The report that I bring before the committee is the third in a series of reports on Scotland’s public finances and is a follow-up to Audit Scotland’s 2011 report, which focused on addressing the challenges that we face in that respect.
The report provides a high-level update on the financial position of the public sector since then and comments on how bodies right across the public sector are meeting the challenges of reduced public spending. It is aimed at public bodies, including national health service boards and central Government bodies, and it raises a range of important issues for those involved in scrutinising public finances, including non-executive directors, chief executives and other board members.
The challenges of increasing demand and cost pressures have been evident for some time now and indeed have been a constant theme in reports that have been brought before the Public Audit Committee in recent years. Almost three years on from our previous update, finances remain tight and most public bodies expect further budget reductions in the years ahead. Those reductions, the ageing population, changes to the welfare system and the need to provide and maintain public assets such as hospitals and prisons are just a few examples of the continuing pressures that public bodies face today.
During 2013, the auditors of 67 public bodies examined and reported on how those bodies are meeting the challenges of budget reductions, and my report provides a high-level summary of the main themes arising from that work and identifies what more needs to be done. It provides the context for the sector-specific checklists that we have published alongside the report and which are aimed at supporting awareness and improvement. The report emphasises the importance of focusing on priorities when setting budgets, of long-term financial planning and of the key role of non-executive directors in ensuring that bodies are well positioned to deliver quality services for less money.
Since 2009-10, the Scottish departmental expenditure limit budget has fallen 9 per cent in real terms to just under £29 billion in 2014-15. So far public bodies have coped well with those reductions, mainly by reducing staff costs, but with further reductions expected, such measures are not sustainable, and public bodies face increasingly difficult choices in reducing spending while maintaining quality and meeting rising demand.
To help manage those challenges, public bodies need to focus more on their priorities when setting their budgets and to make clearer connections between what they plan to spend and the outcomes that they are trying to achieve. Rigorous use of options appraisal based on good information is required for effective budget-related decisions and for making those decisions clear and understood to the communities that public bodies serve.
We found limited evidence of longer-term financial planning. Although funding allocations from the Scottish Government typically cover one-to-three-year spending review periods, that should not prevent public bodies from assessing their spending needs and options over a longer term, and more work is needed to develop and regularly review those long-term financial strategies to reflect priorities, risks and liabilities and their implications for affordability.
My report also emphasises the crucial role played by non-executive directors in ensuring that public bodies are well positioned to deliver quality services with less money. That involves approving budgets and holding people to account for how the money is spent and what outcomes are achieved. We found that public bodies need to improve the quality of information provided to non-executive directors and others involved in scrutiny to help them in that role.
The report makes three recommendations aimed at helping public bodies plan more effectively to deal with the challenges. First, we think that public bodies should implement an approach to budgeting that focuses on priorities and should link spending plans more closely to the outcomes that they want to achieve. Secondly, they need to develop a longer-term approach to financial planning that takes account of the risks and liabilities that they face and provides assurances about long-term affordability. Thirdly, they need to improve the information provided to support the scrutiny and challenge of spending decisions.
Effective scrutiny requires reliable, relevant and timely information. We have published sector-specific checklists that are aimed at non-executive directors to help promote good practice and scrutiny when budgets for 2015-16 and beyond are being set. The checklists are designed to help non-executive directors with their important role of budget setting and overseeing financial plans and financial performance. They can also provide a basis for discussion in public bodies on budget setting, long-term financial planning and the information that is needed to support effective scrutiny of the public finances.
As always, my colleagues and I will be happy to answer any questions that the committee might have.
