Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 16 January 2014 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 16 contributions · 3 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

16 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link


1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01815)

You know that we always aim to please, Presiding Officer.

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Engagements to carry forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
Both the First Minister and John Swinney have said that Scotland pays 9.9 per cent of tax revenues into the United Kingdom and receives back only 9.3 per cent of public spending. That suggests that Scotland pays in more to the UK than we get out. Could the First Minister tell me how much money is 9.9 per cent of tax revenues and how much money is 9.3 per cent of spending?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
The surplus of revenue over spending in that year was, from memory, £4 billion. That contributes to a surplus over the past five years—a relative surplus, compared with Scotland in the UK—of some £8 billion. That is, of course, the point of doing the statistics. The unionist parties—Labour, Tory et cetera—have always wanted to say that Scotland has higher public spending. Of course, that is true, and for very good reasons. However, Scotland also contributes more in terms of revenue. That is why we take the 9.9 per cent of revenue, compared to the 9.3 per cent of spending, because it shows that Scotland is in a stronger fiscal position than the rest of the United Kingdom.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
That is a classic First Minister answer: “If you don’t like the figures I give you, I have another set prepared from earlier on.”

The First Minister did not answer the question that I asked him about the way in which he misrepresents those figures. According to the figures in his own “Government Expenditure and Revenue in Scotland” report, 9.9 per cent of revenue comes to £56.9 billion, and 9.3 per cent of spending amounts to £64.5 billion. So, actually, Scotland gets £7.6 billion more out of the United Kingdom than we put in.

Is it not the case that, if the Scottish Government’s own figures show that we get more money out of the United Kingdom than we put into it, it is deeply misleading to try to give the opposite impression?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Due to a range of things, including the economic crisis, the vast majority of countries in the world have been running deficits over the past few years. There have been some exceptions, of course—Norway, across the North Sea, would be a grand example.

We have the exact figures of deficit between Scotland and the UK. In 2008-09, the Scottish deficit was 2.6 per cent, and the UK deficit was 6.9 per cent. In 2009-10—the very height of the economic crisis—the Scottish deficit was 10.7 per cent and the UK deficit was 11.2 per cent. In 2010-11, when the deficit was coming down, the Scottish deficit was 8.1 per cent and the UK deficit was 9.5 per cent. The last figures that are available show a deficit of 5 per cent in Scotland, compared with one of 7.9 per cent in the UK. For each of the past four years, the Scottish deficit is lower than the UK deficit. That is why we are in a stronger fiscal position. Of course, we do not get the benefit of that, because the money is sucked into the maw of the London Treasury.

I welcome this line of questioning, because we can use those figures to show what the difference is—that is, we can say what money would have been available in each of those years. It would have been £6 billion in 2008-09; £667 million in 2009-10; £1.993 billion in 2010-11; and £4.376 billion in the past year. That comes to a total of more than £12 billion. To put that in terms that I know Johann Lamont will appreciate, that is £2,397 for every man, woman and child in Scotland. That is how much we would have been relatively better off if Scotland had been running its own finances.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
In all of that, the First Minister did not respond to the question that I asked about how his own figures show that we get more out than we put in.

The First Minister should recall that the finance secretary, in a private paper to the Cabinet, confirmed that Scotland will have a larger deficit than the rest of the United Kingdom by 2016. Of course, that paper was for private consumption, not for the rest of us. If the First Minister could put down for a moment his statistical tommy gun and cease randomly spraying out figures in answer to questions that he was not asked, we might get somewhere.

I have asked the First Minister about two specific figures: what Scotland pays into the United Kingdom and what the United Kingdom pays out to Scotland. Can he confirm that Scotland puts £56.9 billion into the UK in tax, as is stated on page 598 of his own white paper? Can he also confirm that we get £64.5 billion back, as per page 68? Those are his own figures. Can he confirm that his own figures are correct and show that Scotland gets more back from the United Kingdom than we put in? [Interruption.]

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I am glad that Johann Lamont has cited the white paper. On pages 72 to 76, it shows—if I can correct her—that Scotland’s fiscal position in 2016-17, the first year of independence, will be stronger than that of the United Kingdom. As I have tried to explain, in each of the past four years Scotland has run a deficit much lower than the deficit that is being run by the United Kingdom as a whole. That means that we are in a stronger fiscal position. Our finances have been stronger over the past four years, but we did not get the benefit of that because we are run from London.

In terms of borrowing, among the many remarkable statistics are the fact that the better together campaign head Alistair Darling and George Osborne—that combination is quite normal—have between them borrowed more than every other UK chancellor in history and the fact that UK borrowing has more than doubled in the periods of office of Darling and Osborne. That is the extent of UK borrowing. We would have been £12 billion better off, relatively. I am not saying that we could have spent all that money, although some of it would have been very useful expenditure on the capital infrastructure of Scotland, but it would have been sensible to borrow less than the UK has done over the past four years. There could have been a combination of borrowing less and spending more, using our better position to power Scotland forward.

We have had a smaller deficit than the UK over the past four years—that is beyond doubt. Can Johann Lamont not see that that would have translated to our being in a stronger fiscal position? That would have meant that we would have been able to use Scotland’s massive resources to benefit the people and the economy of this country.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
It is interesting that the First Minister has now denied what John Swinney said in his private paper, which is that we would have a greater deficit by 2016. I do not think that any of us should take lectures in economics from a First Minister—even a former Royal Bank of Scotland economist—who said in the chamber on 28 November:

“We get 9.3 per cent of the spending, but we raise 9.9 per cent of the revenue; 9.9 per cent is greater than 9.3 per cent.”—[Official Report, 28 November 2013; c 25054.]

Even a primary school child could tell us that that depends on the big figures that those are percentages of—it is not credible.

Since the First Minister embarked on his referendum campaign, he has been making promises that he claims that he will deliver if Scotland votes yes. However, his own figures show that there would be even less money to spend if Scotland voted to go independent. In the real world, where we look at the figures, where we talk in private as we do in public, that is a fact. Is it not the truth that not only will the First Minister be unable to make good on those promises, he will not even be able to deliver on what we have right now?

Tricia Marwick The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
First Minister? [Interruption.] Order. First Minister.

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
When Johann Lamont started this line of questioning I thought that she really understood it but was trying to make some political points. Now I am beginning to think that she actually does not understand the point that 9.9 per cent, as every schoolchild and perhaps every former English teacher should know, is greater than 9.3 per cent and if we have 9.9 per cent of the revenue—[Interruption.]

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I say to Alex Johnstone that 9.9 is greater than 9.3. If we have 9.9 per cent of the revenue and 9.3 per cent of spending we are better off. If it was the other way around, we would be worse off but luckily for Scotland, we have generated 9.9 per cent of the revenue for 9.3 per cent of spending. That means that either we would have been running a smaller fiscal deficit than the rest of the United Kingdom or we would have been in a stronger fiscal position. [Interruption.]

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Being in a stronger fiscal position than London is perhaps not much—just about every other country in the world is in a stronger fiscal position—but it indicates how we could have mobilised the natural resources of Scotland to maintain spending as well as borrowing less over these critical years.

We cannot do anything about the figures of the past four years—that money is gone. However, we can learn a lesson for the future because in every single one of those years—when we were in a better position than that of the United Kingdom and therefore would have had the freedom to invest in our economy or to borrow less or a combination of both—the Tory and Labour parties were never fonder of telling people in Scotland how poor we are. The figures demonstrate that we are relatively better off—we are in a stronger position. That is true of the past four years and it will be true in the future. Is it not high time that we mobilised those resources to benefit the people of Scotland?

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. NHS Dumfries and Galloway (Governance) Questions · 4
  2. Low-vision Aids Questions · 6
  3. Sex Offenders (Management) Questions · 6
  4. Scottish Fire and Rescue Service Board (Discussions) Questions · 6
  5. Cities Strategy (Support for Local Traders) Questions · 6
  6. A9 (Dualling) Questions · 4
  7. Chief Constable (Meetings) Questions · 4
  8. East Ayrshire Communities (Support) Questions · 4
  9. National 4 and 5 Exams (Support for Teachers) Questions · 7
  10. First Minister’s Question Time First Minister’s Questions · 1
  11. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 16
  12. Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
  13. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  14. United Kingdom Government Debt First Minister’s Questions · 6
  15. Tuition Fees (European Union Students) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  16. Unconventional Gas Production First Minister’s Questions · 8
  17. Oncology (Aberdeen Royal Infirmary) Members’ business · 14
  18. Business Motion Business motions · 1
  19. Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 78
  20. Regulatory Reform (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 36
  21. Town Centre Action Plan Debate · 37
  22. Decision Time Decision time · 12

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.