The Subordinate Legislation Committee reported on SSI 2003/518 in its 12th report and raised a point about state aid for environmental protection. The relevant extract from the report has been circulated to members. I invite the minister to make his opening remarks on the instrument, during which he may wish to address the Subordinate Legislation Committee's point.
Official Report · Committee
Subordinate Legislation
Nitrate Vulnerable Zones (Grants) (Scotland) Amendment Scheme 2003 (SSI 2003/518)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Sarah Boyack Lab 8
- Frances Reid Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department 5
- Nora Radcliffe LD 5
- Allan Wilson Lab 4
- Alex Johnstone Con 1
The record
27 contributionsI welcome the opportunity to introduce to the committee the Nitrate Vulnerable Zones (Grants) (Scotland) Amendment Scheme 2003, which amends the nitrate vulnerable zones grants scheme proper. The amendments are required as a condition of the state aid rules. Some members were present when I discussed the NVZ grants scheme with the then Transport and the Environment Committee, but I will give some background.The scheme delivers on a commitment that was given by ministers in March 2000 by offering a 40 per cent grant to farmers in areas that are designated as nitrate vulnerable zones. It is a capital grant scheme and is designed to assist farmers with meeting the close period requirements of the action programme for NVZs. NVZ designations and the action programme stem from the 1991 European Commission nitrates directive, which aimed to reduce water pollution that is caused by nitrates from agricultural sources.One of the most significant aspects of the compulsory action programme is that, during close periods, organic manures and slurries cannot be spread on agricultural land. Therefore, a farmer in an NVZ needs sufficient storage for manure and slurry to comply with that requirement. As members can imagine, the cost of provision of that storage can vary considerably depending on the facility that is required, but it is likely to involve a significant capital outlay for most farm businesses that are required to make the change.As I said, the amendment measures that we are considering stem from the need to ensure that the scheme complies with the state aid rules. When I introduced the NVZ grant scheme at the then Transport and the Environment Committee in February, I said that I believed that the scheme would comply with those rules. We did not want to hold up the scheme's introduction as a not-dissimilar scheme had been in place in England and Wales since 1996.However, at that juncture we made it clear that no decisions would be taken on applications until clearance had been received from the European Union. Over the past few months, through correspondence the Commission has sought assurance about administrative functions relating to the scheme. At a meeting with officials in July, it expressed concerns about the length of time over which the scheme would run.The Scottish NVZ grant scheme allowed farmers a five-year period during which they could apply for grant assistance. During the negotiations, it became clear that the Commission would not approve the scheme unless Scottish ministers agreed to reduce the time for completion of the capital works. The assurance that was sought and given was that the scheme would be amended to require all improvement works to be completed by 31 October 2005. On that basis, state aid approval was granted in September.The crux of the amendments in the instrument that is before us is the bringing forward of the closure date by which works must be completed and the undertaking to that effect that applicants for grants are required to provide. That provision is related directly to the assurance that we have given to the Commission, which I mentioned previously. Most of the other measures in the instrument follow on from the introduction of the new date, which is the critical factor in securing state aid approval.Members may have concerns about the impact that the amended provision will have on farmers who have already applied for grants. I assure the committee that the Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department has kept them up to date on developments. As an interim measure, arrangements were put in place for urgent works authority to be given to any applicants who felt that they could not delay commencement of their works until state aid approval came through. All applicants who were in that position were notified individually when EC approval was granted. They were also asked to provide further information relating to their farming experience and the economic viability of their holdings—additional conditions that were attached to the state aid approval.I do not expect that bringing forward the closure date will have an impact on current applications. Guidance on the scheme indicates that applicants will normally be expected to claim their grant assistance over an 18-month period from the date on which their application is formally approved. Farmers who did not apply for grant in the first tranche will have to do so within the constraints of the time limits that we are now setting.Those are fairly minor amendments to what is an important grant scheme, especially for the 12,000 or 13,000 farmers whom it affects. I know that it is sometimes tempting to criticise the Commission, but I can understand its unease about the relatively long time scale of the original scheme. Under that scheme, in some cases farmers might not have completed their grant-aided works until 2010, but would have been able to comply with the mandatory requirements of the NVZ action programme during that period, which would have obvious environmental implications. I know that the committee agrees that environmental pollution is an important enough issue to warrant restriction of the time scales in this instance.The amendments that are before the committee address the Commission's concerns about time scales; the scheme will now have the full approval of the Commission. I commend the instrument to the committee.
Thank you. I invite members to ask questions and to raise issues for clarification.
We will not debate the instrument at great length, so I seek answers to my questions at this point. Like the minister, I am content that it is necessary that the instrument be approved, but there are a couple of issues that I would like to have clarified.First, I could probably have done more research on the funding streams that the money associated with the scheme follows. Will the minister reassure me that the fact that the scheme is being brought forward will not have a direct impact on the funding of the Scottish Executive Environment and Rural Affairs Department over the two-year period into which the scheme has been compressed? If all the work that should have been done can be brought forward into that period, it will cost more to finance it.Secondly, will the minister or his officials give the committee an estimate of how much of the work will be brought forward and how much might not be done at all? Do you expect the entire scheme to be compressed or will the total amount of work be reduced as a result of compressing the scheme?Those questions cover my concerns. I understand why the minister has had to introduce the instrument, but it is always a disappointment when time scales are compressed. Is the time scale that has been allocated for completion of the scheme adequate to achieve its original aims? Has the time scale been compressed too much?
I will address the first point about the financing of the scheme before I ask Frances Reid to address some of the related issues about applications. The amounts that we allocated originally to the NVZ grant scheme were £6.8 million in the current financial year; £4.8 million in the next financial year; and £5.8 million in the following year, which is 2005-06.One can imagine that it is unlikely that the sums that were allocated for this financial year will be met and that, likewise, there might be pressure at the tail end. However, by truncating the time scale over which the applications are required to be submitted, processed, approved and implemented, I imagine that the total allocated sums will be taken up in full, although that will depend on the level of application for the grant. There is no intention on our part to take account of the truncated time scale over which grant applications will be submitted and approved by reducing the sums that have been allocated.In large part, the answer to the second part of the question is dependent on the level of applications that we receive. We are confident of our ability to process the applications in the truncated time scale. The onus is now on individual farmers to submit proposals rather than to wait, as they might have done, for a couple of years before so doing.
We have not had a high level of uptake of grant in the first round. The estimates were really guesstimates and we have no feel for how many people will need improved or replacement storage. It is up to farmers to apply within the tighter time scales. We feel that there will be enough money in the scheme; although the scheme is to close earlier, we will be able to pay farmers after the closing date. However, there is much work to be done before that date.If the scheme had been over the original five-year period, we might have had underspends and people might have delayed making applications until the nearer the end of the period. We have a substantial amount of money in the scheme and I feel fairly confident that we will be able to meet all aspirations.
You have answered my question partially, but have also indicated that you will be partially unable to answer it. Do you have any idea about the likely level of uptake? What is the total number of applications that you expect to be made? From what you said, it does not seem that a lot of the applications that are lying on the table are waiting for state aid approval.
Perhaps I should give an outline of what has happened to date, although it is not possible to extrapolate from that what will happen in the next tranche of applications. The situation at the moment is that 39 applications were received by the closing date of 30 June. By area office, they are: 16 from Inverurie; seven from Perth; five from Gala; and 11 from Dumfries. If nothing else, there is a fair geographical spread.In the light of state aid approval having been granted, one would expect the process to pick up speed. There is now no obstacle to the grants being paid. Although people might to date have been proceeding on a fairly speculative basis, subject to the committee's approval, after today one would expect that there would be no more speculation about state aid approval.
Is there any indication that truncating the scheme might affect the practicalities of getting the work done? I do not know how many people supply slurry tanks or whether there is any likelihood that there will in the industry be pressure to supply the physical infrastructure.
That is difficult to judge, because we do not know what uptake will be. It would probably have been preferable to have a longer period, but that was not an option as far as the Commission was concerned, so our hands were tied.
How are farmers being notified about that? Are they notified individually?
Yes.
So everybody in an NVZ will have had individual notification that they are now eligible to apply and that there is state aid.
Everybody was notified originally; they were all told about it. We put out a press release when we got the state aid approval, and we told the National Farmers Union in Scotland, which also put out a press release. We will be announcing a fresh tranche before the end of the year, so it will be up to applicants to apply during the next tranche. The union will probably press its members to take up that option.
Are you highlighting to people the fact that the time is now shorter than was originally envisaged?
Yes. That was clarified in the press release.
As there are no other questions, I invite the minister to move motion S2M-607, in the name of Ross Finnie, on the Nitrate Vulnerable Zones (Grants) (Scotland) Amendment Scheme 2003 (SSI 2003/518).
Motion moved,
That the Environment and Rural Development Committee recommends that the Nitrate Vulnerable Zones (Grants) (Scotland) Amendment Scheme 2003 (SSI 2003/518) be approved.—Allan Wilson.
Would you like to make any opening remarks to introduce the debate, or do you feel that everything has been adequately covered?
I think that we have covered everything.
I invite contributions from members.
I would like to make a general statement. The instrument indicates the importance of tackling EU legislation in a timeous manner, but the fact that we are dealing with a 1991 directive says it all. That is not the fault of the Scottish Parliament, I hasten to add.
That is a well-made point.The question is, that motion S2M-607, in the name of Ross Finnie, be agreed to.
Motion agreed to.
That the Environment and Rural Development Committee recommends that the Nitrate Vulnerable Zones (Grants) (Scotland) Amendment Scheme 2003 (SSI 2003/518) be approved.
Excellent. We shall pass that on to Parliament.
In this meeting
Everything on 26 Nov 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Environment and Rural Development Committee Wednesday 26 November 2003 (Morning) Committee business · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 27
- Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 16
- Nature Conservation (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 241
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.