To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-02110)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Salmond SNP 13
- Tricia Marwick 11
- Johann Lamont Lab 8
- Dr Richard Simpson Lab 1
The record
33 contributionsEngagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
Last week, when he sprang to the defence of his health secretary, the First Minister revealed something that a lot of us had suspected for some time. He said:
“I am in on everything”.—[Official Report, 15 May 2014; c 31065.]
If he really is in on everything, will the First Minister tell us why Alex Neil reversed the decision that had been taken by Nicola Sturgeon on mental health services in Lanarkshire? If Alex Neil was acting in the best interests of patients in Lanarkshire, can the First Minister explain what Nicola Sturgeon was doing?
Every health secretary has the right, when taking office, to review a whole range of decisions. Johann Lamont is right, in that this is about health provision in Lanarkshire, which affects 500,000 people. The health secretary was well within his rights to look at health provision in Lanarkshire and the proposals that were coming forward and to make his views known.
He made his view known that there should be provision in Monklands district general hospital, Wishaw general hospital and Hairmyres hospital, the three hospitals concerned. That is what he said in the memo on 26 September. I think that a health secretary is well within his rights to do that. He discharged his responsibilities and he was acting in the best interests of the health service of Scotland.
We are in the unusual situation in which both Alex Neil and Alex Salmond agree that Nicola Sturgeon got it wrong. Who else does the First Minister think got it wrong? Ian Ross, the chief executive of NHS Lanarkshire, on the very morning when he was instructed by Alex Neil’s office to reverse his plan, was still insisting that the original proposals would mean
“improved quality of service to patients”.
Ian Ross said:
“There is no alternative option which can deliver the same benefits”.
Catriona Borland, a senior official in the Government’s health team, said that retaining beds at Monklands would result in a “less than optimal service”.
Can the First Minister explain why health professionals wasted two years trying to redesign a service, if it was not in the interests of patients?
I am not sure whether Johann Lamont is aware that in the proposals of 2006, which were approved by the health team when she was a member of the Government, it was proposed that there be an acute ward in Monklands hospital. I could equally ask her why the Government of which she was a member approved that formulation, if she is now criticising the health secretary for agreeing with her. I find it quite extraordinary that that lapse of memory has crept into Johann Lamont’s articulation.
Other considerations have to be borne in mind—[Interruption.]
Order. Mr McNeil.
Johann Lamont is quite right. There is a letter—which I know is known to Johann Lamont because it was released under freedom of information. For understandable reasons, it is a confidential letter. The letter was written to me by a patient. I found it then, and I find it now, a very moving account of why that patient did not agree that the ward should be closed. The patient said:
“These nurses in the wards know us personally over many years, as long as 20; that’s a very long time. We as patients have bonded with our nurses in such a way that we trust them with our lives. ... Many mentally ill patients can’t read or write, but we do know we need these wards to stay open. Families are much concerned at the best of times; they visit us when they finish work and work long hours, too. Ask yourself this, if one of your own family was ill, after working 12-hour shifts then to have to travel at least 15 miles or so at hours without public transport being available, could you do it? ... You should keep it open for the mentally ill.” [Interruption.]
Order.
I think that that is a moving letter, which should be listened to with respect by members in this chamber—[Interruption.]
Order.
The letter was written in September 2012 by one of the patients who was particularly concerned by rumours about the ward closing—[Interruption.]
Ms McMahon!
I think that it is entirely reasonable for the Government to take those opinions into account and entirely reasonable for a health secretary to discharge his responsibility in the way that Alex Neil did.
For the absence of doubt, the First Minister believes that Nicola Sturgeon got it wrong. He believes that Scotland’s most senior health officials got it wrong.
Of course we should listen to patients and users. What does the First Minister say about Francis Fallon? Mr Fallon is the chair of Lanarkshire Links, which advocates on behalf of 800 mental health service users and carers. Mr Fallon has said:
“The members of Lanarkshire Links were totally shocked, bewildered and very upset about this decision, taken in a spur of the moment, knee jerk reaction by Mr Neil, without any discussion or consideration of those hundreds of service users and their carers.”
Mr Fallon was a mental health nurse for 30 years. He was given an MBE for his work on mental health. He and his colleagues spent two years working on the proposal, only to be ignored. What does the First Minister have to say to him and the members of Lanarkshire Links who have been let down by Alex Neil?
I have read out a moving letter from a patient who was frightened about being affected by the proposals as they were. That was one of the interests that were taken into account—quite rightly—by the health secretary. What the health secretary sent back, through his officials, to the board was a proposal to look at the provision across Lanarkshire and three of the hospitals.
Many of us believe that matters of local provision are really important, both in mental health services and across the range of health services. The board is confident that the configuration that NHS Lanarkshire has now will offer excellent provision for the people of Lanarkshire. That involves acute facilities at Hairmyres, Wishaw and Monklands hospitals. It also involves an expansion of services in the community. That seems to me to be a good position for the people of Lanarkshire.
Those things are, quite properly, taken into account, as they were taken into account in other hospital situations in Lanarkshire. That is what health secretaries are elected to do. A health secretary discharges responsibilities for all the patients of Lanarkshire. [Interruption.]
Order.
There is a great deal of opinion that the formulation and the circumstance that we have come out with is an excellent provision as far as mental health services are concerned. It is really important—the point was made in the letter—that when these patients, who are not always the patients with the strongest voices, make their opinions heard, their voices are listened to with respect. That is what the health secretary did, and he should be proud of his actions in that respect.
I do not know what is more depressing—that the First Minister makes that case or that he thinks that it is a credible case to make. It is desperate stuff. For two years, his cabinet secretary Nicola Sturgeon, the board, the patients, the staff, people who cared for folk with mental health issues and people who used the service themselves came to one conclusion and Alex Neil came to a different one.
One week into this, we have still to hear a credible explanation for Alex Neil’s behaviour. Let us look at what I believe is his charge sheet. Putting his political interests before patients—guilty; undermining the integrity of health professionals—guilty; misleading the Parliament and the people of Scotland—
Ms Lamont.
In my view—
Ms Lamont.
As I said, in my view—
Ms Lamont, “misleading” is not acceptable at First Minister’s question time.
I ask other people to judge an email in the morning that directs the health board to do one thing and, in the afternoon, the health secretary’s claim that he has stepped back. Is the First Minister really prepared to debase his own office and the Parliament even further to save the skin of the health secretary?
It is, of course, perfectly reasonable for Johann Lamont to disagree with the decision—the evaluation—that the health secretary made. It is perfectly reasonable for her to point out that different people have different opinions, although I have heard nothing about why the Government of which she was a member in 2006 considered that there should be acute facilities in Monklands hospital. I presume that all the expertise and advice was available in 2006, when a different proposal and conclusion came forward. When we get to the debate in a few minutes time I will read extensively from a document that demonstrates beyond any doubt whatsoever that that fact and all other facts were volunteered by the Government—[Interruption.]
Order.
Perhaps I should read from the document now. The document, which is dated 1 December 2012, was released to John Pentland on 5 March 2013. Every iota of that information was available to Johann Lamont’s MSPs last March. [Interruption.] I just heard Richard Simpson say, “Oh no, it was not.” I hope that he stays for the debate because yes, it was.
Oh, I will be.
Dr Simpson!
I say this to the Labour leader. This is a time when people are rightly concerned that the Labour Party may be planning to remove free prescriptions from the national health service, a time when people are concerned about the Labour Party’s open questioning of free personal care, and a time when people are concerned that the Labour Party will reintroduce tuition fees. The Labour Party chooses to have a spurious motion of no confidence at a time when people are debating and looking at the great issues that face the country. [Interruption.]
Order.
There will not be judgment on Alex Neil; there will be a judgment on this pathetic Opposition.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 21 May 2014 →- Business Motion Business motions · 1
- Pensioners Parliament Questions · 4
- Pensioners’ Rights (Proposals) Questions · 7
- Education for Children and Young People with Dyslexia (Equalities) Questions · 4
- Pensioners’ Rights (Protection) Questions · 4
- Commonwealth Games (Tickets) Questions · 4
- State Pension (Life Expectancy) Questions · 4
- Pride House (Glasgow) Questions · 4
- Pensions (Retirement Age) Questions · 6
- Women’s Employment Questions · 10
- Long-term Unemployment (Women) Questions · 7
- Company Boards (Female Participation) Questions · 4
- Massive Open Online Courses Questions · 5
- Engineering (Modern Apprenticeships) Questions · 4
- Employment (Gender Segregation) Questions · 4
- Modern Apprenticeships (Assessment of Benefits) Questions · 4
- Royal Infirmary of Edinburgh (Private Finance Initiative Contract) Questions · 5
- Electricity Grid Failure (Wind Turbines) Questions · 4
- Inward Investment (Jobs) Questions · 6
- Care of Older Patients (Lothian) Questions · 6
- Flooding (Support for Householders and Businesses) Questions · 4
- Independence (Overseas Students) Questions · 4
- Motorway Network (Central Scotland) Questions · 4
- Creative Scotland Funding (Kilmarnock and Irvine Valley) Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 33
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- House Building First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Racial Intolerance and Hate Crime First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Modern Apprenticeships First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Motion of No Confidence Debate · 45
- Courts Reform (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 37
- Courts Reform (Scotland) Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 6
- Business Motion Business motions · 1
- Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 13
- Point of Order Procedure · 3
- Scottish Learning Disability Awareness Week 2014 Members’ business · 9
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.