To ask the Scottish Government, in light of the recent Sunday Times rich list figures showing a 19 per cent increase in the wealth of the 100 richest people in Scotland, what action it can take to narrow the gap between rich and poor people. (S4T-00701)
Official Report · Chamber
Wealth Gap
Topical Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- John Swinney SNP 5
- John Mason SNP 3
- Iain Gray Lab 1
- Gavin Brown Con 1
The record
10 contributions
Scotland is a wealthy country. By population, we are the 14th wealthiest country in the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development—wealthier than France, Germany, Japan and the United Kingdom. However, too many people in Scotland are not able to benefit from that wealth. Only this month, the Scottish Government published detailed analysis of UK Government data on wealth and assets in Scotland, which show that 30 per cent of households in Scotland have almost no wealth—that is, they do not own property, have a private pension or savings or own items such as cars and household goods.
The Scottish Government takes all the action that it can within its powers to ensure that we support individuals on low incomes. Measures that we have taken on the living wage and welfare reform mitigation were designed to tackle the poverty that has affected some of our citizens.
If I understand that answer correctly, the Scottish Government has no real powers to tackle the gap between the rich and the poor. Will the cabinet secretary tell the Parliament what guarantees UK ministers have given him that significant powers to tackle the gap would be devolved in the event of a no vote in September?
John Mason summarised the position on the limitations of the powers of the Scottish Government. My first answer to him was that we will do everything that we can within our limited responsibilities, but the data that I mentioned, which the Government has published, clearly demonstrate that there are significant limitations on what the Scottish Government can do to tackle a major problem that affects our society. If we acquired a broader range of responsibilities, we would be in a position to take a wider range of actions to tackle the inequality gap that exists between rich and poor in our society.
On the implications of a no vote, Mr Mason can read the comments that a variety of UK politicians have made, as I have done. Of course, the record demonstrates that UK ministers have been unwilling to give this Parliament effective powers to tackle inequality in our society. That is why we have to vote yes in the referendum in September.
Will the cabinet secretary inform the Parliament about actions that an independent Scotland could take to tackle inequality?
There are choices to be made. The Government made clear in the white paper that we would choose not to support the continuation of investment in weapons of mass destruction and that we would change defence expenditure priorities, so that we could invest in projects and measures that would boost economic opportunities for people in Scottish society who are on low incomes, thereby improving the participation rate in the economy. As we all know, people who are active in the labour market and able to command good jobs can address the poverty with which they wrestle.
In addition, the Scottish Government would be determined to use the integrated range of powers in the benefits and employment systems to create opportunities that would encourage more and more people to participate in the labour market and secure the higher-quality employment that would enable them to work their way out of poverty.
The cabinet secretary could have supported living wage guarantees in the Procurement Reform (Scotland) Bill a couple of weeks ago, even if that meant pushing the boundaries of European law. He was willing to push those boundaries on minimum pricing for alcohol; why would he not do it to reduce the gap between rich and poor?
This Government was the first Administration ever to apply the living wage across the public sector employment for which it has responsibility. We have done that consistently since we introduced the measure.
On the Procurement Reform (Scotland) Bill, we went through the arguments with the Labour Party last week. We set out, with clear evidence from the European Commission, exactly why we could not legislate for the provision to which Iain Gray referred.
However, the Scottish Government included in the bill a range of provisions that are designed to motivate and encourage the greatest possible degree of private sector participation in following its lead and delivering the living wage to people in a range of employment sectors in Scotland.
Does the cabinet secretary support action on wage ratios?
Yes. In his review for the United Kingdom Government, Will Hutton indicated the growing disparity between lower-income individuals and higher-income individuals. The Scottish Government agrees with the analysis that he set out.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 20 May 2014 →- Time for Reflection Time for reflection · 2
- Police (Carrying of Firearms) Questions · 22
- Wealth Gap Questions · 10
- Revenue Scotland and Tax Powers Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 45
- Revenue Scotland and Tax Powers Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 2
- Disabled Persons’ Parking Badges (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 24
- Decision Time Decision time · 4
- Epilepsy (Tackling Stigma) Members’ business · 7
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.