The Scottish Government strongly opposes illegal rendition flights. No representations have been received by the Scottish Government regarding such flights. However, as I said back in 2007, if anyone has any evidence of lawbreaking of this sort, they should come forward with it and help justice to be done. I reiterate that today.
I gather that my colleague Mr Finnie has written to the Lord Advocate on the matter, following reports in the press demonstrating evidence of landings at Wick, Aberdeen and Inverness. Does the cabinet secretary accept that a proactive approach is needed in this matter, that it is not enough simply to wait until evidence of something innately covert is produced, and that, even if flights are returning through Scottish airports for refuelling, for example, without detainees on board at the time when they are at those airports, that is itself complicity, in much the same way that flights taking prisoners through our airports would be?
Kenny MacAskillSNPThe Cabinet Secretary for Justice · Edinburgh Eastern
The Scottish Government takes these matters seriously and would not condone any such action in any shape or form. Mr Finnie’s letter has not yet been received by the Crown, but the Crown has made clear how strongly it would view the matter and has asked that any information be made available to it. The police and the Crown can act only if that information is passed on, and that is what we have always sought to do as a Government.
When Mr Harvie asked me about rendition on 27 June 2007, I said that we treated the allegations very seriously and that we had stated our opposition to rendition flights, but I made it clear that civil aviation is a reserved matter and is, therefore, the responsibility of the United Kingdom Government. Nevertheless, I stated that criminal matters are the responsibility not simply of the Scottish Government but of law enforcement, in particular the Crown and the police. We asked for information to be provided. Amnesty International met me and I passed on the documentation that it had at that stage to the then Lord Advocate, Dame Elish Angiolini, who fully investigated the matter. However, no proceedings could be taken.
I have no doubt that the present Lord Advocate, Frank Mulholland, will give exactly the same assurance in response to the letter that is coming his way from Mr Finnie. We do not support or condone the practice and we would not allow it. However, unless the information is there for our police and prosecutors, there are difficulties with what they can do. Until there is a change in the constitution, civil aviation remains a matter for the United Kingdom Government.
Two years before the exchange to which the cabinet secretary refers, in a debate in the chamber in 2005, Mr MacAskill, speaking from the Opposition benches at that time, said:
“this is not simply a police matter or a matter for law officers, but a political matter ... This comes down to political will: fundamentally, that is what is lacking from the Executive.”—[Official Report, 22 December 2005; c 22075.]
I regret that we appear to be in much the same position at the moment. Can the cabinet secretary tell me of any other area of serious organised crime in which such a reactive approach would be taken, whereby both police and the Government would not take a proactive approach and investigate vehicles that were suspected of being used for such serious criminal offences?
Kenny MacAskillSNPThe Cabinet Secretary for Justice · Edinburgh Eastern
I refute any suggestion that the Scottish police would not and do not take action. If the information were available to them, they certainly would act. In this situation, the information that has been provided is historical and could not have been available to them at the time. If people have information, it should be provided and will be investigated, as it was to the credit of the former Lord Advocate, Dame Elish Angiolini.
We do not view the issue simply as a matter of law enforcement. It is for that reason that I met Amnesty International, engaged with it and gave it the assurance that the issue would be fully considered. It is not for the Government to bring prosecutions but, as a Government, we gave the information to the Lord Advocate that was given to us by Amnesty International. Subsequent to that, I have had discussions regarding the issue with a variety of organisations including—because of a personal friendship with Clive Stafford Smith—Reprieve UK.
If the information is there and is provided, we will pass it on. I give the assurance that Police Scotland and the Crown will not hesitate to take the appropriate action, but they must have the information to be able to act.
This morning, there were reports that Dundee airport may be linked to rendition. Will the cabinet secretary ask the UK Government whether it has any information on the use of Dundee airport for rendition activity?
Kenny MacAskillSNPThe Cabinet Secretary for Justice · Edinburgh Eastern
Again, that is a matter for the law officers and the police. I will be happy to pass that on to the Lord Advocate, who awaits Mr Finnie’s letter. He will, no doubt, consider these matters given the reference suggested.
The matters that were correctly raised with me by Mr Harvie happened not on the watch of the current coalition Government but when there was a Labour Government in the UK. Going back to the information that was provided to me by Clive Stafford Smith, I think that Jack Straw has a lot to answer for with regard to the complicity in rendition that I understand has been involved in the UK’s alliance with the United States.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.