The next current petition is PE1412, by Bill McDowell, on bonds of caution. Members have a note by the clerk and the submissions. As members will know, the Scottish Government states in summary that it will not prioritise the work and is seeking to consult on this area, so there are issues with the timescale.
One suggestion is that we defer consideration of the petition until the end of the year so that we know the results of the Scottish Government’s consultation. We do not have any control over the timescale because of the way in which the Scottish Government has prioritised the issue—or rather, the lack of priority that it has given it—so the end of the year is our best guess as to when the consultation will be completed. That is the reason for the rather lengthy deferral that we are suggesting. Do members have any views?
I am minded to close the petition under rule 50.7, if that is the correct rule. The Scottish Government has said that it will consider the issue only if it has time. Closing the petition would offer the petitioner the opportunity to come back with a fresh petition at a later date, as opposed to our simply deferring reconsideration of the current petition for 10 months when the Scottish Government’s programme might not be any further forward.
It would be more useful to close the petition, with a view to allowing the petitioners to submit a fresh petition once the Scottish Government has set out its legislative programme, which might incorporate the petitioner’s wishes. That would be more appropriate.
David StewartLabThe Convener · Highlands and Islands
I understand why John Wilson says that, but I am not altogether satisfied with the Government’s response or its justification for the lack of action. I note that we are advised that the Scottish Law Commission undertook a detailed review of the matter and that there was an overwhelming response in support of the move that the petitioner has articulated. Although the petition has come to us under the aegis of the petitioner, clearly he is articulating a view that enjoys much wider support.
I am curious about the Government’s response. It kind of sets out the situation, but it is not terribly clear to me why the Government takes the view that it does not want to do anything about it, other than because it needs to have time. I find that a curious response. I am minded to support the original proposition, rather than let the thing drift off.
David StewartLabThe Convener · Highlands and Islands
John Wilson’s view is that we should close the petition, for the reasons that he laid out, and Jackson Carlaw’s view is to defer it and look at it again at the end of the year. Can I have other members’ views?
There is a strong argument for closing the petition for the time being. As John Wilson stated, the petitioner has the opportunity to come back at a later date, once things have moved on.
My concern is whether if we close the petition and the Scottish Government brings the issue forward for whatever reason, the petitioner will be alerted.
David StewartLabThe Convener · Highlands and Islands
If we decided to close the petition, we could write to the Scottish Government to ask it to ensure that the petitioner is kept up to date with any developments from the Scottish Government.
I note that the committee closed a previous petition on the basis that it would allow the Scottish Law Commission to undertake a consultation. It has undertaken its consultation, which supports what the petitioner is asking for. A fresh petition has come to the committee and we are proposing to close that too, with no progress having been made, despite the fact that the commitment of the previous petition was fulfilled and the Law Commission consultation seemed to support its conclusion. I cannot understand why we are being so unhelpful and wishing to bury the issue.
It is my understanding that the majority wants to keep the petition open, and I am happy to defer to that majority. However, rather than deferring the petition for another 10 months, we should seek assurances from the Scottish Government on any timetable that it might propose to review the SLC report, as Jackson Carlaw indicated. It is difficult to keep petitions open when we know that there is no likelihood of an early resolution to them. Unless we get some commitment from the Scottish Government to bring the issue into the legislative programme in the near future—or an answer to the contrary—we should reconsider the petition as early as possible.
David StewartLabThe Convener · Highlands and Islands
We should defer the petition and write again to the Scottish Government—I know that we have written to it recently—to say that the committee is deferring the petition because we are keen for the Government to make some active decisions on it, and to ask it please to let us know what it will do on consultation and in any future legislation. That way, we would have something in focus and we could come back to look at the petition after a further period. Would that satisfy the committee?
Members indicated agreement.
David StewartLabThe Convener · Highlands and Islands
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.