1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01524)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Johann Lamont Lab 6
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
- Tricia Marwick 1
The record
12 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01524)
Engagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
I thank the First Minister.
Nicola Sturgeon’s department told the Public Audit Committee that her five biggest transport projects cost £3.3 billion. The true figure is £3.8 billion—half a billion pounds more. Why did Nicola Sturgeon mislead Parliament and the people of Scotland in that way?
Nicola Sturgeon’s department told the Public Audit Committee that her five biggest transport projects cost £3.3 billion. The true figure is £3.8 billion—half a billion pounds more. Why did Nicola Sturgeon mislead Parliament and the people of Scotland in that way?
Johann Lamont should catch up with the evidence that the permanent secretary gave to the relevant committee yesterday, which made it quite clear that there were no mistakes and that there was no misleading. The question was whether we consider the cost of a project or the cost of things like buying land to prepare for a project. There are many arguments for considering the cost of a project, showing the economic value and showing what is actually done in building the project.
What Johann Lamont should be concentrating on is the extraordinary success of the non-profit-distributing programme, which is building schools, hospitals and colleges around the country. In Glasgow, in particular, the new colleges will help to revitalise further and higher education in the city.
What Johann Lamont should be concentrating on is the extraordinary success of the non-profit-distributing programme, which is building schools, hospitals and colleges around the country. In Glasgow, in particular, the new colleges will help to revitalise further and higher education in the city.
I assure the First Minister that I did catch up with the evidence to the Public Audit Committee yesterday, which was described as insulting to this Parliament. I cannot believe that the Scottish Government thought that we could build a railway without needing to pay for the land on which it would go—I do not know whether Nicola thought that she was going to build a transatlantic monorail.
I think that the First Minister does not understand why people think that he is out of touch. When he is shown a £500 million discrepancy, he does not try to explain it. Instead, he tries to explain it away. That is simply not good enough.
Nicola Sturgeon seems to be running her department with the same competence with which she is running the yes campaign. She missed half a billion pounds. Let me explain what that buys: it buys nearly 14,000 teachers; it pays for 16,000 nurses; and—let me say so that the First Minister, in his world, can understand—it buys nigh on 1,000 trips to the Ryder cup.
Was Nicola Sturgeon being deliberately misleading, or is her eye off rising costs to the taxpayer because she is too busy watching the yes campaign’s support going down?
I think that the First Minister does not understand why people think that he is out of touch. When he is shown a £500 million discrepancy, he does not try to explain it. Instead, he tries to explain it away. That is simply not good enough.
Nicola Sturgeon seems to be running her department with the same competence with which she is running the yes campaign. She missed half a billion pounds. Let me explain what that buys: it buys nearly 14,000 teachers; it pays for 16,000 nurses; and—let me say so that the First Minister, in his world, can understand—it buys nigh on 1,000 trips to the Ryder cup.
Was Nicola Sturgeon being deliberately misleading, or is her eye off rising costs to the taxpayer because she is too busy watching the yes campaign’s support going down?
It is obvious that the long summer of inactivity over the past few months has not improved Johann Lamont’s temper. I could point out that half a billion pounds is one two-hundredth of the estimated lifetime cost of the Trident missile system, which is so beloved of Labour and the Tories.
I know that Johann Lamont and the Conservatives are welded together in the better together campaign, but her quoting a Conservative MSP, as definitive proof, really is evidence that the rest of Scotland would find rather tame and insubstantial.
The £500 million that Johann Lamont is pointing to is money that is spent to prepare for vital infrastructure projects, such as the money spent on the M74 and the M80, the money spent to buy the land for the peripheral route that is coming to the north-east of Scotland, and the money spent in acquiring the land for the vital hospital and other projects that are taking place around the country.
Johann Lamont wants to trade on capital spending. NPD replaced the private finance initiative, through which people ended up paying multiples of 10 of the original capital cost, because of the Labour Party’s total inability to negotiate with private financiers to get a good deal for the public. That is why the £2.5 billion NPD programme is revitalising the capital infrastructure of Scotland in the face of punitive cuts from the Tories and Liberals in Westminster.
I know that Johann Lamont and the Conservatives are welded together in the better together campaign, but her quoting a Conservative MSP, as definitive proof, really is evidence that the rest of Scotland would find rather tame and insubstantial.
The £500 million that Johann Lamont is pointing to is money that is spent to prepare for vital infrastructure projects, such as the money spent on the M74 and the M80, the money spent to buy the land for the peripheral route that is coming to the north-east of Scotland, and the money spent in acquiring the land for the vital hospital and other projects that are taking place around the country.
Johann Lamont wants to trade on capital spending. NPD replaced the private finance initiative, through which people ended up paying multiples of 10 of the original capital cost, because of the Labour Party’s total inability to negotiate with private financiers to get a good deal for the public. That is why the £2.5 billion NPD programme is revitalising the capital infrastructure of Scotland in the face of punitive cuts from the Tories and Liberals in Westminster.
I am glad to see that the squirrel is back, refreshed after its holidays.
In the real word, it is beyond belief that that is a suitable response from someone who is charged with not knowing where half a billion pounds is. You have found half a billion pounds missing and you need to take responsibility—[Interruption.]
In the real word, it is beyond belief that that is a suitable response from someone who is charged with not knowing where half a billion pounds is. You have found half a billion pounds missing and you need to take responsibility—[Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order!
Of course, in the First Minister’s world, that was an explanation. However, if his answer is true, why has the Auditor General for Scotland Caroline Gardner described the Government figures as “incomplete” and “inconsistent”? Why was Peter Housden hauled before the Public Audit Committee yesterday to be dealt with by all the parliamentarians, not just the convener? Was he to be a scapegoat?
Whether he is sneaking into primary schools the back way or fêting Rupert Murdoch at Bute house, the First Minister at the first sniff of trouble refers himself to Peter Housden, knowing that he will be cleared. Now Nicola Sturgeon gets to use Sir Peter as a human shield.
Perhaps they do not know this on the Scottish National Party benches, but we live in an era in which, for too many families, every penny is a prisoner and in which families are putting back on to supermarket shelves treats and even basic goods that they used to be able to afford. How, in that climate, can this Government have got its figures wrong by half a billion pounds?
Whether he is sneaking into primary schools the back way or fêting Rupert Murdoch at Bute house, the First Minister at the first sniff of trouble refers himself to Peter Housden, knowing that he will be cleared. Now Nicola Sturgeon gets to use Sir Peter as a human shield.
Perhaps they do not know this on the Scottish National Party benches, but we live in an era in which, for too many families, every penny is a prisoner and in which families are putting back on to supermarket shelves treats and even basic goods that they used to be able to afford. How, in that climate, can this Government have got its figures wrong by half a billion pounds?
The half a billion pounds has been spent on things such as site preparation. I say to Johann Lamont that it cannot be spent again on the list of things that she has put forward. If she does not think that that money should be spent, by definition she does not think that these capital projects should have gone ahead.
By any acknowledgement, the non-profit-distribution trust is far better than the PFI paraded by the Labour Party. Even George Osborne—belatedly, I have to admit—has started to slate PFI as a dreadful use of taxpayers’ money.
I do not think that Johann Lamont should be accusing civil servants who cannot answer back of a variety of things. As for visits to Aberdeen primary schools, I point out that the response to a freedom of information request totally vindicates our position, just as the people of Aberdeen Donside vindicated the SNP in the by-election.
By any acknowledgement, the non-profit-distribution trust is far better than the PFI paraded by the Labour Party. Even George Osborne—belatedly, I have to admit—has started to slate PFI as a dreadful use of taxpayers’ money.
I do not think that Johann Lamont should be accusing civil servants who cannot answer back of a variety of things. As for visits to Aberdeen primary schools, I point out that the response to a freedom of information request totally vindicates our position, just as the people of Aberdeen Donside vindicated the SNP in the by-election.
The First Minister is not on good land when he talks about civil servants being unable to defend themselves. This is the First Minister who gave us the most accurate answer ever given to any Parliament and then had to come back at 5 o’clock to bravely blame the civil servants for making a mistake. This is about ministerial accountability and responsibility, not about scapegoating civil servants. Over the summer, Alex Salmond promised every Scot a £300,000 North Sea dividend after separation. Now we know that his figures have a half-billion-pound margin of error.
Here is why this matters and what people fear. In the increasingly unlikely event that Scotland votes to leave the United Kingdom, we will find out the day after the referendum that everything that the First Minister claimed before on the currency, on pensions, on welfare, on oil revenues and on corporation tax was possibly incomplete and inconsistent and he will tell the nation, “Sorry—it was the civil servants’ fault”. Is it not the case that ministers are spending their time on their separation obsession that most Scots reject, and that while their campaigning is failing to convince Scots this SNP Government is failing to run the country?
Here is why this matters and what people fear. In the increasingly unlikely event that Scotland votes to leave the United Kingdom, we will find out the day after the referendum that everything that the First Minister claimed before on the currency, on pensions, on welfare, on oil revenues and on corporation tax was possibly incomplete and inconsistent and he will tell the nation, “Sorry—it was the civil servants’ fault”. Is it not the case that ministers are spending their time on their separation obsession that most Scots reject, and that while their campaigning is failing to convince Scots this SNP Government is failing to run the country?
So, after two months of preparation, that is the exact extent of Johann Lamont’s questioning. Last year, the summer climaxed with the something for nothing society; this year, we had the summer of nothing from Johann Lamont, and her rehearsing of her questions did not improve them.
Johann Lamont said that I was misleading about the wholesale value of North Sea oil. The £1.5 trillion—incidentally, that is one thousand billion—is the estimated value of the resource over the next 40 years. I have to say that I find it interesting that she compared the figures with the Treasury paper on this issue—Johann Lamont and the Tories: better together. I had a wee look at that paper, which estimates the value of revenues over the next 18 years. Why are the Treasury and the Labour Party telling people that there are only 18 years of North Sea oil and gas production? I find that very interesting, because a couple of years ago the Prime Minister was declaring that the Clair field would last until 2050. Why on earth does the Treasury talk about the next 18 years when the Prime Minister talks about the Clair ridge development lasting until 2050?
The attempt by Johann Lamont and the Tories to underestimate the value of Scotland’s resources is not a recent phenomenon; it goes back to the 1970s and the 1980s. How do we know that? Denis Healey, thankfully still alive, blew the gaff when he said that there had been a deliberate underestimation of North Sea oil value in order to try to stop the Scottish nationalists.
Of course, Denis Healey said that it was mainly the Tories who did that. I think that it was both the Tories and the Labour Party. Better together means very little to the people of Scotland.
Johann Lamont said that I was misleading about the wholesale value of North Sea oil. The £1.5 trillion—incidentally, that is one thousand billion—is the estimated value of the resource over the next 40 years. I have to say that I find it interesting that she compared the figures with the Treasury paper on this issue—Johann Lamont and the Tories: better together. I had a wee look at that paper, which estimates the value of revenues over the next 18 years. Why are the Treasury and the Labour Party telling people that there are only 18 years of North Sea oil and gas production? I find that very interesting, because a couple of years ago the Prime Minister was declaring that the Clair field would last until 2050. Why on earth does the Treasury talk about the next 18 years when the Prime Minister talks about the Clair ridge development lasting until 2050?
The attempt by Johann Lamont and the Tories to underestimate the value of Scotland’s resources is not a recent phenomenon; it goes back to the 1970s and the 1980s. How do we know that? Denis Healey, thankfully still alive, blew the gaff when he said that there had been a deliberate underestimation of North Sea oil value in order to try to stop the Scottish nationalists.
Of course, Denis Healey said that it was mainly the Tories who did that. I think that it was both the Tories and the Labour Party. Better together means very little to the people of Scotland.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 5 Sep 2013 →- Business Motion Business motions · 1
- Glasgow Airport (Aecom) Questions · 6
- Civil Emergencies Questions · 6
- School Estates Questions · 4
- NHS Lanarkshire (Hospital Standardised Mortality Rates) Questions · 4
- Common Agricultural Policy Reform (Funds) Questions · 4
- Underoccupancy Charge (Bedroom Tax) Questions · 6
- General Practitioners Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 7
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 7
- Syria (Humanitarian Aid) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Housing First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Welfare Reforms (Women) First Minister’s Questions · 11
- Links with China Members’ business · 14
- Where Gypsy Travellers Live Debate · 61
- Ministerial Appointments to Public Bodies (Draft Code of Practice) Debate · 3
- High Speed Rail (Preparation) Bill Bill debate · 2
- European Public Prosecutor’s Office (Proposal for European Union Legislation) Debate · 4
- Point of Order Procedure · 5
- Decision Time Decision time · 3
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.