1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-2301)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Salmond SNP 8
- Iain Gray Lab 6
- Alex Fergusson 4
- Andy Kerr Lab 2
The record
20 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S3F-2301)
Later today, we will publish our full analysis of the United Kingdom Government’s budget. That will be made available in the Scottish Parliament information centre, so it will be available to all members. It shows that, after taking account of all consequentials, the Scottish budget—the departmental expenditure limit—will be 1.3 per cent lower in real terms next year than this year. That is a cut of some £400 million, at a cost of 4,000 Scottish jobs.
Last week, the First Minister asked:
“is it not time for us to unite as a Parliament to demand that there be no cuts in public spending in Scotland next year“?
In fact, yesterday’s budget put the First Minister’s budget up by £82 million. He can reprofile the figures any way he wants; the fact is that he will have more than £1 billion more to spend next year than he has had this year. Is it not time that he had the good grace to welcome that?
“is it not time for us to unite as a Parliament to demand that there be no cuts in public spending in Scotland next year“?
In fact, yesterday’s budget put the First Minister’s budget up by £82 million. He can reprofile the figures any way he wants; the fact is that he will have more than £1 billion more to spend next year than he has had this year. Is it not time that he had the good grace to welcome that?
It is a great misfortune for Iain Gray that he did not anticipate being told what the actual figures are before he asked his question. The analysis, which will be available in SPICe for everyone this afternoon, shows beyond any peradventure, and including the £76 million of consequentials, that the DEL budget will be 1.3 per cent lower in real terms next year. For the first time in donkey’s years, the Scottish budget will be lower in real terms.
Labour members cannot escape from the consequences of cuts from Westminster. They could not escape when the first £500 million cut was mooted, which Iain Gray was not sure about. They could not escape when, last autumn, he called for capital acceleration and was snubbed by the Chancellor of the Exchequer, and they cannot escape today, when the final figures are published for next year, showing the first real-terms decline in the Scottish budget for a generation, thanks to the Labour Party at Westminster.
Labour members cannot escape from the consequences of cuts from Westminster. They could not escape when the first £500 million cut was mooted, which Iain Gray was not sure about. They could not escape when, last autumn, he called for capital acceleration and was snubbed by the Chancellor of the Exchequer, and they cannot escape today, when the final figures are published for next year, showing the first real-terms decline in the Scottish budget for a generation, thanks to the Labour Party at Westminster.
Here are the actual figures that are in SPICe. There is, taking account of the funding from next year that Alex Salmond asked permission to bring forward and spend, an increase of 0.9 per cent. That is the actual figure. He talked about accelerated capital. Yesterday’s budget provided a £2 billion capital fund for renewables, of which we can expect £1 billion of capital investment to come right here, right now, to Scotland.
What else did the First Minister say last week? He said that it was time
”to demand a reflationary package”.—[Official Report, 18 March 2010; c 24753.]
Yesterday, we saw more money for Scottish pensioners, more money for Scottish children and families, more money for Scottish first-time buyers—who, by the way, are still waiting for the help that they were promised three years ago—and more money to help to create jobs in Scotland. Surely it is time for the First Minister to welcome those measures and to get on with his job.
What else did the First Minister say last week? He said that it was time
”to demand a reflationary package”.—[Official Report, 18 March 2010; c 24753.]
Yesterday, we saw more money for Scottish pensioners, more money for Scottish children and families, more money for Scottish first-time buyers—who, by the way, are still waiting for the help that they were promised three years ago—and more money to help to create jobs in Scotland. Surely it is time for the First Minister to welcome those measures and to get on with his job.
Iain Gray gave the game away when he said “taking account of” the capital acceleration. That capital acceleration has been spent this year and, therefore, cannot be spent next year.
You’re a numptie.
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order. Mr Kerr, I will not have accusations of that type made in this chamber. I hope that you will withdraw that remark.
I apologise, and I withdraw the remark.
There is certainly no offence taken, although I have to say that hearing Andy Kerr using that unparliamentary description takes the biscuit.
As I was saying, that capital acceleration cannot be spent next year because, despite Iain Gray’s having joined me last autumn in calling for capital acceleration next year in order to provide a stimulus that would allow the recovery of the Scottish economy to continue, the request was refused in the pre-budget report, as Iain Gray might have noticed. In spite of the fact that briefings had suggested that the request would be dealt with in this year’s budget, no capital acceleration or stimulus package was forthcoming yesterday.
In terms of the chancellor’s desire to impress the markets, I do not think that he has pulled it off. One informed commentator said:
“overall, and despite the warnings about withdrawal of support too early, the fiscal stance is being tightened in 2010-11 by 1 % of GDP”.
Where were the warnings coming from? They came from that centrepiece of profligacy, the International Monetary Fund, which was warning about tightening the fiscal stance. However, the United Kingdom has become the only country in the G20—with the exception of Argentina—to tighten its fiscal stance for the coming year in the teeth of the recession, instead of giving us the sort of stimulus package that every other country has endorsed.
As I was saying, that capital acceleration cannot be spent next year because, despite Iain Gray’s having joined me last autumn in calling for capital acceleration next year in order to provide a stimulus that would allow the recovery of the Scottish economy to continue, the request was refused in the pre-budget report, as Iain Gray might have noticed. In spite of the fact that briefings had suggested that the request would be dealt with in this year’s budget, no capital acceleration or stimulus package was forthcoming yesterday.
In terms of the chancellor’s desire to impress the markets, I do not think that he has pulled it off. One informed commentator said:
“overall, and despite the warnings about withdrawal of support too early, the fiscal stance is being tightened in 2010-11 by 1 % of GDP”.
Where were the warnings coming from? They came from that centrepiece of profligacy, the International Monetary Fund, which was warning about tightening the fiscal stance. However, the United Kingdom has become the only country in the G20—with the exception of Argentina—to tighten its fiscal stance for the coming year in the teeth of the recession, instead of giving us the sort of stimulus package that every other country has endorsed.
There we have it again: he is a grievance, not a Government. He will not take responsibility for his own decision—a correct one—to accelerate capital. He will not take responsibility for his Scottish Futures Trust fiasco killing jobs. He will not take responsibility for the more than 2,000 teachers who are on the dole. He will not take responsibility for the cuts in our enterprise and university budgets. He shouts, he screams and he stamps his feet to hide the fact that he has no idea what to do with the money that he has.
What about those consequentials of £82 million? What is he going to do with them?
What about those consequentials of £82 million? What is he going to do with them?
In one weekend last year, the Labour Party, at its conference, made annual spending commitments of £89.6 million. In the course of the year, it has made further spending commitments of £345 million. As a matter of arithmetic, that is four and a half times the budget consequentials that were announced by the chancellor yesterday. That comes on top of the fact that, as we have already established, next year’s budget in Scotland will, thanks to Westminster, fall in real terms for the first time in a generation, as the price that Scotland must pay for Labour’s economic failure.
Iain Gray asks about responsibility. We want to take responsibility for the Scottish economy not only because it would stop the failures from Westminster but because it would enable us to mobilise Scottish resources to ensure Scottish recovery.
Iain Gray asks about responsibility. We want to take responsibility for the Scottish economy not only because it would stop the failures from Westminster but because it would enable us to mobilise Scottish resources to ensure Scottish recovery.
I asked about £82 million of resources, and the First Minister has not the faintest idea what he is going to do with them.
Yesterday, Alistair Darling created and protected thousands of jobs in Scotland, including 150,000 jobs with the green investment fund, 5,000 jobs—
Members: Fantasy.
Yesterday, Alistair Darling created and protected thousands of jobs in Scotland, including 150,000 jobs with the green investment fund, 5,000 jobs—
Members: Fantasy.
Members say “Fantasy.” What was Alex Salmond’s contribution to the renewables industry this week? It was to delay his £10 million saltire fund by a further two years to 2017. Alistair Darling created and protected 150,000 green jobs, 5,000 jobs from the future jobs fund, and 10,000 jobs in the games industry through tax breaks. That was yesterday. Today, a further 4,000 jobs have been secured on the Clyde. How many jobs did Alex Salmond create yesterday?
I advise Iain Gray strongly not to take the Secretary of State for Scotland’s press statements too literally. Let us look at the claimed 150,000 jobs from the green investment bank. The assumption is that it will take £200,000 million—that is £200 billion—to develop the offshore green energy resource. In that light, a green investment bank of £2 billion represents 1 per cent of the cash and funds that it will take to generate the offshore renewables revolution. The best estimate, because of the co-operation on acceleration of the Scottish Government’s plans for the licensing of offshore renewables in wind, wave and tidal energy, is that that will generate 25,000 jobs in Scotland by the end of the decade. The idea that there will be 150,000 jobs is total fantasy. It was made up by the Secretary of State for Scotland on a whim and it has now been repeated by his sap in this Parliament, Iain Gray. It is incredible. [Interruption.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Just as I think it is wrong for somebody to call another member “a numptie”, I do not think that the word “sap” is advisable, First Minister.
I willingly apologise to Iain Gray. I withdraw “sap” and insert “placeperson”. We can compare the funds that will be available through the green bank with the $25 billion that the United States is investing in a similar initiative. [Interruption.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order.
Will Iain Gray try to get things in perspective? Yes, we have an enormous renewable energy resource off the shores of Scotland and this Government is hugely in advance in exploiting that compared with anything that is happening south of the border, but the real opportunity for Scotland is to control that resource and our other energy resources in order to get the sort of prosperity and long-term growth that we are so clearly being denied by the dead hand of Westminster. [Applause.]
Alex Fergusson
The Presiding Officer · Galloway and Upper Nithsdale
link
Order.
In this meeting
Everything on 25 Mar 2010 →- Business Motion Business motions · 1
- Public Services Reform (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 210
- Teachers (Workforce Planning) Questions · 4
- Speech and Language Therapy Services Questions · 7
- NHS Tayside (Meetings) Questions · 7
- Beauly to Denny Power Line (Community Engagement) Questions · 6
- Transport (Ayrshire) Questions · 10
- Central Heating Scheme Questions · 9
- “The Government Economic Strategy” Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 20
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Mephedrone First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Child Protection First Minister’s Questions · 6
- United Kingdom Budget First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Central Scotland Fire and Rescue Service Questions · 6
- Victims and Witnesses (Rights and Protection) Questions · 4
- Police Numbers (Highlands and Islands) Questions · 4
- Knife Crime (Lothian and Borders) Questions · 6
- Parades (Strathclyde) Questions · 4
- Cashback for Communities (Lothians) Questions · 4
- Community Safety Questions · 6
- Integrated Maritime Policy Questions · 4
- Recycling (Glasgow) Questions · 9
- Illegal Waste Disposal Questions · 4
- “Inquiry into Future Support for Agriculture in Scotland: The Interim Report” Questions · 6
- Farming (Regulatory Burden) Questions · 4
- Commonwealth Games 2014 (Environment) Questions · 4
- Flood Protection (Aberdeenshire) Questions · 9
- Point of Order Procedure · 2
- Public Services Reform (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 85
- Public Services Reform (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 31
- United Kingdom Budget Statement · 31
- Decision Time Decision time · 3
- Gilmerton Core Store Members’ business · 8
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.