Item 6 is a section 23 report entitled “Modern apprenticeships”. We have a written submission from Skills Development Scotland. Do members have any comments?
Official Report · Committee
Section 23 Reports
“Modern apprenticeships”
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Hugh Henry Lab 7
- Mary Scanlon Con 3
- Bruce Crawford SNP 3
- Tavish Scott LD 1
The record
14 contributionsSorry to be the awkward one again, but I was a bit disappointed in the response that we got from Skills Development Scotland. The need to align modern apprenticeships with the Government’s priorities formed quite an important part of the report. The cabinet secretary responded to that point very well. Audit Scotland said that there was insufficient information on the priorities, but Skills Development Scotland simply says:
“SDS’s role in Modern Apprenticeships is primarily to administer the funding for training on behalf of the Scottish Government and ensure Scottish Government programme priorities are met.”
I do not think that that is enough. I am not impressed.
SDS kept telling us that the programme was demand led, but it has given us no idea of when the work will be completed. I think that the committee would be failing in its duty if we did not ask for a bit more information, rather than being fobbed off with a simple sentence such as that. I think that SDS should be doing what the Government and Audit Scotland expect it to do, and I do not think that that one sentence is good enough. I was disappointed in that.
Are there any other comments?
Has SDS answered what we asked it?
Not entirely. For example, we asked about the objectives of the modern apprenticeship programme and the relative priority of each objective. We have not been given a great deal of information on what the priorities are, and I think that more information would be helpful. We need more clarification on that. The work that SDS has undertaken with the Scottish Government to develop outcome measures and assess the long-term benefits of modern apprenticeships has been going on for some time but there is no indication of when it is going to be completed.
Did we ask about that in the letter as well?
I think that it would be helpful if SDS would tell us when that would be completed.
I apologise for missing the first session on the report—I am a bit off the pace on it. If SDS’s role is just to administer a scheme, that raises the fundamental point that that could be done in a different way rather more effectively. The feedback that I get from my part of the world is that SDS is a top-down, bureaucratic organisation that does not add value to a really good programme that is delivering, right across Scotland, as many modern apprenticeships as we want. I think that there are better ways to do things, but this is probably not the occasion on which to raise that subject.
I am with Mary Scanlon, in that I think that there was a fairly woeful answer in response to the objectives point. Frankly, if SDS is just an administrator, I think that there are better ways to do that job and achieve an awful lot more for public money in the ways that we want.
Not only did SDS not answer the first question, but it did not answer the third one, which was a significant question that asked about
“who is responsible for acting on and reporting concerns about training provider performance”.
I brought along Audit Scotland’s report, which states on page 34:
“There are no equivalent independent reviews of the quality of training provided by other (including private) training providers”.
The report states that there are concerns about apprenticeship assessments. However, I think that SDS chose to bypass that issue as well.
I am not impressed and I do not think that we got the information that we asked for. The information that we got certainly does not take modern apprenticeships any further forward.
Can we agree to seek further information? We will write to SDS for some of it and to the accountable officer in the Scottish Government. We will probably need more information and clarification on what the priorities are. We could also ask when the work on developing the outcome measures on the long-term benefits will be completed.
There is also the point about training provider performance.
Sorry—yes.
Those matters were all picked up in the letter to SDS, which I think was right. However, can we set this in context? The “Modern Apprenticeships” report was one of the most positive reports that we have seen from the Auditor General about the performance of Skills Development Scotland. That is the context that we should recognise.
We are simply writing to ask for clarification. No other comments will be associated with that at this stage.
Is that agreed?
Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 25 Jun 2014 →- 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 09:30 “An overview of local government in Scotland 2014” Committee business · 145
- 10:45 Section 23 Report Committee business · 76
- 11:30 Section 22 Report Committee business · 5
- 11:30 Public Audit Committee Report Committee business · 1
- 11:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 14
- 11:30 Section 23 Reports Committee business · 11
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.