John Wilson mentioned some of the correspondence that we have received. He is right that our role is to set policy and that the bodies involved—local authorities, for example—carry out those policies and achieve the agreed outcomes.
I am somewhat concerned by the reference in the Scottish Public Sector Ombudsman’s submission to
“Our lack of direct experience in this area”.
I am not suggesting that we get involved in the legalities of settlement agreements and so on, but if the SPSO does not have this kind of experience, it should hurry up and get some. As part of the landscape of public service, it should at least have an understanding of what is going on.
John Wilson also mentioned the Audit Scotland response, which says:
“The Audit Scotland guidance does not go as far as recommending specific arrangements or processes.”
If the policy is in place, we must ensure that there is—and secure a means whereby there is—some consistency about the processes for securing the interests of those involved and diminish, if not eliminate, the problems that create the need for whistleblowing, or at least eliminate the fear felt by somebody who whistleblows. The same issue has come up in the health service, and major steps have been taken there to deal with the matter.
I also note that the minister’s letter says that local authorities are
“expected to have in place appropriate policies”.
They should not be expected to have policies in place—they should already have policies in place. If we are to secure the society and openness of Government that we wish, such scenarios are, frankly, wholly unacceptable.