lamont that this Government was re-elected in 2011. As she probably knows, there has been not just a financial crisis, which the Labour Party had a substantial hand in, but—pertinently—a reduction of more than £3 billion in the Scottish revenue budget. That has meant that public authorities have had to deal with that position. Although local authorities have been sheltered from that reduction by central Government, they face extreme financial pressure nonetheless.

In order to protect pupil teacher ratios—as Johann Lamont is well aware—in 2010 we negotiated with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities an agreement that that ratio should go to no more than 13.5 pupils per teacher. That has been held to by COSLA. We would like to see substantial improvements in pupil teacher ratios, but I think that we should recognise—in fairness to local authorities the length and breadth of Scotland—that the agreement that was reached in 2010 has been upheld in difficult financial circumstances.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
So, in summary, “It wisnae me.” Talk about being in government and doing what you are supposed to do. Pupil teacher ratios are now worse than they were when Labour was in power, so even that defence does not help the First Minister.

The answer is of course that, seven years on, the number and proportion of classes of 18 pupils or fewer have gone down not up. Pupils in primaries 1 to 3 are now less likely to be in classes of 18 or fewer than they were when Alex Salmond became First Minister. I thought that Scotland was on pause; now we find that it is on rewind.

The number of primary school pupils on the school roll has gone up since 2007. That would suggest that—just to keep pace, let alone meet his own targets—for the First Minister to be serious about his pledges the number of primary school teachers ought to have increased, so can he tell us how many more primary school teachers have been hired since he came to office?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I correct Johann Lamont. This Government came to power in 2007, so let us compare the situation with the one that existed when Labour was in power in 2006. The number of pupils in primaries 1 to 3 in classes of 18 or fewer is better than the 2006 figure. Johann Lamont should at least accept that the Labour Party was in power in 2006 and that the SNP was in power in 2007. That is rather pertinent, because one of the first acts of the SNP Government when it came into power—I remember Fiona Hyslop making the announcement—was to increase the teacher training numbers by 300.

Let us look at the figures in detail across primary schools. In 2006, the average class size in primary 1 was 23.1; it is now 21.2. In primaries 1 to 3, it was 23.6; it is now 23.2. I accept and agree that those are not the improvements that we would have looked for if we had had different financial circumstances over the past few years, but given that I have given Johann Lamont the figures, she ought to accept that there have been improvements in those primary categorisations since 2006. I think that we can reach agreement on the fact that, in 2006, Johann Lamont was a minister in a Labour Government and that, in 2007, I was the First Minister in an SNP Government.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
Our figures in primary school education were better before the First Minister came to power than they are now.

What the First Minister said sounds like one of those answers that prove that the world is not round in order to get him through the next half hour. At some point, he needs to come back to the real world, where parents, teachers and children are. The reality is that he does not appear to have believed even in his own education policy; it was simply grist to the mill to change people’s votes and not to change the lives of our children and their educational opportunities.

The number that I referred to is down, too. We have almost 1,000 fewer primary school teachers now than we had when the First Minister came to office. This is a First Minister whose promises on education are bogus, and the only things that are more bogus than his pledges are his attempts to keep them.

The First Minister put class sizes at the heart of his education policy. In recent years, secondary school rolls have reduced, which should make it easier to have smaller class sizes. Has the number of teachers fallen faster or more slowly than the rate at which the number of pupils that they have to teach has dropped?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
The agreement with COSLA in 2010 has been adhered to. The figure was 13.5 in 2011, 13.5 in 2012 and 13.5 in 2013.

Perhaps Johann Lamont and I can agree on the comparison of primaries 1 to 3 between 2006 and now. The figure was 23.6 in 2006 and it is now 23.2. Over primary as a whole, the figure was 23.2 in 2006 and it is still 23.2. I accept that that is not the improvement that we were looking for, but it is simply incorrect of her to say that the position has worsened since the Labour Party was in power in 2006. Perhaps she could acknowledge that.

I was struck that Larry Flanagan, the Educational Institute of Scotland’s general secretary, said on “Newsnight Scotland” last night that one local authority is responsible for the drop in teacher numbers. I thought that that could not possibly be true—how could one local authority in the whole country be responsible for the drop of 175 in teacher numbers?—so I checked the figures, and I found that a single local authority had a decline of 181 teachers between 2012 and 2013. In that sense, it is—as Larry Flanagan said—responsible for the entire Scottish reduction of 175.

Which is that single local authority? It is Glasgow City Council. Perhaps Johann Lamont should not come along here to challenge the SNP Government on teacher numbers; why does she not take a trip to Glasgow city chambers and speak to her colleagues?

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
I hope that the First Minister was watching “Newsnight Scotland” last night, because his education secretary made the astonishing defence that up was down, that good was bad and that better was worse. The education secretary lives in a fantasy world; I suggest that the First Minister should stop listening to his education secretary and look at what is happening on the ground.

If the First Minister wants to look at what councils are doing, let us look at Dundee City Council—the last time that I looked, it was an SNP administration. In its area, the number of pupils in primaries 1 to 3 who are in classes of fewer than 18 has gone down in one year by two thirds. That tells us that the problem is not for individual councils but for his Government.

Instead of getting civil servants to find some bizarre defence from the figures, it is about time that the First Minister got his Government to confront what is happening in the real world to real families. There are now almost 3,000 fewer secondary school teachers than there were when he came to office and almost 4,000 fewer teachers overall. Class sizes are going up, not down.

There is a pattern here, which we have seen in great form today. The First Minister makes a pledge based not on its merits but on how good a soundbite it is. He then hands the onus to someone else—usually councils. He starves them of cash and blames them when they fail to meet the bogus pledge that he tried to con the public with in the first place. That is cynicism on stilts, and it is not worthy of this Parliament at all.

Here is the question—[Interruption.]

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
The children are obviously not away to their pantomime today. [Interruption.]

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
If we cannot trust the First Minister on his key pledge in his 2007 manifesto, and if somehow Scotland does vote yes next year, who will he blame when we find out that his white paper is not worth the mouse pad that it was googled on?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Johann Lamont should look behind her for that particular punchline, which was pretty bad.

Johann Lamont referred to being starved of cash. Yes, of course—there has been a starvation of cash as a result of Westminster austerity bearing down on the Scottish people. She suggested that it is local authorities that are being starved of cash. Unfortunately for her, during 2006-07, when she was a minister, local government’s share of Scottish Government expenditure plus non-domestic rates income was 34.7 per cent, whereas it is now 36.8 per cent. Of course there is a squeeze on spending, but local government is doing better than general public expenditure.

Yes, there has been a starvation of cash—that has been the case under Johann Lamont’s Government and the Government with which she is now aligned in the bitter together campaign in terms of what has been allowed for the Scottish people.

Johann Lamont mentioned Dundee City Council, which actually has the second-best teacher ratio in Scotland. That is not the situation that we find in Glasgow, which has now moved above the agreed ratio of teachers to pupils that was decided with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities. She says that that is a complex point, but it is not complex at all.

There has been a decline—which I regret—of 175 in overall teacher numbers in the year to September 2013, but there has been a decline of 181 in the city of Glasgow. That means that, as Larry Flanagan indicated last night, the city of Glasgow is responsible—it is a single local authority, but a big one—for that whole decline that we have seen in Scotland over the past year. I think that Johann Lamont should go along and speak to her colleagues on Glasgow City Council. It would be refreshing, given that they employ teachers in Scotland, if she would do so and accept her party’s burden of responsibility in these matters.

We have had success with the legislation that members may remember was brought in to stop class sizes in primary 1 containing more than 25 pupils. In 2006 there were 16,845 primary 1 pupils in classes of more than 25. The figure is now 580, which I think would, in anybody’s terms, be seen as a reasonable improvement. That is a joint success for the Government and for the local authorities that have responded to the legislation.

Let us talk for a moment about the success of pupils and teachers in Scottish schools. We have had record examination results, which is a substantial achievement by teachers and pupils. We have record numbers of school leavers in positive destinations in Scotland—the figure is 89.5 per cent, which is a substantial achievement by teachers and the education system in Scotland.

We now know, from the programme for international student assessment—or PISA—survey, that the attainment gap in maths, reading and science between the most disadvantaged and the most advantaged areas of this country has closed and narrowed for the first time. Again, there is far more distance to travel, but that is nonetheless a substantial achievement.

Instead of taking the view that Glasgow is not responsible for its own decline in teacher numbers—despite the fact that it is responsible for the entire decline in Scotland this year—and even though Johann Lamont refuses to go along to the city chambers, can we at least agree that, in these difficult economic circumstances, the teachers and pupils of Scotland have turned in a substantial and first-class performance?

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Business Motions Business motions · 2
  2. Women Prisoners (Mental Health Services) Questions · 4
  3. Prison Visiting Arrangements Questions · 4
  4. Right of Access Obstructions (Records) Questions · 7
  5. Programme for International Student Assessments (Science Scores) Questions · 4
  6. Housing Land Supply (Local Authorities) Questions · 4
  7. Small Rural Communities (Marketing Support) Questions · 5
  8. Community Councils (Participation) Questions · 5
  9. Digital Connectivity (Cities) Questions · 4
  10. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 14
  11. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 23
  12. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  13. Autumn Statement (Implications) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  14. Junior Doctors’ Hours First Minister’s Questions · 5
  15. Independence (Food Bills) First Minister’s Questions · 12
  16. Payday Loan Industry (Regulation) Members’ business · 28
  17. Victims and Witnesses (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 141
  18. Victims and Witnesses (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 21
  19. Decision Time Decision time · 2

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.