Thank you, convener. As I have been asked to be brief, I will be very brief indeed.I hope that I have set out ALACHO’s position very succinctly in our one-and-a-half page submission. As has been said, many people in the room are well aware of the damaging impact of the underoccupation penalty or bedroom tax. ALACHO is no exception; our members are housing officers and senior housing officers who work in councils and see and experience the policy’s damaging impact every day. We are working very hard to mitigate the policy’s impact and at various points have been involved with CIH and others in campaigns to stop the legislation. Clearly those campaigns have not been successful to date, but we will continue to take part in them.We understand the democratic imperative that councils make rent arrears policy; indeed, we think that they are best placed to undertake that work. We also understand why elected members would wish to comfort tenants who might be affected by this policy by telling them that they will not be evicted for bedroom tax arrears alone if they choose to engage with the authority, and we have acknowledged and support all of that.However, we feel it incumbent on us as a professional body to point out that should the committee be minded to approve the petition there would be challenges in implementing its terms. Although it appears to be straightforward, ALACHO members have told us that the proposal could be quite complex and unwieldy to implement and that money would have to be spent to change information systems relating to the allocation of resources to make a clear separation between bedroom tax arrears and other rent arrears.The proposal could also be unfair. We have heard of other groups such as single people in the private sector who are suffering from welfare reforms and one might ask why there is no similar legislation for or consideration of those groups. Some of our members and indeed some tenants to whom we have spoken also felt the proposal to be a bit unfair in that it might penalise those who, despite financial hardship, try to pay their rent, including the underoccupation penalty.11:00
Most important, the proposal might very well be risky and send out the wrong signals to tenants, ultimately encouraging a culture of non-payment of rent that could go beyond simple non-payment of the bedroom tax and lead to general non-payment of rent. That would concern us, given the good progress that has been made in ensuring that rent gets paid and revenues hold up.In a nutshell, whatever the committee decides and if the proposal is enacted as legislation, we will of course get on with delivering it. However, we think that the best way of addressing the situation is to ensure that tenants receive all the support that we can give, that they maximise their incomes through whatever source and that they get employment advice and information where appropriate, alternative accommodation if possible and funding through, for example, discretionary housing payments, if that, too, is possible.I have taken slightly longer than a minute, convener, but I hope that you will forgive me.