Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Broadcasting

Tuesday 11 March 2014 Education and Culture Committee About 10:00–12:30 Evidence session 362 contributions · 14 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

362 contributions · showing 1–200
Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Good morning and welcome to the seventh meeting in 2014 of the Education and Culture Committee. I remind all those present that electronic devices should be switched off because they interfere with the broadcasting system.

Our first item is to take evidence on broadcasting. The committee published a report on broadcasting last May, which focused on BBC Scotland’s capacity to handle forthcoming major events—namely, the referendum and the Commonwealth games. We will take evidence from representatives of BBC Scotland later, but first we will hear from Professor John Robertson.

In February this year, Professor Robertson published research on the BBC’s and STV’s coverage of the referendum campaign, which will, of course, be of direct relevance to our later discussions. I welcome him to the committee and invite him to make a brief opening statement.

Professor John Robertson University of the West of Scotland
link

Thank you very much, convener.

I thank the committee for allowing me to give evidence, because much has happened in the month or so since I released the research paper. Much of that has been quite upsetting for me, so I want to begin by saying some fairly strong things about my experience in the past month or so.

First, I condemn the behaviour of BBC Scotland’s department of public policy and corporate affairs in suppressing the dissemination of my research, circulating an insulting and ill-informed critique of it directly to my principal—it went straight to my principal, bypassing my head of school and my dean—and circulating that to everyone who sent an email complaint about its coverage of the referendum. The audience is not always here for that condemnation. I appreciate that you are not part of that.

I am sorry if this seems a bit dramatic and over the top, but it has been a very stressful month.

Secondly, I condemn the silence and collusion of almost all Scotland’s mainstream media in disappearing my research, despite its massive online presence. That online presence is a news item that has been ignored. I have my suspicions about why that happened, but I do not know for certain.

Thirdly, unfortunately, I condemn the silence of almost all Scottish academics with an interest in the field, who might have been expected to challenge censorship of intellectual material.

I have been personally hurt by the combination of threat from a powerful institution—there has been no horse’s head in my bed yet; I suppose that that is always something—and abandonment by the mainstream media and academia, other than my immediate colleagues, whom I must thank.

I interpret what has happened as an attempt at thought control in a democracy—and the one that I like best of all democracies. I am very upset by that.

I am happy to respond to any questions.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Thank you very much, Professor Robertson.

The main issue that we want to discuss is your research, which you mentioned. I will ask a general opening question. Will you lay out for us some of the findings of the first year of your research? I know that there is a two-year programme. As you said, you published the first year’s findings around a month ago.

Professor Robertson
link

My research shows a crude quantitative imbalance between the number of statements that have been reported that we could see as supportive of the yes campaign and those that we could see as supportive of the no campaign. I appreciate that there is a high degree of subjectivity in all that. All social, political and historical research is subjective.

I am committed to a kind of research that is often referred to as grounded theory. I take it very seriously and try to hold back as much as I can. I have taught students about it for 30 years. I teach them about the importance of not leaping in the way that, I am afraid, journalists often do.

That finding seemed to grab everybody’s attention. Yes campaigners on the web immediately flew up into a fury of saying, “Ah, evidence at last: a 3:2 ratio.” My feeling was that the 3:2 ratio was not very important, because a lot of it was down to people simply saying, “Well, let’s hear what the Liberal Democrat says” and “Let’s hear what the Conservative says.” That led to an imbalance of a quantitative nature.

Three or four items were far more important and drew less attention, one of which was sequence. There was a common tendency to begin with bad news during the research period. There is a lot of evidence that audiences are quite resilient to political messages, but they are less resilient when it comes to the economy. They are much more likely to believe bad-news stories, so beginning with bad-news stories about the economy, job losses and so on has a disproportionate influence. There was a tendency for “Reporting Scotland” especially to begin with bad-news stories more often than the other channels.

I have been producing a snapshot of what happened in February. The picture for “Reporting Scotland” for February massively improved, in the period after the row about my research blew up. I will not necessarily claim credit for that change, but the imbalance picture for BBC 1 has dramatically worsened. It is almost as if BBC 1 has entered the fray to present bad-news stories.

The personalisation of the campaign in relation to the First Minister and the conflation—journalists mentioned this at the weekend—of the yes agenda with Alex Salmond’s personal wishes and his face on screen were disproportionately done. We hardly ever heard the suggestion that Alistair Darling wants this or that. With due respect, I think that both are capable of being made into figures of fun by the media where that is the intention to do so.

I thought that that approach was imbalanced, as was the undue respect that was shown to political organisations such as the Office for Budget Responsibility and the Institute for Fiscal Studies. The idea that such organisations are impartial is deeply wrong. Any social scientist will provide you with evidence that they are political animals, whose research should be treated with the same caution as research that comes from the Scotland Office is treated.

I am in danger of forgetting, but I think that those are the main points.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

That is fine, Professor Robertson. I am sure that we will get into the detail when members ask questions.

Clare Adamson SNP Central Scotland
link

Professor Robertson, thank you for your opening remarks. We have all taken on board your comments about what has happened since your report was published.

Professor Robertson
link

I should say that I have been promoted in the interim. I thought that that was delayed—it took months and months, and I wondered whether I had shot myself in the foot. However, my new principal is Australian and I do not think that he gives a 4X about any of this.

Clare Adamson SNP Central Scotland
link

You said of the methodology that you used:

“The coding which led to the evidence of bias emerged from a grounded theory/phenomenological approach which allows the data to speak.”

Will you talk about where else the methodology has been used and why you chose it?

Professor Robertson
link

The methodology is long-standing in the social sciences—it was used as far back as the 1970s. Around the time I was an undergraduate, there were the beginnings of a shift from a more positivist approach—rather arrogant social scientists thinking that they knew what was in the evidence before they went looking for it. I am not crawling when I say that feminist methodology has been very influential; there is a strong suggestion that the move towards a more qualitative approach, which allows the evidence to emerge rather than be selected, was driven by the greater presence of women in social science research.

Clearly things cannot be perfect, but that can be the intention. Ian Bell, who is the only journalist who is really mentioned in my research, commented on my commitment to fairness and self-awareness and agreed with the approach. There is a lot of talk among journalists and educators about balance and bias, which are very subjective. We cannot really achieve balance; what we can do is have a good intention to be self-aware all the time and to be fair to the evidence, rather than go in with preconceptions.

I am sorry; that was a long answer.

Clare Adamson SNP Central Scotland
link

In what period was your research conducted?

Professor Robertson
link

The first block covered September to September in the first year since the announcement of the referendum date. I am currently working on the second year.

I publish mostly in peer-reviewed journals, which largely encourage us to stay well away from politics. It is a sad fact that intellectuals have become detached from politics. There is a place for engagement, as long as it is intelligent engagement.

I was urged by Scottish Affairs to sit on the whole thing until it was finished, but that struck me as pointless. I was hoping to improve coverage. I did not think that I would necessarily shout out one way or the other, but rather naively I thought that the BBC’s department of self-improvement—if there is one—might be interested in the research and invite me along for a chat about it. However, the BBC just reported me to the principal.

I am sorry; did I answer your question?

Clare Adamson SNP Central Scotland
link

Yes, you did.

You talked about the reaction of your academic colleagues and the BBC to your research. Are you aware of the BBC getting so involved in criticising any other research in Scotland?

Professor Robertson
link

No, I am not.

On an online blog, I have been compared with Professor Curtice, from the University of Strathclyde—I will not say anything that is offensive to Professor Curtice, of course. A commentator said, “I’ll explain it: Professor Curtice is premier league; this Robertson guy is playing in the reserves at Elgin City.” That kind of thing is happening in the background.

There are huge bodies of research that are not being questioned. Professor Curtice’s research—I can say this without insulting him—is based on sampling. He and his team sample perhaps 1,000 people to represent the electorate of Scotland, but how many millions have been reduced to 1,000? Such an approach introduces massive potential for distortion, as you will see from how ineffective polling has been for a long period of time.

One of the reasons why I am quite angry about this is that I did no selection; instead, I looked at all the broadcasting from 6 pm to 7 pm over the year in question. Once you start to select, people can say, “You missed something. You just happened—unluckily—to choose the bad news.”

10:15

Joan McAlpine SNP South Scotland
link

I want to ask a quick supplementary on your methodology. What research have you done in the past? Is this the first time you have looked at Scottish politics?

Professor Robertson
link

My interest is in—dare I say it—thought control in democracies. Thought control is totally ineffective in totalitarian states because the entire population pretty much knows that they cannot trust the media or the stuff from the party and that they are being lied to. However, there is undeniably thought control in democracies.

Media and political elites often work in each other’s interest. They do not get round some big cauldron and say, “Let’s do down the working classes and send our boys off to die”—they just mix. They went to the same schools, their children go to the same schools, they share the same cultural interests, and so on. As a result, we end up with a degree of thought control not as a result of conspiracy but through self-censorship, with members of elites acting in their own interests and therefore in the interests of their elite.

For many years now, I have researched the media coverage of war and the economy, but this is my first piece of research to attract any interest. All my research is published in academic journals, and when I get the occasional postgraduate student writing to me I think, “At least I’ve influenced one person.” Most of my work has, I think, been more controversial than this piece of work; I guess that what has happened is just a matter of timing.

I have been a bit naive. I had just finished a piece of research on the television coverage of the British Airways cabin crew strike, which I thought would be interesting because of the gender dimension and the idea that cabin crew are quite different from real crew. Under my contract, I am expected to produce research and submit it for review and, when I had finished the research on the cabin crew strike, I was looking around at subjects that might be interesting right now.

I have to say that, when I published the research that we are discussing, I was surprised by the email from Mr Small of the BBC. It caught me off-guard. That might be naivety on my part; I do a lot of quantitative stuff, so I might have a slightly autistic streak. I do not always pick up the political.

I am sorry—that was a long answer.

Liam McArthur LD Orkney Islands
link

Good morning, Professor Robertson. I read with interest the report that you provided to the committee. In your opening remarks, you drew attention to what you saw as the conflation of the First Minister and his views and perspectives on independence with a line of attack that was unique to those seeking to retain the union. Would you say that there is a similar tendency by the First Minister and, more broadly, the yes campaign to characterise the union as something to do with David Cameron, George Osborne, posh southern Tories or whatever you will? Might both sides be echoing a personalisation of politics that goes on in all elections and all political contexts?

Professor Robertson
link

I can talk about only the period that I surveyed. I admit that that period did not stretch to a full year of the campaign, but I noticed that an intensity of the demonisation of the First Minister happened during the first six months. It reminded me very strongly of how Michael Foot—many of you are probably a bit too young to remember him—and Neil Kinnock were treated and made fools of by the media. In other words, the idea was to associate a fool with a political stance.

I do not know because I have not yet looked at the data, but I think that George Osborne has recently been picked out in a similar way and, to be fair, I think that the Scottish media has been quite keen to jump on him. For example, we have seen Bernard Ponsonby shouting at him—and no doubt everyone has been cheering at that.

There might be some truth in what you say, but in the period that I covered there was a very heavy imbalance. Hardly ever was it suggested that Johann Lamont wanted anything, even though it would have been as easy to demonise her as it was to demonise Alex Salmond.

Liam McArthur LD Orkney Islands
link

Does that not throw up a possible problem with your approach to the research? The association, particularly of David Cameron, with welfare reform and other difficult decisions that were being taken at United Kingdom level was being conflated with the independence debate in very much the same way that Alex Salmond was being conflated.

Professor Robertson
link

Not in the year that I surveyed. You must remember that my commitment is to record what is there, and the tendency that you have mentioned with regard to David Cameron was much weaker than the tendency to commonly associate Alex Salmond with everything and to open broadcasts with “Alex Salmond this” and “Alex Salmond that”.

Liam McArthur LD Orkney Islands
link

I would be very surprised if between September 2012 and September 2013 there was not extensive coverage at UK and Scottish level about welfare reform and attacks by Alex Salmond—

Professor Robertson
link

Are you looking at “Reporting Scotland”?

Liam McArthur LD Orkney Islands
link

—and Scottish National Party ministers on what was happening with welfare reform and the budget cuts to deal with the economic crisis.

Professor Robertson
link

The way that a welfare reform story is presented might not be directly concerned with the referendum. I appreciate, though, that you could take it that way.

Liam McArthur LD Orkney Islands
link

Your report also refers to health-related matters, which are entirely devolved to the Scottish Parliament, but I am not entirely sure what point you are making about reports on health-related issues with regard to the referendum.

Professor Robertson
link

I agree that subjective decisions had to be made when I looked at this material and thought about where to put it. I am open to the suggestion that another team might move things about a bit, but I do not think that they would make a big difference. I suspect that, if you were to bring in fairly naive undergraduates—the kind I know the BBC has recently recruited in some number and directed with a view to destroying my research—and if they were to look at the raw data, they would probably come out showing more bias on the part of the BBC.

Liam McArthur LD Orkney Islands
link

Frankly, since the 2010 election, the point that has been made about welfare reform—sometimes implicitly and often explicitly—is that everything will be done very differently in an independent Scotland. Surely, then, the reporting of that is material to where there might be balance or bias in the reporting of political issues.

Professor Robertson
link

All I am talking about is what I have found, and that is what I found in that period. I do not want to comment on gut feelings and whatever I am thinking at the moment—I want to hold back until it is time to look at the material—but I suspect that you might be correct that there has been an increased tendency to associate Cameron and Osborne as people with particular initiatives and to demonise welfare reform as a consequence. However, in the year that I surveyed, there was no such tendency.

Professor Robertson
link

If you can dig up some examples, please send them to me. If I have missed anything, I will admit as much.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

I am happy to bring you back in later, Liam, but other members are waiting to ask questions.

Jayne Baxter Lab Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Good morning, Professor Robertson. My view is that, in life, we often see things as we not as others are. Do you accept that, as far as research studies are concerned, the coding of language is subjective, that a person’s world-view and understanding of life will have an impact on their decisions about language and that you are as susceptible to that as anyone else? How impartial do you think you have been able to be in the process?

Professor Robertson
link

I agreed entirely with you until you said that I was as susceptible to this as anyone else. I have spent 30 years trying to be less susceptible by immersing myself in constraining procedures. I know that it sounds tremendously elitist, but I do not think that my performance is the same as the average person’s. After all, this has been my job for 30 years.

I agree and will admit that all research into politics into political, social and economic factors can be presented in certain ways. I have looked at some of the other papers that have been presented to the committee for discussion later on this morning, and I could jump all over them if you wanted me to.

What puzzles me is: given the potential to have a critique and a debate, why did the BBC, The Guardian or The Herald not report the study? Why did they not find a professor who disagrees with me, call me in and have me debate it with him? Why did they just suppress it? I think it is because, in the end, there was a feeling that it could not be. They cannot pin me down to membership of anything or to having an alignment. You have suggested that I am human—thanks for that. I am a bit autistic, which I think makes me a bit more suited to this kind of thing than normal humans.

I have wandered a bit there—I am sorry.

George Adam SNP Paisley
link

Good morning, Professor Robertson. I know your principal, Craig Mahoney, quite well, because he is based in Paisley. I met him not so long ago and I know exactly what he is like in his attitude towards things.

In your report, you mentioned the personalisation of the campaign in relation to Alex Salmond during the first year. You mentioned Michael Foot and Neil Kinnock, who are perfect examples of how the media went out of their way to play the man and not the ball.

You said that, on 23 October 2012, “Reporting Scotland” used the phrase, “Alex Salmond under pressure!” and that, in the same show, it was said that Willie Rennie “challenged Alex Salmond’s policy”. You also stated:

“On 25/10/12, in Reporting Scotland, Salmond is described by Johann Lamont (Labour) as ‘straight as a corkscrew’ and then compared by Ruth Davidson (Con) to bent salesman ‘Delboy’.”

Those things hardly seem fair and open.

In your chart, your figure for the personalisation of ideas as Alex Salmond’s is 35, whereas the figure for the personalisation of ideas as those of better together individuals—you broaden it out to take in everyone else—is absolutely zero. I would say that that is quite an important part of your findings. If we want to make the debate better and have engagement with the public, we have to move away from the personalisation of the process.

Professor Robertson
link

I am not a political scientist—I am a media researcher—so I could agree with you, but I do not feel tremendously expert on what should be done. I think that, in a democracy, the media should be open and self-critical. What angers me most is that I do not think that it is self-critical; I think that it is rather closed and cosy.

George Adam SNP Paisley
link

Taken on their own, the figures of 35 and zero seem incredible.

Professor Robertson
link

Mind you, that is out of hundreds of messages, so you could argue—if you were to take the other perspective—that it is quite a small percentage.

I am not suggesting anything about impact here, although I hinted a little. There is hard research evidence that bad news sticks and may affect voters—bad news about the economy, in particular, does that. It is less clear what the impact of the representation of Alex Salmond is. My mum dislikes Alex Salmond very strongly. I do not know why. I think that she just dislikes the way he is, which I think has a lot to do with what she has seen and the way he is presented, so it may be that that has had an impact—I do not know what she thought before the campaign.

Were this the Crimea, we would say, “Okay, pass, not bad, reasonably balanced.” The coverage is not really extreme, it must be said. This is by far the most civilised process in the world when it comes to an attempt to separate one country from another—it is incredibly polite.

The 3:2 ratio is of almost no significance. We are talking about the respect for certain allegedly independent agencies. It is the presentation of individuals that really counts.

George Adam SNP Paisley
link

You mention some of the stuff that has been part of the debate that has no academic substance or value. Statements have been made that have no backing. An example that you give in your evidence is:

“On 5/10/12, in Reporting Scotland, the Scottish Government’s commitment to universal benefits was immediately followed by a reference to ‘spending watchdog chief Robert Black who has questioned whether such benefits are affordable’ and reinforced by reference to Black’s cv”.

I see that as an example of how certain things are said and are just left to hang there during the debate.

Professor Robertson
link

You could have a debate about whether Mr Black’s CV is important. I have played a similar card when I have said that I am not subject to subjectivity because of my training. I suppose that it could be argued that his CV gives him a certain entitlement to speak. However, if there are too many of those examples, it leads to an imbalance. I have not been treated with particular respect—far less respect than Professor Curtice has been treated with—and I do not think that I should be treated with enormous respect.

10:30

George Adam SNP Paisley
link

You have been dragged into the matter because of your research. One of the examples that you give is that you have been told that you are the equivalent not of a premier league player, but of an Elgin City reserve. I take offence at that, because my wife’s family is from Elgin.

Professor Robertson
link

I am actually a Falkirk fan, as well.

George Adam SNP Paisley
link

Another perfect example that you give is:

“On 26/4/13, in Reporting Scotland, a generally negative assessment of the future of insurance companies after independence finished with the”

line from a Labour spokesperson talking about

“‘billions in costs’ and ‘potential closures’.”

There is no substance behind all that. It seems to be very one-sided. The yes campaign has asked for answers and definites, but those seem to be just fluffy lines.

Professor Robertson
link

Journalists will often say that they are working under the pressure of deadlines—and they are. What they do is not a conspiracy, as such. If, over a period of time, they produce an imbalance, that is partly random and partly to do with their subconscious preferences. They do it without really planning to do it. It is not malevolent.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I will also defend Elgin City. I remind you that Inverness Caledonian Thistle and Ross County were in the Highland league, and look where they are now. I have to do that because I am a Highland MSP.

Professor Robertson
link

Of course. Due respect.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Professor Robertson, do you favour independence for Scotland?

Professor Robertson
link

Yes.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

You favour independence for Scotland—I have a quotation that says that you do—and I favour Scotland remaining part of the United Kingdom. Would I be right in saying that, if we watched the same television broadcast, I would be more sensitive to comments about David Cameron, George Osborne or any Conservative, including my leader, Ruth Davidson, whereas, because you favour independence, you would probably be more sensitive to comments that are anti-independence?

Professor Robertson
link

I have made reference to being slightly autistic, but I cannot deny that I have some kind of humanity and, therefore, weakness. I have made it very clear that there is always subjectivity and the way to deal with subjectivity in a democracy is to report it and argue about it, not to hide it because it is bad news. Therefore, I agree with you. However, although I favour independence, I do so for many reasons that would not allow me to join the Scottish National Party.

Researchers should surface themselves. There was a belief in the past that researchers should hide themselves. Teachers were also encouraged to hide who they were because it was thought that, otherwise, they would contaminate everything. My belief is that, if we surface who we are, we can tell more.

I am primarily a socialist—I would put that first. I am not a nationalist in that sense. I would probably put pacifist in second position, so NATO is anathema to me. In third position, I would say that I am a feminist. The abuse of women in Scottish society is an enormous scandal. We might even argue that it should be the first thing to be dealt with. The treatment of women in this country—and in other countries, obviously—is horrific. I would put those three before any interest in independence.

I have a feeling that small countries tend to be more democratic. They tend to be less likely to be imperialist states. I am also an anti-imperialist. I condemn the history of the British empire. It cannot be rewritten: the British empire was a massive protection racket that brutalised enormous parts of the world. In 100 years’ time, once everything is out in the open, historians will probably be hard pushed to say whether the Soviet Union or the British empire was worse.

As you can tell, nationalism is way down the line. I am a nationalist because I think that the Danish seem to do it quite well, so I would quite like to be like them.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

You have completed the quotation that you previously gave:

“I’m a socialist, pacifist, feminist and anti-imperialist. The latter position inevitably means I do favour independence for Scotland”.

Professor Robertson
link

For small countries.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

As an academic for 20 years before becoming an MSP—I lectured economics as opposed to your subject—

Professor Robertson
link

The miserable science.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Would it be fair to say that another researcher in your shoes, with my thoughts, my views and my values, which favour Scotland remaining in a United Kingdom, would be able to interpret the same information in a different way? As you have confirmed, you favour independence for Scotland, which is fine. I welcome your views; I feel strongly that, in a democracy, the views of academics are as important as any views expressed in the Parliament. Do you think that another researcher looking at the same information could have presented a different conclusion if they favoured Scotland remaining in the United Kingdom?

Professor Robertson
link

To a point. Again, I make this arrogant claim for exceptionalism. If a researcher has been at it for 30 years, if they use grounded theory and if they are committed to allowing evidence to emerge, as modern researchers are, I do not think that they could have come out of the evidence with a hugely different picture.

I have referred to multiple phases of coding. It is not possible just to collect all this stuff and code it once. As we code changes, we see how we might have coded what came earlier. I coded the data twice. That is a big task—it takes absolutely ages. The first time through, I came out with a stronger imbalance against the yes campaign. I went back through the evidence and I looked at sentences. I thought, for instance, that some statements were still pro no, although it was not as obvious, and somebody else might disagree with me. I dropped those ones. The category for where everything else goes therefore grew bigger the second time.

In the end, I have to agree that I come with baggage. I cannot entirely escape it, but I have done my level best.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

We all come with baggage.

The BBC has said that your report

“singularly fails to define – ‘fairness’, ‘insulting language’.”

What may seem unfair to you may seem fair to me. Insulting language could be subjective. Is that reasonable?

Professor Robertson
link

There were very few examples of that in terms of the number of messages.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

The BBC was looking for your definition. It said that you failed to give one.

Professor Robertson
link

You are right. I did not give a definition; I used examples. The examples, such as those that George Adam gave earlier, were almost entirely from Johann Lamont and were aimed at Alex Salmond. Sometimes, they came from your leader. One example is “straight as a corkscrew”. I do not think that there is any ambiguity in that as an insult.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I refer to the examples that you have mentioned. The first example on page 5 of our papers is:

“Scots savers and financial institutions might be at risk”.

We have discovered this week that European Union legislation means that financial organisations such as the Royal Bank of Scotland have to be based in the area where the majority of their customers are. There is uncertainty. George Adam rightly mentioned that things are hanging in the air, and I agree with that. Do you appreciate that many people are concerned and that there are some big questions to ask?

You also mention the subsidy for renewables. At the moment, the subsidy falls on a United Kingdom-wide population. In the event of independence, the renewables subsidy would fall on 2 million households. Do you understand that those are talking points and that, at the moment, because there is no pre-negotiation, there are no answers?

Professor Robertson
link

I do understand that. You will be far more knowledgeable than I am about what is happening.

Professor Robertson
link

I mean with regard to the politics. I am interested only in the representation of the politics.

Professor Robertson
link

I agree that that is selection, which is subjective. However, those are real examples. I am not saying that they are either true or false; I am saying that they are bad-news examples, and I am saying that there were lots of bad-news examples. I am not suggesting for a minute that anybody was wrong in what they said; I am just saying that they were presenting bad news.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

Is it not fair for the BBC and others to be part of the debate and to highlight risks and uncertainty where they feel that they exist? Is that not an obligation, on behalf of the freedom of the press, that the BBC has to have in a democracy?

Professor Robertson
link

Sure, but one of the reasons why the BBC head of policy was so angry with me was that the BBC has a charter, under which it is committed to fairness. Fairness is not the word that it uses, of course, but its journalists are committed to impartiality. If they are reporting negative stories more than positive stories, that opens up questions about their impartiality.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

A number of members want to ask questions. I will begin by bringing in those who have not yet spoken.

Neil Bibby Lab West Scotland
link

We have heard, Professor Robertson, that you are in favour of Scottish independence. Is it your belief, stated publicly, that the Labour Party is fatally corrupt?

Professor Robertson
link

Have I said—

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Hold on a second, Professor Robertson.

Mr Bibby, we are asking Professor Robertson about his views with regard to his research. I allowed Mary Scanlon’s question because I could see its relevance, but we are not going to get into a personalisation situation. If you want to ask questions about the research, that is fine, but we are not going to get into the area of Professor Robertson’s personal views.

Neil Bibby Lab West Scotland
link

In an interview that you gave to openDemocracy, you said:

“There are good people in the BBC. Mindless loyalty to a now fatally corrupted Labour Party is not uniform”.

Professor Robertson
link

I do not think that I should have said that last bit. I should have said the first bit, because I am not having a go at the BBC—I am not having a go at anybody, except defensively now, because the BBC had a go at me, and I do not see why I should take it lying down. The “fatally corrupted Labour Party” thing was inappropriate and I regret saying it.

Neil Bibby Lab West Scotland
link

If you regret using the phrase “fatally corrupted”, do you still believe that BBC employees are loyal to the Labour Party?

Professor Robertson
link

I do not know. I think that Kirsty Wark is.

Professor Robertson
link

It lies in her jumping all over Alex Salmond on television at every opportunity that she could get. Anyway, we are wandering off the subject of my research and into my personal views—or do you think that my views undermine my research?

Neil Bibby Lab West Scotland
link

Your view appears to be that you have retracted what you said about the Labour Party being corrupt, but—

Professor Robertson
link

No, I have not retracted it. I have said that I regret saying it.

Professor Robertson
link

I do not retract it.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

I have given you a little bit of time. We have only a limited amount of time and Professor Robertson is here to talk about his published research. If we can stick to that, I will be more than happy to take questions from you, Mr Bibby.

Professor Robertson
link

Would it help to reiterate what I said at the beginning—that I am a socialist and a pacifist? That means that there is virtually no mainstream political party in this country that I can hold in high respect. None of them.

Neil Bibby Lab West Scotland
link

My last question on this line sums up the point. When it comes to accusations of political bias, you are not a neutral observer, are you?

Professor Robertson
link

Political bias? Who have I accused of political bias?

Professor Robertson
link

I have not accused anybody of political bias. I have condemned the reaction to my research as undemocratic, unfair and unethical; those are probably the appropriate words. I have not condemned anyone in the research at all. I have observed something that I thought might be of interest.

Neil Bibby Lab West Scotland
link

I thought that the line,

“Mindless loyalty to a now fatally corrupted Labour Party”

was—

Professor Robertson
link

That is not in my research, is it?

Neil Bibby Lab West Scotland
link

That was part of an interview that you did with openDemocracy, but I just—

Professor Robertson
link

I agree. You will have said things in interviews—

Neil Bibby Lab West Scotland
link

I think that that was an interview that you did following your research.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

I am going to stop this now, because today’s evidence session is about the research that Professor Robertson has published. I am not going to let us get into a personality spat between members of the committee and witnesses. If any member wants to ask questions about the research, please do so, but we will not get involved in attacks on individuals about their personal views, which have nothing to do with the research that they have published.

I call Colin Beattie.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I have a couple of questions, the first of which is brief. I notice that you refer to phase 1 of your survey, which I presume refers to the period from September 2012 to September 2013. Is phase 2 the following year?

Professor Robertson
link

Yes.

Professor Robertson
link

It is currently under way, but I am not looking at it. Members have mentioned things that are happening in politics, but I am trying to stay back a bit from engagement, because I value the researcher’s role. I acknowledge that I will let slip gut feelings and emotional viewpoints—as I have admitted, I am only human—but I am doing my best to hold back. The whole two-year survey, plus a review of the literature and the references—I was once given a row for not having enough references and got only a C for my essay—will appear as a chapter in a book with other media academics, including those I have condemned today for not supporting me.

10:45

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I was also very interested in your discussion of evidence from sources other than the political parties that purport to be independent or whatever, and I think that you referred to academic or scientific evidence. On the OBR and the IFS, which you mentioned and which, to my mind, are very frequently used to support evidence that is put forward, you have stated:

“Notably, there was very little use of such evidence in the reporting overall”.

Professor Robertson
link

You should remember that that is a slightly teacherly reaction to the reporting. I do online debates with postgraduates and other students, who are slammed if they do not make heavy use of evidence and references. In what is a very important political debate, it seemed quite rare for any kind of academic, apart from one or two regular pet ones, to appear. Obviously I am not a pet academic. I do not know how I come across—as a bull terrier academic, perhaps—but it seemed to me that not very much evidence of that type was being used compared with the many statements of opinion that we were hearing from political editors. We have Brian Taylor over and over again saying what he thinks and yet there is hardly a professor or another academic saying what they think about the issues.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

I find that interesting because, as I have said, to my mind such references seem to be made very frequently. However, you have actually done the count and are saying that there is very little use of such evidence.

Professor Robertson
link

There has recently been a run of chief executives saying things. Is that what you mean?

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

No. I am thinking of your examples of the IFS and the OBR. For a long time now, they seem to have been very frequently mentioned in the press in support—

Professor Robertson
link

You must bear it in mind that I looked at only the television coverage. Press coverage is another matter. I suppose that the press has more time and more space. I can say only what I found; I did my best to let it be found.

Colin Beattie SNP Midlothian North and Musselburgh
link

It is an interesting anomaly. Thank you.

Liam McArthur LD Orkney Islands
link

Professor Robertson, you started by framing the research around your interest in censorship of the media. Earlier, George Adam referred to the comment about the “Reporting Scotland” report from October 2012, in which the watchdog chief Robert Black was mentioned as questioning the affordability of the Scottish Government’s commitment to universal benefits. I think that you said that the view was that his CV gave him an entitlement to speak. He was the Auditor General and, generally speaking, auditors tend to raise concerns and questions rather than give endorsements. Do you think that it would have been of greater concern if he had been raising concerns but he had not been quoted and the story had not been reported by “Reporting Scotland”?

Professor Robertson
link

I agree that if someone has a CV in a certain area, we should be interested in what they have to say—

Liam McArthur LD Orkney Islands
link

We are not talking about a CV. He has a statutory role to look at—

Professor Robertson
link

I am sorry, but the CV is the evidence for this. Are you talking about his current role?

Liam McArthur LD Orkney Islands
link

He has now demitted office but he had a statutory oversight role—

Professor Robertson
link

So you are saying that he does not have that role now.

Professor Robertson
link

So it is accurate to refer to his CV. If I refer to his CV, that is what I am talking about. It is not his current role.

Liam McArthur LD Orkney Islands
link

Right, but he would have been interviewed on the basis of the concerns that he had expressed as Auditor General—

Professor Robertson
link

But that was his previous role. I refer you back to your colleague Mary Scanlon’s point. Robert Black, too, will be subject to bias, will have baggage and so on.

Professor Robertson
link

But that is all right—we are all human.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

To say that we are all human is a fairly reasonable statement.

Mary Scanlon Con Highlands and Islands
link

I am sorry, but he is talking about the Auditor General.

Liam McArthur LD Orkney Islands
link

It is a fairly reasonable statement to say that we are all human but we are getting into fairly dangerous realms if we are impugning the reputation of the Auditor General.

Professor Robertson
link

I have not impugned anyone. I am simply saying that he is human and he may bring certain perspectives to bear. The point is that—

Liam McArthur LD Orkney Islands
link

With respect, his role as Auditor General is to question and highlight areas where further answers or greater clarity is needed or where figures have been presented that do not necessarily add up in the way that—

Professor Robertson
link

I do not know the Auditor General at all but, like all the other people involved in this, he is a political animal. He, too, will be political. I do not know that—I do not know anything about him—but he was mentioned on “Reporting Scotland”. I do not think that the other channels mentioned him; for example, I do not think that STV mentioned him that night.

You seem to be implying that we should pay attention to this particular statement, but the fact is that journalists choose. Sometimes they choose the chief executive of BP or Shell or whatever, and the other channel does not. Sometimes they choose differently. I am arguing not with the veracity of anything that is being said but about the overall picture.

Liam McArthur LD Orkney Islands
link

So because the Auditor General has sought to raise questions about the Government’s approach to one area, it reflects the Auditor General’s inherent political bias.

Professor Robertson
link

I have not said that at all.

Professor Robertson
link

I have not said anything like that. If you read what I have written, you will see that I have said that it is an example of bad news that has been left uncontradicted and has been treated with deference. That is just an objective statement. I am not saying that it should not have been treated that way.

Liam McArthur LD Orkney Islands
link

But there seems to be an implication that, because we are going through a process leading up to the referendum in September this year, if a negative perspective is taken on any issue, however it is perceived, it is somehow part of an anti-independence approach. I encourage you to watch much of BBC’s reporting on the UK Government. One could equally say that it takes a pro-independence approach in that it plays into the argument that Alex Salmond and others within the yes campaign are trying to prosecute.

Professor Robertson
link

You are setting me up as some kind of political scientist, which I am not. I am a media researcher. I have just described something that happened and which I thought was fair to code as an anti-independence statement that would worry people who are voting yes. It was presented without being countered, as if it were of unquestionable high status. I am not saying that it was not. How would I know? I know nothing of the Auditor General’s area of expertise. Without really having any emotions about it, I just looked at it and thought, “That was an uncontradicted negative and deference was shown to the whole thing.” What is wrong with that?

Liam McArthur LD Orkney Islands
link

Only the fact that Auditors General raise questions about Governments of all political hues. That is their role.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Before we move on, perhaps Professor Robertson can help us with a point of clarification. When that statement was made, was Bob Black the Auditor General or the former Auditor General?

Professor Robertson
link

I do not remember. I think that he was the former Auditor General but I would have to check my records.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

I, too, think that he was the former Auditor General. Liam McArthur keeps saying that he was the Auditor General but I do not think that he was at the time. A different impression would have been created if he had been the Auditor General.

Professor Robertson
link

To be fair to Liam McArthur, I think that he said that he was not sure.

Liam McArthur LD Orkney Islands
link

In your written submission, you seem to link the OBR and the IFS with the UK Government and other Government departments. Can you explain the IFS’s link to the UK Government?

Professor Robertson
link

I know of the IFS from previous research, and I know that it is aligned with a particular neoliberal view of economics. It is inaccurate for that organisation to describe itself as impartial because, although it might not see itself as such, it is also a political movement.

I am coming at this not as someone who has a view on independence but as someone with a particular view of the intellectual world and its impartiality. Far too many agencies in this world—the World Bank, for instance—try to present themselves as being somehow outside ideology, and I think that that is wrong. The OBR and the IFS are clearly aligned with certain political ways of thinking.

I am not saying that we should not be listening to them. However, there are examples of bad news that are coming from organisations that present themselves as impartial, and I am simply casting a little doubt on whether any of them is impartial.

Liam McArthur LD Orkney Islands
link

So when the First Minister quotes favourably from the IFS when it is critical of the UK Government, he is misguided, as was John Swinney when he talked about the establishment of an equivalent of the OBR in Scotland.

Professor Robertson
link

Again, you are turning me into a professor of politics. I just observed what was there, and I leave you to draw your conclusions as to whether anything should be done about it. I tried to describe what was there as coldly and impartially as I could. Should I have just kept quiet and said nothing at all about the fact that I have become in favour of independence for Scotland? I do not know. I have to say that I have become more so because of the no campaign. The research has made me slightly more in favour of independence. However, it is not a big deal for me; it absolutely does not drive me, and it comes way down the line after pacifism and other issues.

Clare Adamson SNP Central Scotland
link

I should probably have put on record earlier that I have worked with a number of students from the University of the West of Scotland—obviously, the university has a campus in Hamilton in my region—and that I recently had a journalism student doing work experience in my office.

Ms Scanlon gave the example of George Osborne’s concerns about where financial institutions have to be based, but I want to put on record my belief that the European Union is reviewing those rules and that, according to current reports, it seems that they are unlikely to continue.

We have had a wide-ranging discussion, but I have a fundamental concern about the issues that Professor Robertson set out in his opening statement and what has happened. Are you willing to give an opinion on the impact that your academic peer-reviewed research has had on the students at the university and the university’s reputation? Of course, we are very proud of the university in Scotland.

Professor Robertson
link

As Mao Zedong said when he was asked in the 1950s about the lessons to be drawn from the French revolution, it is probably too early to say. According to the head of policy at the BBC, I have damaged the corporate reputation of the UWS, which is why he reported me to the principal. He thought that I might have damaged the university’s corporate reputation. Of course, there are other kinds of reputation apart from corporate reputation.

I have not used the material with students, because the study has just been done this year. I use my research with students to demonstrate how to do research, but this research is too recent, so I cannot comment on that. I think that the impact will be mixed. There has been a huge amount of the kind of online activity that younger people are more engaged in. Someone suggested to me that there are about a quarter of a million online messages on Twitter and other things that I do not use referring to my research. As a result, the fact that the issue did not make The Daily Telegraph or whatever is perhaps not a big deal. Again, however, I am being drawn off the subject and on to things that I should not talk about.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Before we finish, I have a direct question about the research results. You mentioned that the 3:2 ratio is—if I can put it this way—not a headliner for you. I note that in some lines in the column in your data on “Reporting Scotland” and BBC 1 combined figures, there is a comparison between the two sides. For example, there were 211 pro-independence statements and 317 anti-independence statements; four pro-independence academic statements and 23 anti-independence academic statements; and there were 79 cases of an anti-pro order and 43 cases of a pro-anti order. We have mentioned some of the others, and I will not list them all, but in every single case in which the data can be compared the numbers are greater on the no side than on the yes side. Is it possible that, over a 12-month period, that could have happened by random accident?

Professor Robertson
link

I do not think that it could have happened in a random way. It suggests something structural. As I think I explained earlier, there was a tendency to allow everyone in the major parties to speak. There are three major no campaigning parties and one major yes campaigning party—obviously, that leaves out the Greens, the socialists and so on, who are presumably considered to be too small to be allowed to comment very often. If everyone in that group of no campaigning parties had been allowed to speak, we might actually have had a 3:1 ratio.

Often, the comments were very short. For example, the Lib Dems would be given barely a sentence. That can lead to an imbalance. That might, I think, not really matter a huge amount, but I do not know because the study is not a study of the effects. I have not interviewed potential voters, so I do not know. I leave it to Professor Curtice to interview voters.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Thank you for giving us your evidence and discussing your report—we appreciate it. I am sure that we all look forward to your future publication when it is finally completed.

Professor Robertson
link

That will happen when it is all over.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

I suspend the meeting briefly for a change of witnesses.

11:00 Meeting suspended.

11:03 On resuming—

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

I welcome our second panel of witnesses, who are all from BBC Scotland and will give evidence on broadcasting. We have with us Ken MacQuarrie, John Boothman, Bruce Malcolm and John Mullin.

I thank the witnesses for their further written evidence on BBC Scotland’s preparations for the referendum and the Commonwealth games. I will start with a question. I presume that you all heard the evidence this morning from Professor Robertson, who has just left, and you have, as an organisation, responded to his research. Mr MacQuarrie, can you tell us why you took the view that it was necessary to respond in the way that you did to Professor Robertson’s research?

Ken MacQuarrie BBC Scotland
link

Yes, I can. First, it would be worth putting a couple of points about Professor Robertson’s report on the record. We read the report with some interest, but we have serious concerns with it that pertain in particular to elements of its methodology and factual accuracy, its findings and its conclusions. We believe that the report displays fundamental errors in all those areas and for that reason we question its validity. We have detailed our concerns in our report, which we understand has been distributed to committee members.

When Professor Robertson’s report was first published on a website, it was not sent to us for comment. We were alerted to it by concerned members of the public, but even from a cursory examination we could see that there were errors in it. We contacted the author, and copied in the university given that the report had been published with the university’s logo appended. It was to my mind entirely proper that we did so, and the content and tone of our communication was also entirely proper.

We asked whether we might see the raw data, as we did not recognise the evidence that was presented in the report as an accurate reflection of our broadcast output, but the request was rejected by the report’s author. The report makes it clear that its evidence base was a series of transcripts of broadcast output. We are not, unfortunately, in a position to say how accurate those transcripts were, but, given the number of factual errors in the report, it is at least fair to ask the question.

We are aware that the version of the report that has been presented to the committee differs from the version that the author originally published in January, and that one or two of the errors that we pointed out have been corrected. However, the vast majority of the errors remain.

The original version claims that the weekly bulletins are the focus, but we pointed out that the report’s figures were therefore out by more than 200 hours. I see that the latest version of the report now claims that all the weekend bulletins were considered, and the figures have been revised down by around 100 hours, from 730 hours to approximately 640 hours. It seems that the author is unclear about what or how much news the report covers, which is the basis on which the entire report is predicated.

The report makes a number of allegations about our news coverage, as it does about the coverage by STV. We completely reject those allegations, as we reject the questioning of our journalists’ professionalism and of what they have brought to air.

The evidence that the report presents does not support its contentions, and the conclusions are based largely on flawed analysis and occasionally on intuitive guesswork. The report is not, as it claims to be, a piece of analysis that is based on empirical research, but rather a highly subjective and selective assessment of our news coverage.

It is important for the committee to note that the BBC is governed by the requirements of our editorial guidelines and by the Office of Communications’ broadcasting code. It is against those criteria that our impartiality is judged and we are entirely confident that not one of the examples in the report would have fallen foul of them.

We take full cognisance of sound analytical broadcasting research, such as the report, “From Seesaw to Wagon Wheel: safeguarding impartiality in the 21st century”, which was published in 2007, and Professor King’s report, which was published the following year.

Our issues are not with Professor Robertson, but simply with the report as it is published on the University of the West of Scotland’s website. We welcome all contributions to the debate, but we feel that it is important that we make it clear where there are errors of fact.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Thank you for that comprehensive response, Mr MacQuarrie.

How many pieces of academic research—I am sure that you will have to guess this, if you can—would BBC Scotland cover in a normal 12-month period?

Ken MacQuarrie BBC Scotland
link

I cannot give you an exact figure for how many we cover, but we feature a number of different pieces of academic research in our news broadcasts.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

It is a lot, is it not? That is a regular occurrence, almost on a daily basis.

Ken MacQuarrie BBC Scotland
link

Yes, although I could not give you an exact figure.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Can you tell me on how many occasions you expended BBC resources on—to be polite about it—tearing apart any such pieces of academic research and reporting that research to the principal of the institution from which the research came?

Ken MacQuarrie BBC Scotland
link

The piece of academic research that we are discussing was about our output, and our desire was not to tear it apart but simply to put on the record where there are factual errors. The report was on the University of the West of Scotland’s website, so it seemed to be perfectly reasonable to copy in the principal. I do not see it in any sense as a piece of academic research, which is always welcome in the debate that we are involved in by reporting on it.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

We know what you did with Professor Robertson’s research. I am asking whether you can give the number of occasions on which you have done something similar in relation to any of the many hundreds of other bits of academic research that you report every year.

Ken MacQuarrie BBC Scotland
link

In general terms, I cannot give a specific instance in which we would have copied the principal into a comment on a piece of academic research. What we do in our journalism is test, debate and discuss academic research on a regular basis. On the aforementioned research, Professor Robertson was given the opportunity to put his views on “Good Morning Scotland”.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Let me be clear about what you are saying. The answer is none at all.

Ken MacQuarrie BBC Scotland
link

Not to my knowledge.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

This is the only piece of research in relation to which that happened.

Ken MacQuarrie BBC Scotland
link

To my knowledge, as we currently stand.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Would an ordinary person who was looking at this not find it rather peculiar that although the BBC accepts academic research day in, day out and responds by publishing stories and having debates about it, on this one occasion, when the research was about the BBC’s own output, you responded entirely differently?

Ken MacQuarrie BBC Scotland
link

I do not think that it is peculiar in the slightest. We wanted to correct the errors of fact that were in the report. It is perfectly reasonable, given that the report was about our output and was on the question of our impartiality, that we would get the facts on the table. We wrote only to Professor Robertson, and copied to the principal.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

I am surprised by your answer. It seems astonishing that on no other occasion have you expended such effort in analysing academic research—you said that you did not think that you had ever done that before—but on this occasion you seem to have expended substantial effort in an attempt to discredit Professor Robertson’s research.

Ken MacQuarrie BBC Scotland
link

We simply wish to ensure that we have registered that the factual base of the research is incorrect. We wanted to supply example by example for Professor Robertson, with the true facts.

George Adam SNP Paisley
link

Do you get a lot of complaints about your coverage?

Ken MacQuarrie BBC Scotland
link

We get a number of complaints across the BBC about our coverage on any given subject. We also get a lot of plaudits, neutral comment and inquiries. There is a high volume of engagement with the public.

George Adam SNP Paisley
link

Do you have figures on the number of complaints you receive per annum?

Ken MacQuarrie BBC Scotland
link

The number of individual contacts with the BBC is in the order of 1 million per annum. I cannot give you a breakdown at this point—

George Adam SNP Paisley
link

Into news, current affairs, BBC Scotland and so on?

Ken MacQuarrie BBC Scotland
link

—if you want, I can supply that to you.

John Boothman BBC Scotland
link

Mr Adam, if it is helpful, I can say that in the past couple of years, in the context of the onset of the referendum debate and stories that we have done on Scottish football, there has been a rise in the number of complaints that BBC Scotland has dealt with. We try to answer each complainant as promptly as possible.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Mr MacQuarrie, did you say that you are willing to supply the committee with the total number of complaints, broken down by whether they are to do with football, the referendum and so on?

Ken MacQuarrie BBC Scotland
link

No. We would not be able to do that. I was talking about the generality of the number of contacts that we have with the audience in any particular year—

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

The question was about complaints. Can you give the number of complaints that you have received?

11:15

Ken MacQuarrie BBC Scotland
link

We would not normally do so as a matter of course in the BBC, but that—

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

I asked because when I put a freedom of information request to you on how many complaints BBC Scotland receives, you refused to answer. I thought that you just said that you would supply the committee—

Ken MacQuarrie BBC Scotland
link

No. I said that I could supply the number of contacts.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

You will not supply this committee with the number of complaints that the BBC has received about its referendum coverage.

Ken MacQuarrie BBC Scotland
link

In terms of the referendum coverage specifically, no.

Ken MacQuarrie BBC Scotland
link

In general terms, we use that contact and we reply to each complaint—and first of all, the body that would release that information is the BBC trust rather than the executive, and we would not break it down.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

I am trying to understand why not. You are a body that is paid for by the public. Surely the public have a right to know about the level of interest in or complaints about your output.

Ken MacQuarrie BBC Scotland
link

The trust publishes the data about the number of contacts on an annual basis.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

I am not asking you about the number of contacts. I am asking about the number of complaints that you have received from the public about the referendum coverage.

Ken MacQuarrie BBC Scotland
link

We would not break down the complaints into specific subject areas.

George Adam SNP Paisley
link

Has there been a cut in the number of people who deliver news and current affairs in BBC Scotland?

John Boothman BBC Scotland
link

In the run-up to the referendum, because of the £5 million of additional investment for Scotland, I think that more people are working in news and current affairs than has ever been the case. I think that we have added nearly 50 staff in the past year, to deal with all the additional output that we are providing in the run-up to the referendum.

George Adam SNP Paisley
link

Are you saying that flagship shows such as GMS and “Reporting Scotland”, the main news show, have more people working on them than they had previously?

John Boothman BBC Scotland
link

Yes—I can give you some examples. You will have read in the press recently that Sarah Smith is coming to present a new programme called “Scotland 2014”, which will start at the end of May. The chief reporter from The Herald recently joined us, and an economics correspondent from Northern Ireland, Colletta Smith, has joined us. Laura Bicker has been seconded to the position of political correspondent. We have 14 new news trainees. We have more producers coming to join us, to fulfil our obligations in relation to the extra coverage that we want to do.

The last time that we were here, we told the committee that for the fixed period of the referendum we would employ up to 50 additional staff to deal with all the new output that we propose for the referendum, some of which I am sure that members have already seen. We have had a number of debates and documentaries, and we have beefed up staffing around some of the programmes.

George Adam SNP Paisley
link

I am slightly confused—it might be entirely my fault; perhaps I live in a permanent state of confusion. The National Union of Journalists has told us on numerous occasions that its members are under more pressure. We have heard in various media outlets that shift patterns have changed to such an extent that producers are working through the night and then doing some of the early morning stuff. If we have so many people working for BBC Scotland, how come we are still hearing those reports from people who are employed in the industry?

John Boothman BBC Scotland
link

As I said, we have had £5 million of additional investment for the referendum and we are employing up to 50 additional staff. Until the end of the last financial year, we were in a period of making savings, which resulted in a number of redundancies, but since then, and for the period of the referendum, as well as our permanent staff we have had the additional £5 million and an additional 50 staff—

George Adam SNP Paisley
link

What is the breakdown of the 50 additional staff? Are they new staff? Are they newly qualified?

John Mullin BBC Scotland
link

May I step in here? Fifty staff have joined the referendum unit. All of them are contract staff and their contracts run out at the end of the referendum period. Many positions are for documentaries, so they are three-month contracts. We have beefed up online, with four new employees. We probably have a dozen or so people working on documentaries at any one time, but that is a rolling figure.

We have a gold standard form of training scheme for the trainees. They do three months of extensive training, and we put them around different programmes. Some of them are attached to online, some of them are attached to radio and some of them are attached to TV.

George Adam SNP Paisley
link

You are saying that we have more staff than we have ever had but that it is in effect all temporary contracts—it is all until the referendum is over.

John Mullin BBC Scotland
link

All 50 are temporary posts, yes.

George Adam SNP Paisley
link

You would say that, in the middle, between the two stories, there has probably been a change to your way of working, but the NUJ would say that there has been a cut in the number of journalists with full-time contracts in the BBC in Scotland.

Ken MacQuarrie BBC Scotland
link

We regularly meet the joint unions and we discuss the level of staffing. At a previous committee hearing, we indicated the level of savings that we had to make, due to the extra responsibilities that we have to undertake as part of the current licence fee settlement, which has been frozen for a period of pretty much seven years. We had to make savings in excess of £700 million across the organisation, on which we gave full evidence to the committee during a previous discussion.

We are working with the unions, and we have had constructive and positive meetings with them. There is an absolutely open channel with them. I absolutely believe that that is a matter for industrial relations between us, as the BBC management, and the unions and the staff.

George Adam SNP Paisley
link

We are talking about 35 full-time journalists, possibly, being let go from BBC Scotland. I recently saw a public advertisement for a public policy officer job, at between £39,000 and £62,000 a year. That brings me back to my original question about the level of complaints, which you have said is quite a lot higher. I have been led to believe that that post would assist with dealing with the level of complaints from the general public. Do you think that, following the changes to the management structure, as you would say—the union would probably describe it as the cut in journalist staff at the BBC—it presents the right image to advertise a job for £39,000 to £62,000 a year, which is in effect for someone who will just be dealing with complaints?

  1. 10:00 Broadcasting Evidence session · 362
  2. 12:30 Cyberbullying Evidence session · 68

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.