We have made changes in a number of areas since the petition was brought, and we have been involved in a number of discussions with Mr Smith and Mr Robertson.
One of the main changes was in relation to the reimbursement of training costs. It is important to note that the issue is set against the backdrop of the Fédération Internationale de Football Association requirement for associations to have in place a system for rewarding clubs for investing in the training and education of players. That is a mandatory requirement for associations.
One issue in the past was that there were two systems of reimbursement for training costs: one was governed by the SFA and the other was governed by the Scottish Premier League. The Scottish Football League, as it was at the time, used the one that we used. Some of the figures in the system were regarded as fairly random and it was unclear as to how they related to what was actually spent, so we undertook an exercise to consider what clubs were spending on the training and development of players.
It became clear to us that there was a clear correlation between what was spent and clubs’ star ratings under the club academy Scotland scheme. Because of that, we set up a new, matrix-type system—basically, the higher up a club is, the more it has spent and the more it expects to get in reimbursement of training costs.
In tandem with that, we brought in two new rules, which make it quite clear that no rights of compensation that a club might have shall prevent a player from moving to a new club. In the past, there was a perception that clubs that were due compensation were stopping players from moving to new clubs. We have put in a rule so that clubs cannot do that.
On the limited occasions on which there have been issues—in the two years since I have been at the SFA I would say that there have been less than a handful of cases—we have been brought in as mediators. We help the club, the player and the parents to look for a compromise, so that the player can be released to the new club.
That is probably the biggest change that we have made, although we have made others, as the RealGrassroots guys are aware. One is in relation to the registration and licensing of team scouts. We brought in new rules on that and put in place a new process so that the senior clubs have to register their team scouts. That has been quite successful.
There was also an issue about players being released from club academy Scotland clubs and appearing to go into the ether, so to speak, and being lost to football. That is not a good thing, so we have set up a process whereby information is passed back to the Scottish Youth Football Association to reunite those players with the clubs that they came from originally, or any other club, in the hope that we do not lose them to football.
Another significant issue was that players in club academy Scotland were not allowed to play for their school teams. The rule has been changed so that they can play for their school teams, although it is still at the discretion of the club academy Scotland club. I have had quite a number of discussions with various people involved in that and I would say that clubs generally provide support in that area. Many players who are club academy Scotland players still play for their school teams.
That gives you a broad overview of a number of areas in which we have made changes in the past couple of years.