1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01582)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Salmond SNP 7
- Johann Lamont Lab 6
- Tricia Marwick 4
The record
17 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01582)
I have engagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
Why is the Scottish Government cutting help for victims of the bedroom tax by £20 million next year?
I should congratulate Johann Lamont first. If my memory serves me correctly, this is the first time she has mentioned the words “bedroom tax” and raised the matter at First Minister’s questions. Now that the Labour Party feels itself to be in a position to address at First Minister’s question time a huge issue that has affected people in Scotland over a matter of months, we should congratulate Johann Lamont on raising it at last.
As Johann Lamont well knows, the Scottish Government has made a substantial increase in discretionary housing payments—one and a half times what the Westminster Government was offering—in order to address, and to allow our local authorities to address, some of the worst aspects of the bedroom tax. That effective action has been welcomed by a wide range of organisations that care about the people of Scotland and talk about the bedroom tax all the time.
As Johann Lamont well knows, the Scottish Government has made a substantial increase in discretionary housing payments—one and a half times what the Westminster Government was offering—in order to address, and to allow our local authorities to address, some of the worst aspects of the bedroom tax. That effective action has been welcomed by a wide range of organisations that care about the people of Scotland and talk about the bedroom tax all the time.
Yes, of course—but the problem with the First Minister is that he talks about the bedroom tax all the time, but does not act in the interests of ordinary people. If people were to be comforted by promises in the future, we would be in a strange place. What we can do now is what actually matters. There is £20 million this year, but there is nothing next year and, this year, there is half of what the organisations that he mentioned expected.
The real reason why the Scottish Government is cutting off support for the victims of the bedroom tax is that it sees injustice not as an opportunity to help people in Scotland who are suffering, but as one to be exploited ahead of the referendum. If the First Minister really wanted rid of the bedroom tax, he would urge voters in England in 2015 to vote Labour to abolish it—[Laughter.]
The real reason why the Scottish Government is cutting off support for the victims of the bedroom tax is that it sees injustice not as an opportunity to help people in Scotland who are suffering, but as one to be exploited ahead of the referendum. If the First Minister really wanted rid of the bedroom tax, he would urge voters in England in 2015 to vote Labour to abolish it—[Laughter.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
—rather than asking them to vote for Nick Clegg, as he did in 2010. The memory banks have been wiped, but the evidence of the First Minister’s poor judgment is seen again in that.
We know that the First Minister does not agree with John Swinney on renationalising postal services, on pensions or on the public finances. Does he agree with his Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Employment and Sustainable Growth that the reason why the Government will not help victims of the bedroom tax is that it does not want to let Westminster “off the hook”? [Interruption.]
We know that the First Minister does not agree with John Swinney on renationalising postal services, on pensions or on the public finances. Does he agree with his Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Employment and Sustainable Growth that the reason why the Government will not help victims of the bedroom tax is that it does not want to let Westminster “off the hook”? [Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
The finance secretary, John Swinney, has helped victims of the bedroom tax. I will quote the people who talk about the bedroom tax all the time. Shelter Scotland’s Graeme Brown said:
“We are delighted that the Scottish Government has listened to Shelter Scotland’s campaign and is making £20 million available to help thousands more households … affected by the so-called bedroom tax.”
Children in Scotland’s chief executive Jackie Brock said:
“Whilst Scotland does not have the power to change the policy, we are pleased to see the Scottish Government utilizing the powers they do have to help mitigate the impact on our most vulnerable households.”
Let us not have it from Johann Lamont that John Swinney has not helped people who are afflicted by the bedroom tax. That is the effective action that the Scottish National Party Government has taken.
In Johann Lamont’s question was something more interesting. She says that what we must do in order not to have the bedroom tax imposed on the people of Scotland is to make an appeal to people in England to vote Labour. That is the sum total of the Labour Party’s ambition for the people of Scotland. Many people in Scotland—this party, other parties and many people throughout Scotland—say that the way to stop iniquities such as the bedroom tax being imposed on the Scottish people is to take the power over social security so that we can build the society that we want to have.
“We are delighted that the Scottish Government has listened to Shelter Scotland’s campaign and is making £20 million available to help thousands more households … affected by the so-called bedroom tax.”
Children in Scotland’s chief executive Jackie Brock said:
“Whilst Scotland does not have the power to change the policy, we are pleased to see the Scottish Government utilizing the powers they do have to help mitigate the impact on our most vulnerable households.”
Let us not have it from Johann Lamont that John Swinney has not helped people who are afflicted by the bedroom tax. That is the effective action that the Scottish National Party Government has taken.
In Johann Lamont’s question was something more interesting. She says that what we must do in order not to have the bedroom tax imposed on the people of Scotland is to make an appeal to people in England to vote Labour. That is the sum total of the Labour Party’s ambition for the people of Scotland. Many people in Scotland—this party, other parties and many people throughout Scotland—say that the way to stop iniquities such as the bedroom tax being imposed on the Scottish people is to take the power over social security so that we can build the society that we want to have.
John Swinney has given less than half of what people asked for this year and will give them nothing next year. The reason why he will give them nothing next year is that that is another justification for separation, rather than a policy that should be tackled.
The First Minister is fond of saying that the best people to make decisions about Scotland are the people who live here, and who care most about Scotland. He has the power to help victims of the bedroom tax now and, with an underspend of £179 million last year, he has the funds. Is it not the case that although the First Minister might live in Scotland, he has decided not to act because he does not care about the victims of the bedroom tax and would rather exploit their pain?
The First Minister is fond of saying that the best people to make decisions about Scotland are the people who live here, and who care most about Scotland. He has the power to help victims of the bedroom tax now and, with an underspend of £179 million last year, he has the funds. Is it not the case that although the First Minister might live in Scotland, he has decided not to act because he does not care about the victims of the bedroom tax and would rather exploit their pain?
Of course, the £20 million that we are providing is the limit, under the powers that we have at present. That is exactly what Shelter asked for.
Let us return to the question of where these matters should be governed and settled. I presume that even Johann Lamont and the Labour Party do not believe that the Scottish Government can find resources to cope with all the welfare changes that are being imposed on the Scottish people. I presume that they accept that, in conjunction with our colleagues in the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities, we have done what we can on council tax benefit. I presume that Johann Lamont understands that the reinforcement of the ability of Scotland’s charities to help people who are in extremity has been an important move to make, and I presume that she concedes that Shelter asked for £20 million because it realised that that is the legal limit that exists under the powers of this Parliament.
If it is accepted—as it is by many people, including the charities—that we are doing everything we can, within the powers that we have, to mitigate the effect of Westminster-imposed cutbacks on the Scottish people, surely the solution is obvious. If we want not to have the bedroom tax, and if we do not want people with disability to be subjected to humiliation, why cannot we in this country have the power to frame our own welfare system so that it meets the ambitions of the Scottish people?
Let us return to the question of where these matters should be governed and settled. I presume that even Johann Lamont and the Labour Party do not believe that the Scottish Government can find resources to cope with all the welfare changes that are being imposed on the Scottish people. I presume that they accept that, in conjunction with our colleagues in the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities, we have done what we can on council tax benefit. I presume that Johann Lamont understands that the reinforcement of the ability of Scotland’s charities to help people who are in extremity has been an important move to make, and I presume that she concedes that Shelter asked for £20 million because it realised that that is the legal limit that exists under the powers of this Parliament.
If it is accepted—as it is by many people, including the charities—that we are doing everything we can, within the powers that we have, to mitigate the effect of Westminster-imposed cutbacks on the Scottish people, surely the solution is obvious. If we want not to have the bedroom tax, and if we do not want people with disability to be subjected to humiliation, why cannot we in this country have the power to frame our own welfare system so that it meets the ambitions of the Scottish people?
If the First Minister was interested in his day job, he would know that there is not a £20 million limit on what he can spend. Even if that were true, it does not explain why he is not putting any money into next year’s budget. There is nothing there.
Perhaps another reason why the Government is not helping is that, instead of having civil servants try to improve the lives of Scots and to find ways of supporting people, the First Minister has them writing fantasy plans for a Scottish air force, Scottish embassies and our own secret service.
While the First Minister has been doing that, between trips to the Ryder cup and Wimbledon—I advise him not to go again to Wimbledon and behave in the way that he did this year—we have been working. I have here the bill that can protect Scotland from the bedroom tax. It has been lodged in Parliament today and it has support from the very organisations that the First Minister has cited. Instead of cutting help for victims of the bedroom tax, will the First Minister pledge to sign this bill now and do the right thing by Scotland, rather than the right thing by the SNP?
Perhaps another reason why the Government is not helping is that, instead of having civil servants try to improve the lives of Scots and to find ways of supporting people, the First Minister has them writing fantasy plans for a Scottish air force, Scottish embassies and our own secret service.
While the First Minister has been doing that, between trips to the Ryder cup and Wimbledon—I advise him not to go again to Wimbledon and behave in the way that he did this year—we have been working. I have here the bill that can protect Scotland from the bedroom tax. It has been lodged in Parliament today and it has support from the very organisations that the First Minister has cited. Instead of cutting help for victims of the bedroom tax, will the First Minister pledge to sign this bill now and do the right thing by Scotland, rather than the right thing by the SNP?
It is now six months since SNP councils across the country moved to a no-evictions policy. That did not meet with unanimous support: on 25 March 2013, Aberdeen City Council, which is led by Labour in alliance with the Tories, rejected the motion that called for no evictions. [Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
On 13 February, the Labour-Tory alliance in Falkirk Council rejected the SNP motion. This spring, the Labour Party refused to endorse the no-evictions policy that was being implemented by SNP councils across Scotland, and we all know that Labour-run North Lanarkshire Council was trying to evict a disabled single mum until the Daily Record exposed it on 22 August. It was only after the council leader, Jim McCabe, was confronted by Ms Fraser and the Daily Record that the eviction threat was withdrawn. If the Labour Party’s concern is for people across Scotland who are under the heel of the bedroom tax, why did it not support the SNP’s policy of there being no evictions across Scotland?
But then, of course, Johann Lamont has a track record these days: it is of waiting to raise the bedroom tax until it was said at the Labour conference that—finally—the Labour Party is prepared to argue for a repeal of the tax. For six months, we have been waiting, with different interpretations from different Labour figures in Scotland, because they have been waiting for God, or for Ed Miliband, to give them the sign that they could argue for repeal. It has been six months since Nicola Sturgeon pledged to repeal the bedroom tax in an independent Scotland.
It is absolutely extraordinary to argue, as Johann Lamont and Jackie Baillie do, not that we could not control social security in Scotland, but that we should not control social security in Scotland. That is why the majority of the Scottish people see the route forward for social security—so that we can banish the bedroom tax from Scotland and banish the iniquities that are being foisted on people with disabilities—as being to take the power in this country to have a social security system—[Interruption.]
But then, of course, Johann Lamont has a track record these days: it is of waiting to raise the bedroom tax until it was said at the Labour conference that—finally—the Labour Party is prepared to argue for a repeal of the tax. For six months, we have been waiting, with different interpretations from different Labour figures in Scotland, because they have been waiting for God, or for Ed Miliband, to give them the sign that they could argue for repeal. It has been six months since Nicola Sturgeon pledged to repeal the bedroom tax in an independent Scotland.
It is absolutely extraordinary to argue, as Johann Lamont and Jackie Baillie do, not that we could not control social security in Scotland, but that we should not control social security in Scotland. That is why the majority of the Scottish people see the route forward for social security—so that we can banish the bedroom tax from Scotland and banish the iniquities that are being foisted on people with disabilities—as being to take the power in this country to have a social security system—[Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
—that is fair and which meets the aspirations of the Scottish people.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 26 Sep 2013 →- Sport (Regional Performance Centre in Dundee) Questions · 6
- Commonwealth Games 2014 Questions · 8
- Universities (Overseas Students) Questions · 4
- Renewables (Department of Energy and Climate Change Consultation) Questions · 6
- Child Protection Questions · 4
- Environmental Projects (Community Benefits) Questions · 4
- Dementia (Under-65s) Questions · 4
- Opencast Mine Restoration (East Ayrshire) Questions · 6
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 17
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 13
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 7
- Royal Mail Privatisation First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Older People (Residential Care) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Mobile Phone Coverage (Rural Areas) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Offshore Safety Members’ business · 20
- Ryder Cup 2014 Debate · 51
- Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 3
- Decision Time Decision time · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.