We requested clarification from the Executive on the definition in the Prohibition of Keeping or Release of Live Fish (Specified Species) (Scotland) Order 2003 of "Scotland" and its relationship with territorial waters. We also requested further clarification from the Subordinate Legislation Committee of its recommendations on the order. An extract has been circulated of the Subordinate Legislation Committee's 14th report, containing the recommendations, along with the memorandum from the committee's legal adviser and the memorandum from the Scottish Executive. Do members have comments or questions?
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Prohibition of Keeping or Release of Live Fish (Specified Species) (Scotland) Order 2003 (SSI 2003/560)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Sarah Boyack Lab 8
- Alasdair Morrison Lab 3
- Rob Gibson SNP 2
- Malcolm McMillan Scottish Executive Legal and Parliamentary Services 2
The record
15 contributionsI do not want to make a large issue of this, because it is fairly clear from the advice that we have had how the order will be interpreted—any matter reaching the courts would be marginal. However, because the definition of "Scotland" has to be the definition in the Scotland Act 1998 as read with the Scottish Adjacent Waters Boundaries Order 1999, I wonder whether we might alert the Executive to the possibility of amending the primary legislation to take the new definition into account.
Having read the briefing from the Subordinate Legislation Committee, I think that there are two ways in which to deal with the order. One is for the Executive not to include article 2 in the order; the other is for somebody to provide a judicial interpretation of the definition. I do not think that there is a problem with the order in the context of the issue that we are discussing. However, as we have the Executive officials here, it might be worth asking them for a view. Why is article 2 in the order?
Article 2 was included in the order to clarify its scope. We are always mindful of the need to clarify the scope of an offence where provision is made in a Scottish statutory instrument. That is one of the issues that the Subordinate Legislation Committee raised with us. Given that there is no precise definition of the boundary judicially or in acts of the United Kingdom Parliament, we included article 2 to give the precise definition, so that a person releasing fish into the wild would know precisely the scope of the offence.
The advice that we have taken is that the issue of the boundary is not clear. Is that a correct interpretation?
The Executive's position is that the boundary as set in article 2 is the same as the boundary that would have been set pre-devolution. Our position is that the meaning of "Scotland" pre-devolution was the land and internal waters of Scotland and the territorial sea adjacent to Scotland. The same definition has been adopted in the order, following the Scottish Adjacent Waters Boundaries Order 1999 and the definition in the Scotland Act 1998.
I remember us getting into this issue previously—
Agreed.
At length in the Parliament.Perhaps we should deal with the issue by agreeing to make no recommendation to the Parliament on the order and by informing the Executive that we have received advice that there is a question about interpretation.
I was just listening to Mr McMillan's explanation. I must be missing something, because I thought that it was straightforward. I understand what he means and have no difficulty or delicacy with the explanation. We should just move on as quickly as we can to the next item.
We have had different interpretations of what the issue means.
That is the point that I am trying to make. We have just had a clear and straightforward explanation and I do not think that we should waste any more of the committee's time or of the officials' time.
I see members nodding. Do you want to dissent from what has been said, Rob, or are you happy to move on? The fact that we have interrogated the matter will be reflected in the Official Report.
As I said, I am happy with what is in the statutory instrument. At the same time, I wish that the instrument had been brought to us in a clearer form. I have had my say.
You have logged your point.Do we agree to make no recommendation to the Parliament?Members indicated agreement.
In this meeting
Everything on 17 Dec 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Environment and Rural Development Committee Wednesday 17 December 2003 (Morning) Committee business · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 2
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 15
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 11
- National Waste Plan (Parliamentary Debate) Committee business · 3
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.