I welcome committee members, witnesses, the press and members of the public to the meeting. I remind everyone to turn off their mobile phones, as I have just done. We have one instrument to be considered under the negative procedure, the End-of-Life Vehicles (Storage and Treatment) (Scotland) Regulations 2003 (SSI 2003/593). The Subordinate Legislation Committee has considered the regulations and has identified a drafting error, which the Executive has undertaken to correct by an amending instrument. Members will have seen the extract that has been circulated from the Subordinate Legislation Committee's 17th report. Do members have any questions? I spoke to you about the regulations yesterday, Maureen. You asked me about implementation in rural areas, but I was not able to answer your question.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
End-of-Life Vehicles (Storage and Treatment) (Scotland) Regulations 2003 (SSI 2003/593)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Sarah Boyack Lab 11
- Eleanor Scott Green 5
- Maureen Macmillan Lab 3
- Alasdair Morrison Lab 3
- Nora Radcliffe LD 2
- Allan Wilson Lab 2
- Rob Gibson SNP 1
- Alex Johnstone Con 1
The record
29 contributionsI am not sure how the various bits and pieces are going to be extracted from cars, given that the current practice in some parts of the Highlands and Islands is for a crusher to go round crushing all the cars. That has seemed a good solution to the problem of the dead cars that litter the islands in particular. What are we going to do now, however? Will it be worth taking the vehicles back to wherever to have their bits extracted? Surely a balance must be struck.
I agree with what Maureen Macmillan has said. I have looked into the current approach to licensing and there is a question about whether people can be licensed in the islands to deal with the problem. Is there enough work for people to bother to obtain licences? I would like that to be clarified. It is essential to those island areas that we do not go backwards with the legislation.
There have been issues in the past about people abandoning cars on their own land. Nothing could be done about that, because the car belonged to the owner or the crofting tenant, who was not terribly willing to do anything about it.
There are issues about ownership and responsibility and the tracing of information through the Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency.
The clerks might wish to speak to Western Isles Council, which has invested in an excellent mobile crushing machine.
How do people get the bits out of the car once it has been crushed?
They do not, basically.
I wish to comment on the extract from the Official Journal of the European Communities that is appended to the instrument. How can we legislate for producers to take stuff back? How do we legislate for Toyota, for example, to take bits back to Japan? Article 5 of directive 2000/53/EC, which is cited on page L 269/37 of the Official Journal of 21 October 2000, states:"Member States shall take the necessary measures to ensure that producers meet all, or a significant part of, the costs of the implementation of this measure and/or take back end-of-life vehicles under the same conditions as referred to in the first subparagraph."That would be fine if cars were being built in Scotland, but it is harder to achieve with cars that are built on the other side of the world. The document also refers to member states increasing consumer awareness and says:"Member states shall take the necessary measures to ensure that the following targets are attained by economic operators".There are various targets on the percentage of reuse and recycling to be attained"no later than 1 January 2006, for all end-of-life vehicles".The targets are stringent and I am interested to know how we will meet them.My final point—to show what a sad person I am—is that there is a typo on page 7.
Page 7 of which part?
The main body of the document.
The document says "of" instead of "or".
Yes. There are two sad people.
Will you direct me to the exact paragraph?
It is paragraph 3(c) of part 2 of the schedule to the regulations. We think that it should say "the removal or neutralisation".
Excellent. I am grateful to both members for doing their job of scrutiny properly.
Why did the Subordinate Legislation Committee not come up with that?
Quite.
Even though our job is only to scrutinise the policy, you found a typo. Very good.We seek clarification of how the instrument will be implemented. I do not hear anyone saying that they are unhappy with the policy; everyone agrees that it is the right thing to do. However, it is obvious that there are some concerns about its implementation. We must report to the Parliament on the regulations by 19 January. If I read committee members correctly, our concerns are about clarity; we are after feedback from the minister about how the regulations will be implemented. It seems that no one has concerns about their principles. I suggest that we are happy to make no recommendation to the Parliament but that we should write to the minister to say that we have questions about implementation. We should ask him to report back to us on how he envisages taking the matter forward, because the concerns that have been raised are genuine.
An issue that concerns me, but which has not yet been raised, is how one identifies who is responsible for a vehicle, particularly if it has been abandoned.
Maureen Macmillan raised that issue in passing. We should ask questions about the DVLA, to clarify the ownership issue. I am not going to bring the minister in, although he could probably answer the question.
I am champing at the bit.
There are important issues about implementation. It is not that we are unhappy about the regulations, but we have to get on and get things done properly. I ask the committee to agree that we write to the minister and ask him to respond to us in due course.
If the minister has a response now, that would save a sheet of paper, would it not?
It would do so only if he can answer all the questions to our satisfaction and I do not want to put him in that position.
Is the issue not on the agenda to be discussed later?
No. We are dealing with it now. We have to report to the Parliament by 19 January and I do not suggest that we should invite you back next week. If we get answers from the minister, we will post them on our web page. Presumably, discussions are taking place between the minister and local authorities. Are members content with the regulations and happy to make no recommendation to Parliament?
Members indicated agreement.
We will get feedback from the minister in due course.
In this meeting
Everything on 14 Jan 2004 →- Scottish Parliament Environment and Rural Development Committee Wednesday 14 January 2004 (Morning) Committee business · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 29
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 45
- Work Programme Procedure · 22
- European Issues Committee business · 113
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.