The Subordinate Legislation Committee has considered the instrument and copies of that committee's comments have been circulated to members. As with the previous statutory instruments, I intend that members should ask for any clarification or raise any points directly with the minister before we move into the formal debate. I invite the minister to introduce his officials and to make any opening remarks before we move on to questions.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Fishing Vessels (Satellite-tracking Devices) (Scotland) Scheme 2004 (SSI 2004/379)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Ross Finnie LD 6
- Sarah Boyack Lab 5
- Mark Ruskell Green 3
- Richard Lochhead SNP 2
- Ewen Milligan Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department 1
- Alasdair Morrison Lab 1
The record
23 contributionsI am joined by Ewen Milligan from the fisheries division.As members will be aware, the monitoring of fishing vessels' position using satellite technology has become an increasingly important aspect of fisheries management control. It was first introduced in 2000 for vessels of more than 24 metres and it is now to be phased in for all vessels of 15 metres or more in length.Satellite monitoring underpins the control arrangements in many of our fisheries, including those in which geographic separation is important, for example the pelagic fisheries, and the cod and haddock fisheries in the North sea to which spatial management applies. However, experience of operating control systems here and elsewhere in the European Union has shown that they can be vulnerable to deliberate interference or manipulation. Consequently, under a revised European regulation that was introduced in December 2003, vessels must have a terminal fitted that does not permit the input of false positions and is not capable of being overridden. As the new tamper-resistant terminals will have no function other than fisheries control, we felt that it was appropriate to provide 100 per cent grant funding for them. Grants will be available to cover the purchase and installation costs of terminals that are sourced from an authorised provider and will also cover the cost of a three-year warranty on the satellite equipment that is provided. The statutory instrument gives Scottish ministers the powers to implement the scheme, which is fairly straightforward and broadly similar in content to other fisheries-related grant schemes that the committee has seen in the past.
I have no objection to the scheme as such and I welcome the 100 per cent grant, but I have concerns about the process that officials will follow if they decide that the scheme might have been breached and decide to try to recover the funds from the boat owner. The instrument says that the appeal process is limited to "making written representations". Is there a general trend in the Executive towards imposing administrative penalties on fishermen who breach regulations? I understand that there is a lot of concern about that.
We have not taken a general policy decision on that. There are some pressures from the European Union in that regard, but we monitor the situation, because there are limits on the application of administrative penalties. As you are aware, one of the great difficulties with breaches of the law in fisheries regulation is that they take place at sea and it is often difficult, if not impossible, to obtain the corroborating evidence that is required as a test in Scots law. I regard that test as important, so I am slightly reluctant to move towards more management operations. We must bear in mind the relative costs and the severity of the penalty that might be applied, but we have come to no firm decision on the matter and must keep it under review.
I might pursue that later.
link
I seek clarification from the minister. When the Subordinate Legislation Committee considered the instrument, it seemed to uncover some circularity in how it will operate, which is reflected in another Scottish statutory instrument on fishing. My understanding is that the instrument gives officials powers to enter premises or vessels to find out information about how other officials have not been allowed to gain access to vessels or premises. How has the minister addressed that circularity? It is an outstanding issue to which we have been asked to give some attention.
I ask Ewen Milligan to address the technical aspect of the question.
The powers in the instrument—such as the power to enter into premises where documents that are relevant to the application might be held—are a fairly standard set of powers that would be found in any instrument that deals with fisheries matters. We do not accept that there is any circularity in those powers.The Subordinate Legislation Committee's 33rd report states:"Paragraph 9 obliges any applicant, or any employee or agent of any applicant, to give to an authorised officer such assistance as that officer may reasonably request in order for that officer to exercise the powers conferred by paragraph 10 … Accordingly, should there be reason to suspect that an applicant failed to comply with a reasonable request from an officer for such assistance",the officer may"exercise any of the powers under paragraph 10 to ascertain whether … the applicant failed to comply with the obligation imposed by paragraph 9."It is not the person who is assisting the officer who is exercising the powers, but the officer who is empowered by the instrument. Anyone acting to assist the officer under the scheme's enabling provisions is not directly empowered by the instrument; it is the supervising officer who would invoke and carry out the powers available under the instrument.
Is that helpful?
link
Yes, that is helpful. It will be useful to see how the instrument works in practice. If it does not work, it will have to be reviewed.
If we drift to the person assisting, that does give rise to an interpretation of circularity. As Ewen Milligan has explained, it is the principal officer who is empowered, so the problem that you envisage would not arise in those circumstances.
link
That is clear. Thank you.
I welcome the instrument, which I am sure every reasonable individual will support. I have three short questions on how the industry and fishermen will benefit. First, are there safety benefits for the crews of fishing boats? Secondly, what are the benefits for stock management? Thirdly, over a period of years, will the instrument help to give us a clearer picture of the process of determining the state of stocks and where exactly they are to be found?
There are no safety benefits as such. It is a sad fact that any regulatory procedure is brought about by a minority, not by the majority. Originally, we wanted to proceed with combined satellite instruments, with both a navigational use and a tracing use. Sadly, because their use was manipulated, not just in Scotland but elsewhere in the EU, a minority brought about the revised regulation, which then required us to have tamper-proof instruments for satellite monitoring purposes only. The regulation is intended entirely for the benefit of stock management, to ensure that persons are not wrongfully and unbeknown in an area for which they do not have the appropriate licence or permit and are not carrying out fishing activities illegally outwith their own regulatory provisions.In the sense that we are—Interruption.
I am sorry, minister. Could somebody please switch off that mobile phone? Thank you. Please continue, minister.
In so far as we will know more about other landings, and in so far as information about where vessels have been fishing is entirely accurate, I suppose that we will be helped in building up data on stocks. However, I regret to say that the essential feature of the instrument is that it will provide a more accurate way of pinpointing that persons who are in the required areas at the required times are carrying the required permits to fish. That is another reason why we felt obliged to assist with the cost; that is the approach that we are taking.
If there are no other questions or points of clarification, we move to the formal debate on the motion.
Motion moved,
That the Environment and Rural Development Committee recommends that the Fishing Vessels (Satellite-tracking Devices) (Scotland) Scheme 2004 (SSI 2004/379) be approved.—Ross Finnie.
Motion agreed to.
We shall report to Parliament on the three statutory instruments.
Meeting suspended.
On resuming—
In this meeting
Everything on 5 Oct 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Environment and Rural Development Committee Tuesday 5 October 2004 Committee business · 1
- Interests Procedure · 3
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 9
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 9
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 23
- Petitions Petitions · 8
- Water Services (Executive Consultations) Evidence session · 81
- Water Services etc (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 114
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 3
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.