My meeting with representatives of ICAS and R3 last week was extremely helpful. We had a positive discussion. ICAS and R3 were able to ventilate their concerns fully. We do not share their concerns, for three reasons. It might be helpful if I run through them, given that these are serious points. We recognise that IPs operate in a profession in which members carry out their duties in accordance with the rules and in a professional manner, and that cases of abuse, if there are any, are minor. I think that ICAS acknowledged that in communications to the committee as recently as today or yesterday. That is common ground.However, we do not agree with ICAS for these reasons. First, in England and Wales there is a solution that is equivalent to the PTD: the individual voluntary agreement. The usual practice is for an IVA to run for five years, not three, so there are 60 monthly payments. If ICAS’s argument were correct, we would expect IVAs to have dropped in popularity, importance, prevalence, usage and uptake, but in fact the opposite has happened. IVAs have been a success, despite payments going on for two years longer than would be the case with bankruptcy.The central tenet of ICAS’s case is that if there is a discrepancy between the periods of total payment—36 months as opposed to 48 months—debtors will automatically go for 36 months. Well, despite the period being 60 months in England, take-up of IVAs increased from 1,928 in 1990 to 49,039 in 2011. The proposition seems to be that debtors will always go for the cheapest option, but that is simply not the case. We are not saying that IVAs are identical to PTDs, but they are broadly equivalent. Therefore, there is clear evidence that a longer period of payment—and paying more—will not discourage people from choosing the option of the PTD, which is equivalent to the IVA, over bankruptcy.Why is that? There are a number of reasons. From my glimmering recollection of operating in this field as a solicitor for many years before I was elected, I know that those reasons are very real.First, debtors choose to enter a trust deed rather than bankruptcy because they perceive that there is less stigma. That is very important to understand. A great many people do not want to enter bankruptcy: they do not want to say, “I am a bankrupt.” Whether people are right or wrong about that perception, we feel that the idea that there is that stigma is wrong and that it is something that we should try to remove, because many people who enter bankruptcy do so through no fault of their own as a result of circumstances in their lives such as redundancy, bereavement and so on. There should be no broad-brush generalisation that all people who are bankrupt are rogues, as that is just not the case, and we would therefore like to tackle that stigma.Be that as it may, there is still a view out there that there is a great stigma attached to bankruptcy. Many people who believe that they can make a substantial contribution and want to give their creditors something back—even if they perhaps cannot pay all their debt—want protected trust deeds because the stigma is not as great as that which is associated with bankruptcy.There are other reasons, which may be lesser, although they may be more important in some cases. There is a fee of £200 to enter bankruptcy, but there is no fee for entering a PTD, so there is an immediate financial cost for bankruptcy that is not attached to PTDs.Some debtors find—this can be very important for some people—that their terms and conditions of employment do not allow them to continue in their job when they are an undischarged bankrupt. If someone cannot get a job or risks losing their job if they enter bankruptcy, they plainly have a very strong interest in PTDs as a possible means of avoiding such a cataclysmic and disastrous consequence in their life. That affects a minority of people, admittedly, but it is the case for a few.The much wider argument is that a lot of people in Scotland want to pay their debts in full—they do not want to take the easy or cheap option. They do not want to get off with it all; they want, through a sense of moral probity or of duty to pay back creditors, to pay their debts in full, and we want to encourage that.If ICAS is correct that people would just choose the cheapest option, nobody would pay off their debts—they would all just enter PTDs or, depending on their choice, sequestration. That is not the case, and I am delighted that the numbers of those who are going into the DAS are rising, thanks in part—I think—to the changes that have been made during my period of stewardship of this area of responsibility. That is good news, and we want the situation to continue.Some people who enter PTDs should be going into the DAS because they can pay their debts off in full, and we want to encourage that. I respect the IPs’ views, and I wanted to take the time to acquaint myself with the arguments. However, having had the opportunity to do so and to reflect with my officials, I urge the committee to accept that, for the reasons that I have set out, the significant impact on the numbers of people entering PTDs as opposed to sequestration that IPs say will happen as a consequence is unlikely to occur.