As you have rightly said, convener, paragraph 31 in the papers available for public consumption makes it clear that the Scottish Government has no plans to instigate an inquiry. I would find it unfortunate if that remained the position, not least because it pre-empts some of the other matters that I am going to allude to.
I should say that the Justice for Megrahi committee has very generously given our committee some credit for the Scottish Government finally admitting that it actually had powers and a remit under the Inquiries Act 2005, after saying for 18 months that it did not. There is certainly a wide range of issues to examine around that particular aspect.
On the nine allegations that the Justice for Megrahi committee has subsequently made, I point out that they are allegations of serious criminality in what was a mass murder case. We know from the paper that has been circulated the various stages that the allegations have gone through. Three of the issues are frozen, and it is a matter of considerable concern that the Justice for Megrahi committee received no update from Dumfries and Galloway Constabulary, which continues as the Dumfries and Galloway division of Police Scotland. We know—because, convener, you were directly involved in writing the letter—that Deputy Chief Constable Pat Shearer undertook to get back to us in a matter of weeks. We were told that in, I think, September 2013, but the same gentleman retired in October. Key to all of this is the role of the senior investigating officer—indeed, they play a pivotal role in any criminal inquiry—and Mr Shearer was the senior investigating officer in this case.
Convener, the letter that you have alluded to, which was sent by Detective Superintendent Johnstone to Mr Forrester and which, with incredible timing, arrived the day before this committee meeting, intimates that “from this point forward”—the letter is dated 17 February—Mr Johnstone is to be the senior investigating officer. That raises some very legitimate questions. Who, for instance, was the senior investigating officer between Mr Shearer’s departure and Mr Johnstone’s announcement yesterday of his own appointment to the role? Indeed, was anyone acting in that role? In some respects, we could be very reassured by Mr Johnstone’s comment in the letter that the matters
“will be resolved before the end of March”,
but it is strange that he is unable to say how many officers are employed on the inquiry.
All of this adds up to an extremely dismissive approach by the authorities to the Justice for Megrahi committee—and by default, I would suggest, to our committee, which plays an important oversight role. The timing of the letter is entirely cynical. What we have seen is procrastination and obstruction, and whose interests are served by that? We know that Police Scotland undertakes criminal inquiries at the behest of the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service, and I have to say that, given the nature of the matters under discussion, I cannot see it injecting any urgency into this inquiry.
It is questionable whose interests are being served here. In any case, our obligation is to ensure that the public interest is served, and I have to say that some young man under a breach of the peace charge might well wonder what sort of treatment he would receive from both authorities if such a high-profile mass murder case can result in this kind of response to the legitimate concerns that have been raised—reluctantly, in the case of the criminal ones. We must ensure that there is confidence in the criminal justice system—from those charged with investigating crimes to those charged with prosecuting them.
The issue demands political oversight and I think that this body should be carrying that out. For those reasons—and I await Mr Johnstone’s update with great interest—we should keep the petition open.