For me, it is perfect not only that I can meet the committee but that the meeting has been prepared in the way that you describe, because the purpose of having somebody such as me wandering around Europe is for us to get away from the ivory tower in Brussels and find out what is going on and what we are missing at the European level. I am therefore very pleased to have the committee’s time.
The digital agenda for Europe was launched in the first year of the Barroso 2 college, which is now at the end of its five-year mandate—the new team will be in place on 1 November, I hope. This is therefore a moment when we look at what has happened, what has surprised us and what we are missing. In the area of most concern to the committee, which is infrastructure, what is happening is that connectivity is improving across Europe. However, what we are missing is a sense that the speed of infrastructure roll-out in almost all the member states is fast enough to meet growing business and societal needs. On the one hand, we are getting there rather slowly but, on the other hand, the question that emerges is whether there is now a measurable gap between where any society or community in Europe needs to be to attract new investment to build jobs and a strong society, and where it is.
Europe, not uniquely in the world, is underweight in spending on electronic infrastructure, as it is in every other area of infrastructure spending. In the golden age of rail, in the late 19th century, a lot of the riches of Britain were invested in railways, some of which survived for only 20 or 30 years and were vanity projects. We could argue, taking a Treasury view, that money was being wasted, but actually the infrastructure was there. If you are growing a garden, you want to allow things to grow a bit, and then you prune them back, and that is what we did in those days. Coming forward to today, I argue that we are billions short of the rate of investment that we need. That does not necessarily mean that taxpayers’ money should be used to bridge the gap, although that model is being used in places such as South Korea and Australia, but we need to be conscious that there is a gap.
The question that then arises is whether we should wait until the need is demonstrated or build it so that they may come. That is an economic strategy challenge. One choice is to build the infrastructure and see what grows around 100 megabit connectivity, rather like what happens with a motorway; another choice is to be more cautious and leave it to the market.
The difficulty with the market in this field is that, as we all know, we have a market that is not competitive. Electronic communications is a rootedly uncompetitive market. That is why we have organisations such as the Office of Communications across Europe and why we have ex-ante and not ex-post competition rules. It is hard to generate market-led investment at sufficient levels in a market that is not fully contestable. On the infrastructure side, we can say that we have more to do.
More broadly—this is my second big message—when I took this job in 2010 and we launched the strategy, a lot of people in Europe said, “We know digital is nice to have, but it’s interesting that it is coming first in the strategic initiatives of this college.” People were a bit surprised about that. In subsequent years, as can be seen from the positions of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, McKinsey & Company, the Boston Consulting Group and so on, the idea that digital is crucial to the survival of any society has gone completely mainstream. There has been a shift with regard to recognition that digital is everywhere and we need to have it in our mindset, whatever our core business is.
Even given that situation, however, we can highlight some lacunae that we need to work on. One is skills. Digital literacy is still inadequate, whether we are talking about retired and old people or the under-10s. That can be addressed through establishing coding clubs, having programming as a core part of the curriculum and having a clear map of where business needs are not met by our education system.
The second lacuna concerns the need to get small and medium-sized enterprises to be information technology ready, which does not mean buying them a new computer. Most SMEs need to change their business model, which will enable them to sell to more new markets. That can work right down to the microenterprise level. For example, in rural Connemara, we have had some interesting experiments that have shown that a few hundred euros here or there can help people to understand how their cottage enterprise—some are literally run from a cottage—can get online in a way that can transform their prospects.
The third lacuna concerns the individual consumer and citizen angle. It is that neither e-government nor e-commerce is growing as a proportion of the way in which we live our lives as fast as we think that they could, or as fast as we see them growing in countries where the infrastructure is stronger, the skills are in place and self-confidence is higher, such as Norway.
My sense is that the next college of commissioners will need to have not only a strong digital commissioner in Brussels but a digital college and, I hope, a digital president of the college of commissioners so that, in every area, the digital aspects of the transformation that we need, whether it is in education, infrastructure or business strategy, will come first. That would mean that, in 2015, we will quickly level up some of the areas of policy that have been lagging in the past four or five years and in which we hope to do better.
Everything that I have said is directly relevant to Scotland, which is a European leader in some areas, such as e-health. I mean that literally, as Scotland helps to lead and co-ordinate work across Europe in those areas. Similarly, the information and communications technology team in the University of Edinburgh is a global, as well as a European, beacon.
My sense is that many of the policies that are being rolled out in Scotland are pretty much in line with what I am saying, so I do not have a sense that I am coming to teach anybody anything. However, seen from the European level, those are the strengths and weaknesses that we have discovered in our journey over the past three or four years.