Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Financial Services Inquiry

Wednesday 3 February 2010 Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee About 09:30 Evidence session 305 contributions · 16 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

305 contributions · showing 1–200
Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

Good morning. I welcome everyone to the fifth meeting of the Economy, Energy and Tourism Committee in 2010. We have one item on today’s agenda: to continue taking evidence for our banking and financial services inquiry. We have three panels to hear from today.Our first panel is Angus Tulloch and Stuart Paul, who are both in the investment management industry. They are here in a personal capacity; they are not representing any companies. I welcome you both to the meeting. I invite you to make opening remarks, after which we will have questions.

Stuart Paul
link

Good morning, everybody. It is a pleasure to be here—thank you very much for having us. I will start with a few comments to give you a feel for what Angus Tulloch and I do and where we are coming from.We are joint managing partners of a business that invests in Asia-Pacific and emerging markets equities. We are based here in Edinburgh. Previously, we were with a private Edinburgh business called Stewart Ivory. That business was acquired in 2000. We are now a subsidiary of the Commonwealth Bank of Australia.Our company has about 100 people in its Edinburgh office, with another 70 or 80 people in London. Half of our team is based in Hong Kong and Singapore. We are very much an international business, albeit significantly based in Scotland with a strong Scots heritage. Our business is also global from a client perspective. By number, about 75 per cent of our client base is overseas. The majority of our clients here in the United Kingdom are based, ordinarily, down south. We have only one or two clients here in Scotland—Angus Tulloch might comment on that later.In total asset terms, our team manages a little over $30 billion.That makes us a reasonably sizeable player in the markets in which we operate. To give you a feel for the commercial dynamic, fees range from 50 to 100 basis points on average in the fund management business. The business as we define it is quite mature. It has existed since the late 1980s, so relative to our markets we are regarded as being quite experienced and having quite a long track record.I will not labour the detailed comments about the business, but it is worth trying to give you a feel for how we invest money. First, fund management is different from banking and, although we are owned by a bank, we regard the culture and ethos within the business as being quite different. We run what is effectively a business within a business, and we have broad autonomy in the day-to-day running of our affairs.You might describe our philosophy as fundamental. We are long-term investors. We have a longer time horizon than might be believed from the reporting of the industry in the press these days. Typically, we are looking at three to five-year investments, which, in the quoted market, would be regarded as quite long term. We have relatively low turnover, and we focus on quality, so for us the single determinant of the type of company that we own is a basic assessment of the underlying quality of the business and the integrity of the management team, its track record and so on.We spend a lot of time meeting companies here and overseas. One of the more significant commercial dynamics of fund management in Edinburgh is the extent to which fund management companies are well served here because of the flow of corporate traffic through town. We can talk more about that: it is important to us and how we go about our business.That is a little flavour of our business proposition. I am happy to discuss anything that the committee would like.

Angus Tulloch
link

I have prepared a few points on how I think the Scottish Government might be able to help and grow the industry.The Government has to encourage better transport links, particularly direct flights from Edinburgh and publicity for them. Heathrow is really a shopping hub through which the people who own the airport direct as much traffic as possible. They are not really interested in promoting direct flights, so anything the Government can do about that matters, because the focus of our business is meeting the management of companies, and we want them to come here. We also want clients to visit us, because the business is very much about relationships. The same applies to through railway services to Europe. Because airport security is getting tighter all the time, going through hubs discourages people from travelling.It would be helpful if the Government recognised that because our business is very mobile, the tax regime has to be competitive. We have offices in Hong Kong and Singapore, and our people can move there. When one talks about income tax rates of more than 50 per cent, everything included, people really do start to think about moving abroad. I am too old and have no intention of doing so, but we have younger team members. Only a quarter of our investment team are Scots by origin. Tax makes a difference, however morally justified it is. People are also put off by a lot of the rhetoric about incentivisation in the UK at the moment. Any action on tax has to be co-ordinated internationally.Because we have to employ the best people, regardless of their origin, diversity is a very important part of the process. A key strength of our business is the ability to move people around offices, but with the increase in bureaucracy over the past three years we have found it a lot more difficult to give people training stints in Scotland.Improving Scottish education would also help an industry that relies on intellectual curiosity, analytical skills and international awareness. Arithmetic and literacy skills are very important in, for example, support operational services, and there should be more emphasis on vocational education. We have to be very wary of any decline in the reputation of Scottish education. It has been fantastic, and overseas it is still regarded much more highly than I think it deserves to be. The Government should consider introducing an independently and internationally verified international baccalaureate programme.Financial education in schools is important. That is supposed to be the responsibility of the Financial Services Authority, but the Scottish Government should be much more active in that regard and more prepared to use outside providers. Of course, the industry itself is responsible for making links with universities, but the Government should be encouraged to do anything that it can to help.Having headquarters in Edinburgh is important for stability and scaleability. I also believe that, as in the electronics industry in Scotland, we need lots of smaller, more dynamic companies that are stronger in intellectual capital than larger process-based units.Finally, public and local authority pension schemes should be encouraged to give Scottish fund managers a go. We manage only £10 million of Scottish institutional money out of the $30 billion, or £20 billion. I find it quite incredible how difficult it is to be a prophet in one’s own country. I am not saying that any favour should be shown to Scottish fund managers, but they should certainly be given a much fairer crack of the whip, particularly with regard to start-up companies. Singapore, for example, has been very innovative in the way that it has encouraged small companies to set up there.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

Thank you for those opening remarks. Could you consider the other side of the coin and highlight some of Scotland’s strengths in the investment management market?

Stuart Paul
link

First, our international brand and educational and business reputation are still regarded as very strong. Part of that comes down to weight of money. Some very sizeable pools of assets are still being managed here, primarily through the life companies, and that source of capital acts as a commercial imperative for companies.In my working lifetime, a lot of businesses in the industry have regenerated through spin-offs and start-ups that have subsequently been quite successful, and a number of independent firms have continued to grow. As a result, Scotland’s international standing is strong. As Angus Tulloch suggested, that might be partly due to the impact over the past century or more of the Scottish educational system. Certainly the heritage and investment trusts have a strong hand in all that; after all, Scotland was one of the leading investors in the emerging markets during and at the tail-end of the industrial revolution and such dynamics are very well regarded by international investors.For investors to make money, they have to be prepared to take a different view to that of the consensus—although they should stop short of being difficult just for the sake of it. Scottish firms might have been helped by the fact of their being at one remove instead of being in London or elsewhere. That has probably made it easier for them to step back from the noise.If you interviewed a dozen people from Scottish management companies, each would probably claim to do things quite differently, but you would get a feel for a commonality between the businesses in their fundamental approach. They tend to be longer term and, interestingly, they tend to be long-only funds—there are very few hedge funds in Scotland. We believe that that is partly because the natural leaning of fund management companies does not lend itself to short-term short selling.09:45

Angus Tulloch
link

With regard to the cultural aspect, Scots as a people quite like to be contrary. They love arguing with each other, and that is an important part of our business. I say this carefully, but I think that the Calvinist dimension is important too. There is a degree of loyalty up here: there is much less mobility between companies than there is in London. People work pretty hard, and they do not like losing money. That is very much part of what we do: we are not making fancy new products; we are genuinely trying to work in the interests of our clients.A colleague of mine has prepared a paper, which we did not submit to the committee but I will leave it here if anyone wants to see it. We think that if Scottish institutions could get together, we could have a code of behaviour. That would be one way of emphasising a characteristic that has an influence up here.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

Where do you draw your client base from, and how do you go about attracting new clients? You mentioned the Scottish institutional aspect in particular.

Stuart Paul
link

It is relatively complex in terms of the underlying client base, but I will try to summarise it. We have public offer funds, so it is possible for private individuals here and elsewhere to invest in the pool vehicles that we run. On the institutional side of our business, there is typically a gatekeeper between us and the client. The gatekeeper is often a global consulting firm, which conducts due diligence visits and basic research visits. That involves the firm getting comfortable with our investment approach, and—increasingly, given the turmoil in the broader financial industry—gaining a clear understanding of the commercial and ownership dynamics within businesses.Giving someone your money to run is ultimately a very different decision from buying a tangible product, and we are very aware of that. We are stewards of other people’s assets, and that is not about trying to grow those assets in isolation but about looking after them.We spend far more time discussing the dynamics of ownership and incentivisation—Angus Tulloch mentioned taxes, for example. We know from people’s visits to Edinburgh that they are keen to know what is going on. They read the press and they hear that changes are afoot. Those are important issues for potential clients, even though they might be based a long way away. The clients are sourced very broadly, and we often rely on a positive recommendation from a consulting firm that acts as a gatekeeper.

Angus Tulloch
link

Pension funds and charities make up the institutional side, which accounts for probably around half of our business.

Stuart Paul
link

Yes, it does.

Angus Tulloch
link

We do not do much direct advertising in relation to the retail side, which is probably why you have not heard of us. We manage money for institutions such as Barclays and their clients, all the clearing banks and Fidelity. They have platforms that retailers can go through to put their money into our funds. More than three quarters of our money comes from overseas: the Ohio state teachers fund was our first emerging markets client. We also manage money for three county councils in England, although none in Scotland. We get a lot of money from Australia and a growing amount from the far east, and middle east Governments account for around 15 per cent. We have a very broad base.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I want to ask about how the financial crisis has impacted on the investment management industry in Scotland, but first I have a follow-up question on the suggestion that it would be a good idea for local investors to think about using local fund managers. Is it possible to compare the success of Scotland’s investment management firms with that of others? After all, sentiment is one thing, but the bottom line is another.

Stuart Paul
link

Two things immediately come to mind. In some ways, our business is the most transparent in the world, because our performance is clearly visible to anyone who has an interest. The counter-argument is that there are lies, damned lies and statistics. As everyone sitting around this table will probably be aware, the industry has asked itself many questions over the years about how it presents information and advertising. Typically, when people want to buy into a certain investment strategy or area, that means that the investment is popular. However, to take the contrarian view, that means that it is questionable whether it is the right time to make such an investment decision. There is often a somewhat inverse logic to such things.The information is freely available, but people need to be careful about how they use it. Often, people’s timeframes are too short when they look at performance data. We used to talk about the need to evaluate fund managers over a complete economic cycle because, arguably, all boats tend to rise with the high tide. Everyone has stories of people who made a lot of money when the market was set in one direction or the other, but relatively few people, unfortunately, have the ability to add longer-term value over a complete cycle. That perhaps prompts the question about how long the economic cycle is—of course, people are starting to redefine it these days—but I think that the principle still holds.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

In the business insight section of yesterday’s edition of The Times, Ben Thomson made much about transparency for investment firms. Can local councils and charities in Scotland access that information easily?

Stuart Paul
link

The information is available and such organisations will have advisers who have access to it. The question, I suppose, is who provides advice and on what basis fund managers are selected. However, we probably do not have a great insight into that.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Thank you.My question is on the impact of the financial crisis on investment management in Scotland. What has been the impact on your clients? Presumably, many clients have experienced a reduction in income from their portfolios.

Angus Tulloch
link

The impact has been nil. Fortunately, we have not been associated with what has gone on in the banking sector. We are a very different industry. There has been no impact at all.

Stuart Paul
link

Fund management in Edinburgh is probably in a stronger position now than it was before the financial crisis. I say that because there are a number of strongly independent ownership structures here. Those independent firms will have prospered with the removal of the worry about parental ownership and what that might mean. Given the type of investment that takes place here—this is a generalisation—it is fair to say that, although nobody thanks us for losing their money, we are measured on a relative basis. In 2008, on average, Scots firms probably did relatively well. We could give a number of anecdotes about companies that performed relatively well through the downturn. In the short term, there will have been a commercial impact, because if assets under management fall, revenues generally also fall. However, in the longer run, we are probably reasonably well positioned.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

So basically—this relates to the restructuring that might happen in banking—the strength of the investment management industry lies in its diversity and firms’ independence.

Stuart Paul
link

Yes. When I spoke to a colleague from another firm here over lunch earlier this week, he told me that his firm has definitely benefited from being perceived as making absolutely no changes to its head count or its systems. His firm has done no restructuring, which has been taken as a reassuring sign.

Angus Tulloch
link

We have prepared a short paper—we did not submit it before the meeting, but I will leave it for anyone who wants to see it—that gives personal views on what caused the financial crisis, what its impact will be on Scotland and what can be done. Most of us think that we should focus on narrow banking and that many functions that are in big banks should be taken out of them to be run and capitalised separately, so that the amount of capital against businesses varies according to the amount of risk that people take. For some very risky activities, that might mean returning to a partnership-type structure, under which those involved would personally suffer and lose their houses if they took ridiculous risks.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

I am interested in seeing the paper that you summarised. Committee members have many questions, so we will move on, but the whole committee welcomes those comments.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

I will follow up on Stuart Paul’s answer to Rob Gibson’s earlier question on whether fund managers should be judged on long-term returns. Would there be a problem with that, in that fund managers obtain their business on the basis of short-term rather than long-term results? That produces in the sector a tendency to chase returns rather than long-term value. Does anything in your company’s bonus structure result in people chasing short-term returns or is the structure such that that does not happen?

Stuart Paul
link

The answer to your first question is an emphatic yes. A trade-off—probably the best way to describe it is as a potential conflict—often exists between the commercial imperative and the investment decision.The answer to your second question is that we have designed a remuneration structure that aligns what we do with clients’ interests. In essence, we are paid in three ways. Remuneration has two variable components—both focus on the long term and one has a deferred element.The first component is a fairly traditional bonus structure that is based on investment performance. Most fund managers would say that the key question to ask is over what period performance is assessed. It is not uncommon for investment bonuses to be awarded annually and based on a rolling 12-month performance assessment. We both argue that 12 months is way too short to make a meaningful assessment. Performance in 12 months often comes down to luck. However, the commercial desire of companies to have the carrot and the stick leads to that short-term focus. In our case, 90 per cent of the variable bonus structure is based on three and five-year investment returns. We have definitely made an effort to recognise the situation and to push the period further out.The second variable component, which is often missing in other structures, is a link between the business’s underlying profitability and the investment decisions that are made. A lot of debate is still taking place in the public arena about the right structure for share-ownership schemes and incentivisation and about whether they encourage one-way risk taking. Having a system such as ours, in which our fund managers think not just about producing investment returns but about retaining capital and ultimately retaining clients in the longer term, is important and guards against people just chasing whatever is happening in the market from day to day.It is worth mentioning the other aspect of our remuneration structure, which is that any profit-share reward that flows to the team is deferred for three years. While it is deferred, it is reinvested in the funds that we run, so we are very much invested alongside our clients. For most people on the team, that is a significant part of their overall affairs. Those elements reinforce the investment decisions that fund managers are inclined to make.10:00

Angus Tulloch
link

Education is one aspect. We have spent a huge amount of time explaining to clients that we report over three years rather than three months. Clients know that they are in for the long run. In relative terms, we have had significant underperformance this year—up 35 or 40 per cent against an index of 55 or 60 per cent—but we have had remarkably few complaints, because clients understand that we define risk as losing money rather than underperforming against a very flawed notional benchmark index.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

Is your bonus structure a hindrance to the recruitment of good staff, in that people think that they can get more money more quickly somewhere else, or does the longer-term approach mean that you retain staff longer, because they know that the rewards are on the way?

Stuart Paul
link

It is very much the latter case. Our approach prevents us from recruiting a certain type of investor, but we argue that they are not the type of investor whom we want to recruit in the first place.I am sorry if I am labouring the point. If you were to ask me what are the two or three key commercial considerations in the business, I would say that the structure has been critical. We have enjoyed a degree of success during the past 10 years and the implementation of the current structure, which took place six years ago, has been a critical contributor to that success.I mentioned the due diligence that applies to us as managers. It is not unusual for a third of due diligence meetings to focus on exactly the issue that we are considering. Fund managers typically talk a good game, but the ability to cut through all that and say how we are incentivised is critical to clients.

Marilyn Livingstone Lab Kirkcaldy
link

Has the crisis affected your ability to recruit in Scotland the qualified staff that you need?

Stuart Paul
link

We have been able to recruit. I will put that in the context of our overall team size. About 25 people are directly involved with the investment team. As I said, roughly half of us are based here and half are based in Asia. We have taken on three people since September—one chap joined us just a couple of weeks ago.We do not specifically target Scots in the recruitment process. Our team is very diverse in nationality. Scots tend to come up from time to time, but I cannot comment on how easy or hard it has been to recruit Scots. None of the three whom we hired recently is a Scot, but that is a casual reflection rather than anything else.As Angus Tulloch said, linking the curriculum that is taught in secondary schools to its practical application in the investment world is an area in which Scotland potentially offers quite a lot. We have both been involved in initiatives on that front, not just on basic financial education and understanding compound interest and so on, but on understanding the investment business as an industry. In recent years, a number of firms that focus on the operational side of our industry—the support side—have been successful in growing their businesses here and making the industry attractive to work in. I understand that that success is on-going.

Angus Tulloch
link

We have been recruiting on the operational, support side, which is mainly locally recruited. Recruitment has continued apace and we are employing more people in both the investment and operational sides than we were employing a year ago.

Marilyn Livingstone Lab Kirkcaldy
link

You talked about the importance of having headquarters in Edinburgh. We have heard from witnesses that Scotland’s highly skilled staff are a key reason why people locate in Edinburgh or elsewhere in Scotland. However, you said that bureaucracy has increased and you talked about Scotland’s declining reputation. Will you amplify those comments?

Angus Tulloch
link

In common with other firms, I have a number of points to make. We are not convinced that standards of arithmetic and literacy have improved—indeed, in some cases, they may have declined. The comment on bureaucracy was in relation to the need for mobility between our offices, so that people can train with us for a couple of months and then return to their home office. That is important.

Marilyn Livingstone Lab Kirkcaldy
link

If the committee were to make recommendations to the Government, I take it that you would want us to ask it to look at numeracy and literacy standards in the school system.

Angus Tulloch
link

That is correct.

Angus Tulloch
link

The answer is probably no, but we are trying to do something about that. I am involved with a group of people and the University of Edinburgh in looking to set up a centre of financial history, given Scotland’s huge contribution to the world’s financial history. If that happens, the approach will be deliberately pragmatic and not theoretical. Universities tend to be extremely academic in their approach to investment, which is a problem for us. They are very good at producing mathematical models and so forth, but that is not what investment is about. The meeting of minds has been difficult to maintain.

Stuart Paul
link

We experience a lot of difficulty in moving people around the world. I am sure that that is driven not by anything that is done in Scotland, but tighter immigration policies. For example, it is very difficult to try to bring someone into the country on a two-month secondment. That is the case even if they are part of our team in Hong Kong or Singapore. Anything that Scotland can do to facilitate a two-way flow that broadens the experience of people in this country will serve the industry well in the longer term.

Angus Tulloch
link

Let us say that a large Chinese pension fund is making its first overseas investment in this country. If we can offer to have someone from the organisation to train with us for six months, we have a huge edge over other people. We are very open to doing that. As much as it is possible to do so, we have people sitting in with us and learning about the business.

Marilyn Livingstone Lab Kirkcaldy
link

I return to your links with universities. Graduate training and employment is very important. Are you involved in any graduate training schemes?

Angus Tulloch
link

The answer is no. We do not do a formal training scheme. We are not big enough to do that. We tend not to employ graduates. If people are going to be internationally aware, we quite like them to go away from Scotland, find out about the rest of the world and get London out of their system. We can put people into Hong Kong and Singapore for a couple of years. We have done that quite a lot. As I said, we do not have a formal scheme. Although we have taken on a couple of people at graduate level that is not something that we focus on.

Marilyn Livingstone Lab Kirkcaldy
link

You talked about financial education in Scotland and said that it may be the role of the FSA and the Scottish Government to do that. We have been told that various bodies are working in partnership to look into financial education in Scotland. Has anyone from the FSA asked for your opinion on that?

Angus Tulloch
link

Not from the FSA. We have spoken to the Scottish Government education directorate—we have had quite a lot of discussion with it—and the Scottish centre for financial education. However, they are interested only if it is home-grown—if it is produced by them. They are really not interested in outside services.When we sold Stewart Ivory and were bought over, we set up a foundation for financial education. We now provide financial education for about half the school pupils in Scotland, but it is extremely difficult to raise money to continue that work unless the Scottish Government is seen to participate. I have arranged to meet the new Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning to find out whether we can do something, but we had little joy in the past on that because we were not prepared to do the curriculum exactly as the Government wanted.

Marilyn Livingstone Lab Kirkcaldy
link

We have heard from other witnesses that sector-specific qualifications are required. You made that point in your opening remarks.I will ask a more general question. Has there been any long-term damage to the reputation of the financial services sector in Scotland?

Angus Tulloch
link

None from which it is not possible to recover. It is unfortunate that two banks with Scottish names were significantly involved in what went wrong, but they are regarded as international banks and many of the activities that went wrong were managed from outside Scotland anyway.

Gavin Brown Con Lothians
link

Do you anticipate many—or any—regulatory changes to your industry in the near future? If so, what concerns do you have about any proposals?

Stuart Paul
link

I am sure that there will be regulatory changes; we expect that to happen. I imagine—this is a personal view—that there might be far more focus on remuneration structures.Another area on which we have views and which is commonly focused on is risk and how it is defined. We probably diverge from mainstream thought within the industry, which commonly attempts to control risk by controlling divergence from a benchmark. For us, that is nowhere close to how we should define risk. Unfortunately, it is an easily understood way of trying to control risk, but I am not sure that that is the right direction to push in.The same is true of remuneration structures—again, this is a personal view. It is important that they be absolutely transparent. If there had been more transparency and more understanding of the implications of certain remuneration structures, certain products would almost have become unsaleable because anybody who really understood what they were investing in would probably not have done so.Rather than trying to create a one-size-fits-all approach, education, understanding and transparency would be a better way ahead.

Angus Tulloch
link

The problem with regulation is particular to the retail sector. Because we do not interface directly with the retail customer, we are not so affected by it, but anyone in the retail sector will tell you that the amount of box ticking that goes on is incredible. It is becoming very expensive and the consumer pays for it in the end.Regulation must focus on the spirit, rather than the letter, of the law. A lot could be done through trying to reprofessionalise the industry to ensure that people behave by genuinely looking after the client and putting their interests first. I will leave the committee a paper in which we have suggested that if everyone in the industry had to take a sort of Hippocratic oath, saying that they would put the clients’ interests first and placing themselves under a professional obligation to consider the longer term, that might have a much bigger impact in the long run than ticking the right box.

Gavin Brown Con Lothians
link

We have had evidence from some witnesses on regulation. One specific piece of regulation—nicknamed the hedge fund directive but, I think, officially titled the alternative investment fund managers directive—has been debated in the Parliament, even though it is a European Union proposal. Do you have any comments on that? Will it negatively affect your industry?10:15

Stuart Paul
link

I will talk more generally. The directive’s direct impact on our business would be limited, but it would have a significant impact on the investment trust sector in Scotland. I am sure that members have already heard about that. I understand that the proposals threaten self-managed investment companies in particular and that they would be very damaging. Several very large self-managed companies employ a number of people in Scotland, and they would certainly be affected. I know that they are lobbying hard on the directive.

Gavin Brown Con Lothians
link

In your first answer, you talked about remuneration and risk, which you think might be regulated. You have talked about how your organisation is no worse off—indeed, it is possibly better off—in relative terms than it was prior to the financial crisis. Has its approach to risk management changed at all? Have your risk-management procedures been considered and reviewed, or are they broadly the same as they were before?

Stuart Paul
link

We are fortunate. Earlier, I mentioned that we have a broad degree of autonomy over running what is effectively a business within a business. Ultimately, Angus Tulloch and I are our business’s risk managers. That places a huge responsibility on us, but it also gives us the ability to not make changes to satisfy people in the short term. I would probably give you a very different answer if we were part of a bigger organisation. I am sure that there is a lot of pressure in big, broad-based financial services companies and that many questions are being asked.As I have said, a framework can be produced in which it looks as if risk is being controlled relative to a benchmark. It is a fact that, three years ago, a UK fund manager would have said that owning shares in every bank in the UK was not risky for the simple reason that they were minimising the divergence of their portfolio against the benchmark index. However, if the benchmark index is itself flawed, that is clearly very risky. Having a commercial environment that allows people to take a commonsense approach to risk is important, but it is quite rare. A number of Scots firms take that approach relatively well. To be immodest, that is certainly something that we do.

Angus Tulloch
link

Risk should be defined, and losing money in real terms should be adjusted to inflation. That is where people should start from when they consider risk.

Stuart Paul
link

Another issue that is likely to be put under the microscope is fees. That is completely understandable, but the focus on fees often distracts from the focus on what is fundamentally being invested in. Reducing costs for the consumer is a popular cause and, in some cases, it has a lot of merit, but it is even more important to ensure that the structure of the products or the strategy has integrity and that the end investor understands what they are investing in. It can be argued that people would not mind variable fees as long as they were achieving the returns that they set out to achieve. It is quite easy to produce a low-cost solution, but whether that is the right solution may be questionable. That was tried with stakeholder pensions. It is clear that I am talking from a particular perspective; you are hardly likely to hear me say anything else.

Angus Tulloch
link

We have a potential problem with capacity because of the markets with which we are involved, so we have closed quite a lot of our products. The problem is that, if you simply do everything with flat fees, some of the better fund managers will be excluded, because there is a limited amount that can be managed in particular markets. Obviously, the best way to ration that is through prizes.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

I have a couple of questions. First, I want to follow up on that interesting set of questions and answers on risk. You talked about having a commercial environment that allows a common-sense approach to risk and said that, in simple terms, the approach should fundamentally be about whether money is lost. Would that approach to risk have made a difference to the financial services sector over the past three or four years and, if so, how?

Stuart Paul
link

If, rather than the absolute performance that a fund manager achieves, they are held to account for their investment performance during periods of relatively short-term underperformance, there tends to be commercial pressure to do something about it. If a certain sector is prominent and is performing well—as the financial industry was two or three years ago—the commercial pressure is great for fund managers to participate in that, even if, on a five or 10-year view, they regard many of the dynamics in the sector as unhealthy. Anything that enables a fund manager to step back and consider whether something is in the clients’ long-term interests is good, as that is a healthy question to ask.I say this slightly tongue in cheek, but the problem is that a fund manager will always argue that they did not necessarily get a decision wrong, just that it has not worked yet. That is why people say that it is difficult to pin down investors and find out what they actually mean, which is why it is important for the process that the nature of the product is understood.For example, in our business, our emerging markets strategy underperformed significantly in relation to the index for five out of the six years from 2002 to 2008—we outperformed in only one of those years. However, we still delivered real returns of between 30 and 40 per cent compounded, because the market was so strong. A danger would have arisen if somebody had told us to make up the shortfall against the index, as that would have led to our trying to own many companies that we fundamentally did not want to own. The alternative is being prepared to hold our ground and say that we will be rewarded for that stance in the longer term, although we can never say when. We must consider the whole approach, rather than shorter-term considerations.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

The broad issue is of great interest to us. We have had evidence from two or three witnesses that different parts of the financial services sector have almost profoundly different approaches to risk. Could the investment banking sector—which led us into some of the difficulties that we are talking about—learn from the approach that you describe, or is there such a profound difference in what you do that your approach to risk could never be the same as the approach in the investment banking sector?

Stuart Paul
link

There are areas of overlap and areas of divergence. The areas that overlap revolve around incentivisation, time horizons and reputational risk. Our clients would not expect us to lose money in a falling market—that would be an unexpected result for them. For investment banking businesses, if there were a clearer definition of types of business that they wanted to be associated with, or did not want to be associated with, a different approach could be taken. There is a vast area of business that is very different from the one that we are involved in.

Angus Tulloch
link

Basically, the investment banks took risks using Government money. At the end of the day, they were going to be bailed out, so the situation was completely skewed. That is a different problem. One issue with investment banking that I feel strongly about and which is one reason for excessive incentivisation is that there is perhaps not enough competition in the business. There are certain oligopolistic practices that need to be considered. For instance, for an initial public offering in the States, there is a standard fee of 7.5 per cent, which is considerably more than the fee in this country. No one has ever explained to me why that cannot be competed down, which is what normally happens when people make huge margins.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

The regulatory function lies elsewhere—with the FSA, the Bank of England and so on, and in carrying out their regulatory reforms they need to learn from other sectors of the financial industry. Should they be learning lessons in rolling forward the Turner recommendations regarding the approach to risk and fund management that you follow—lessons that would be applicable to the wider financial services sector?

Angus Tulloch
link

The key thing is to focus people on responsibilities to the client, rather than on the short-term transaction. It is debatable whether it is possible to change people’s behaviour in that way, but one can have a go, by trying to make people in the industry feel that they have a responsibility.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

As you say, it is a behavioural, cultural issue, rather than one that is amenable to regulation. Would that be fair comment?

Angus Tulloch
link

Yes, absolutely. If you make more regulations, it just encourages very bright people to work out ways to get round them—and they will, as has been shown over the past year. I do not think that they provide the answer.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

That is helpful.I have a further issue to pursue. In your opening remarks, Mr Tulloch, you said that the first thing that the Scottish Government could do would be to promote direct flights. You will recall the direct routes fund that operated in Scotland previously, which has not operated for the past two and a half years. Would you support it being brought back, perhaps in a slightly different form?

Angus Tulloch
link

I should be familiar with that scheme but I am not. It is difficult to know what a demand for something is until the supply is created. Anything that would help for the first year or two years, so that a service can be established, would be very beneficial.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

A route development fund was suspended two and a half years ago because of concerns about European regulation and so on. Those concerns could be addressed. We are concerned with what enables you to do business effectively. Missing out Heathrow is a critical part of that.

Angus Tulloch
link

Yes—and I am sure that the French could teach us a few ways of getting round such things.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

A fair point.You will be aware that, in its current round of decision making, the Scottish Government has decided to abandon plans for a rail link to Glasgow airport—and previously abandoned plans to build a rail link to Edinburgh airport. Such links might improve connectivity for your business and for the companies with which you work. Do you think that such things are important to enable customers and clients to come here?

Angus Tulloch
link

I cannot really comment on their cost effectiveness. There is no doubt that they would improve connectivity, but the Edinburgh tram system shows that one can spend a huge amount on something where there might have been a simpler, lower-cost solution.

Stuart Paul
link

When we travel to Hong Kong and Singapore we are struck by how easy it is to get there, and then to get into the city. Anything that we can do to mirror their success would be helpful. As Angus Tulloch mentioned, Singapore, which is within our sphere of operation, has been very successful in getting businesses to relocate and in encouraging investment in the core business that it sees as being part of its economy for the next 10 years or so.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

Those models are well connected, with hub airports and rail links directly to the city centre.

Stuart Paul
link

Yes.

Stuart McMillan SNP West of Scotland
link

I will start with that point about rail links. Your organisation is affiliated to the Commonwealth Bank of Australia. I am not sure whether you have been to Melbourne, but it is a major city and industry hub, and the transport from the airport into the city is quite excellent without a rail link. I just wanted to get that on the record.I will go back to the points that have been made about universities in Scotland, which Marilyn Livingstone was asking about earlier.Numerous courses in numerous universities in Scotland give students the opportunity to study or work abroad, which helps to broaden their international perspective and awareness. I appreciate that that might be for only a semester or two rather than two, three, four or five years, but the message that I got from you was that there are no links and that very little has been done to recruit graduates, whether Scots or non-Scots—the percentage of whom at Scottish universities is high—from Scottish universities. You might be overlooking some excellent graduates who have the potential to enhance your organisation in the longer term. Would you like to comment on that?10:30

Angus Tulloch
link

One will always overlook people, however hard one tries. When we recruit, we try to ensure that we advertise internationally. We hope to attract people from Scotland as well as elsewhere. On the operational side, quite a lot of the people we recruit went to university here—about 20 to 25 per cent of the investment team were at Scottish universities. However, any team must be diverse. We need language skills, for example, so we have to be diverse. If we had a recruit Scotland policy, we would cease to be able to compete internationally.

Stuart McMillan SNP West of Scotland
link

I am not for one minute suggesting that you should recruit only Scots. I studied European business and languages. When I came out of university in 1997, there was a lack of understanding of the course that I had taken and it was difficult to get over to people its diverse nature. Folk from my course struggled to gain employment in the international sphere or work that had a European outlook. There must be a two-way street. Universities and graduates need to sell that aspect and businesses need to sign up to it. I wanted to get that on the record and to get a feel for your views.

Stuart Paul
link

In our business there are two areas we can talk about—the hiring of investment talent and the hiring of operational talent. My perception is that the industry has done quite a good job in the latter area. Although we have almost the same number of people in the broader business in London as we do in Edinburgh, the vast majority of the operational side of the business is run from Edinburgh. That is testament to the skills pool that has developed here and the ability that exists to build a team.However, there is still a disconnect in the first area, at investment level. We are slightly wary of some of the academic initiatives to create more of a link between a prominent industry in Scotland and its universities as they tend to become heavily mathematically and quantitatively based. That suits some approaches but not others and, unfortunately, it does not really fit with our approach. It has been interesting to have with us interns from the investment and finance course at the University of Edinburgh but, ultimately, as investors, they would probably not sit comfortably with what we do. Further scope still exists for progress in that direction.Stuart McMillan’s point is well made and understood; it is a link that should be easy to create.

Angus Tulloch
link

Students forget that there are lots of ways of getting into a business. If we have someone on our operational side who has any interest in investment matters, they are always welcome to attend any of our meetings. It is remarkable how seldom people take advantage of that. Our hours fit in with Hong Kong’s and Singapore’s so we are in at 7.30 in the morning and it is easy for people to come in an hour early and sit in on the meeting. If they occasionally ask a good question, there is no reason why they cannot move into the investment side if we are looking and feel that they are bright enough.There is a mindset among students that makes them want to join graduate trainee schemes—where places are extremely limited—and we do not run one. However, there are many different ways of getting into companies. People might feel that they are a little below them, but that should not be the case. Everyone wants to help and to bring up the people who are working around them if they show real enthusiasm and ability, and people are always much happier to employ someone they know, because they have seen them work roundabout them, than someone from the outside.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

I return to the future of the investment management sector as a whole. You spoke persuasively about the desirability of culture change and not relying on a tick-box mentality as well as about your institution’s commitment to looking at the fundamentals of the companies in which you seek to invest, although you conceded that that might not be typical of the entire sector. In that context, next week the committee has the chance to meet Lord Myners, the City minister, who reflected that without significant change, ownerless corporations will sleepwalk into further catastrophe. When looking at institutional ownership, the Treasury Committee described institutional investors as “supine and ineffective”. Perhaps such colourful language is less typical of this institution, but the comment raises the issue of what is the right way to address the phenomenon of ownerless corporations and strengthen the hand of institutional investors in the future. I am interested in your views.

Stuart Paul
link

How long do you have? We both have views on that—I will make one or two comments and I know that Angus Tulloch will too. It goes back to the point about the timeframe for assessing performance and decision making. My personal view is that the industry has got to where it deserves to be in some ways, because as the focus has become more and more short term, there has been less and less interaction between shareholders and executive management teams. As I said at the outset, that is what our business is all about. However, it is a two-way street: if you are a chief executive of a public limited company, you will spend time speaking to investors only if you feel that you have a duty to satisfy and hope to get something back. It should be a two-way street. We should be helping by being a sounding board or providing ideas.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

How do we incentivise that behaviour to typify the industry more generally and not just individual players within it?

Stuart Paul
link

To want to do that in a commercial sense you have to believe that, in the long run, understanding a business’s strategy and ultimately where it is going will lead you to make better investment decisions. The problem is that if you are being assessed on whether your decisions have worked on a rolling 12-month basis, there is almost no point in having such a conversation because there is no requisite timeframe over which you can be rewarded. That disconnect has definitely led to some of the ownerless corporation-type approach.

Angus Tulloch
link

On the corporate governance front, we strongly believe that companies that do not look after all their stakeholders—not just their shareholders—will not be good, long-term, sustainable investments. There are a lot of companies that we will not touch, because they do not look after their employees or customers or the community—I am thinking about pollution incidents in China, for example. During the past year we have been partially responsible for senior management changes in companies in which we have investments. We find that discussing such issues helps our investment process tremendously, as Stuart Paul said.My personal view is that I have no objection to a 10 per cent capital gains tax on short-term investment, as there is in India. Such an approach would encourage people to exercise their shareholder rights more. Lee Iacocca, from Chrysler, suggested that people should hold shares for a year before they can vote them. Consider Marks and Spencer: the future of a strong, 100-year-old British tradition is being determined by arbitrageurs who do not give a hang about the future or the employees and just want to make a quick buck. I do not think that people should be allowed to vote shares unless they have had them for a year—but that is not a common industry view.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

You have made helpful suggestions on capital gains tax and holding shares.On another fundamental issue, you mentioned the importance of having headquarters functions in Scotland. Later in the meeting we will hear from representatives of the Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland. In its submission to the committee, ICAS talked persuasively about how the movement of headquarters functions away from Scotland results in“fewer one-off advisory engagements”and changes, in a deleterious way, the nature of the business of other businesses that provided services.There has been a significant move of headquarters functions away from Scotland because of what happened to our two principal retail banks. The issue will manifest itself as UK Financial Investments disposes of the stakes that it holds in RBS and Lloyds Banking Group—stakes of 84 per cent and more than 40 per cent respectively. Given the importance of having headquarters functions in Scotland, should UKFI have an interest in whom the ownership of the organisations is entrusted to? Representatives from UKFI told the committee that they do not regard that as a matter for them in any shape or form; they are completely blind as to how the stakes should be disposed of. Angus Tulloch knows the issues that I am hinting at, so I will not go on.

Angus Tulloch
link

I feel strongly that a local banking sector is important. The sector in Scotland that will be most hit by the loss of headquarters is the charities sector. I am thinking about sponsorship of events and a myriad of activity that we do not see. It is tragic. We are experiencing an age in which big is beautiful, but big is not beautiful at all. People overestimate the economies of scale and completely underestimate the diseconomies of scale. In any disposal of the stakes, it is terribly important for Scotland that there should be local participation—I very much hope that there will be.It is also about giving people a sense of identity. We always ask companies in which we invest whether their employees have shares in the business. John Lewis is a fantastic example of what can be done when that happens. The issue is relevant.10:45

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

For state-aid reasons, the EU has forced various disposals in Lloyds Banking Group and RBS. RBS’s balance sheet is envisaged to shrink by about 40 per cent. Is there a case for a future Government—after the forthcoming general election—to consider further shrinkage of RBS’s balance sheet or further disposal of activities, or should that stop there because the EU went far enough?

Angus Tulloch
link

I cannot really comment because we focus much more on overseas businesses than on local businesses.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

My final question is about the way forward for financial services in Scotland. You will know of the Financial Services Advisory Board. The Scottish Government has mooted the idea that Scotland should have an entirely separate equivalent of the FSA—a separate regulatory authority—which could introduce another regulatory authority for organisations that operate from a Scottish base but are UK-wide and global. Do we want to duplicate the FSA and have a separate regulatory authority? Would such a development be desirable?

Angus Tulloch
link

I ask Stuart Paul to go first. Our answers might differ; I am not sure.

Stuart Paul
link

I think that I know what Angus Tulloch thinks that I will say, but I might say something different.I have an open mind on the question. I can see the case for such an authority being made. How the industry is regulated is critical to what can be done to make Scotland a more attractive place in which to conduct investment business. If we were prepared to be brave and to regulate on issues that we think matter, as opposed to tackling the hot issues of the day, and if we put in place a serious regulatory body that set the bar high enough but encouraged businesses to be developed from here, I could see the case for it and would not have a problem with it.I can—obviously—see the other view, to which Wendy Alexander alluded. Such a body could become just a me-too entity that added another layer of difficulty. I echo Angus Tulloch’s comments. We are part of a global business, but the local level is important and we still feel like a small business. Arrangements will differ here. The businesses here are different, for example. A question was asked about the alternative investments directive, which is a classic example of a one-size-fits-all approach that does not really work. Little of the activity that the European Commission is worried about is going on in Scotland. A case could be made for a Scottish authority.

Angus Tulloch
link

The authority would have to be original and different and would depend on the people who ran it—they would have to focus on the spirit rather than the letter.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

The original proposition was for regulation light compared with the FSA in the UK. I am not sure whether that idea prevails.

Angus Tulloch
link

The issue is not whether regulation is light or heavy but whether it is properly focused. One should try to identify, focus on and hit hard people who are clearly misleading the public. Regulation should be light until people show evidence of being irresponsible, when they should be hit hard, rather than having hundreds of people ticking boxes and not considering the spirit of the law.

Wendy Alexander Lab Paisley North
link

Would it have been easier for a Scottish FSA to confront RBS—whose total balance sheet was 20 times in excess of the national gross domestic product—and to regulate it effectively? We face such challenges. The issue is scale. We celebrate the financial services in Scotland, but the dilemma is that if a country is home to retail banking institutions whose assets are 20 times in excess of the national GDP, that creates a perplexing power balance for the regulatory community.

Angus Tulloch
link

Does that not suggest that regulation must be international rather than national? The question is not whether it should be Scottish or British. Whatever happens, we must move together internationally much more when we talk about such institutions. Who was responsible for regulating the Icelandic bank system, for example? The issue is difficult.

Christopher Harvie SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

You stress the relatively long-term policies that you pursue in allocating investment, which seems to contrast dramatically with what I have read in the sensationalist press—the Financial Times, in other words—about operations in London hedge funds, for example, where a portfolio might change rapidly over a couple of days. When we interviewed David Nish, from Standard Life, he stressed that a lot of Standard Life’s investments were going into private equity, which was not known for unadventurous activity when it comes to changing portfolios. What was your attitude to investment in private equity organisations during the two or three years of the boom that came before the spectacular slump?

Stuart Paul
link

Almost all of the investments that we make are in the quoted arena, which means that we do not really invest directly in private equity. We have views on what happened in that sector, however, which I am happy to give you.Again, the terms “hedge fund” and “private equity” probably have negative connotations at the moment, but the reality is that both of those approaches have been around for a long time and there is nothing innately wrong with either of them. However, they are both vehicles that can be used to other ends. One of the failings has been the amount of leverage that they have been allowed to carry, which has had the effect of enabling them to gear up their returns. Another failing involves the fee environment. Following the collapse of the technology market in 2000, people were prepared to take a far more adventurous approach to what they did with their money. Interest rates were reduced to a low level and money was freely available, and people capitalised on that. The time horizons have shortened, however, and the fee structures of private equity companies and hedge funds have increased, as has their leverage in business models. There are private equity companies and hedge funds that have not done any of those things, and will probably still be around in 20 years’ time, but a lot have taken a short-term, opportunistic approach.

Christopher Harvie SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

Do you, as investors, have a readily accessible map of the exposure to particular types of organisation that you would get within a particular investing community such as Edinburgh? Do you have a notion—whether it is based predominantly on anecdotal evidence or on information on balance sheets and so on—of who is heavily into private equity, hedge funds and so on or is that an area where you would just have to suck it and see in order to work out what is going on?

Angus Tulloch
link

Scottish Financial Enterprise would be the organisation to ask. If anyone ought to know about that, it would. I know only a couple of organisations that manage hedge funds—Martin Currie and Standard Life—and that is a small part of their business in Edinburgh. The organisation with the biggest involvement in private equity is Standard Life, but that is not a huge part of its business.

Stuart Paul
link

The information is publicly available from the prospectuses that are published. Investors are told what they are investing in. However, whether the average investor understands the nature of what they are investing in is a different matter.

Christopher Harvie SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

The points that you made earlier about financial education and so on have relevance for any Scottish political structure, because it must provide the infrastructural funds that will supply your needs, for example for trained manpower. Therefore, do you see problems in a situation in which the profit can go into secrecy jurisdictions and the like and not make it back to the place of origin, as is the case in the present system? There has to be some sort of loop whereby the money that the Government spends on providing infrastructure that enables enterprise to function—whether in the form of airports, trained workers or whatever—is returned to the community. However, in our investigations, we have repeatedly come across the fact that the other end of that loop seems to disappear, somehow.

Stuart Paul
link

My thought on that is that it can be difficult to prove a direct link. Forgive me for using a sporting analogy, but the situation strikes me as being similar to developing youth talent within a football or rugby club. The talent might not immediately flow through to the first team and make that team more successful; it might make its way elsewhere. However, the idea is that, ultimately, the positive flow and knock-on benefits that are produced are a good thing. There are two or three examples in Edinburgh of companies that have spawned quite successful business as people have left one business and set up another one. Ultimately, the investment in those individuals was not necessarily directly to the benefit of the organisation that trained those individuals, but it was of indirect benefit, as it helped to create a more vibrant industry. Certainly, it was of benefit to Scotland.

Angus Tulloch
link

Private equity funds provide useful operational and financial discipline. We do not have a vested interest in that regard, as we do not run private equity funds, but that is our observation. What I like to see in Asia is a family that controls a business with a private equity shareholder, because that lets you know that they are being watched, so it serves a purpose. A problem arises when the private equity shareholder has excessive leverage, as has been the case in the past, because if it is involved for a three to five-year term, it can squeeze the business of cash towards the end of that period.

Christopher Harvie SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

The Chinese family could be equated with Hawick, in terms of rugby. It would like to benefit humanity in general, but Hawick first. That is important, and the thing that worries me is the secrecy jurisdictions, which have not been mentioned so far. There are a large number of tax havens into which activities disappear. One knows that something is going on, but it appears that the matter can be settled only by international regulation.

Angus Tulloch
link

All that I can say is that I know nothing about international jurisdictions.

Angus Tulloch
link

I know nothing about either, other than their names.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

I thank Stuart and Angus for a fascinating evidence-taking session. We could have gone on for considerably longer. In particular, we would have liked to explore in more detail the papers to which you referred. It would be useful if you could submit them formally as evidence to the committee, and we will certainly take them into account in our report.10:59 Meeting suspended.

11:03 On resuming—

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

I apologise to our second panel for the delay—we took a little longer than expected to hear from our first panel, whose evidence was interesting. In that session, the issue of whether Scottish public sector funds are giving Scotland-based companies a fair opportunity to manage them was raised. It might be worth while for us to write to the pension funds to ask them how they go about selecting their investment managers and what consideration they give to using Scotland-based companies. Is that agreed?Members indicated agreement.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

I am pleased to welcome to the meeting representatives of the Association of Chartered Certified Accountants, the Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland and the Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales, which has a Scottish branch. I ask them to introduce themselves and to make some brief opening remarks, before we move to questions.

David Wood Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland
link

I am the executive director of technical policy at the Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland. I am in charge of all the representation work that we do on behalf of our members and in the public interest.

Bruce Cartwright Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland
link

In my day job, I am a partner at PricewaterhouseCoopers in the business recovery services department, which deals with troubled businesses—there are lot of them at the moment. I also chair the technical committee of ICAS alongside David Wood. That is my other hat.

Richard Martin Association of Chartered Certified Accountants
link

I am head of financial reporting at the Association of Chartered Certified Accountants. The ACCA is a global body for professional accountants with 500,000 members and students around the world. We are well established in Scotland, as more than 7,000 of our members are here. They work in a variety of fields—such as the public sector, and corporate and public practice—as professional accountants. Our global administrative headquarters are in Glasgow. We have a separately constituted branch—ACCA Scotland—which looks after our members in Scotland.

Iain Coke Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales
link

I am head of the financial services faculty at the Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales. I am a Scot, but I am based in London. The ICAEW is pleased to come here to give evidence. We have more than 1,400 members in Scotland who work in senior positions in the public and private sectors, so we are well placed to give evidence.I will make a few opening comments on our thoughts on the crisis. The financial crisis is an economic one stemming from systemic failure in the sub-prime mortgage market in the US, which transmitted on to the wider financial services sector. We are now moving towards economic recovery, but the market remains fragile, as we see from the GDP growth figure for the last quarter—0.1 per cent, which was lower than expected. However, we do our own business confidence monitor, which showed that confidence in the business sector in Scotland was higher for the last quarter of 2004 than that in other parts of the United Kingdom, so we might be about to witness a recovery led by Scottish business.One of the keys to restoring confidence is establishing trust in financial information. People need good information to make good business and investment decisions, and our members have a key role to play in that. They provide, analyse and advise on information. Therefore, we have an important role in restoring confidence.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

You just said something about 2004.

Iain Coke Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales
link

Did I? I apologise. I will correct that—it is quarter 4 of 2009. It was a slip of the tongue. You already have me on the run.

Iain Smith LD North East Fife
link

You have avoided confusing us too much—it is easy to confuse us.Our questions will focus on two areas: the general impact of the financial crisis on businesses in Scotland; and the role of accountancy agencies in issues such as corporate governance and auditing the banks.What impact has the financial crisis had on the accountancy profession in general in Scotland and, in particular, on its clients? How is your profession handling those issues?

David Wood Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland
link

We have 10,000 members in Scotland and a good mix of members in practice and in business. We have not done an up-to-date survey as the ICAEW has, but we did a survey in March 2009 and will repeat that next month. The 2009 survey was of interest. Firms found that their clients were struggling. Many had working capital problems and blamed the banks for the withdrawal of finance.There is growing demand for advice in the recession. That is sustaining our members in practice. Accountants also have a lot of recurring work, such as auditing and the preparation of accounts and tax returns. That sort of work keeps the practising firms in the profession afloat.Many of the larger accounting firms have business recovery consultancy arms and, at times of recession when the corporate finance transaction-based work is very low, resource can be moved to business recovery. We therefore have some in-built safeguards against recession in the industry.

Richard Martin Association of Chartered Certified Accountants
link

In many ways, the current recession and downturn emphasise the importance of finance functions and properly managed finances—we have seen the same in previous recessions. On the whole, the role of finance in organisations large and small tends to be more important in recessionary times, so to some extent the importance of accountancy has increased.We are also closely monitoring access to finance by small and medium-sized enterprises. We are doing surveys both across the UK and on a regional basis, so we are therefore covering Scotland. The picture is that Scotland was not as badly affected by the downturn as some other parts of the UK but that there has certainly been rising demand for overdraft facilities and other forms of finance among SMEs as the cash-flow position has deteriorated. In our most recent surveys, the cash-flow picture is looking a bit better; there has been some improvement after the reduction in the earlier part of last year of the facilities available to small businesses.Scotland shares that picture with the UK as a whole. The particular factor that we notice about Scotland is the dominance of two banks in the market and the fact that there is more competition for SME finance in the rest of the UK. However, that does not seem to have had a significant effect on the availability of finance to SMEs in Scotland.

Bruce Cartwright Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland
link

Stuart McMillan talked about graduate recruitment earlier. It is very clear that the accountancy profession is not here for the short term: there is a blip, but we are in a transitional period. In the larger firms, mine included, there has been no change in graduate recruitment in the past two years. We are probably recruiting as many people, if not more—I believe that my firm recruits about 80 graduates in Scotland.The key message to graduates is that we are here for the duration. We do not cut and base our graduate numbers on a two-year programme; we base our decisions on a 10 to 20-year programme, first for our own business and secondly so that we can deliver to the Scottish business community.

Iain Coke Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales
link

We are increasing the number of banks that are training with us. RBS is one example—it has trained with my colleagues’ bodies for some time and has recently started training ICAEW students. As a profession, we are working to increase the availability of training contracts and working with the financial sector as well as within professional practice.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

I want to pursue the question of credit availability. On the one hand, the banks tell us that they are open for business and that they are approving roughly the same percentage of business loan applications as they ever did but that the problem is that demand is down and that businesses are not asking for the money. On the other hand, businesses are telling us that they cannot get credit, that their overdrafts are being cut or converted into hard loans that they have to secure against personal properties, and that their fees, such as arrangement fees, are increasing significantly compared with what they were in the past. The result is probably that they are not even asking for loans because they do not think that they will get them. From your experience as accountants, which side is right—the banks or the businesses?11:15

Iain Coke Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales
link

We undertook research into that in the middle of last year and found that, to an extent, both sets of views are correct. We spoke to our members. Some SMEs are finding it harder to find finance, but there are regional variations, variations among banks and even variations within banks. There may have been some movement of foreign banks out of the UK, so there may be less capacity, but I think that a real element of fear exists. Some people have not wanted to raise issues with their banks because of their fear that terms would be reduced or taken away, or would be less favourable. There was a divergence of views. Some people commented on whether repricing was fair and whether banks were overcharging in difficult circumstances. The alternative view was expressed that the banks were moving the charges to more realistic levels.Both points of view came through in the information from our members.

Bruce Cartwright Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland
link

The convener’s point resonates with me. When I meet companies for the first time, they often say that their bank manager or bank does not understand them. We often hear people say that they need money for growth. If we get behind the facts, we will get to the real question. Once we get the financiers and companies on the same factual page, we can move forward. Things often start from a misunderstanding. Some smaller companies do not even understand where they are. When someone says to a bank that they need more money, the bank will want to understand what it is for. People often say that it is for growth, but it is often found that it is for funding losses. People will say that they need more money, but if it is for funding losses that will simply go bad, what is the point? One must reverse slightly with companies, get them on the right platform, and ask them why they need the money. If it is for losses, we should tell them to cut out the losses and then look at what they need. Sometimes there are genuine misunderstandings.Banks are lending. They have gone through a period of reflection. Perhaps the cultural slackness was not only in the business community, and perhaps money was too easy to get. People said, “Let’s not worry about the underlying trading performance of the business because of property accumulation and capital.” As a society, we collectively forgot some of the fundamentals. Some people are saying that things are difficult, but that is because fundamentals are being applied that people were perhaps a bit lazy in applying previously. That comes into play as well.

Richard Martin Association of Chartered Certified Accountants
link

I agree with that; it is all true. All our surveys are done through the Open University business school and are funded by us and Barclays Bank. The overall survey view tends to reflect the business position in a simpler way than the banks’ position. There was a distinct drop of around 10 per cent in the facilities that were available in the early part of 2009. We are seeing some recovery from that position, but the drop was noticeable.People are reporting that costs are greater. People thought that overdraft facilities cost more, but I am not sure that everybody had a clear idea about that; there were quite a lot of don’t knows. I could certainly make the report available to members.The Scottish Government also produced a report, whose findings seemed similar to ours: the percentage of loan applications that were turned down increased in the early part of the year. Quite a lot of the information points in the same direction.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

It would be helpful if you could provide the committee with a copy of your report. We have seen the Scottish Government report, but it is relatively dated and we want to see what the trends are. Yours sounds as if it might be slightly more up to date, and it would be helpful to have it.I have one more question on the banks before I open up the questioning to other members. One of the big criticisms that we hear from the business sector is that decision making on business finance has become more centralised and that local managers do not really understand business and cannot make the decisions. That relates to what Bruce Cartwright said. The approach to applications has almost become a tick-box exercise—”Computer says no,” like in the “Little Britain” sketch. Do you see that trend? Do you think that increased competition in Scotland’s banking sector might lead to change and give businesses more opportunities to find a bank manager who understands their business?

Bruce Cartwright Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland
link

There is an irony there because some of the time it comes down to pricing. At the lower end of the scale—personal and individual banking—the lower the sum involved, the less there is to move around, and the more it is like a credit application. An individual applying for a £5,000 loan will probably fill in a form as they would do when applying for a credit card. The irony is that the more sophisticated and heavy—”heavy” is the wrong word—or large the lending gets, the more sophisticated the bank’s response will be.From my experience over the years, I have seen that the difficulty comes in when there are larger companies that borrow more. They have sophisticated information systems, so the relationship can be less immediate. However, if a committee or a syndicate is involved, that is fine. I have always felt that the system disconnects in that middle market, in which a business that is borrowing £2 million to £4 million might not produce regular accounts, which does not help. Such businesses might not be quite big enough to have robust systems in place, so the bank is very reliant on the individual who, ironically, is the one who needs the most help, but the most help is actually available to the larger companies and the smaller guy who is making his credit application. That is where there is a disconnect.I understand why the banks have centralised things; it comes down to cost. The customer wants to pay less for the service, but he also wants the service to be personalised. That applies not just to the banks but across the retail sector. There is a disconnect in the current situation. It would be good to have someone to turn to immediately in your own city—Dundee or wherever—but that has to be balanced against the economics of the business. That is no different from shopping: people prefer to talk to a human being.

Richard Martin Association of Chartered Certified Accountants
link

The banks have business branches and managers, so there is someone to talk to. However, I completely agree with Bruce Cartwright that banks set thresholds below and above which applications are dealt with differently, and different information is demanded at different thresholds. It is not surprising that banks do things differently with applications and on-going monitoring according to how much money they have out there.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

From what you have just said, is there a gap in the business advisory services that are available to small and medium-sized enterprises? If there is, who should be filling it? Should it be the accountancy profession, the business gateway, Scottish Enterprise, or someone else?

Bruce Cartwright Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland
link

It is funny that you should ask that. I am sitting here as a member of ICAS and thinking that there are ICAS members in local communities all over Scotland. For example, in the farming community, it is obvious that people talk to their accountant. Sometimes we have to be fair and say that people like getting free advice; they do not like to pay for it. There is a natural network, but it is a two-way thing. A small business with a £2 million loan might not do its accounts regularly and might not be able to give facts and information. People are sometimes reluctant to turn to a lawyer, an accountant or professional adviser because the clock is running, but there are probably ICAS members in every location in Scotland. I do not want to brag about ICAS, but the professionals are out there, and perhaps they are underused.

Iain Coke Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales
link

Our experience is that, for many SME businesses, the accountant is often the trusted business adviser. Such a business will probably have a lawyer and an accountant, even if they do not produce or audit the accounts. Most businesses of a reasonable size—I am talking about the £2 million-plus level—will have an accountant as an adviser. Perhaps they could talk more to their accountants to get help through a period of crisis.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

We have been talking about competition. In its submission of last September, ICAS said:“many of the relationship managers at banks have either been replaced or no longer have the authority that they previously had”.You have partly covered the issue, but from the point of view of competition, surely that does not amount to reaching out to the sector that we have talked about. Are we saying that accountants can take the place of local relationship managers in banks?

Richard Martin Association of Chartered Certified Accountants
link

No, I do not think that they can. They are people who can advise customers. As has been said, surveys in many countries indicate that accountants are among the most trusted business advisers. The fact that that helps to give the banks confidence in them means that, to an extent, they are trusted by both sides, partly because, as a profession, accountancy has a dedication to integrity, ethics and so on. That is accountants’ role; they cannot replace the banks’ relationship managers.

Iain Coke Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales
link

Accountants may be akin to translators, in that they help to bridge the information and knowledge gap between small businesses and the banks.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

The role of auditors has come under greater scrutiny as a result of the financial crisis. Do you have any comments on that?

David Wood Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland
link

The role of auditors is extremely important, as it is about giving confidence to capital markets in relation to financial reporting. There have been some challenges.I should explain that financial statements are the responsibility of the company’s directors, who make estimates and judgments on the valuation of assets, provisions for losses and disclosures within the constraints of accounting standards. The role of the independent auditor is to examine those judgments and financial statements and to provide an independent report that gives confidence to the markets.The auditor’s role includes consideration of a 12-month period from the date on which they sign their report. They must consider the company’s situation as a going concern over that period, so they would naturally think of various events that could happen that might have an impact on that. They would look at the company’s forecasts and its business model for the period. Things could crop up that are not anticipated, as happened in the financial crisis, so the auditor cannot guarantee 100 per cent that the company will remain a going concern. That is one issue that came up in the context of the work of the Treasury Select Committee at Westminster.Two other issues came up, one of which was whether, even though the auditors did the job that they were expected to do, the audit should be broadened to make it more useful. I am sure that Iain Coke will be able to fill us in on that because the ICAEW did a project to take that forward. The other issue was the provision of non-audit services by auditors to their audit clients. ICAS did a project on that, which I would be willing to talk about further in due course, if you wish me to.11:30

Richard Martin Association of Chartered Certified Accountants
link

Obviously, whenever there are major financial losses, questions are asked about audit and the role of auditors. We have seen that in previous crises with Enron and so on. Our view is that the auditing and accounting profession of course needs to look at what has happened to see whether any lessons can be learned. We are certainly doing that—not just in the UK but in other countries around the world—and we are considering whether the audit should look at wider issues. However, we come back to the position that the audit is on the financial statements, which are historical records. That is an inherent limitation in financial reports and in the audit of those reports that we cannot get away from.

Iain Coke Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales
link

Further to Richard Martin’s allusion to the post-Enron reforms, we have gone through a significant strengthening of the accounting and audit regulatory system over the past few years, so we perhaps arrived in the current crisis in relatively good condition. I think that those reforms have held up quite well. Press reports in early 2008 about the performance of auditors indicated that auditors were being quite strongly challenging of management—which is what one would want them to be—and that auditors were doing their job under quite difficult circumstances.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

David Wood referred to the non-anticipation of the sub-prime mortgage crisis. Given their understanding of collateralised debt obligations and the like, surely sub-prime mortgages should have flagged up dangers in the minds of auditors ahead of time. Were challenges being made to management about such financial investment structures, which were proliferating in the market at the time?

Iain Coke Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales
link

At the start of 2008, there was a challenge in valuing assets and liabilities in stressed markets. Responsibility for doing that lies with management; the auditors review the judgments that management have made in putting together the year-end accounts. That was quite challenging for the auditors, whose job is not to decide on or report on the business model that the management use but to report on whether the accounts present a true and fair view of that.

Richard Martin Association of Chartered Certified Accountants
link

I emphasise that the audit is a true and fair view at the balance sheet date. During the crisis, we know that events moved extremely quickly. Although some investments were difficult to value—there were many problems with that—investments that were being traded at a particular value subsequently saw their value diminish significantly over a matter of a few months. Therefore, very big losses were incurred by some institutions. However, on the whole, the picture that we now see is that those losses were recorded in the right period. I do not think that we have seen lots of cases in which the values that were attached at the balance sheet date were necessarily widely out or wrong. The values were right at that date, but events changed subsequently. In those few months, major losses of value were incurred that had to be recognised.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

Following on from that, have any changes been observed in the demand for auditing and accounting services by headquarters of financial institutions in Scotland?

Iain Coke Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales
link

I can probably offer comments on the UK more generally, rather than on Scotland—

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

It would be helpful if your comments relate to Scotland, as we are trying to focus on what is happening here.

Iain Coke Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales
link

I do not expect that there would be any difference between the UK position and the Scottish position.A lot of the major firms’ financial services practices have commented that they have never been so busy. Some of that will be because they are providing audit services to their audit clients, and some will be providing non-audit services to, and doing advisory service work with, non-audit clients. In the financial services sector in particular, there has been a lot of demand for the skills of accountants and auditors.

David Wood Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland
link

I endorse that. Audit is a statutory requirement anyway—certainly at the top level. Lower down, there is auditing exemption for the lowest companies, so demand for audits at that level is slipping away slightly.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

So, it is a good time for auditors and their profits.

Bruce Cartwright Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland
link

It is not necessarily a good time for auditors. They might be busy, but that does not mean that the market is not competitive. I would like to think that any profession has a revenue stream to support it, but it is not as simple as saying that this is a profitable time. It is a case of having a business that will be sustainable for the next 50 to 100 years. It not about making hay in one year, but about how a firm stays in the business over a lifetime, as with any business.

Richard Martin Association of Chartered Certified Accountants
link

There has been quite a bit of change between different parts of the business, and we have seen that in previous recessions. The audit is clearly an on-going requirement, so the demand for it remains fairly steady, but demand for other services, such as tax advice, tends to diminish in a recession, while business recovery services tend to increase. The picture is one of different professional service firms growing at different rates.

Rob Gibson SNP Highlands and Islands
link

The headquarters of financial institutions in Scotland, the asset managers, insurance firms and so on, as well as the banks, are all seeking your services. Is there any noticeable difference in that demand just now? That was the root of my question.

Bruce Cartwright Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland
link

From observation of our businesses, I would say that there is a demand for the services. Is it higher than before? The transactional work has changed, perhaps temporarily. There is less corporate finance work, and more transaction work of a different nature in my area. Within that, tax services seem to be more focused on transactional corporate finance. If any part of the industry is finding things slightly more difficult, it is the tax advisors within the profession because there is less transactional work and less merger and acquisition activity.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

I go back to the audit issue, and ask for a little bit more clarification of the audit process in a major bank, for example. What will the auditor do, and to whom will it give account at the end of the examination of the accounts?

David Wood Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland
link

I will give you a brief introduction and perhaps others will supplement it. The most important thing for an auditor is to understand the business. In planning an audit, that understanding is vital when the auditor is looking at the riskiest areas. The auditor normally approaches their work on the basis of risk and, because the concept of materiality features highly, the auditor focuses on the largest and riskiest figures.Audit work involves checking financial controls in the business, which applies to all companies—not just banks. The auditors might run through a sample of transactions in different areas. They also scrutinise in great detail the financial results that are being reported, and try to match those to their understanding of the different patterns and seasons of the business. They also undertake a detailed analytical review of the financial statements. In a company such as RBS, for example, which has a US listing, the auditors also work on internal controls under the United States’ Sarbanes-Oxley Act. At the end of that process, the auditors complete a report to the shareholders, which is expressed in terms of the accounts as presented, and which gives a true and fair, or roughly right view.As I mentioned before, there is a going-concern aspect to that.Do you want to add anything on the financial services side, Iain?

Iain Coke Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales
link

It is important to remember that the auditors of a bank have exactly the same job as the auditors of any other institution. They have only limited responsibilities in relation to the FSA and on the regulatory side. Therefore, if a bank auditor or an insurance auditor becomes aware during the course of their normal audit work of anything that the regulator ought to know about, they have a statutory obligation to report that to the regulator.However, their main job involves examining financial statements. They do not have responsibilities over bank regulatory returns, so they are not required to get an audit on the financial information that banks provide to the FSA. That is different to the way in which insurance regulation works: insurance regulatory returns are on the public record and are subject to audit, whereas banking returns are private and there is no audit requirement in relation to them.We think that there is scope for examining the relationship between auditors and the FSA. That is an area that we were asked to examine by the Treasury Select Committee, and we are going through a process of stakeholder interviews with investors, bank chief financial officers and audit committee chairmen.Last week, we met John McFall to talk about the demand regulators, and we think that there is scope for more to be done in that regard; there is, in particular, scope for bank auditors to have greater dialogue with the FSA. Under the previous regulatory regime of the Bank of England, there were regular meetings between bank auditors and the Bank of England. We think that more use could be made of such meetings. The FSA has increased the frequency of its meetings, and is committed to an annual meeting between a bank auditor and itself, which is not that frequent for a major bank.As well as meetings, there should be a good and open dialogue that involves not only the auditors giving information to the FSA but the FSA sharing with the auditors information that might have an impact on the audit assignment. For example, there is no requirement for the FSA to tell the auditors that it is about to shut down a bank, even if that were scheduled to happen the day before the audit report were signed. We think that that is a weakness in the current regime. It is different to the position in the USA under the Federal Reserve System, where there is a duty for regulators to give information to auditors.

Richard Martin Association of Chartered Certified Accountants
link

I would emphasise the importance of shareholders. The financial reports of the companies are designed to inform shareholders, the market and investors such as the people you heard from earlier, and the audit follows the financial reporting because it is an audit on the financial reports. The auditor must always remember that he is responsible to the shareholders of the company, not to the company.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

That is a relevant point. Numerous witnesses from various sectors have stated that a critical feature of the crises that hit HBOS and the Royal Bank of Scotland was the failure of non-executive directors in particular, and of the board in general, to pick up on the risks that had got out of control, and to rein in the executives who were clearly taking outrageous risks with other people’s money. What is the role of the auditor in that situation? If non-executive directors and shareholders fail to recognise overly complex financial instruments, risk that is out of control and acquisitions that are not in the best interest of the acquirer, is the auditor responsible for alerting non-executive directors and shareholders to those issues before they arise?11:45

Richard Martin Association of Chartered Certified Accountants
link

The auditor has no role in communicating with shareholders beyond the question of the truth and fairness of the financial statements that are issued. We have to remember that that was in train before the financial crisis. Those financial statements now try to communicate much more the sort of messages that you are talking about, such as taking on risk and the strategies and sorts of business models that banks and other companies are pursuing. That information is increasingly in the financial statements. There is a responsibility for the auditors in that regard.Auditors prepare more lengthy internal reports to audit committees and therefore to the boards of directors of companies on what they see as important issues that have come out of the audit or important decisions that are being made by the company about valuation or whatever. So, there is another form of reporting that is private, as it were, to the directors via the audit committee.

Iain Coke Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales
link

Auditors are not there to second-guess management and they do not have a particular duty to look for risk problems, other than those that relate to risk of misstatement in financial statements. However, the auditor might become aware of things in the course of the audit report: if so, there is a duty to report that to those who are charged with governance. The typical route is through an audit committee. Auditors are not necessarily required to look for everything, but if they become aware of problems there are obligations to report them.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

Would reporting to the audit committee be on a separate channel from the ordinary conversations with the chief financial officers that you would, I presume, have on a daily basis during an audit?

Iain Coke Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales
link

Often, it would happen in both ways. The auditor would only not tell the CFO something that he was going to tell the audit committee if there were particular concerns about the actions of the CFO. It would be unusual not to inform the executive management. Typically, it would happen in cases of fraud with which the executive management is associated.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

What is interesting is that the auditor is better qualified to understand the financial processes within a company than almost any other independent external person. Have auditors’ professional judgment and understanding been fully utilised in respect of financial sector organisations that have got into difficulties such as we have seen?

Richard Martin Association of Chartered Certified Accountants
link

You are right that auditors must have an overall view of often large and complicated institutions and that there is something in that position that could be useful. As I said, the financial statements have to talk about how the company manages its various risk exposures and about the nature of its investments. All that has to be covered as part of the audit because it is in the financial statements and, sometimes, in associated documents that the auditors are responsible for examining.

Iain Coke Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales
link

We need, however, to be realistic about how far auditors might be able to go. They have financial skills that they use in looking at and reviewing internal control processes, but they are not economists, nor are they better able to predict the future than anyone else. There is therefore a risk that if we oversell their role, we might create an expectation gap with regard to what can realistically be achieved.

David Wood Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland
link

I have a point to add on corporate governance. The auditors also have a role in ensuring that disclosures that relate to corporate governance in a company are fairly stated and not misleading. That would not extend to comments about the non-executive directors not being challenging enough; it relates more to structural matters. That is another important role of the auditors.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

Would it be true to say, as I think John McFall said, that the number of firms that would have the range of skills and knowledge to audit effectively the large financial institutions would be quite small? Is that a fair comment?

David Wood Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland
link

Yes, that is right. We are talking about very big financial conglomerates with global operations. The number of firms of similar size with expertise to match is fairly small.

Lewis Macdonald Lab Aberdeen Central
link

Such expertise would be available in Scotland—if a Scotland-based institution were being audited, a Scotland-based auditor would be available to do that.

Bruce Cartwright Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland
link

Yes. I can state categorically that such expertise exists in my organisation.

Iain Coke Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales
link

There is a so-called big four of accounting firms. Other organisations are looking to get into that market, but the focus is on the big four.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

I want to press you a bit further on the true and fair nature of financial reports, because it seems to me that that is the crucial issue here. I presume that in producing such reports, you must be satisfied that you understand the nature of the risks that the banking industry has undertaken. It appears, from the crisis, that some banks were not clear about the nature of the risk that was involved in the cut-and-sliced instruments that they were dealing in. Are you satisfied that the auditors understood the nature of the assets that were held by the banks—in particular, the toxic assets that are now costing the taxpayer a fortune?

Iain Coke Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales
link

We have accounting standards to help to describe the type of risk disclosures that are needed. Recently, the level of disclosures on financial instruments has increased and been strengthened. “International Financial Reporting Standards 7—Financial Instruments: Disclosures”; which deals with disclosures on financial instruments and covers risk disclosures among other things, came in for the first time for 31 December 2007 year-ends, which was probably slightly too late for the current crisis. The accounting profession has been looking to strengthen risk disclosures over the past few years.

Richard Martin Association of Chartered Certified Accountants
link

With many such instruments, it is a question of what the value of those instruments was. That is what I was trying to say. Such instruments have a value on a particular date, which is a true and fair value on that date but not at a subsequent date, so a great deal is caught up in the valuation that is put on them. The valuation that was put on the instruments in question was put on them by the management and was based on transactions that might have been taking place on similar instruments. There are specialist firms that value such instruments. It is accepted that the market priced some of those instruments incorrectly: it did not understand the risks, so it got the valuation wrong.

Bruce Cartwright Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland
link

Richard Martin is right about valuation, but even if we move away from considering instruments—in order to make the issue more tangible for people here—and look at the property market, which people can see and feel more readily, we see that the values that were put on property were correct at that point in time. An irony is that the financial crisis was a liquidity crisis but, because that made people lose confidence, there was an almost self-fulfilling expectation that property prices would begin to move downwards due to lack of liquidity. For example, values in the commercial property market are probably 50 per cent of what they were two years ago. I do not think that people would have predicted that sort of correction. I find it easier to consider the issue in the context of the property market because I can see and feel it. Property prices were not previously wrongly valued—people were willing to pay those prices for property, although they would certainly not pay the same price today. Values will come back, but it might take seven or eight years.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

I want to press you on that because, to my mind, you are mixing up price and value. The price of something is what someone is willing to pay for it, but that is not its value. For example, if I was foolish enough to buy a fake painting, I could pay a large price for it but it would not actually be worth anything. Did the people in the accounting industry who were auditing the banks understand the underlying value—as opposed to the price, which we all know was wrong—of the assets? Did they understand the risks that were contained within those assets in a way that enabled them to say that they had been given a true and fair value, as opposed to a true and fair price?

Bruce Cartwright Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland
link

Before answering that question, I need to be clear that, if someone is willing to pay the price, that is the value that they attribute to the asset. I am sorry to disagree on this—

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

Auditors are meant to check that the value that the banks have put on something is a true and fair value. That is for the benefit not of the bank but of the shareholders. If the value is completely wrong because the underlying risk related to the asset has not been properly assessed, surely the auditors have a responsibility to highlight that. If the auditors do not understand the underlying risks and therefore do not understand the value, surely they have a responsibility to highlight the fact that the assets are such that it is impossible to assess whether a true and fair value has been given to them because the auditors do not understand the meaning of them. That is what I am trying to get at. Did auditors understand the assets that they were valuing as part of the audit process?

Iain Coke Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales
link

Price is probably the best and most objective indication of value at any point in time. Yes, price and value are different, but price is an objective measure whereas value is a bit of a theoretical concept.

David Wood Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland
link

Perhaps a linked issue is that the market for some of these instruments was fairly thin. In that respect, it is actually quite difficult to say that price is a realistic value, but there is nothing else to go on. Value obviously exists in the eye of the beholder, so the market price is the most reliable. The other side of the issue is that financial statement users need to understand and be aware of the limitations of the accounts in that respect.

Gavin Brown Con Lothians
link

Clearly, auditors look at the balance sheets of companies and organisations. To what degree do auditors have discussions with institutions—financial or otherwise—about what is not on the balance sheet?

Iain Coke Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales
link

The International Accounting Standards Board has been looking closely at off-balance-sheet issues over a number of years and has tightened up what goes on to the balance sheet. The IASB chairman, Sir David Tweedie, is on record as saying that he will feel that his job is done when British Airways has its aeroplanes on its balance sheet. There has been an on-going process at looking at what is on and off balance sheet.In the current crisis, in the context of financial instruments and securitised vehicles, there was a problem with the definitions under US generally accepted accounting principles—GAAP—that was fixed in the crisis. However, we did not see particular problems in the international financial reporting standards definition of whether things are on or off balance sheet.12:00

Richard Martin Association of Chartered Certified Accountants
link

I agree. Obviously, the UK and the other European banks have been using the international financial reporting standards, and the generally accepted accounting principles apply to the US banks. The off-balance-sheet issue is always difficult and significant, but I agree that it was more of an issue for the US than for the IFRS. When Deutsche Bank moved from using US GAAP to using IFRS in 2007, its balance sheet expanded by 40 per cent as a result. It is right to say that the issue of what was off balance sheet was much bigger for the US.

Gavin Brown Con Lothians
link

Much of this morning’s discussion has been about looking back at what went wrong and why certain things were not spotted. You have responded to those questions, but I have a big concern. You have explained what auditors do and what they ought to be expected to do, but based on that it does not seem to me that they would spot the next Northern Rock, Dunfermline Building Society, HBOS or RBS now or in five or 10 years’ time. Is that a fair assessment?

Iain Coke Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales
link

There are probably a lot of lessons to be learned about how banks are regulated. The FSA has been considering those lessons. There may be questions about how accounting interacts with regulatory standards and about how some regulatory numbers fed into the capital rules, made them pro-cyclical, and therefore helped to inflate performance in the good times and caused it to become more severe in the downturns. The capital rules need to be looked at.Ultimately, we have financial regulators to consider business models and look for the causes of potential business failures. It is generally accepted that auditors do 12-month going concern assessments, but problems at banks tend to happen quickly. Banking failures do not happen over a period of years. Rather, they happen over days or hours, and action needs to be taken to avoid the problems that we saw with the run on Northern Rock.

Richard Martin Association of Chartered Certified Accountants
link

I agree. I return to what I said earlier. An inherent limitation of financial reports, and therefore of audits, is that they are historical. It is a matter of trying to get a true and fair record of what has happened in order that investors can make their own judgments about how companies will perform in the future. Financial reports and audits are historical information that allows investors to make future estimations and predictions. Truth and fairness are needed on the balance sheet date, and that should be informed by events right up to the date on which the accounts are agreed by the directors and signed off by the auditors. Balance sheets should try to be records of conditions on the balance sheet date, and true and fair records of the period that led up to that date. To some extent, the business is not predictive; rather, it is a matter of providing historical information from which others will make predictions.

Gavin Brown Con Lothians
link

I accept that the data are historical, that there cannot be 100 per cent guarantees, and that events moved extremely quickly. However, things such as the loan to deposit ratios of certain banks did not happen overnight.

Iain Coke Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales
link

A lot of information was known. The accounts provided a lot of information if people went through them. The accounting did its job to the extent that it provided information to the market, which was aware of many things and made its own judgments. It is quite difficult to hold auditors accountable for judgments that are made in the market.

David Wood Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland
link

It was mentioned previously that the accounting standards are being improved in specific areas and there are extra disclosures of things such as risks and financial instruments. In essence, risks are flagged up to the outside world for regulators or shareholders to inquire about and act upon. The auditor’s role is to ensure that there is transparency and that what the company says is true and fair.

Bruce Cartwright Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland
link

Your concern is correct. If we were to say that there were no lessons to be learned from the past three years, that simply could not be true—it would mean that we all had sacks over our heads. What is needed is an understanding of the auditor’s role and perhaps a redefining of part of it. However, that cannot be done in isolation; the regulator’s role also needs to be looked at, as well as the question of what is the right loan debt capital. Your concern is genuine, but the body of regulation also needs to be considered.

Iain Smith LD The Convener · North East Fife
link

It does not mean anything to me.

Bruce Cartwright Institute of Chartered Accountants of Scotland
link

You have lost me.

Christopher Harvie SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

That is interesting, because they were the little guys in a downtown office in New York who were the auditors of Bernie Madoff. Two of them were there, one had retired and gone to Florida and there was a secretary, which means that there was a staff of three. Those guys audited the books of what was probably the biggest scam in world history—they were auditors.Another point is that firms such as KPMG, BDO Stoy Hayward and PricewaterhouseCoopers went through the books of the people who invested money in the Madoff Ponzi scheme and did not go further into it. I am basing my comments on a piece in Time magazine that came out not long after Mr Madoff went into a police station and said that there was no possible innocent explanation of his business practices. Those are very big firms: three of the six biggest such companies in the world were not, it seems, practising any form of due diligence. We are looking at the minutiae of Scottish regulation, but when one looks, as we will do with the next panel, at the impact on the ratings agencies of the fact that many of the ratings agency classifications were based on AIG having underwritten the firms concerned, is there a question about whether the really big firms were themselves not up to the job—and that might be an innocent explanation?

Iain Coke Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales
link

On the point about the small firm that audited the Madoff firms—again, my comments are based on reports rather than on detailed information—I understand that the people involved may not have been members of the American Institute of Certified Public Accountants and that they may not have had audit licences, so there are wider problems. It is difficult for us, as a professional body, to comment on action taken by someone who is not one of our members and who should not be doing the job anyway.

Christopher Harvie SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

But surely PricewaterhouseCoopers, KPMG and such firms would make such judgments.

Iain Coke Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales
link

And they are subject to the US audit regulation, which was strengthened significantly after the Enron problems. I was referring to the specific small firm that was mentioned.

Richard Martin Association of Chartered Certified Accountants
link

Clearly, if there are audit failures, the people responsible must be held accountable for what they have done and the accountancy profession as a whole has to examine its role in the monitoring that we do and the disciplinary action that we take over our members.

Christopher Harvie SNP Mid Scotland and Fife
link

With respect, you had the Arthur Andersen failure as a result of the Enron fraud three years before this and yet the same thing has happened again—this time, even less of a real firm was involved. The dominance of the big firms went on: they signed off accounts and people believed them. As Lady Bracknell might have said, “To allow this to happen once is an accident, but to allow it to happen twice seems like carelessness.”

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.