Agenda item 4 is consideration of three petitions. I will take the petitions in the order set out in paper 7.
The first petition is PE1466, on local authority charges for non-residential services. Members will see from the arguments in the paper on the petition that there is little or nothing further that the committee can do on it. The suggestion is that we agree to close the petition but draw it to the attention of the Local Government and Regeneration Committee for information. Do members have any comments? Richard?
The very welcome thing is that the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities is now publishing the charges. I know from personal experience that that is already having a political effect. If when local authorities are drawing up their budgets their charges are below the average, they are tending to limit increases to putting them up to the average. Of course, that moves the average up, but nevertheless it is a reasonable constraint, and those who charge above the average might in turn be constrained not to put up their charges. I think that that is very useful.
The letter from COSLA in March 2013 referred to “a fundamental review” of charging policy. Do we know whether that review has been completed? Has the petitioner been advised as to whether it has been completed? Should we advise the Local Government and Regeneration Committee that it might wish to take that matter up with COSLA instead of this committee doing so?
Duncan McNeilLabThe Convener · Greenock and Inverclyde
We could certainly also draw the Local Government and Regeneration Committee’s attention to that point, but it is not for us to decide that committee’s work programme. We would pass on the petition and make the point.
I concur with what Richard Simpson said earlier: yes indeed you are back and it is good to have you back, sir.
I remember the previous evidence session on this petition. There seemed to be a bit of nervousness about publishing the various charges that each local authority levies. I think that I suggested that perhaps the local authorities should inform their constituents where they ranked out of the 32 local authorities so that they could see whether, for example, they were the most expensive in the country for having grass cut or the least or most expensive for bulk uplift.
It is good that the authorities are now systematically publishing such information, which I think in itself has been a bit of a result for the petitioner and this committee. Dr Simpson’s comments reminded me of that, and I want to stress it for the record.
Duncan McNeilLabThe Convener · Greenock and Inverclyde
Do we concur with the suggestion, then, that we close the petition but draw it to the attention of the Local Government and Regeneration Committee for information, with the addition of the point that Dr Simpson made?
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.