To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-02144)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Johann Lamont Lab 9
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
- Tricia Marwick 5
The record
19 contributionsLater today, I will travel to France, where I will attend a series of events at Bayeux cemetery and Sword beach to mark the 70th anniversary of the D day landings. Those fitting events remind us of the sacrifice of those who died during the biggest amphibious assault in military history and, of course, they remind us of the necessity never to forget the sacrifice that was made by those who fell in conflict.
I thank the First Minister very much for that information. Our thoughts will be with all those for whom it is a particularly painful day. However, it is a proud opportunity to commemorate an important time in our history.
Last week, we found out that the First Minister does not know what it will cost to set up a separate Scottish state. This week, we found out that he does not know how he will pay for his promises to those in greatest need of welfare. Can the First Minister now reveal what he will tell us next week that he does not know?
We published the framework of an independent Scotland in the white paper described as “Scotland’s Future”. If Johann Lamont consults chapters 6 and 10 of the white paper, she will see the extensive information that was presented on how we would go about producing a modern democracy in Scotland. Above all, she will see the arguments for why Scotland, as a modern democracy, will be able to build a more prosperous and, above all, a more equal country for all its citizens.
Most of us, when we looked at the white paper, found that it answered a lot of questions that we were not asking but addressed none of the main questions that really matter.
Last week, my colleague Neil Bibby asked Aileen Campbell a simple question. He asked her what her childcare policy would cost. She answered:
“‘Independence is the answer.’ That is exactly right.”—[Official Report, 28 May 2014; col 31494.]
We asked for a figure and we got back nonsense.
Every policy that the First Minister unveils to try to persuade Scotland to vote yes is uncosted. Either he has a plan to reverse the rules of arithmetic or he has no intention of delivering those policies. The Institute for Fiscal Studies has told us that after independence the First Minister will not be able to deliver what we have now, but the uncosted promises still tumble from his lips.
Let me put it another way. When will the First Minister announce a money tree for every garden in Scotland?
I remind Johann Lamont of what we have delivered as far as childcare in Scotland is concerned. We inherited 412.5 hours for three and four-year-olds, which is moving this year to 600 hours. That is a substantial achievement. We will move on provision for two-year-olds in workless households this year and over the next two years, which is a very substantial advance.
I remind the Labour Party that in January it said that that was not enough. Indeed, so desperate was Labour to make that point that it was prepared to sacrifice school meals for primary classes 1 to 3 in the vote in January. Labour said that there was the ability, within the consequentials, to move immediately to 50 per cent coverage for two-year-olds. We now find that those consequentials do not even approach what would have happened if we had followed Johann Lamont’s advice.
I think that people who are looking at the considerable advances that have been made by this Government, within the restricted budget and the austerity programme that is coming down from Labour and the Tories at Westminster, will see a track record of substantial success that will give people every confidence that, as we move forward to independence and controlling our finances, we will be able to do even more for the families of Scotland.
This, of course, is the Scottish Government that decided that it was not in the public interest to know what its childcare policy will cost. That is simply an insult to people who are concerned every day about childcare.
However, let us take the k out of the First Minister’s Eckonomics and listen to some real economists. The Institute for Fiscal Studies said this week:
“Scottish government ministers have also not always been as careful as official Scottish government publications when referring to these figures”.
It says that Nicola Sturgeon, in particular, is bad with figures. The IFS says that the deficit in an independent Scotland would be £1,000 more for every person in Scotland. [Interruption.]
Order.
That does not stop the First Minister, for he has a referendum to win. So we have got more childcare and increased welfare. What is next week’s offer? Whatever people want, and it will not cost us a coin. Why, when the IFS says that an independent Scotland could not afford what we have now, does the First Minister—[Interruption.]
Order.
Why does the First Minister try to dupe the people of Scotland by offering things that he knows he cannot deliver?
I remind the Labour Party that it was Johann Lamont who said that we could not afford the social gains of devolution and set up a cuts commission to examine them. I have not heard from Arthur Midwinter for some considerable time, but I am fully expecting that report to emerge and tell us what Johann Lamont wants to do. Will she sacrifice free tuition in Scotland? Will she sacrifice free transport and free personal care for the elderly? The Labour Party has had all the social gains of devolution in its sights. As we remember it, those social gains were part of the something-for-nothing society that Johann Lamont said is not sustainable.
I believe that people seeing the track record and the social democratic gains of devolution will recognise that, in this Government, we have a Government with ambition for Scotland that knows that if we match and marry the natural resources of this country with the talents of our people, we can create a better, more prosperous and more equal society. It is about having confidence in the ability of Scotland to govern its own affairs, like any other nation. It is about stopping talking down the country. It is about getting some sort of recognition from the Labour Party that it could not run Scotland when times were good—who would trust it to run Scotland now?
There needs to be some sort of dawning realisation that, after almost a century of political dominance in Scotland, the Labour Party loses election after election and the reason for that is that it has no ambition for the people and the country of Scotland. [Applause.]
Order. Order.
We ask the First Minister a serious question about the cost of his proposals and we are treated to the First Minister’s greatest hits of the past two years. It is about time that he was serious about the job that he is supposed to be doing.
If the symbol for the United Kingdom is the pound sign, the symbol for Alex Salmond’s separate Scotland is crossed fingers. But the fingers are not crossed in the hope that things might work out well, but in the hope that the people of Scotland will be daft enough to believe a word that the First Minister says. [Interruption.]
Order.
Most people in the real world know that we need to know what things cost. What have we got? The childcare policy is uncosted, and there has been no attempt to find out what the figures would be. John Swinney doubts that he can afford pensions, but still we get an assertion that they will be better. On welfare, there are big cynical problems for those who are in greatest need, but there is no clue about how to pay for the solutions.
I agree with the First Minister when he says that the people of Scotland are talented, ambitious and bright—[Interruption.]
Order.
It is not always in evidence. However, I do believe that people in Scotland are talented, ambitious and bright. Where I disagree with him is on the key quality that his plans rely on: his unerring belief that the people of Scotland are gullible and will believe anything that he says.
Let us agree that the people of Scotland are talented, ambitious and bright. It is just that this side believes that these talented, ambitious and bright people are capable of making a success of running our country.
I do not think that Johann Lamont should have described our proposals for welfare in the way that she did. I think, for example, that the recommendation to increase the carers allowance from £61.35 a week to £72.40 a week, which is worth £575 a year to 57,000 individuals in Scotland, is a substantial investment in Scotland’s future. The cost of that policy, which is very important, is £32.9 million a year. I believe that we should afford that. Incidentally, Mike Brewer, a research fellow at the Institute for Fiscal Studies, was a member of the expert working group on welfare that produced that policy. That commitment and recommendation is an important declaration of faith in the work done by carers in Scotland, which people across this chamber should support and aspire to. Yes, it will cost £32 million but, in my estimation, that is £32 million well spent to help those people.
Johann Lamont should have a care about the company that she keeps. We know that Danny Alexander exaggerated the set-up costs of an independent Scotland by 12 times. We know that because the source, Professor Dunleavy, told us that. We know that Danny Alexander did that and that they have been running from that reality ever since.
I have been looking at what Danny Alexander has been saying about his allies’ plans. For example, earlier this year Danny Alexander said:
“Labour’s new borrowing bombshell will pile another £166bn of extra borrowing on to the debt mountain left by their catastrophic mismanagement of the UK economy.”
All I am saying to Johann Lamont is that she presumably does not believe that Danny Alexander is correct in his assessment of Labour’s borrowing bombshell, so why on earth should she believe that he is correct in his assessment of the cost of an independent Scotland? Professor Dunleavy does not believe it; we do not believe it; and, above all, the Scottish people do not believe it.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 5 Jun 2014 →- General Question Time Questions · 1
- Royal Mail (Universal Service Obligation) Questions · 4
- Independence (Economic Challenges) Questions · 6
- General Practitioners (Rural Practices) Questions · 10
- NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde (Meetings) Questions · 6
- Commonwealth Games (Special Reserve Fund) Questions · 4
- Shambellie House Questions · 5
- Household Numbers Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 19
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 16
- Policing (Stop and Search) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Expert Working Group on Welfare First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Vale of Leven Hospital (Inquiry Report) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Edinburgh Trams Project (Public Inquiry) First Minister’s Questions · 5
- Aberdeen’s Engagement Strategy with Japan Members’ business · 12
- Improving Entrepreneurship among Women and Young People Debate · 56
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 7
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.