PE645 is a new petition that calls on the Scottish Parliament to take a range of steps to ensure the control of offensive and noxious odours from waste treatment plants. The committee is required to consider the petition and to agree a course of action. Everyone will have read their papers, so I imagine that they have noted that the issues that are raised in the petition are broadly similar to those that were raised in PE517, although this is the first time that we have considered the new petition. Are members content to accept the referral from the Public Petitions Committee and to consider PE645 alongside PE517? The local member is here this morning.
Official Report · Committee
Petitions
Waste Water Treatment (PE517 and PE645)
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Sarah Boyack Lab 14
- Des McNulty Lab 4
- Marilyn Livingstone Lab 3
- Alasdair Morrison Lab 2
- Roseanna Cunningham SNP 1
- Susan Deacon Lab 1
- Christine May Lab 1
The record
26 contributionsPetition PE645 relates to the Pathhead waste water treatment works in Kirkcaldy, which is affectionately known as the "Pathhead pong". Matters have moved on since the petition was submitted, but issues remain. The residents group, the council and I met Scottish Water, but we have reached an impasse. As members are aware, we are awaiting judgments and we are considering closely what the City of Edinburgh Council is doing. Fife Council will monitor the situation over six weeks and we have issued recording sheets as we did in the past. With the residents in Kirkcaldy who still suffer from the odours, although there are fewer of them now, we are looking at the measures we can take to address that impasse.
I am concerned that we have two petitions from two widely different areas, but which seem to relate to the same problem. That might be evidence that the problem is much more widespread. Although we see that problem in the context of individual petitions, perhaps we need to take the bigger issue more seriously. I know that the committee's work load is horrendous for the foreseeable future, but I am wondering about option C in the paper on PE517, which proposes monitoring the situation. That option could also apply to PE645 and it would allow us to monitor developments that are wider than those in the two petitions. My guess is that they might only be the tip of the iceberg.
The suggested action on PE645 addresses the broader issues with which we have been dealing under PE517. The two petitions relate to issues which, although they are experienced locally, are not local issues because they raise broader issues throughout Scotland. I am keen that we agree to consider PE645, but that we consider it alongside PE517, which picks up the point that the issues are not isolated and that they are public policy issues.
My constituents would have no problem with that. They know that, although their petition concerns the Pathhead works, broader issues are involved, as the convener said.
So we would agree to pursue option A, which is that we accept the referral of PE645 and undertake further consideration of the issue in conjunction with PE517. I want to ensure that we deal with the petition properly, instead of simply closing it down.
I think that I am in the same position as other members, in that an existing sewage works in my area has been producing odours for a long time. The works have recently been renewed and the smell periodically worsens. Moreover, there is a proposal for a significant extension to an existing sewage works 500yd from the centre of Clydebank, which means that we will get the smells from the north side of Glasgow and from Renfrewshire in quite a narrow space.I want to identify three action points in connection with this issue. First, I would like the committee to highlight that the matter should be taken into consideration in the proposed Water Services (Scotland) Bill. Legislation that relates to this matter is coming down the track and, given colleagues' comments about what is happening around Scotland, it is entirely unacceptable that only one abatement notice has been served since 1999. As the Executive will have an opportunity to examine legislation in this area when the proposed bill is introduced, an early indication from the committee that it would expect such an examination would send an important signal.Secondly, the petition raises the significant planning issue of permitted development rights. There is no legislative obligation on water authorities to carry out normal planning scrutiny or to provide notification of proposals to develop an existing facility, however small it might be. As a result, planning authorities have no opportunity that is backed by legislation to enforce conditions as far as planning consent is concerned. Although such conditions were enforced with the proposed Erskine works, which are on the opposite side of the Clyde from my constituency, that was done largely on a grace-and-favour basis. We need to address the way in which permitted development powers are used in that respect and how they allow public authorities to bypass legislative planning mechanisms as opposed to mechanisms that address odour problems.Thirdly, Scottish Water recognises that it could maintain higher odour-control standards. However, with the funding regime that it operates under the water industry commissioner and the Scottish Executive's policy direction, it is not funded to achieve such standards. Indeed, it could be criticised for imposing higher standards, which is a completely topsy-turvy arrangement. I suggest that the committee could flag up the issue to the Finance Committee, which is investigating the funding regime of the water authority.I suppose that I am making three suggestions. First, I suggest that the committee writes to Ross Finnie in relation to his legislative powers; secondly, that it writes to Margaret Curran to ask about permitted development rights in the context of the on-going consultation on planning matters; and thirdly, that it writes to the Finance Committee in the context of its investigation into Scottish Water's funding regime.
We know that you are the convener of the Finance Committee, so I take it that you are actively seeking that advice from us.Alasdair Morrison was about to ask a question.
I have nothing to add.
I seek members' agreement that we accept the referral of PE645 and that we wrap it up with PE517.Members indicated agreement.
It was important that Marilyn Livingstone was able to speak about how the matter has impacted on her constituents.I want to pick up some of the other issues that were raised by Des McNulty in relation to the previous petition and which are also relevant to PE645. I will bring everyone up to date on the progress of PE517 and then bring in Susan Deacon, who is keen to speak on it.This is the second time that we have considered PE517. At our meeting of 10 September, we agreed to write to the Minister for Environment and Rural Development to seek his view on all the issues that arise from it, including the effectiveness of the current system for regulating odour nuisance from water treatment plants, on which Des McNulty has just commented. The minister's response is attached to the petition cover note. We will try to sweep up some of the broader issues that Des McNulty and Marilyn Livingstone have raised and consider how to proceed with PE517.
I attended the previous meeting at which this issue was raised, so members will be aware of my interest in petition PE517. Seafield sewage works, which prompted the petition, is in my constituency.The specific point that I would like to make is in direct response to the minister's reply. It is approximately 18 months since PE517 was submitted to the Parliament. I recognise that the petition has been progressed actively by the Public Petitions Committee and by the Transport and the Environment Committee before the election and by the Environment and Rural Development Committee since. Nonetheless, 18 months have elapsed since the issues were first raised.It is more than six months since the Minister for Environment and Rural Development, Ross Finnie, acknowledged to the Transport and the Environment Committee that there were inadequacies in the statutory and regulatory regime and gave certain commitments in that regard. I am deeply concerned that we are not moving forward further and faster.Other members are absolutely right when they say that this is not an isolated case—I have acknowledged that from the outset. We are hearing about more and more such cases across the country. Recently one Sunday newspaper investigated the issue and established from the Scottish Environment Protection Agency that in excess of 30 plants are subject to various forms of investigation. The four members present who have experience of the issue in their constituencies know that we are dealing with a major environmental nuisance to the community. The existing arrangements have proven somewhat inadequate in addressing that.My fundamental point is that I have read the minister's response and do not believe it to be satisfactory. It is a reiteration of the situation that prevailed a considerable time ago. I understand that a House of Lords ruling is awaited, but I am not convinced that consultation on legislative change must await that. There is a wide range of issues on which discussion and debate could usefully be initiated. I echo Des McNulty's suggestion that we seek other vehicles for addressing the problem.Even if the House of Lords rules that the statutory nuisance provisions of the Environmental Protection Act 1990 apply to odour from sewage treatment works, that does not deal with the wider legislative and regulatory issues that are involved—for example, the planning issues to which Des McNulty referred.I can do no more than request that the committee, in its response to PE517 and PE645 and, indeed, to the minister, goes beyond simply noting the current position. Every further month or six-month period that elapses during which work is not actively commenced to tighten up the regulatory and statutory regime in this area is time during which communities are suffering.I realise that this is the third time that I have echoed Des McNulty—it is becoming worrying—but he was right to touch on the complex issue that is the nature of Scottish Water and to say that it must have a basis on which to invest time, energy and, crucially, money in the development of its infrastructure. Odour is not treated seriously enough at the moment. It has been seen as the cinderella in the major investment projects that have been carried out at a range of pre-existing and new waste water treatment plants.Last week, several of us attended a briefing with Scottish Water and the chair, Professor Alan Alexander, essentially or loosely acknowledged that point, although I do not want to put words into his mouth. The Scottish Parliament has an opportunity to make a difference, but if the minister's response is accepted as it stands, people will start to lose faith in the Parliament's processes and powers to address an issue that affects thousands of people throughout Scotland.
Although my area has not submitted a petition, the Levenmouth sewage treatment works is experiencing similar problems. Scottish Water has been very good at coming to meetings, but one of my criticisms is about what I and the community perceive as its lack of urgency in taking steps. I echo what Susan Deacon said: unless Scottish Water comes under pressure from those who have the power to legislate—us—I suspect that it will feel no sense of urgency, particularly because of all the other pressures that it is under. If that happens, the situation will continue in which my constituency has been told that it might be up to a year before any remedial work can be planned and put in place. That is not acceptable to the community, but we cannot put any more pressure on Scottish Water and we hope that the committee can use its powers to do so.
No member of the committee has spoken thus far. The options that we have available to us require a varying amount of work. Option A says that we are happy with the Executive's response and that we will defer further consideration of the petition until the House of Lords appeal is resolved. We have had representations from colleagues who have odour problems in their patch saying that that is unsatisfactory. The second option is for us to write to the minister outlining further views and asking how the Executive plans to address the issues relating to odour control on landfill sites. The committee has been picking up on that issue and announced that in the report that was published yesterday. Thirdly, we could appoint a reporter to monitor developments in relation to noxious odours from waste water treatment plants and landfill sites, who could then report back to the committee.Noting what has been said today, it seems to me that there are two issues. One is a short-term enforcement issue on local authority powers. I wonder whether it would be helpful for the ministers to write to local authorities and tell them what the Executive's powers are at the moment. Guidance might come along later this year in the form of a voluntary code, but it would be no bad thing if ministers were to tell councils what they think the current provision is and to reinforce the fact that the House of Lords ruling will be binding under Scots law. Local authorities are allowed to take enforcement action and it might be useful if that fact was reinforced.Des McNulty has highlighted what we can do with the proposed Water Services (Scotland) Bill and the planning bill, which concerns permitted development rights. When we come to scrutinise those two bills—the water bill will be our responsibility and the planning bill will be the responsibility of the Communities Committee—we could gear up to make points at stage 1. Would it be worth it if we said now that that work had to be done? We could write to the ministers with our views and ask them to start considering those views in the context of both bills. Alternatively, we could appoint a reporter to do that for the committee and then we could tell Ross Finnie and Margaret Curran what we are looking for.I seek members' views. Do we do it ourselves now or do we write to the ministers and tell them that we expect those issues to be considered in the bills that are being prepared? We could write the letter tomorrow, or we could do the scoping work for the discussion of the principles of both the bills.
The first option—writing to the minister—is the obvious first course of action.
We have written to the Minister for Environment and Rural Development and have received feedback, so we would be writing to make a concrete proposal that the issue be addressed in the Water Services (Scotland) Bill. That would pick up Des McNulty's point that the current legislative framework under which Scottish Water works does not require it to address the issue to the extent that we think it needs to be addressed. We will flag that up now and, in effect, get the minister to do the work. Is that agreed?Members indicated agreement.
The second point is—this is an efficient use of time—permitted development powers under the proposed consolidated planning bill. Following the same principle, we will write to Margaret Curran and say that the issue has been highlighted and that it should be picked up in the planning bill. We do not want the issue to be dealt with at stage 3 of the two bills; we want the work to be done now so that it sends the message to a series of agencies that the issue is one that the Parliament feels is important and on which it wants legislative action. We should ask for a response from the minister and, if we think that the response is lukewarm, we can appoint a reporter and do the work ourselves. We are firing a shot across the Executive's bows and saying that the committee expects the issue to be included in the bills.Do members feel that that would be a good way to proceed? It picks up Susan Deacon's point about time scale and raising the issue up the agenda so that people outside the Parliament can see that we think it important and want it to be dealt with through legislation.Members indicated agreement.
I suggest a third letter, which would be to Ross Finnie in the context of the quality and standards consultation that he will be opening in February 2004 and would say that we seek higher standards of odour control, which would have to be factored into the way in which arrangements between the water industry commissioner and Scottish Water would be addressed as part of that consultation. Again, we would be asking the civil servants to do early work on how that could best be achieved.
It might be worth copying our correspondence to—I have forgotten the technical term—the environmental regulator for the water industry, as opposed to the water industry commissioner. They are different: one deals with environmental standards and the other is about the water industry as a whole.
You mean SEPA and the water industry commissioner: the WIC deals with economic aspects, which have been a barrier, and SEPA deals with environmental considerations and enforcement.
We should flag up that we are taking an early interest in the matter and that it will be coming to those to whom we are writing. Is there anything else that we should do at this stage to ensure that we have swept up all the issues properly?
You talked about a letter to local authorities outlining to them what measures can be taken at the moment. In my area, we have found that the most difficult thing is measuring the odour. That difficulty needs to be pointed out. Scottish Water is putting monitors around the site in my area at the moment.Secondly, the definition of nuisance seems to be quite loose. We need to tighten up how we measure and define nuisance. My constituents who are living with the odour would say that it is a nuisance, but the issue is how the local authority determines nuisance.I would appreciate it if those points could be clarified.
Those are important issues to put in front of the ministers. I clarify that my suggestion is that Ross Finnie should write to local authorities to clarify the current legal position, but it is important to put your points about measurement and definition into a letter. The other ministerial letter that we need to write is to the Minister for Communities, and, out of courtesy, we should copy that letter to the convener of the Communities Committee. Des McNulty, as a local member, also requested that we write to the convener of the Finance Committee to recommend that the issue be addressed.That is a lot of letter writing, but it is quite a concrete way in which we can flag up the issues. We will make a judgment on the responses that we get from the ministers and decide whether we are happy with them or whether we feel that we need to take ownership of the issue and appoint a reporter.
I want to pick up on a point that Marilyn Livingstone made. There is an issue about the method of measuring odours and the standard that is set for that. There is also a related issue about having a cordon sanitaire around such plants, which is to do with how close they should be to residential and other areas. Planning is the other way in which the problem can be dealt with. It is probably worth flagging up that we want both those issues to be considered.
We certainly picked up that issue during our waste inquiry. As members will be aware, we identified the need for minimum distances between new landfill sites and such areas, and suggested that the minister should adopt that.I think that we have swept up all the issues that are raised by the petition for today. I hope that members of the Communities Committee will be able to read the Official Report of today's meeting and will realise that we were persuaded by the arguments that people have made, which need to be acted on. That picks up on Susan Deacon's point.Are we agreed on the way forward for the petition?Members indicated agreement.
I thank members—especially visiting members—for their comments.
In this meeting
Everything on 19 Nov 2003 →- Scottish Parliament Environment and Rural Development Committee Wednesday 19 November 2003 (Morning) Committee business · 1
- Nature Conservation (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 358
- Petitions Petitions · 1
- Petitions Petitions · 3
- Petitions Petitions · 26
- Petitions Petitions · 6
- Petitions Petitions · 9
- Petitions Petitions · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.