To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-02074)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Salmond SNP 6
- Johann Lamont Lab 5
- Neil Findlay Lab 1
- Tricia Marwick 1
The record
13 contributionsEngagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
Last year, the Scottish Government again missed its accident and emergency target, meaning that thousands of Scots had to wait more than four hours for treatment. The First Minister’s response was to lower the target. According to Audit Scotland this week, the Scottish Government is not just missing the original target; it is now missing the new, easier-to-reach target as well. More patients are suffering.
Last year, the First Minister promised action. This year, we learn that the number of those who are waiting more than four hours for treatment has tripled on his watch. When will his actions start to prove effective?
Of course, Audit Scotland was referring to the statistics for 2012-13, which is also the year that Johann Lamont is talking about. Let me first say what we are doing about the situation, because that is the real issue.
I do not know whether Johann Lamont heard Dr Martin McKechnie, the vice-chair of the Scottish board of the College of Emergency Medicine, on the radio this morning. Dr McKechnie said:
“We have had a lot of support and investment in the last 18 months from the Government and we are beginning, I hope, to feel and to see the effects of some of these changes.”
The year 2012-13 was a hugely tough one for the emergency services of the national health service in Scotland. We had a substantial number of ward closures because of norovirus. However, the emergency action plan that was announced by the Cabinet Secretary for Health and Wellbeing has been welcomed by the profession, as indeed has the substantial increase in the number of consultants, staff and facilities around Scotland. Working together, we will bring about the improvement that Scotland requires and which the patients of Scotland deserve. That improvement is happening in the statistics already and, if Johann Lamont was fair about it, she would note that Audit Scotland remarked on the substantial improvement since the yearly statistics to the end of financial year 2012-13.
Yes, but Audit Scotland pointed out that the improvement was against the worst ever statistics in this area.
I know that the First Minister will have plenty of facts and figures to prove that there is not really a problem, but we know that there is a problem in our hospitals because healthcare workers are telling us so. Let us hear what patients think. Margaret Watt, chairwoman of the Scottish Patients Association, said:
“People have died as they couldn’t get into hospital because they were kept waiting in A&E. The distress it causes patients and families is huge but the situation seems to get worse year on year. I have never known it as bad as this and our national treasure, the NHS, is becoming a nightmare for patients.”
Last year alone, more than 100,000 people had to wait for more than four hours—that is more than half a working day. Nearly 1,500 people waited more than 12 hours for treatment. The First Minister has been in office for seven years—why have waiting times trebled on his watch?
I do not know how familiar Johann Lamont is with the statistics but, as she said that the waiting times were the worst ever in A and E, I will just correct her. I will give her the exact statistics and then I hope that she will be able to admit how wrong she was.
Johann Lamont was right in quoting the statistics for 2012-13: 103,782 people waited more than four hours. That is exactly the situation that we are trying to tackle. That is out of total attendances at A and E of 1,618,610. We are seeking to tackle those figures and bring them down to what we believe are more acceptable levels.
However, Johann Lamont said that those were the worst figures ever. I will give her the figures for 2006-07, when she was a minister. In that year, there were 1,342,737 attendances—some 300,000 fewer than there were in 2012-13—and the number of people waiting more than four hours was 125,753.
Now that Johann Lamont has heard those figures, will she withdraw the suggestion that 2012-13 was the worst ever year, as clearly it was not? Will she acknowledge that, although we are trying to improve performance, it is substantially better than it was when she was a minister? Will she agree to concentrate on the action plan that will serve the people and patients of our community in the best possible way?
The degree of complacency in that response is staggering—let us go back to our comfort zone in which a politician makes a debating point, rather than responding to what patients, staff and Audit Scotland are saying. The reality is that the First Minister does not seem to understand or care about the problem.
We have a social care crisis, which is fuelling an A and E crisis. People attending A and E need beds, but they cannot get them because patients are being parked in inappropriate wards, waiting to be discharged but with nowhere to go. Hard-working nurses and doctors are not to blame; they are doing their best. Is the First Minister going to get serious about the crisis, or is he just going to fiddle with the target again?
Johann Lamont should accept that it is rather more than a debating point to point out that she is fundamentally mistaken in her claim that 2012-13 was the worst year ever. I am afraid that 125,753 is a much bigger figure than the one that she cited.
Johann Lamont accuses me of complacency, but I reject that totally. The health secretary has set out the action plan, which has been widely welcomed by health professionals. This Government, unlike the Labour Government, pledged to protect real spending in the national health service and we have done so.
The figure for patients seen within four hours increased last December, in the heart of winter, to 93 per cent. We want to get that figure higher, to the interim target of 95 per cent and then on to 98 per cent. If Johann Lamont wants to hear about complacency, perhaps she should recall that, when she was a minister and Andy Kerr was health minister—it is quite recent history—the figure was 87.5 per cent.
Take some responsibility.
Mr Findlay!
The figure of 87.5 per cent was hailed by Andy Kerr as showing
“that the vast majority of A & E departments are meeting the four hour target ... Investment ... in the NHS is paying off”.
For her party’s credibility and her own, Johann Lamont should explain why, if 87.5 per cent was wonderful when she was a minister, 93 per cent under the current Government is such a disaster. Will she accept that, thanks to the hard-working professionals in the national health service, there is an improvement, which we intend to drive up further, thanks to the investment plan? Will she acknowledge that, when she comes to the chamber and makes up figures because she cannot substantiate her points, she and her party are fundamentally lacking in any credibility on the national health service? [Applause.]
The fact that the Scottish National Party back benchers respond so warmly to that answer tells us everything about the problem that we face. Dr Nikki Thompson, chair of the British Medical Association Scottish consultants committee, said:
“medical staff are working under considerable strain to try to maintain high quality care in an overstretched system; clearly this is not sustainable.”
However, with an unsustainable NHS, what we get is a First Minister coming up with unsustainable answers.
Let us be honest about what is happening here and what the Scottish Government’s approach is. It is revealed in the following line in the Audit Scotland report:
“The Scottish Government has indicated it will review the 95 per cent interim target after September 2014.”
What could possibly be happening in September 2014 that matters more? We are not prepared to wait for his referendum before we make sure that the ill and the injured do not have to wait for treatment. Is it not the case that the First Minister cares more about the constitution of our country than the health of our people?
In dealing with the situation, we have announced the £50 million emergency care plan, and we are reviewing the 95 per cent figure towards the end of the year because we want to drive it upwards towards 98 per cent.
I have been critical of the Labour Party on the health service because neither in 2007 nor in the run-up to the 2011 elections would it commit to protecting the health service budget in real terms. I remember Lord McConnell saying that every other service, including the health service, would have to cut its cloth because he was going to put all the consequentials into education.
Another Administration in these islands—a Labour Administration—decided, because of the pressure of spending cuts from Westminster, that it could not protect the health service in real terms. I have the figures for emergency care in Wales. Not on a single occasion over the past few months has even 90 per cent been reached there, never mind 93 per cent. Labour has failed every time.
In contrast, we have a rising number of staff in the national health service in Scotland. We had 127,000 in September 2006, before we took office, and we had 135,000 at the end of 2013. We have a rising number of medical staff—the number has gone up from 9,600 to 11,438. We have rising numbers of staff in nursing and midwifery. That has all been made possible because we have protected the health service in real terms. If the Labour record in office in this place was so lamentable, and if its current record in Wales is so much worse than that of this Administration, how on earth can Labour have any credibility on the national health service?
Why not welcome the investment that has been put in to drive up the figures for emergency care? That has been welcomed by the health professionals. Labour should get behind the action plan and it should stop trying to rewrite the dismal history of its Administration or the present practice in Wales.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 8 May 2014 →- Planning (Falkirk Council) Questions · 4
- Policing (Dumfries and Galloway) Questions · 4
- Commonwealth Games (Rail Services) Questions · 7
- “Review of Fatal Accident Inquiry Legislation” Questions · 4
- Opencast Mines (South Scotland) Questions · 4
- Living Wage (Government Contracts) Questions · 8
- Genetically Modified Crops Questions · 4
- Repeat Prescriptions Questions · 7
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 13
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Population Increase First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Free Personal Care First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Alcohol Minimum Pricing First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Skin Cancer Members’ business · 19
- Care and Caring Statement · 27
- Life Sciences Debate · 65
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 2
- Decision Time Decision time · 4
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.