We will see.
I welcome the opportunity to speak to my motion. As members will be aware, my colleague Neil Findlay moved a similar motion last year, and I do so for the same reasons today. Teachers, like many other public sector workers, have had their wages squeezed, have been subjected to the cost-of-living crisis and have been put under increasing pressure from cuts that are overstretching vital public services such as school education.
For two years, teachers have had their pay frozen and they are now finally receiving a long overdue 1 per cent rise. However, many teachers will be concerned that, yet again this year, they are set to pay an increase in pension contributions. In effect, that means that there is no 1 per cent pay rise for teachers, as they have been given the rise in the one hand while money has been taken out of the other hand to pay for an increase in pension contributions.
When we discussed Neil Findlay’s motion last year, the cabinet secretary said:
“At a time of wage restraint and financial hardship, it is wrong to ask such public employees to pay more for their pensions in this way”.—Official Report, Education and Culture Committee, 26 March 2013; c 2140.
I agree. Therefore, the question is: why have Scottish teachers yet again been asked to bear something that is wrong?
The general secretary of the EIS has described the latest increase as
“an austerity tax on hard-working teachers.”
As members will be aware, the EIS has welcomed my motion. It has pointed out that this is the third increase in three years and that it will increase the average pension contribution that is deducted from teachers’ pay to 9.6 per cent of their salary. That means that the amount that is deducted from teachers’ pay will have increased by 50 per cent since April 2012, from 6.4 per cent to 9.6 per cent for the average teacher. For classroom teachers on the main grade pay scale, the three years of increases will mean that they will be paying more than £1,000 more per year in pension contributions. The EIS has said:
“The objective of the Coalition Government was not to protect the low paid or to minimise opt outs. It was to raise revenue.”
The Scottish Government has accepted that objective.
The Scottish Government has also decided to pass on the increases in the same tiered way as the coalition Government. The EIS has expressed concern that teachers who are progressing by increments through the main grade scale should have been protected. That point was raised last year and was supported by hundreds of emails from teachers, but the Scottish Government ignored it.
In October 2013, the Scottish Secondary Teachers Association conducted a survey of members, more than half of whom expressed concern about their likely financial situation post-retirement. Almost half said that they were ready to take industrial action to protect their pensions.
Teachers are working flat out and are under a great deal of pressure to prepare children for new exams and to implement the new highers. They deserve far more support and recognition than they are getting. They deserve far better from the Scottish Government, which is simply passing on a Tory teacher tax.
I move,
That the Education and Culture Committee recommends that the Teachers’ Superannuation (Scotland) Amendment Regulations 2014 (SSI 2014/44) be annulled.
10:30