Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 13 March 2014 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 23 contributions · 5 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

23 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day.

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

Engagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

The Government’s revenue and spending figures show that Scotland is in deficit to the tune of £12 billion, which is the equivalent of all our health spending. Oil revenues have gone down by more than £4 billion in just one year, which is the equivalent of all our spending on schools. If Scotland were independent, how would the First Minister cope with that revenue drop—by cutting services or by raising taxes?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

I do not know whether Johann Lamont has come across the fact, but the United Kingdom is in deficit to the tune of more than £100 billion in the years that she has noted. The key point, which we have put forward before, is who is in the relatively stronger position. Johann Lamont knows—we have discussed this many times—that, if we look at the past five years, as John Swinney has just mentioned, or at the past 30 years, the answer is that Scotland has been in the stronger fiscal position relative to the United Kingdom.

That is, of course, in the context of the United Kingdom. Our case for independence is that by marshalling the great natural and human resources of Scotland we can build a fair and just society in this country.

As so many of the better together notaries have said on so many occasions that they do not doubt that Scotland is an economically viable successful country, and given that Standard & Poor’s, which is not noted for its optimism on such matters, said it only two weeks ago, can Johann Lamont not bring herself to concede that, economically, this country can build that prosperous and just future for the Scottish people?

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

All that was very interesting, but that was not the question that I asked—there is nothing new there.

The First Minister has in the past criticised me, but it appears that he is saying today that a £4 billion revenue drop is just a wee thing: something that we do not have to worry about.

Michael Russell SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning · Argyll and Bute
link

A great wee line.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

Indeed—exactly. I have learned my lesson, and perhaps he should do the same.

The First Minister has talked of a stabilisation fund, but he could put money in that only by cutting services or by raising taxes. Last year, he said that Scotland had a relative surplus in comparison with the rest of the United Kingdom. Will he now confirm that the rest of the United Kingdom has a relative surplus in comparison with Scotland’s relative deficit? Can he explain how he would maintain our schools when he has lost the equivalent of an entire schools budget? Would he cut services or raise taxes? [Interruption.]

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

I am delighted that we will no longer hear about the wee things. For those who did not understand the allusion, Johann Lamont is referring to when she seemed to think that employment policy, competition policy, control of oil and gas revenues and control of nuclear weapons were just the “wee things”, which it did not matter if Scotland controlled.

Those are of course the big things, but now that that lesson has been learned—

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

Now that that lesson has been learned, the something-for-nothing society will, I hope, also disappear from the Johann Lamont lexicon.

Let us look at the relative position of Scotland and the rest of the United Kingdom. If we look at the years going backwards, there was a difference of £283 per head last year, which was the figure that was published yesterday. However, there was a positive £489 difference the year before, £214 the year before that, £75 the year before that and £1,100 in 2008-09. That is a total of £1,600 per head. Over the past five years, that is how Scotland would have been relatively better off than the UK as a whole.

Given that—because it amounts to £8,000 million—would it not be possible that Johann Lamont would concede that, over that period of time, we could have borrowed less or invested more, or had the stabilisation fund to make sure that, over that period, we could use that wealth to benefit the people of Scotland? Or does she still think that it is a wee thing that we would have been £8 billion better off, or £1,600 per head?

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

It is the First Minister who seems to be entirely relaxed about the fact that he would have £4 billion less to spend on jobs, education and support for our young people than we would have otherwise. This is the man who lectures us about economics, and he gives us an answer like that—numbers that make no sense whatsoever.

I am not even asking the First Minister something difficult, such as what currency he would raise taxes in. Whether it is groats, bawbees or Armenian drams—[Interruption.]

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

—in the past 12 months, Scotland has lost more than £4 billion of oil revenue. At the moment, that loss is borne across the United Kingdom because we are in the United Kingdom. If Scotland were outside the United Kingdom, I ask again: how would the First Minister pay for that loss in revenue—by cutting services or by raising taxes?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

I point out that Scotland loses out on £5.5 billion of oil revenues, because they are the oil revenues for the past year from Scottish waters that are siphoned down to the London Treasury. Over the past 30 years, we have lost out on several hundred billion pounds. It is an indication of the strength of the Scottish economy that, over the past five years, we would have been £8 billion better off if we had been running our own finances rather than having them run for us by London.

I know that Johann Lamont believes that oil and gas is a dreadful burden on the Scottish economy. There are many oil and gas producers around the world, and every single one of them regards the hydrocarbon industry and the revenues that flow from it as a valuable resource that they are benefiting from. Why is it that, according to better together—Labour and Tory, Tory and Labour—it is only Scotland for whom oil and gas is this incredible curse?

If, over the past five years, we had been £8 billion better off, can we not all think of some wee things that we would have liked to invest in in the economy, such as jobs for the people and a fairer society? That is why Johann Lamont’s campaign to tell people in Scotland that they are too poor to be independent will get the same giant raspberry as it did in the Daily Record poll this morning. [Interruption.]

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

I think that that must be a record number of straw men that the First Minister put up in order to defend himself. Of course, I have never said that oil is a burden to Scotland, because without oil, Scotland’s deficit would be £16 billion. What we got from the First Minister there is what they call on television quiz shows a pointless answer, although in fact it is charitable to call it an answer at all.

We know what the First Minister would not do. He would not be able to borrow his way out of trouble, because who would lend to a country that had just walked away from its debts? [Interruption.]

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link

That is not scaremongering; that is quoting the First Minister himself.

We also know that the First Minister would not raise taxes on the rich, because he ruled that out last week. He would not raise taxes on banks and big business, because he is committed to cutting tax for them lower than George Osborne is. The First Minister has lost the equivalent of the entire schools budget. I ask again: how would he pay for our schools—by cutting services elsewhere or by raising taxes on every family in Scotland? [Interruption.]

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link

Johann Lamont asked who would lend money to an independent Scotland. Two weeks ago, the ratings agency Standard & Poor’s noted that

“even without North Sea oil and calculating per capita GDP only by looking at onshore income Scotland would qualify for their highest economic assessment.”

If an international ratings agency can say that, can the leader of the Labour Party in Scotland not bring herself to say it?

Of course, it was not so long ago that the better together parties told us that we could not be independent because we would lose our AAA rating. In fact, I have here the leaflet about the AAA rating that went round the doors. Then, of course, the UK lost its AAA rating from two of the agencies.

The reason why there is confidence from so many people on Scotland’s economic prospects comes from looking at the figures that Johann Lamont has been given. Over the past five years, there has been a relative surplus of £8 billion. Scotland has been £8 billion stronger—almost £1,600 a head for every man, woman and child—than the UK as a whole.

Johann Lamont did not seem to appreciate the reference to the Daily Record poll this morning. That poll showed the “highest” support for independence recorded this year and that the Scottish National Party is “the most popular party” by some considerable distance. Most interesting of all, it showed that a quarter of the remaining Labour supporters in Scotland intend to vote for independence. Perhaps one of the reasons for that is the miserable, doom-laden running-down of our country that Johann Lamont has come to every day this week. [Interruption.]

  1. Independent Expert Panel on Unconventional Oil and Gas Questions · 8
  2. Glasgow Queen Street Station (Upgrade) Questions · 6
  3. Rail Travel (South Scotland) Questions · 6
  4. E-commerce Questions · 4
  5. Scotland Food & Drink (Export Plan) Questions · 4
  6. Structural Defects (Assistance for Home Owners and Council Tenants) Questions · 4
  7. Tuition Fees (Scottish and non-Scottish Students) Questions · 4
  8. Scottish League Cup Final (Supporters from the North and North-east) Questions · 7
  9. Independence (Economic Benefits) Questions · 8
  10. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 23
  11. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
  12. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 12
  13. Child Poverty First Minister’s Questions · 6
  14. Antisocial Behaviour Orders First Minister’s Questions · 4
  15. Housing Investment (Lloyds Bank Affordable Cities Review) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  16. Greener Kirkcaldy Members’ business · 7
  17. Local Government Finance (Scotland) Amendment Order 2014 [Draft] Debate · 20
  18. Welfare Reform Debate · 89
  19. High Speed Rail (London – West Midlands) Bill 2013-14 Bill debate · 2
  20. Decision Time Decision time · 6
  21. Correction Procedure · 1

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.