1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01534)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Alex Salmond SNP 6
- Johann Lamont Lab 5
- Tricia Marwick 1
The record
12 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01534)
Engagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
In 2008, as part of the preparations for the Glasgow airport rail link, four plots of land at 57 Clark Street, Paisley, were bought on behalf of the Scottish Government for £840,000. Can the First Minister tell me from whom the land was bought and to whom has the land been subsequently sold and for what price?
If Johann Lamont wants to write to me with these questions, I will supply the answers. I should say to her that, as we heard yesterday, this Government’s track record in taking forward transport projects in Scotland under the circumstances of the cutbacks from Westminster is considerable indeed. That said, the member should by all means send in her questions and we will supply the answers.
There you go: there was me thinking that this was First Minister’s questions, where the First Minister has the opportunity to show how much in control of his Government he is.
Let me help the First Minister. The land was bought in 2008 for £840,000 from a businessman called John McGlynn, who was then a donor to the Scottish Conservative Party. Since then, of course, Mr McGlynn has been on something of a political journey; he now supports the yes campaign. Since then, he has been appointed to the Scottish Government national economic forum and he has bought back the land from the Scottish Government for £50,000 and made a profit of £790,000. Is there some connection here or has Mr McGlynn just benefited from the First Minister’s gross incompetence with public funds?
Let me help the First Minister. The land was bought in 2008 for £840,000 from a businessman called John McGlynn, who was then a donor to the Scottish Conservative Party. Since then, of course, Mr McGlynn has been on something of a political journey; he now supports the yes campaign. Since then, he has been appointed to the Scottish Government national economic forum and he has bought back the land from the Scottish Government for £50,000 and made a profit of £790,000. Is there some connection here or has Mr McGlynn just benefited from the First Minister’s gross incompetence with public funds?
As Johann Lamont should know, ministers are not involved in property transactions with regard to transport projects or anything else. Maybe it was different when the Labour Party was in power, but that is what has happened since the Scottish National Party has been in power.
Clearly, Johann Lamont had the answers to her own questions all the time, so she was not really eliciting information. However, I was not clear from her question whether it was an attack because someone was a donor to the Conservative Party when the land was bought or it was just an attack for no apparent reason against a Scottish businessperson. [Interruption.]
Clearly, Johann Lamont had the answers to her own questions all the time, so she was not really eliciting information. However, I was not clear from her question whether it was an attack because someone was a donor to the Conservative Party when the land was bought or it was just an attack for no apparent reason against a Scottish businessperson. [Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
If Johann Lamont has any evidence whatever that anything untoward has been happening in property transactions, she should bring it to the chamber or to public notice. If she has no such evidence—and she has no such evidence whatever—she should not attack people in Scotland with no reason whatever or come to this chamber to attack people who cannot answer back in the chamber. It is ridiculous.
I was attacking no one. I was expecting the First Minister to justify his actions, and he has absolutely failed to do so.
The fact of the matter is that the Scottish Government bought the land for £840,000; it was signed off by the Scottish ministers; and the Scottish Government then sold the land for £50,000 when not obliged to do so to kill a project that John Swinney himself has called “desirable” and which Transport Scotland is still exploring.
In case the First Minister has not noticed, Scotland has for the past five years been going through one of the deepest downturns in our history. In that time, the First Minister has slashed spending on skills and colleges; has underfunded vital public services with the result that some of our most vulnerable old people get just 15-minute care visits; and has cut funding so that many people with a bus pass have no bus to get on. In those circumstances, how does the First Minister justify buying a piece of land for £840,000 and then selling it back to the person he bought it from for just £50,000? What was the First Minister thinking of?
The fact of the matter is that the Scottish Government bought the land for £840,000; it was signed off by the Scottish ministers; and the Scottish Government then sold the land for £50,000 when not obliged to do so to kill a project that John Swinney himself has called “desirable” and which Transport Scotland is still exploring.
In case the First Minister has not noticed, Scotland has for the past five years been going through one of the deepest downturns in our history. In that time, the First Minister has slashed spending on skills and colleges; has underfunded vital public services with the result that some of our most vulnerable old people get just 15-minute care visits; and has cut funding so that many people with a bus pass have no bus to get on. In those circumstances, how does the First Minister justify buying a piece of land for £840,000 and then selling it back to the person he bought it from for just £50,000? What was the First Minister thinking of?
Neither the First Minister nor any other minister was involved in the property transaction that the member has spoken of. Such transactions are not conducted by ministers in this Government. I do not know whether the practice was any different in the previous Labour Government—I suspect not—but the purpose of Johann Lamont’s question seems to be to smear a perfectly respectable Scottish businessman for no apparent reason other than she did not like his politics then and does not, for that matter, like them now. I do not really think that that is the way a political leader should behave in a parliamentary chamber.
If, as Johann Lamont occasionally says, she wants to talk about the real issues, then let us do so. This Government has given an unequivocal commitment to universal services and benefits—the mark of the Parliament over these past 14 years. It is Johann Lamont who, as I understand it, wants to cut people’s bus passes and stop free access to higher education and who has put a question mark over free personal care for the elderly. Those are matters that, as I understand it, are being considered by her cuts commission as part of the something for nothing society that she outlined only a year ago.
As we said in our programme for government, we believe in a something for something society in Scotland. We believe that those benefits to people in Scotland are well justified, and I think that people in Scotland want to hear about those substantive policies, not totally unfounded smears on a Scottish businessperson.
If, as Johann Lamont occasionally says, she wants to talk about the real issues, then let us do so. This Government has given an unequivocal commitment to universal services and benefits—the mark of the Parliament over these past 14 years. It is Johann Lamont who, as I understand it, wants to cut people’s bus passes and stop free access to higher education and who has put a question mark over free personal care for the elderly. Those are matters that, as I understand it, are being considered by her cuts commission as part of the something for nothing society that she outlined only a year ago.
As we said in our programme for government, we believe in a something for something society in Scotland. We believe that those benefits to people in Scotland are well justified, and I think that people in Scotland want to hear about those substantive policies, not totally unfounded smears on a Scottish businessperson.
I think that we might hear the First Minister talking about a something for next to nothing Scotland. I am not addressing the question of the businessman who benefited; I am asking the First Minister to take responsibility for what was done by his Government.
All of the displacement activity that we just witnessed might make the First Minister feel better for the present, to get him through the moment, but when he is done with that he will still have to answer this serious question—and I do not think that the First Minister understands, even at this stage, how serious the issue is. I am asking a simple question: how did we get in a situation in which a piece of land was bought with taxpayers’ money for the guts of £1 million and sold back to the same person a few years later for just a fraction of that?
There are people watching this at home who are struggling to pay the bills or put food on the table. They have to account for every penny that they spend. Can the First Minister explain to them either why the issue has nothing to do with him or how he managed to buy a piece of land with their money for £840,000 and sell it for just £50,000?
All of the displacement activity that we just witnessed might make the First Minister feel better for the present, to get him through the moment, but when he is done with that he will still have to answer this serious question—and I do not think that the First Minister understands, even at this stage, how serious the issue is. I am asking a simple question: how did we get in a situation in which a piece of land was bought with taxpayers’ money for the guts of £1 million and sold back to the same person a few years later for just a fraction of that?
There are people watching this at home who are struggling to pay the bills or put food on the table. They have to account for every penny that they spend. Can the First Minister explain to them either why the issue has nothing to do with him or how he managed to buy a piece of land with their money for £840,000 and sell it for just £50,000?
Because neither the valuation of land for purchase nor the valuation of land for sale is made by Scottish Government ministers, as Johann Lamont perfectly well knows.
If her question was not an attempt to smear a Scottish businessperson, as she said, why did Johann Lamont casually mention—or read out—that he was a donor to the Conservative Party? Why did she say that he was on a political journey? Why did she say that he was appointed to the Scottish Government’s economic forum? What was that about if it was not a fairly blatant attempt to smear a perfectly respectable Scottish businessperson?
I think that the people who are watching will be interested and concerned: are they going to keep their bus passes under Labour? [Interruption.] Well, we do not know—the cuts commission is still considering the issue. Is Johann Lamont not going to reintroduce tuition fees for Scottish students? Is free personal care going to be safe under Labour? The answer is no to all of those questions. She has them under consideration by the cuts commission and its something for nothing society.
Johann Lamont does not want to talk about the issues that concern the people of Scotland, because people know that Labour has let them down in the past and, if it gets the chance, will let them down again. That is why she is sitting there, reading out the questions, and this Government is in office.
If her question was not an attempt to smear a Scottish businessperson, as she said, why did Johann Lamont casually mention—or read out—that he was a donor to the Conservative Party? Why did she say that he was on a political journey? Why did she say that he was appointed to the Scottish Government’s economic forum? What was that about if it was not a fairly blatant attempt to smear a perfectly respectable Scottish businessperson?
I think that the people who are watching will be interested and concerned: are they going to keep their bus passes under Labour? [Interruption.] Well, we do not know—the cuts commission is still considering the issue. Is Johann Lamont not going to reintroduce tuition fees for Scottish students? Is free personal care going to be safe under Labour? The answer is no to all of those questions. She has them under consideration by the cuts commission and its something for nothing society.
Johann Lamont does not want to talk about the issues that concern the people of Scotland, because people know that Labour has let them down in the past and, if it gets the chance, will let them down again. That is why she is sitting there, reading out the questions, and this Government is in office.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 12 Sep 2013 →- General Question Time Questions · 1
- Passenger Rail Franchise (Bicycles) Questions · 10
- Cycle Paths Questions · 4
- Cluff Natural Resources (Meetings) Questions · 4
- Patient Safety (Monklands, Wishaw and Hairmyres Hospitals) Questions · 6
- NHS Greater Glasgow and Clyde Questions · 4
- Broadband (South Scotland) Questions · 4
- Forth Crossing (Local Jobs) Questions · 4
- Speed Limits (A9) Questions · 9
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 12
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 10
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Fostering First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Child Poverty First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Palliative Care First Minister’s Questions · 7
- Dogs (Compulsory Microchipping) Members’ business · 13
- Scottish Independence Referendum Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 104
- Point of Order Procedure · 5
- Scottish Independence Referendum Bill: Financial Resolution Bill debate · 1
- Decision Time Decision time · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.