To ask the First Minister what assessment the Scottish Government has made of the cost of an independent Scotland’s welfare system and whether it would seek the co-operation of the United Kingdom Government in its implementation. (S4F-01981)
Official Report · Chamber
Independence (Welfare System)
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Salmond SNP 3
- Alex Johnstone Con 2
- John Mason SNP 1
The record
6 contributionsAs Alex Johnstone will know, the expenditure on social protection as a share of gross domestic product is estimated to have been lower in Scotland than in the UK in each of the past five years, accounting for 15.5 per cent of GDP in Scotland and 16 per cent in the UK in 2012-13.
Alex Johnstone will also know that the transitional period of shared administration was recommended by the expert working group on welfare. We agree with that view.
I am aware of the First Minister’s figures, which he has given in previous answers. However, it is clear that moneys in the Scottish budget as a whole are already allocated to other priorities and that, with a theoretical deficit of £12.1 billion built into the figures for the last full year, any additional money that is promised to the welfare system—as it is regularly promised by the First Minister’s back benchers—will have to be accounted for somewhere. Can he tell us whether it would be through cuts in other areas of expenditure, increases in taxation or additional borrowing that he would account for the £12.1 billion deficit that he would have to address?
Alex Johnstone will see, if he examines the white paper, that—as I pointed out to Ruth Davidson—the projections for 2016-17 show Scotland being in a stronger fiscal position than the rest of the UK during that period.
In terms of the white paper, I will point out some details. We have pointed out that
“Scotland delivers almost all parts of the current UK benefits system to people living in Scotland from locations within Scotland”.
That is at paragraph 4.50. Also,
“Scotland provides a wide range of services to England ... such as working age benefit processing for London and services for pensioners in England, and involve a claimant count measured in millions rather than thousands.”
I make that point because Alex Johnstone talks about deficits in Scotland, but seems to be totally oblivious to the fact that the deficit of the United Kingdom—George Osborne’s deficit—is more than £100 billion.
Some appreciation of the plank of wood in his chancellor’s eye would perhaps help Alex Johnstone before he looks for specks of sawdust in the Scottish Government’s eye.
Does the First Minister agree that the best way to deliver a fairer society is not just to tinker at the edges of devolution but to enable this place to have control over the whole social security system, the tax system and the statutory minimum wage?
In fairness, I will point out to Alex Johnstone before I answer the question that my previous answer was for the benefit of Willie Rennie, who asked me last week to quote the Bible more often, but it turns out that he is not in the chamber.
I agree with John Mason that only the full fiscal powers of independence will allow key decisions on tax, wealth and employment policy to be made in Scotland by those who have Scotland’s best interests at heart.
The figures that I read out earlier with regard to the impact on families of all the tax and benefits measures came from the UK Government’s own papers that were published yesterday. I cannot understand, given the extent and depth of the recession and the suffering that has been endured by people in all categories of income, why on earth the second biggest impact of all should, in a situation in which all families are less well off on average, fall on those who are least able to pay and to bear that burden.
That is why I think that a Scottish Government of any political complexion would better reflect the general interest of the Scottish people, and why we must—we absolutely must—have tax and benefits under the control of this Parliament.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 20 Mar 2014 →- Energy Sector (Employment) Questions · 5
- Literacy and Numeracy Targets (Fife Schools) Questions · 3
- NHS Fife (Meetings) Questions · 6
- School Rolls (Optimum Size) Questions · 4
- Ministerial Engagements Questions · 6
- Marine Protected Areas Questions · 6
- Co-operative Group (Agricultural Assets) Questions · 6
- Offensive Behaviour at Football and Threatening Communications (Scotland) Act 2012 Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Free Prescriptions First Minister’s Questions · 10
- United Kingdom Budget First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Human Trafficking First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Independence (Welfare System) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Miners’ Strike 1984-85 (Anniversary) Members’ business · 24
- Business Motion Business motions · 1
- Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill: Stage 3 Bill debate · 56
- Bankruptcy and Debt Advice (Scotland) Bill Bill debate · 24
- Decision Time Decision time · 1
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.