Agenda item 3 is an evidence-taking session for our inquiry into the delivery of regeneration in Scotland. On Monday last week, committee members undertook two more community fact-finding visits as part of the inquiry. That brings to six the number of fact-finding visits that we have undertaken around Scotland during that work, and I estimate that we have now engaged directly with nearly 200 local community representatives since we began our inquiry in January.Richard Baker, Cameron Buchanan, Stewart Stevenson and I visited Whitfield in Dundee to meet local community groups. At the same time, the deputy convener, John Wilson, Anne McTaggart and Stuart McMillan visited Ferguslie Park in Paisley for the same purpose. Between those two visits, we engaged with another 70 local people from communities across Scotland. I thank all those local people who took the time to meet us and the staff from Dundee City Council, the Whitfield Development Group, Renfrewshire Council, Engage Renfrewshire and the Ferguslie Park Housing Association for all their assistance in helping to facilitate those visits.We will have three panels of witnesses before us today representing urban regeneration companies, local authorities and enterprise agencies. We will conclude the session by hearing from the Minister for Housing and Welfare, Margaret Burgess, on behalf of the Scottish Government. The witnesses have provided written submissions, which members have in their papers.I welcome Ian Manson, chief executive of Clyde Gateway; Alan Robertson, projects director of Clydebank Rebuilt; Patrick Wiggins, chief executive of the Irvine Bay Regeneration Company; and Eric Adair, director of PARC Craigmillar. I am conscious of the time limitations. Would you like to make any opening statements? They will have to be brief.
Official Report · Committee
Regeneration
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Kevin Stewart SNP 85
- Allan McQuade Scottish Enterprise 32
- Margaret Burgess 28
- Patrick Wiggins Irvine Bay Regeneration Company 24
- Ian Manson Clyde Gateway 21
- Douglas Duff Scottish Local Authorities Economic Development Group 21
- Stuart McMillan SNP 20
- Eric Adair PARC Craigmillar 19
- John Wilson SNP 18
- Stewart Stevenson SNP 17
- Anne McTaggart Lab 16
- Alan Robertson Clydebank Rebuilt 14
- David Cowan Scottish Government 7
- Richard Baker Lab 6
- Cameron Buchanan Con 4
- The Minister for Housing and Welfare Margaret Burgess 1
The record
333 contributions · showing 1–200Thank you very much. Clyde Gateway is keen to contribute to your inquiry. Over the past few sessions, you have heard from a number of witnesses who have represented Clyde Gateway, although you may not have realised it. Councillor Chris Thompson, our vice chair, was here recently. Brendan Rooney, from the Healthy n Happy Community Development Trust, and Jimmy McLellan, one of our community representatives, have also been here.You toured our area about a year ago. If you were to tour it today, you would see an area undergoing a major transformation. We have a good story to tell, but we have a long way to go before we finish the job. I am happy to have been able to provide a written submission that says that the community should be at the heart of regeneration. It is a long haul to do the job well. Up-front public money is required to get it going and we all have to convince the private sector to invest so that the jobs that we all desire can be created.
Thank you, Mr Manson. Please give our regards to everyone in your organisation, particularly wee Jimmy, who we thought was an amazing witness.If you have no other comments to make, we will move to our questions. How did your organisations respond to the financial crisis? Did you alter projections and targets at that time?
We were born into the storm. Clyde Gateway was created in 2008 so, from the very beginning, our tactics, strategy and operating plans were amended to take into account the poor market conditions. As you would expect, previous assumptions about values, joint ventures and the state of the private sector market were altered from day 1. The tactics that Clyde Gateway adopted at that time were to identify early projects to ensure that there were early wins, as it was going to be even more difficult to do that than it was before, and to get early action on the ground in the face of what we knew was a crisis. We also tried to have a number of market opportunities ready. At that time, it was difficult to guess which aspects of the market were going to come back or develop, so we put a range of opportunities out into the market.Unfortunately for Clyde Gateway, the financial crisis was a day 1 issue, and Clyde Gateway has continued constantly to review the position in deciding what to do in the face of changing market conditions. The committee may be interested to know that we have adhered to our original targets. Our board felt strongly, at its very first meeting, that to reduce or amend the targets in any way would not be the right thing to do. Over a 20-year period, we still intend to provide 400,000m2 of business space and to have 10,000 houses built in our area. That 20-year period will cover a number of recessions and economic good times. The board has reviewed its position constantly, but it has continued to pursue ambitious targets for the future of our area. On the back of the M74 completion investment and the legacy ambitions for the Commonwealth games, we still feel that that is the right thing to do.
You were born during the beginning of the downturn. Were your targets, therefore, initially much more realistic?
The targets were set in a business planning process over 2006 and 2007. You could easily question whether the targets were still realistic, given the changed economic circumstances. However, the key thing to remember about Clyde Gateway is that it is a 20-year commitment. Those targets will be met because the fundamentals are there. There is the room, the land and—when we have finished—the infrastructure to accommodate that level of investment and those outcomes. We feel that, over that 20-year period, it is right to stick to those targets and they are still realistic in our view.
Okay. We may come back to that.
We were born at a different time from our colleagues. Our initial business plan was for the period from 2003 to 2010, so we were on both sides of the fence and experienced both the good times and the deteriorating times. We refreshed our business plan in 2010 and very much took account of the wider circumstances. As a result, we pared back some of our targets for the creation of business space and certain jobs targets. For example, we had identified that, in the period to 2010, we would like to achieve something of the order of 14,400m2 of business space in our area. However, the reality was that by 2010 we had achieved 5,700m2 and we decided that, in the planned period from 2010 to 2016, we would only marginally increase the cumulative target to 15,550m2. We had initially hoped to achieve 420 construction jobs, but by 2010 we had achieved 65. Again we pared things back and the cumulative target for 2016 for construction-related jobs is now 139.
Having been born at the end of the last significant period of growth, we have significantly changed our business plan over the past few years; indeed, our submission contains a diagram that shows the number of iterations that we have been through. We have responded in a number of ways. First of all, we have of course taken account of the recession’s impact, particularly on commercial development and private sector investment. We have also taken account of the squeeze on public finances and have pared back some of the original ambitions in our business plan with regard to the level of funding that we could secure from the public sector, because we realise that such ambitions are not appropriate and that the funding is not available.Moreover, we and our partners have looked very closely at how all the partners have responded to the economic crisis that has hit North Ayrshire. Through the community planning process and the North Ayrshire economic development and regeneration strategy, there has been quite a shift in emphasis by all the partners towards job creation. Our original jobs target was in the region of 1,100 jobs because we were trying to create the setting for investment and undertaking a lot of urban renewal work, but we have now shifted fundamentally to more opportunistic job creation and are also taking advantage of the opportunity presented by the enterprise area. We have recalibrated what we are doing and are still very optimistic about our ability to pull in the jobs we want to achieve; in fact, because of the enterprise area and its opportunities, we have increased our jobs target.We are trying to balance different things, and our shift of emphasis towards job creation opportunities is a reflection of the area’s needs, the views of the community planning partnership and our main sponsors Scottish Enterprise and North Ayrshire Council and the opportunity afforded by the enterprise area. It is certainly a unique opportunity for us as an urban regeneration company.
When PARC Craigmillar developed its business plan’s goals and objectives over 2003, 2004 and 2005, the economic circumstances were buoyant and the view was that, by 2007, 2008 or 2009, the whole enterprise would effectively be self-sufficient and proceeding on the basis of the profitability of the previous investment and normal bank lending to the private sector. However, by late 2008, there were very limited if any profits to be made from development and bank lending had disappeared, which meant that the two fundamental features of the second phase of PARC regeneration were not in place. From 2009 on, we were unable to pursue our original objectives at any pace and, by the end of 2009, the company was technically insolvent; its liabilities exceeded its assets; and, like many private sector development companies at the time, we were in survival mode with a question mark over whether survival was possible.Although we held on to our vision, we had to drop many of our short-term targets and alter those targets from long-term investment to anything that would enable the company to generate cash in the short term. Our view was that, if we did not survive, we would be unable to achieve the long-term objectives, so survival became the focus of our activities and has been until very recently. With the beginnings of improvements in bank lending and in the economy over the past 12 months, we are now returning again to look at our longer-term vision.09:45
Before I move to questions from colleagues, I want to ask about the figures on the fifth page of the submission from Irvine Bay Regeneration Company. The submission suggests that £0.5 billion of gross value added has been secured so far. Can the other organisations give us an indication of where they are at in that regard? Mr Manson?
Sorry, let me make a slight correction. Actually, the amount secured is not that high, but we believe that our work can lead to that level of GVA. If the table in the submission is slightly confusing, I apologise.
How much GVA has been secured thus far?
We have secured £7 million thus far.
And how much public money has been invested?
The public money invested is £33 million.
So £33 million of public money has been invested, and thus far the GVA is £7 million.
Yes. We believe that the projects that we are working on will generate substantially more. At the moment, we are putting in place the infrastructure that will lead to the private sector investment, which will lead to the GVA. That is why the figures in the table show the amount that has been secured and the amount that will be secured on the back of the work that we have commenced. For example, the enterprise area will lead to very significant amounts of GVA and is already beginning to do so.
Okay. Mr Manson?
GVA predictions form part of the business planning process for Clyde Gateway. The expected GVA was part of the outcome from the expected investment. We use GVA predictions on a project-by-project basis to decide whether a project will provide good value going forward, but we have not calculated GVA outcomes cumulatively for our projects. We would be happy to do that, but we do not have such an indicator available at the moment.
The committee would be very interested in seeing that. Obviously, if you are doing that for individual projects, I imagine that it would be quite easy to add it all up. Mr Robertson?
Like Mr Manson, I do not have those figures immediately to hand. The intention was that the issue would be clarified towards the end of the business plan, which would have been 2016. After the up-front investment from the urban regeneration company and partners goes in and gets things moving, the private sector investment should be attracted in thereafter. That is when we believe the appropriate time is to measure GVA. Like Mr Manson, if the committee is looking for further details, I would be happy to look into that.
The committee most certainly is looking for further details. We would be grateful if you could pass that information on to the clerks.
Similarly, we have not been using GVA as a particular measure. Equivalent figures that we have suggest that, for £26 million of grant investment, we have levered in another £38 million of private sector finance.
Thank you very much.
Good morning, panel. I want to ask about community involvement. The joint submission from the west coast URCs notes:“We have provided, and will continue to provide, money and people resources to support the establishment and operation of community groups.”I hope that you all remember writing that. Could each of you provide us with more detail in respect of the numbers, the roles and the investment that your organisations have made in those community groups and the impact of that on local community regeneration?
Mr Adair, would you like to start?
You quoted from the submission from the west coast URCs, but obviously PARC Craigmillar is not included in that. We have supported the local neighbourhood partnership throughout the existence of PARC Craigmillar and we have effectively been supporting its role as a liaison with the community. We have contributed an average of £20,000 a year towards that. Our management team also contributed for a number of years by having a full-time community liaison officer.We have also, through sponsorship, supported many local community groups, although I do not know off the top of my head what the cost of our involvement in that has been.
We play a number of engagement and support roles within the community, and we have engaged in a number of specific projects. For example, we have worked with Kilwinning Community Sports Club for a number of years and have put in about £200,000, which has allowed the club to secure a £2 million investment for refurbishment of its training facilities and so on.We have also worked with an organisation in Kilwinning called PRYDE—Pennyburn Regeneration Youth Development Enterprise—which took an old pub and got some grants and support from the lottery and so on. We added £50,000 to £60,000 to that pot, which enabled the group to transform an old and derelict building into a vibrant centre for youth training, enterprise and community events.We have in the past done a number of other things through community engagement; it might be worth touching on those. For example, each of our towns has a town regeneration plan, and we have made sure that community engagement and consultation are right at the heart of developing those plans. We ran some events and 800 members of the public were engaged in that process. We had annual public meetings and so on. There is a full community engagement programme.One of the interesting things that we have been able to do is reach out through a schools programme. We link into the—I am sorry, I cannot remember the title of the new education programme for excellence.
Curriculum for excellence.
Forgive me.About 5,000 schoolchildren across our patch have been involved in projects that link with our regeneration work. We have established a youth regeneration forum at which senior people from the secondary schools come together to contribute ideas on how we might deliver the various projects that we work on.Finally, another interesting example is Kilwinning town centre. We made a substantial investment there and used the youth programme for engagement on design of the streetscape works. We worked with the promoting Kilwinning group, which is made up of traders who want to promote Kilwinning and get more business into the area. They specifically affected the design that we were proposing so that they could run events and host more activities in the town centre.We also worked with a local archaeological group and that has become a nationally recognised success story through the Heritage Lottery Fund. The group celebrates the history of Kilwinning and something like 300 volunteers were involved in the archaeological dig in the centre of the town. That all added to the vibrancy of what we are trying to achieve and deliver and, as a result, we have had a much more successful public-realm scheme than I think we could have hoped for at the start of the process.
Clydebank Rebuilt obtained £196,000 for public consultation, which we took forward by establishing our own community-based group called the design forum. That has been an opportunity for community representatives to come forward and, importantly, for members of the public to attend what were, to all intents and purposes, public meetings at which they could meet Clydebank Rebuilt and understand our plans and proposals. It was important that they were able to meet our professional teams who were working on specific projects.As a result of that, a number of heritage-related considerations came up. I am sure that the committee is aware that there is in Clydebank a great deal of pride in the Singer sewing machine factory and in shipbuilding. Through the forums, it was made clear that that should be noted respectfully in our designs. To date, we have had 16 forum meetings; everyone who attends receives a report on it, which also goes up on our website. We always have substantial local press coverage both in advance of the meetings and subsequently.As part of the consultation exercise, we also meet the business community. When we meet communities, the assumption is sometimes that it is particularly local residents whom we will meet, but we feel, given the economic situation, that it is especially important that business owners and managers are also involved.Just to finish on the design forum, I add that, as part and parcel of the community’s aspirations for regeneration of the town, it was made clear to us—the committee might have seen the substantial press coverage that we got for a major international heritage award just a few weeks back—that something needs to be done with the Titan crane and it needs to be reused. The community was also concerned about the state of the town centre. Based on those aspirations and requirements from the community, we have undertaken a project valued at £7 million. That is the larger, more set-piece element.In 2008, I think, our community engagement activities were recognised by the Scottish Government as representing good practice, but there is also a more informal side of things. The amounts of money are not large, but there might be a few hundred pounds here and a thousand pounds there for community interests to take forward their projects. For example, a number of individuals have approached us who wanted to improve local sports facilities; we were able to provide them with initial funding to do preliminary feasibility work. That has progressed over the years and a community sports trust has been formed, a business plan has been written and lottery funding is being applied for.
The community is at the heart of everything that Clyde Gateway does. A healthy community is vital to regeneration of the entire area, so the community is a key component of everything that we do. We are supporting some of the most deprived communities in Scotland; they are fragile communities that need support all the way through the process.We give support through our own resources, grants, support from our staff and in various other ways. The key way in which we do that is through support to three community development trusts. They are independent bodies that are intended to support the community, particularly on the ownership of assets and long-term sustainable community development. I am glad to say that the trusts have already been successful.The committee took evidence from Brendan Rooney; the support that we have given his organisation has allowed him to lever in about £0.5 million of additional investment. The People’s Development Trust in Dalmarnock has levered in an additional £1 million of investment that would not have come to the area, otherwise.I have a couple of figures to give you an idea of the scale of what we do. In the Camlachie community, we have spent £185,000 so far on capacity building, youth diversionary activities, health and employability work and outreach work. In the Dalmarnock community, we have spent £100,000 to establish the trust, a community shop, allotments and capacity building. In Burnhill, which was described to the committee before, we have spent £276,000 to support Healthy n Happy’s activities, which are about outreach, financial inclusion and jobs. Successful regeneration has to encompass such work, and we would like to continue that direct investment in our communities for as long as we can.
I want to explore your decision-making processes in the projects that you undertake. I will start by asking an obvious question, and a nodding-head answer will do, I suspect. Do you have more projects than you can do?
A yes or no will do.Witnesses indicated agreement.
I see that the answer is yes for all of you. That is money in the bank, in questioning terms.We heard from the panel about various slightly different approaches to financial appraisal of projects, so I have a few questions on that, first of all. Do you use the financial appraisals to rank projects? Do you have a return-on-investment measure or other measure that you use in driving that rank? Do you have a minimum figure that a project has to exceed before you would consider it, in financial terms?To give some context, I absolutely understand that we do the physical regeneration and spend money in order to deliver societal benefits. It is a complex question, but I am focusing on finance. Who would like to start?10:00
I am happy to respond to that question. Yes—our projects are scored. They are ranked and our board makes a decision about what goes forward into the operating plan every year. We use our key performance indicators to rank them. Projects that have a major impact against our overall 20-year outcomes go forward.The point that you raise on finance is interesting. We have projects in our operating plan that we hope the private sector will finance. One of the things that Clyde Gateway does is de-risk projects. At one extreme we may not succeed in de-risking a project and so have to consider making direct provision ourselves, with our own resources. However, success for us is when we have sufficiently de-risked the project; that is, invested in land reclamation, designed a building, found an occupier and found a development partner for which public money is not required.The finance question is probably more complicated than even Stewart Stevenson expects. Once we have ranked it and asked whether we will finance it, our job as a team is to make sure that we do not have to finance the work. The best example of that is our Eastgate office development: the committee stood in its atrium last year. Although that was in our operating plan at the top, ranked and financed, we secured Aviva’s 100 per cent funding and, in fact, made a return on that building.It is a rather complex process. Where public money is at stake, everything follows the various appraisal and public sector finance manuals in terms of value for money and justification.
It is rather awkward for me to answer the question directly because what Stewart Stevenson has suggested is a very quantitative approach to how projects are identified.Our modus operandi has been more qualitative; if I may, I will briefly explain the background to our URC’s operation. When we were first set up, the intention was that we would work closely with the private sector on a number of key sites within Clydebank. Due to circumstances that time does not permit me to go into, that has not happened. We were able to secure—
On the circumstances, if you are talking about the economic downturn, please say so. If other circumstances stopped the progression of projects, we would like to know that, too.
The problem was primarily the economic downturn.We were able to secure land. We accept that historically, in redevelopment and regeneration initiatives, sites have been prepared and then left to their own fortunes, so sometimes the redevelopment has taken many years. Our approach was to build directly; that has been the focus of our efforts over the years since Clydebank Rebuilt was formed.In many ways, the activity that we have undertaken has been internal, where we have built directly. The projects that we have proposed, particularly to develop economic infrastructure, have been passed through the operational plan by our board and our funders.
I echo some of Ian Manson’s comments. We probably go through a three-stage process. We have not mapped it out that way, but when we undertake a fundamental review of the business plan we go through a full ranking and prioritisation process that looks at finance, outputs, risks, deliverability and environmental considerations. That gives us a long list of projects which we then passport into our annual operating plan. When we go through the operating plan we look at affordability, deliverability and the projects that we think will deliver the biggest impact and the best return.When we get the sign-off for the individual projects, some of that process is repeated. We take a very hard look at the projects in terms of commercial assessments. We understand that there are lots of risks in the projects with which we are dealing and that there is severe market failure so there is not always a financial return. In fact, there is very rarely a financial return, as such, because we have to subsidise projects to get them going.We also have a range of projects in which our financial input is relatively low because we try to prepare the ground and create the conditions for private sector investment so that there is not always a quantum of finance going in at the front.There is also partnership work, enabling work, facilitation work and engagement with the private sector, which is a long-term process in the current economic circumstances, but we believe that it will deliver significant investment in the future, and very high returns.
There is no single approach that PARC Craigmillar has used; our approach has varied, depending on the phase of the overall regeneration and on the project.Many of the early projects that we undertook were about changing perceptions and creating a position for longer-term development. For example, a key early development was to build two new primary schools, because our view was that that changed the local community’s perception of the area. It made a statement to the younger generation, who we hoped would stay in the area for the period over which we would be involved in regeneration, and it made a statement to the city. No direct financial return was associated with that investment; the financial return was expected to come after 20 years or later. The same applies to our work on greening areas. It is difficult to measure the financial return on planting £20,000-worth of daffodils, but there is a significant return in the longer term.As we moved into the house building phase, we set financial targets. We used industry-standard financial returns for housing development and we were seeking to match the returns that a commercial house builder would seek to achieve. However, that was not possible in the early stages—indeed, if it had been, there would have been no need for regeneration. A fundamentally different approach was needed. Therefore, although the industry standard was our benchmark, we recognised that we could not achieve it. In some of our initial housing phases we were happy if we broke even, although we tried to do better than that.The goal was to move towards meeting full industry profitability on housing developments and then to go further and move the average house price in Craigmillar from around 60 per cent of the Edinburgh average to 80 per cent of the Edinburgh average. If we could achieve that, based on the initial land values, we would be able to exceed the profitability of normal commercial house building.The measurement process for our projects has therefore changed throughout the period of regeneration, depending on what we have been trying to achieve.
You mentioned two new schools. How were they paid for?
They were paid for using a combination of Government grant and our own profitability.
Did the City of Edinburgh Council not pay for the schools?
It contributed £1 million towards a school; it also contributed the land. The vast majority—probably 95 per cent—of the land in Craigmillar is owned by the City of Edinburgh Council.
Who do they belong to now?
Some of the land belongs to the City of Edinburgh Council, but much has moved into private ownership—
I am asking about the schools.
The school is owned by the City of Edinburgh Council.
Instead of paying for the two new schools by traditional means, the City of Edinburgh Council got you to get various grants and so on, so its mainstream budgets have been bypassed. In other communities in Edinburgh it would be the norm for the council to build and pay for a new school. Is it fair to say that?
Yes, although in a strict analysis the council would probably add that it had to invest to clear the site and is still contributing the remaining land to regeneration of the area—
Therefore, it could be said that your organisation’s ability to get money from other bodies has saved the City of Edinburgh Council from using mainstream resource to build two new schools for communities in Edinburgh.
That could be said, yes.
As I expected, each of the witnesses has suggested that there are not only financial but societal considerations and returns. I think that the committee will welcome that, because we do not simply regard the issue through a financial prism.I will close by asking a specific question. Do you, for each project that you undertake, have a named and identified person who is responsible for, and whose job depends on, delivering the benefits that were identified when the decision was taken to proceed with the project? When you take a project forward, you will have in the decision-making process—it is clear from what you said that this is the case—a set of financial and societal benefits that you expect to be delivered.
Very briefly, gentlemen.
Strictly speaking, the answer to the question is no; there would not be just one named person. A project might have somebody who is responsible for the physical delivery, who would probably be expected to be responsible for the financial aspects, and another individual within the organisation might seek to work with the community on delivery. A range of individuals might be involved. Ultimately, though, the organisation’s board of directors would take overall responsibility for the project.
Just before we move on, would you be absolutely clear that the board sees its responsibility as being to deliver all the benefits? By the way, I absolutely accept that in individual projects there will be things that turn out not to be deliverable, although there should be a process that makes it clear what is being discarded and accepted.
I am confident that the board recognises its role and responsibilities.
Yes, but does it do so specifically in the way that I asked about?
Yes.
Right. That is fine.
We assign a dedicated project manager to each project, who is responsible for the life cycle of the project. We also have—
Can I just stop you there? That goes precisely to the nub of what I am asking. In a sense, a project differs from a responsibility in that it has a beginning, a middle and an end. A responsibility has a beginning and it endures. My experience of projects is that we get to the end and the project manager leaves the project. However, it is over the next 20 years, as Clyde Gateway suggested, that the benefits will be delivered. So, my real question is: how does the benefits cycle work?
Okay. There are probably two answers to that. First, different people might be responsible for a project at different times, so we tend to have a project development manager, who will work up the project and perhaps do the deal, put in place all the components and then procure whatever development route we will go through. We also now have an in-house project manager who does really detailed stuff in terms of project control and scope control, and looks at the range of activities that are associated with the project. In addition, we have monitoring and evaluation, so we have a monitoring report and an evaluation report. We then report back to the board on where we are with individual projects in terms not only of the delivery phase, but of the outputs.
That leaves me unclear. Whose job is on the line if the benefits that were included in the decision-making process are not delivered?
It would be my job on the line.
That is fine.
Mr Robertson?
I concur with my colleague’s view, so I have nothing to add.
Mr Stevenson has put his finger on the added value that comes from having a focused organisation that lives or dies by its record of success. The point of my organisation is that it has to produce the goods in terms of the outcome, so we are structured so that each project has a project manager who sees it all the way through.I would like to add two things. First, in some cases, specialist knowledge is required to make things happen. We have succeeded with community benefits and in securing numerous jobs from construction contracts because we have brought to bear a specialist member of staff on that.Secondly, on Mr Stevenson’s tale about the 20 years, please do not forget that something significant has happened in that the bodies here in front of you have charitable status in the main, and have assets, and if those assets are to be passed on to anybody, our successor bodies need to have the same aims as us. Something important has happened here in Scotland; we now have the resources and the assets in the grasp of the community, with the flow of further assets going back into the community. Whatever the future of bodies such as ours, something significant has happened because a successor body would need to follow through to exploit the assets and ensure that communities benefit as we intend.10:15
Mr Manson, you said in response to the convener that you have not had to revise your targets in the light of the financial crash. Your key performance indicators suggest that you are broadly on track to reach your targets. Is that a fair reflection?
We are satisfied with the indicators on land remediation and job creation, but we are slightly frustrated on commercial development and house building—we would like to be further ahead on that. There is a sequence for our indicators. Five years ago, no sites in the area were ready for development—and we cannot get jobs or housing into the area unless we clean up the sites. We are on track to clean up the sites, but we need to motor to get the private investment that will bring jobs and further investment.
I note that qualification but, in comparison with the experience elsewhere, you are closer to your targets than other regeneration companies are. Unlike other members, I have not had the chance to visit the gateway. Why are you closer to your targets? Did you learn from experience because you started later than other companies, for example?
We learned from the other pathfinder companies and we used our experience in regeneration over many years. We set out with clear targets and a timescale, which are vital. Such information is needed to inspire people. We set out a clear vision for the area, which local people share. We adopted the community’s commonsense priorities of jobs, tidying the area, sorting the pollution and making the area the sort of place where people want to live and work. We have taken a commonsense approach.We have not overpromised, because the history of regeneration in the east end has been to overpromise and underdeliver. We are not perfect, but we have tried to ensure that we take the community with us, that we deliver what we say we will deliver, and that we have momentum and the community’s confidence in us. That is a fragile element that we work hard every day on sustaining.
My final questions are more general. Your comment about taking a commonsense approach is interesting. Such projects have 10 to 20-year lifespans. In the past few years, we have had the economic crash. Will future approaches to such schemes be revised as a result, to take greater account of ups and downs in the economy?I am looking at Mr Wiggins’s targets. You have done reasonably well on your job target—you have created 420 jobs against an original target of 1,100. Now that you will be an enterprise area as well, you have set a revised target of 3,200 jobs. You also had an original target of building 1,200 homes, of which eight have been built.I am asking about the approach that has been taken. Have we learned from the past? Are targets being based on common sense and not on overpromising, which would give an unrealistic expectation about such important schemes?
We have reflected the opportunity that we have with the enterprise area, which has a huge capacity. We have a one-off opportunity to exploit that, so we have shifted our activity heavily to focus on it.You are right about the original jobs target, on which it looks as if we are performing pretty well, given the resource that we have been able to pull down. However, we believe that we can achieve more by redirecting what we are doing. Enterprise area status gives us a unique selling point, which we are looking to exploit. We are already getting good results from that. We expect significant investments and we have already achieved one or two investments, which will come through in our performance, monitoring and evaluation in later years.We have two key sites for housing, on which all the preparation is now done. We are ready and we have in place development partners, but they need to get the finance in place to take forward the schemes. We are continuing to work with those private sector investors—we are supporting them through the crisis and helping them to find different and innovative ways of funding the schemes, but we are not putting more money into the schemes. Our emphasis is clearly shifting to job creation.A bit like Ian Manson said, given the depth of the recession that we have had, if anyone was asked what the area’s priority is, they would say that it is jobs. We have taken on board that clear message and have clearly realigned our projects to do everything that we can to unlock the area’s jobs potential.
Does anyone want to pick up on Richard Baker’s point?
Without stating the obvious, regeneration areas are very difficult to operate in. Factors such as site conditions and the current economic circumstances in which we find ourselves have an effect. I am clear that our job as a URC is to crack on. Our work is about building confidence, making our places attractive and competitive, and getting them to the start line so that developers and investors will—when they come out to play again—very much be looking at areas such as Clydebank and the other regeneration sites. That is our primary function, and as an organisation we are now at the start line, so we need the private sector to come in and play its part. That is the future for Clydebank’s regeneration.
Before we move on to Mr Wilson’s questions, I have a question for Mr Manson. You have not really mentioned the Commonwealth games to any huge extent. Is one of your main advantages as a URC the fact that a lot of the new facilities and infrastructure for the Commonwealth games are in the east end of Glasgow, which is the area that your URC covers?
Yes—I apologise if I have not emphasised that sufficiently. The games village is a significant part of our housing target. The Emirates arena is, in business development terms, the local leisure facility that people can enjoy and use after work, and the refurbishment of Dalmarnock station has also been heavily helped by the Commonwealth games.The M74 completion is equally important. Without accessibility, and without the basics being addressed—improvement of the three mainline railway stations, for example—the regeneration simply would not take place, even with the Commonwealth games.A common criticism of regeneration is that having the games, building a road or building houses is not enough. Clyde Gateway’s response to that is, “Absolutely—we agree.” Regeneration must involve doing a bit of everything. The magic of the games and the fact that they have such strong support among local people is a game changer in terms of aspiration and hope for the future, and we are taking full advantage of that.Equally, the Commonwealth games needs to deliver legacy in order to be successful. I think that Scotland expects and hopes that regeneration of the east end will be one of the key legacies from the games. We have a fantastic partnership under way in that respect.
If the Commonwealth games investments had not come into play, where would that have put you with regard to the targets that you originally set yourself?
We would have fundamentally reviewed the targets. If the M74 had not been funded and the Commonwealth games had not been won, it is a moot point whether Clyde Gateway would have even been formed.Those decisions were all taken in a very short period of time during 2007-08. I like to dwell on the fact that we have a synergy of a number of important things that have happened. We should not forget that Clyde Gateway was created to make things happen in an area where nothing had been happening for the previous 20 years. We are dealing with long-term market failure, through boom and bust, and Clyde Gateway has to use the games and the M74 to make a real sea change in the area.There is another world out there in which those things did not happen, and I am afraid it is all too obvious what would have been going on in the area. There would have been some development and some change, but it would be far from the transformational change that is now under way.
That is very useful, Mr Manson. We may well call on you to provide some of the information that we received on our visit with regard to the legacy in housing and so on. The clerks may write to you so that we can furnish new members of the committee with that information.John Wilson will come in now.
If you have left me any questions to ask, convener. You asked three questions in particular that I had written down and wanted to ask. Laughter.
Great minds think alike—although we will not move on to the second part of that saying.
Good morning, gentlemen. I will follow on from the convener’s question about the schools that were built in Craigmillar—or the plans to build two schools—and the current ownership of those schools. I note that Mr Adair said that 95 per cent of the land belonged to the local authority, so the schools would therefore be returned to the City of Edinburgh Council. Was there any discussion about transferring the schools to community ownership and using them as community hubs, rather than, once they have been built, simply transferring them back to the council?
I was not employed by PARC Craigmillar during the early stages of those decisions, so I do not know whether there were discussions of that nature. My understanding is that that was not part of early discussions, although I might be wrong.
I raise the question because Mr Manson said that he expects all the assets that are developed through the URC to become community-owned assets. I ask Mr Manson to define what he means by “community-owned assets”. Is it similar to what happened in Craigmillar, in that the assets that are created through the public funding that has been ploughed into the URCs will be transferred to the successor local authorities, which in Mr Manson’s case would be South Lanarkshire Council and Glasgow City Council?
That simple transfer is not possible. We are an urban regeneration company with charitable status, and any successor body has to have the same objectives. Therefore, it would not be possible to split up the portfolio in a simple way unless the successor bodies can demonstrate a continued intention to redevelop the area. There is a new situation in front of us, and it is one that I find quite exciting.
To clarify, you say that the successor organisation would need to have the same commitment to redevelop the area. Surely the objective of the URC is to have the area redeveloped in a 20-year timespan so, based on your current plans, there should be no need for further redevelopment of the area. Therefore, any successor organisation would not have the same objective of redeveloping the area, because it should have been redeveloped.
Areas change, and vacant and derelict land will be created in future. In the east end of Glasgow, there will always be further change. Perhaps “redevelop” is too strong a word, but any successor organisation would have to have the specific interests of the area at heart. I suggested that assets that are created by Clyde Gateway could be transferred in that way. The key is the attitude of the partners—Scottish Enterprise, South Lanarkshire Council and Glasgow City Council—which would have to decide how they want to proceed.When I talk about community ownership, I mean the real thing. The best example that I can give is the Dalmarnock community hub, which is in our operating plan to be funded. It is undergoing scrutiny by a number of bodies and will, we hope, get additional funding from the European regional development fund and regeneration funding. That asset will be owned and managed by the People’s Development Trust. I am clear that, when I talk about community ownership of assets, it is the real deal.The key factor is what the community wants to own and what it wants responsibility for. At present, the community in Dalmarnock wants to own a community centre. I have no pressure on me from the community to take control of the remediation of gas works or to put in sustainable urban drainage infrastructure or to put pipes under the ground to prevent flooding. That is seen as our job, and we are getting on with it. There is no reason why the assets that are created on the back of that cannot be taken forward through some form of community ownership, but that is a wider policy issue and it is not for me to specify what happens.
That response goes to the heart of the issue about what we mean by regeneration of an area. You talk about major infrastructure works being carried out by the URC. Should that work not be carried out by agencies other than the URC, such as local authorities and Scottish Water? I have some figures on the level of public funding that goes into the URCs. As with the Edinburgh schools situation, it sounds as though the money that has been going into URCs has been subsidising what should have been spent by other agencies to ensure the redevelopment of areas. It seems that there has been a transfer of resources from the agencies that should have provided those facilities and services, such as local authorities and Scottish Water.10:30
The starting point for creating URCs was to make things happen where things were not happening and to achieve targets and outcomes that were not being achieved otherwise. You can take one of two approaches to that: either you persuade every agency, every organisation and every private sector funder to change its own approach and priorities and to invest in what should happen in an area, or you create a dedicated body to achieve that aim one way or another. There is no doubt that the picture is mixed. For some schemes we have had to put the money on the table to lever in other public sector money, while in others we have been able to make the case to other public sector agencies and convince them to make the investment on their own. If it were as easy as saying to those agencies, “Come in and do what’s right in this area,” you would not need a dedicated body. We have to face up to the fact that we are dealing with public sector agencies that have other priorities and private sector companies that will not invest, and we need to ask how we dig into a spiral of decline that, in areas like mine, has been going on for 40 or 50 years now.In some cases, you might have said, “That organisation got help with that asset when it should have put its own money in”—I have certainly felt that many a time—but on the other hand you have to get things going and get an area that was not a priority for an organisation higher up the list. The best way of doing that is to put some finance on the table, match-fund and ensure that you get the result that you are looking for. That is what Clyde Gateway has done.
That last point brings me on to the issue of match funding. I thank the URCs for the evidence that they have provided for this session, but I have to say that, when I look at the investment that has been made in areas, I see very little private sector investment, and where there is any such investment—or indeed any such anticipated investment—it has been made predominantly in house building. I assume that the major objective of all URCs is the creation of sustainable employment, but in my experience private house building provides only relatively short-term employment opportunities for local individuals. How can we guarantee that the leverage of the public money that goes into URCs ensures sustainable employment opportunities for local residents in the areas that the URCs are supposed to be having an impact in?
Again, there are several ways of approaching the question. First, our two major housing schemes—as they might be badged—are in fact mixed development schemes. We make it very clear that we are not trying to create new housing estates and that we want a mixed development with a mixture of employment and housing opportunities. We are trying to change the housing market, but we are also looking at how we might tie in leisure opportunities such as the marina in Ardrossan and create more business space on the back of this enhanced environment. In short, these are not just housing schemes; we know that we need to look at a wider canvas than that.Secondly, you need to look at the span of things that we are doing. Some things are costly because they require repairs to infrastructure that was damaged in, for example, the industrial past. We are also trying to create a vibrant place. We want not only a varied and effective housing market that offers a range of choice but attractive town centres where people want to live and spend their money and business infrastructure where people can work and which others find attractive enough to invest money in.A lot of what we are trying to do is to put in place an environment or landscape that is attractive to investment, and these issues and our different types of intervention have to be seen in the round. We are trying to attack those different elements: a good place to live, a good place to visit, a good place to spend your leisure time and a good place to invest in and create your business. We are trying to create that entire package.
One of the initial prompts in this session was about why my organisation came into existence. When several large employers in the Clydebank business park left the area, we had to focus on the need for economic infrastructure. That has been our particular priority and, in response, we have developed the kind of office space—particularly small office space and small workshops—that investors and developers would not necessarily pick up because it is not necessarily financially attractive.From our early stages, we have had a successful workshop development, which has created successful employment for local residents as well as people coming into the area, and the same is true of our offices. However, as Patrick Wiggins mentioned, there is an element of sophistication to our economy, and regeneration needs to be multistranded, taking account of considerations such as housing. For example, Clydebank may be a comparatively cheaper place for people to reside than parts of Glasgow, which leads to wider economic benefits such as people paying council tax and shopping locally in addition to locally provided jobs.Likewise, one of our strategic objectives is to be better connected. We are a small town on the edge of a city region, and if we are not to provide solely a dormitory function there needs to be on-site economic activity. However, if we are better connected we can get people in and out of the city, which reinforces the local economy. Getting sustainable jobs that are available to local people is absolutely a priority, but it is one of many priorities for successful, sustainable long-term regeneration.
We have an example of a sustainable house-building industry. Much of the kit is now made off site and, in our area, we have 50 Clyde Gateway residents working in a housing manufacturing plant. That is a green job because it ensures that the highest environmental standards can be met; it is a warm and comfortable job compared with being on a site; and, as long as the company does well, it is a long-term, sustainable job. We can, therefore, provide an example that challenges the house-building example that Mr Wilson gave.We are engaged in sustainable employment opportunities. Some of the companies that have moved into our area work in the oil and gas industry, and we have six local people working in the Glacier Energy Services factory, making widgets and exporting them to oil and gas companies abroad. Manufacturing is on its way back into the east end of Glasgow.On the leverage issue, the history of the past 50 years tells us that the private sector will not invest in sites that are contaminated, that have been vacant for 50 years and that sometimes have health-threatening contamination in them. Without the public sector pump priming the investment and getting rid of the contamination, we will not get the private sector leverage. I am pleased to report that we have succeeded in getting private sector leverage on the first sites that we have decontaminated and made ready for development. Although the figure for our whole estate spread over 20 years is not yet up to scratch, if you look at it on a site-by-site basis you will see that the model of pump priming to attract private investment is working.
I am looking at some of the figures. In the opening paragraph of the Irvine Bay Regeneration Company’s written submission, which is part of the performance summary, we are told:“this in turn has secured an additional £37.3M in private and other public funds towards key projects”.A few pages on, however, we find out that the direct private sector leverage is just over £7.4 million—the rest is public sector funding. Given those figures, where is the private sector funding coming from? The written submission from Clydebank Rebuilt cites the figure of £65.4 million as “Indirect Public Funding”, whereas the indirect private sector funding is cited as £11 million. The private sector leverage figures do not seem to match the level of public funding.I take on board the need to clean up contaminated land. The health boards and other organisations used to build houses on contaminated land before they cleaned it up. Given the responsibility that has been placed on the URCs and the public sector to clean up the land and make it usable once again, it seems that a lot of public money is being invested—not only through the URC, but through other public agencies—in these communities, but I do not see the same return from the private sector. Will we be guaranteed the level of investment that we expect to get from the private sector?
I would like very brief answers, please, gentlemen.
Nothing in life is guaranteed. What you look at is what is in front of you. On the specific sites that we have remediated, where we have been able to attract developers and companies, the leverage is very high. Private funding is coming from institutional sources, such as Aviva, the BT pension fund and other sources, so it is possible to get such investment.However, to provide the background to your question it is appropriate to ask: where has any private money gone into any property development over the past few years? The achievements in the east end of Glasgow come against the tide. The situation is that market failure has gone as far even as city centres, so you have in front of you a hard-won achievement in very difficult circumstances. It is for the committee to judge whether this start means that, over the 20 years, £1.5 billion of private investment will come in. My judgment is that the land is available, the infrastructure has been put in, we are dealing with an area in the heart of Scotland’s biggest conurbation and we must help that particular community with the provision of future jobs and employment, so it will happen.
I mentioned that in all our areas we deal with very difficult sites, so there is a requirement for front loading, which will mean that there is a very high profile of public spending.I return to my comment about getting us to the start line. Increasingly, we are getting to the point at which we have sites that the private sector—be it developers or investors—will now consider; they are at the start line. We recognise that private investment is a competitive game. However, we now have sites that 10, 15 or 20 years ago would not have been capable of development for business to create jobs, housing and so on for local people or people from other parts of the world. We now have wares to sell, which was not the case prior to our interventions.
Pump-priming investment has to go in at the start of the process. We believe and are optimistic that returns will come. We are beginning to see an uplift in the level of inquiries that we get, particularly on the back of the enterprise area. If we can convert some of those inquiries into investment in jobs, the investment will arrive and returns will come, but it is a long-term process. We are dealing with deep-seated generational problems in areas where the decline has been going on for decades and we are trying to turn the situation round. We put in place the infrastructure, prepare the sites, prepare the land and put in place some of the business opportunities. We believe that we are putting our communities in the best possible position to take advantage of any economic upturn.
In the past three or four years, there has been very little private sector investment even in the centre of Edinburgh, which is clearly not in a regeneration area—only one commercial office block has been built on spec in central Edinburgh. To expect that there would have been private sector investment in a regeneration area such as Craigmillar would therefore be unreasonable, yet we are now reasonably able to expect that there will be private sector investment in retail developments in Craigmillar. As the economy in general improves, I therefore believe that the investment that has been put into the Craigmillar area will, over a number of years—it will take significantly longer than we originally envisaged—attract a significant level of private sector investment for the good of a sustainable community.
My question is for Mr Manson, Mr Robertson and Mr Wiggins. Your submission states that your business plan puts the emphasis on attracting private investment. What are you doing to keep the initial private sector jobs that you attract and to ensure that they last? My experience is that often such private sector jobs come and go. Are you doing anything to sustain them and retain them?
The private sector jobs that have come are good ones in oil and gas, and in construction. My judgment is that those are key sectors that will continue to grow, and I think that that is also Scotland’s judgment.The best thing that we can do to help and sustain companies is to ensure that, if they grow, we can make the business support, the land and the premises available for them to grow in the area. The history of the east end has been of successful companies that are looking to expand not being able to find an uncontaminated site or a suitable building and therefore moving out. Barr’s Irn-Bru is a classic example. For the first time, we are ensuring that land and sites are available for companies that want to expand and remain in the area. Business support is available from various other sources, but we do not supply that because we do not duplicate what is already provided successfully in the public sector.
When the tenants in our industrial and office properties first come in, and on an on-going basis, as a matter of course, we ensure that they are aware of the services of our partner agencies. That may be the business gateway service or the economic development team at West Dunbartonshire Council or, particularly for fast-growing companies, there may be support available from Scottish Enterprise with regard to account management. It is very much the case that we speak to them when they come in to reinforce that there may be a range of business support mechanisms, including support in taking on local people.10:45
A lot of the investment that we have received so far has been from good-quality local companies that have a long-standing relationship with the area and an on-going relationship with the communities and the people whom they employ, so we are confident that they will be there for the duration. We also work very closely with North Ayrshire Council and Scottish Enterprise to ensure that there is aftercare and that the business support mechanisms are in place.If one looks at the enterprise area and at the way in which the financial incentives are structured for that, one sees that they are very heavily geared towards the end user. For example, the capital allowances that are available in the enterprise area are for plant and machinery, not for buildings. The idea behind that is that people who invest very heavily in plant and machinery are much less likely to move away and to find a cheaper place to produce whatever it is they produce, because they have made a significant investment in plant and machinery in situ. That is much harder to shift so it should be longer term and more sustainable.
link
Good morning, gentlemen. I have a couple of questions. On page 4 of the joint submission, regarding Riverside Inverclyde, there is a reference to an MSP being an ambassador for the Ocean Youth Trust. For the record, I am that MSP.On page 8 of the submission, there is a reference to common targets that URCs would like to see considered. Can you provide the committee with any information on the common targets that you would like to see in place?
That comment came from the other URCs. I was not involved in writing that comment and I am not quite sure what my colleagues meant by it.
I will have to refresh myself on that point. We have common targets in as much as we all look at leverage, jobs and space regenerated and so on. There is some commonality in the types of KPIs that we have.I do not think that in that document we were suggesting that there should be anything over and above that commonality. We are all measured in pretty much the same way. We all respond through the monitoring and evaluation framework, which the Scottish Government provides every year. It is all tied into the Scottish Government’s core objectives and strategies for economy, health and wellbeing and so on. Everything that we do feeds back through that monitoring and evaluation framework.
link
I will read a small part of that paragraph. It states:“we would also welcome the introduction of a small number of common targets for URCs”.
We report on 34 different indicators through our management and evaluation report. It probably is the case that a smaller subset of that would be more usefully interpreted in respect of URCs. For example, in our submission we have pulled out four or five key indicators rather than the full 34, which tends to confuse matters a bit. There are a number of key indicators that we would all accept are appropriate.
Would you all measure yourselves against all 34?
We report on 34, but there are more—
There are 34 that you would report on to the Government.
There are more within the monitoring and evaluation framework, but we do not hit all the targets. The targets in the monitoring and evaluation framework cover a whole range of activities. We do not cover them all, but we report on 34—
I think there may be some confusion there.I call Mr Stevenson to speak very briefly.
I want to be clear about one point. KPIs are not targets and targets are not KPIs, are they?
They are not the same. Performance indicators show what progress is being made towards a target.
That is fine—the information was just presented in a way that suggested something else.
Mr Robertson can return to Mr McMillan’s question.
To be honest, Patrick Wiggins has covered the answer that I would have given.
I would welcome common definitions. Even GVA, which has been mentioned, can be calculated in a number of ways. If we are to compare leverage and the amount of land remediated across Scotland, we need to be much clearer about the common definitions.I would welcome the collective setting of targets for public sector agencies on key things that we are trying to achieve. In London, convergence targets have been set with the intention that the east end should reach the average figures across London on education, ill health and so on. That could be a way forward for Scotland. A URC on its own could not achieve such targets, but the full might of the public sector, working with the private sector, could. That would be a noble aim for us.
link
Phrases such as“dealing with the effects of decades of major deprivation and disadvantage”are littered throughout the joint submission, and we have heard variations on that comment today. Given that, have the expectations that have been placed on the URCs been too great?
You could probably go on for hours on that topic, gentlemen, but I ask for brief answers, please.
The expectations have been demanding, but they are not too great.
It is not just URCs that are resourced to address such problems; we must work in partnership. That is why we feel that community planning partnerships are critical, because they ensure that all the public agencies that work in an area focus on key deliverables to address the deep-seated problems of deprivation. That is not just for us on our own.
link
Is that the case for every URC?
I cannot speak for others, but I know that all the URCs routinely work in partnership with their local partners. They can say for themselves what form that takes.
There are no two ways about it—in the current environment, we are standard bearers for the regeneration of our area. It is undoubted that close connections with partner agencies are needed. It is important that we have ambitions and that we are demanding of ourselves and our partners, but external factors can kick in, such as an economic downturn. A subtlety concerns how organisations such as us are reviewed in a way that takes account of factors that we might not always have direct control over. However, the reality is that we are thrusting and demanding about getting a job done that has been left for many decades and needs to be completed.
First and foremost, Clyde Gateway is a partnership. We lead on the targets and ensure that they are addressed, but they cannot be achieved without major investment from Scottish Water, without the support of the two councils in the area and the utilities, and without support from the Scottish Environment Protection Agency on flood prevention and decontamination.This is a partnership. I spend about a third of my time on what could roughly be called maintaining and sustaining the partnership. Within the partnership is a body that has a board, resources and assets, and it can do some of the jobs itself. We have the right mixture.
link
Mr Manson spoke about remediation costs. It would be useful to hear how much each URC has invested to deal with that and to get to a position in which it can encourage investment.
I ask for very brief answers, gentlemen.
Every URC is different and faces a different set of issues. The defining issue in the east end of Glasgow and in Shawfield in South Lanarkshire is ground conditions, so the bulk of our public funding has gone into bringing sites up to a state from which they can be developed. About £70 million or £80 million has gone under the ground to fix the problems of the past. Without that, nothing would have happened.
It would be useful to have the specifics in writing to the clerks.
I am unable to give you a specific figure. However, for our primary site—Queen’s Quay—the decontamination, site preparation and major civil engineering cost about £8.5 million out of a total redevelopment cost of £60 million. That proportion is often reflected in our other locations.
Again, it would be good if you could get details to the clerks.
Our decontamination costs are less because we have avoided some of the worst contaminated areas in our patch. The costs tend to be quite light, so a lot of our expenditure is on site assembly and infrastructure to open up the sites.
I do not think that any of this applies to Mr Adair to any huge extent, does it?
No, it does not. For example, we have probably spent only £5.6 million on site infrastructure, although that does not include costs incurred by the City of Edinburgh Council for site clearances.
Okay. It would be useful to get the detail to the clerks.You have said that you talk to one another. Do you benchmark against one another? In what you do, do you see yourselves as allies or as rivals? Please give very brief answers.
Comparisons between the URCs are useful because of the history of the areas. However, they are very different, so detailed benchmarking does not take place. I benchmarked against the urban development companies and corporations in England, but most of those have now been abolished in one way or another. However, in the east of London, significant onward investment is going on and I compare us very closely with that. The level of investment that is going into the east of London is astonishing. For example, post-Olympic games alone, £0.5 billion has been invested in continuing the legacy. So, I benchmark against that and I aspire to that.
I can understand that, but surely you have near neighbours and could benchmark against what they do.
As has been mentioned, local circumstances can be such that it might be difficult to undertake direct comparisons for benchmarking. On whether we are friends or rivals, it is fair to say that we are all part of the regeneration movement, so without speaking on behalf of my colleagues, I would suggest that we are friends.
We are definitely allies, not rivals. We learn a lot from one another, quite often about ways of delivering. There are significant differences between the URCs in terms of population, geography, types of land issues and depths of market failure, but we can learn from one another’s practices. We do that by officers from the different organisations having regular contact.
I agree with the previous comments, particularly those from Patrick Wiggins.
Okay. Thank you very much for your time, gentlemen. I suspend the meeting for a few minutes for a change of witnesses.10:58 Meeting suspended.
11:05 On resuming—
We now have our second panel of witnesses. I welcome Allan McQuade, business infrastructure director of Scottish Enterprise, and Douglas Duff, member of the Scottish local authorities economic development group and head of economic development and environmental services at Falkirk Council. Does either of you gentlemen want to make a brief opening statement?
I do not.
If you do not mind, convener, I will give a brief opening statement to explain a bit about SLAED and my purpose in coming along to this meeting. The SLAED acronym refers to the representative body for local authority economic development officers, which brings together officers from across the country whose aim is to help develop the economic development services that we all offer through our councils. We do that in addition to our day jobs—we all have an active involvement in economic development and regeneration across the country. We try to muster support to develop that jointly through the activities of SLAED.SLAED has a number of sub-groups, including one on regeneration. We also work on business support, employability, tourism and so on to try to galvanise the activity that is taking place. SLAED has gone through considerable changes in recent years, particularly as a consequence of the decision to transfer responsibility for business gateways and regeneration to councils. We have focused particularly on how we develop the organisation, bringing forward work with the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities and the Improvement Service on an improvement guide for the development of economic development services and the development of an outcomes framework, which is being shared across the country and which will give a common means of reporting on our activities.SLAED is very much starting to galvanise its activities. That has been recognised and welcomed by the different partners with which we work, most recently in the development of our local economic development partnership forum that is jointly chaired by the Minister for Energy, Enterprise and Tourism and the portfolio holder at COSLA. We see that as a valuable way forward to help integrate the local and national agendas that we deal with.I am involved quite heavily with SLAED, but I also have a day job with Falkirk Council. My responsibilities relate to economic development and environmental services. We have a strong track record in the field of regeneration, most recently in bringing forward quite a significant tax increment financing—TIF—initiative, with which some of the committee might be familiar. It involves quite a substantial commitment by the council to investing in the area and hoping to attract significant investment from the private sector. That is an important flagship initiative that we believe is for not just Falkirk, but the country as a whole.We have also been working in our town centres. We have been working to develop Falkirk town centre and four district-level centres. We have also been delivering the project that is known as the Helix, which is a national living landmark project and one of three across the United Kingdom. We believe that it signifies the transformation that is possible in an area such as ours. There is quite a lot going on, and we are certainly keen on, and actively interested in, regeneration.
Thank you, Mr Duff. I will start by asking you a few questions about economic development activity. Committee members have visited various places at different points and we know that some councils choose to invest quite heavily in economic development activity but that some do quite a lot less. Given your national experience, can you give us an indication of how much of the economic activity that is taking place in the 32 local authorities is looking at regeneration, particularly community regeneration?
SLAED has done work recently to estimate councils’ total commitment to economic development activity, which works out at about £213 million annually and is recognised as a significant contribution. I do not have details of the breakdown across the various fields of activity but I could certainly ask for that. The total amount covers our activities in respect of physical regeneration, employability and business support.
It would be useful for the committee to have that information. We all have a certain amount of experience of economic development activity in our areas, and we know that activity can be extremely varied. It would be grand to get an indication of how much effort is put into regeneration.Mr McQuade, how much of Scottish Enterprise’s expenditure goes on regeneration activity? Can you give an idea of the proportion of that spending that goes on community and social regeneration?
As you know, our primary focus is on increasing Scotland’s economic prosperity. We moved away from local regeneration in 2008, when the approach to enterprise companies changed, and in 2012 we moved away from funding urban regeneration companies.Our primary focus is on economic growth, but that is not to say that we have abandoned regeneration. We are still involved in such activity, through our work with the urban regeneration companies and a number of other initiatives. There are the national initiatives of Clyde waterfront and Dundee waterfront, and other initiatives include work to bring economic activity to Hunterston, in North Ayrshire. We are still involved with Ravenscraig and Gartcosh, and in West Dunbartonshire we are involved with Strathleven Regeneration Community Interest Company. In Aberdeen city and Aberdeenshire we are involved with Energetica—
May I stop you there? You said that you have moved away from regeneration to a degree and are concentrating on economic growth, but you have listed a number of regeneration projects in which you are involved. It seems that Scottish Enterprise has not stepped away from regeneration.
We have absolutely stepped away from local regeneration in relation to councils’ responsibilities. We are still working through legacy issues, such as at Ravenscraig and Gartcosh, and we are involved in regeneration to the extent that we bring expertise from a national perspective, for example in relation to the closure of Diageo in Kilmarnock and Rolls-Royce’s move from East Kilbride—I am on the East Kilbride task force.We are involved, but we are not directly involved. Our investment is limited—I do not have a figure that I can give you, but it is not substantial—apart from our commitment to Dundee waterfront, on which I can provide figures to the committee.We are involved in supporting regeneration in the context of our work with companies and our sector growth activity, on which we are very focused. Companies get support through regional selective assistance via Scottish Enterprise, and the regional selective assistance map is drawn with a view to supporting areas in most need. Through our support to companies we therefore indirectly help areas in need to regenerate.Some of our major sector initiatives are in areas that are adjacent to areas of need. For example, the bioquarter in Edinburgh is a life sciences project and is adjacent to areas of need in the city; a renewables infrastructure plan, which is following the Government’s offshore wind agenda, supports development in Ayrshire; and in the creative industries, Pacific Quay is being developed along the Clyde in Glasgow, next to Govan. Our activities help with regeneration, by providing and growing employment that can be taken up by people in areas of need.11:15
I find it interesting that you said that you have moved away from regeneration, but at the same time you listed all those projects, which are either adjacent to or in regeneration areas, and you said that there are monetary commitments to regeneration projects such as the Dundee waterfront. Maybe it would be a good idea if you sent us some detail on the framework that you work to in this regard.
By way of clarification, I say that our primary focus is on creating economic growth. The proportion of Scottish Enterprise’s overall budget that is allocated to the areas that we are discussing is small. Many of the projects are partnership projects and we bring our expertise to assist with their development.
However, the aim in certain areas is to grow the economy through regeneration projects such as the Dundee waterfront.
That is one. Yes.
I think that we require further clarification. It would be good to get an indication of how much money is being spent on some of the projects in regeneration areas.
I am happy to provide that.
I have a question specifically for Scottish Enterprise, although Mr Duff might wish to say something on it as well. My constituency crosses the boundary between the areas of Highlands and Islands Enterprise and Scottish Enterprise. HIE has a social aspect to its remit and, in the long run, we can see the effects of its efforts in generation, perhaps, rather than regeneration, because there was nothing there to start with. Does HIE have some advantages in the area because of its different remit?
That is an interesting question. Before I joined Scottish Enterprise, I worked at HIE. It has different challenges in that it is charged to unlock things under its communities remit. I think that it would be unfair for me to comment on that, because Scottish Enterprise has a remit and is working to it, as does HIE. There are many challenges in rural areas of Scotland and we could look at them and say that they are similar, but I think that it would be unreasonable for me to comment or speculate beyond that.
I will develop the rural issue. Of the mainland council areas, Aberdeenshire is the one with the greatest proportion of its population living in a rural area—the proportion is 2 per cent higher than in Highland. There are substantial rural areas within Scottish Enterprise’s remit, including elsewhere in Scotland, such as in the south in particular. Given that the social aspect is outside Scottish Enterprise’s brief but is included in HIE’s brief, in the partnerships and relationships that you have with others, do you see that part of HIE’s remit being discharged by others?I understand that you work to your remit, and that is a fair comment, but do you see the social part of the remit, which is fundamental to what the committee is looking at in its work on regeneration, being picked up by others, or do you see things that we should consider as a committee and mention in our output from our deliberations?
Again, I do not have enough experience of rural areas to be able to comment on that. Scottish Enterprise has strategies to support the economic growth of our rural areas but, as we have discussed, it is not within our remit to become involved in the communities remit that HIE has.In HIE, there can be overlap and grey areas between what is community development and what is economic development. Scottish Enterprise has a clear economic development remit and we ask whether something fits with our priorities and whether the scale is relevant in terms of the level of investment for a rural area.
Forgive me, and let me have one final shot at this. As an individual, you are perhaps in a unique position to be able to help the committee because you have been in both HIE and Scottish Enterprise.I am really trying to see, based on your personal experience, as distinct from your current role—and I understand the distinction—whether other bodies with which Scottish Enterprise works pick up that responsibility, which in HIE is inside that enterprise agency. If your experience tells us that there are limitations and difficulties there, then I think that this committee should go away and do other things.
I do not see limitations, but I would qualify that by saying that most of my focus is on the urban areas of Scotland, so I do not see that on a day-to-day basis.
That is good enough, thank you.
My question is for Mr McQuade. What role do you believe you play in the community planning process?
We are a fully engaged partner. We are involved in all the community planning partnerships through senior officers at Scottish Enterprise who are representatives to each of the organisations. As part of that responsibility we have a senior officer within Scottish Enterprise as a location director, a role parallel to that which the Government has, with each of the local authorities.I observe that community planning partnerships, like all partnerships, work differently and that our engagement with some is different from our engagement with others. We are absolutely fully committed to community planning partnerships.
You say that your engagement with some is different from that with others. Does that mean that some of the engagement is good and some not so good? Where does the difficulty lie? Does it lie with the individual community planning partnerships or is it perhaps the case that you do not have the right personnel engaging with the community planning partnership?
I will answer from my experience. I have responsibility for three local authorities and it depends on the focus of the community planning partnership how they engage and what the priorities are in a specific area.
You say “how they engage”. Surely you, as a member of a community planning partnership, have some say in the direction of that community planning partnership.
We do.
You have said that your focus is on economic growth. I imagine that most community planning partnerships have similar goals in their single outcome agreements.
Yes.
Could you maybe expand on where the difficulties lie?
I am not highlighting difficulties. I am flagging the fact that relationships across partnerships can be different and that in some they are better than others.
For what reasons? What makes a good relationship compared with a bad relationship?
You are referring again to good and bad. I am not. I am saying that some relationships are stronger than others.
What makes a strong relationship, compared with a weak one?
There is potentially a stronger relationship where one has worked with a colleague over a number of years compared with becoming involved more recently in a partnership. It takes time to build relationships.
We may come back to that point.
My next question is for Mr Duff. During the committee’s visits to communities, community groups often told us about the difficulty of trying to access resources because access is overly bureaucratic and the funds are available only for a certain time. Is that your view? How would you go about rectifying it?
Circumstances have certainly been very challenging. There has been quite significant pressure on budgets across the board and there has been pressure in areas that have focused on community support. A lot of that comes down to demonstrating the evidence of the benefits of community engagement and, having seen some of the committee’s work, I know that you have seen some good examples of proposals for community projects that have justified their call on resources.Coming back to community planning partnerships, I think that we must ensure that community engagement is a fundamental part of their role and should be resourced properly. As you will have seen in the evidence that you have received, some partnerships have put quite significant resources into that and have helped communities to access those resources; however, the situation is a bit patchier in other areas. That issue must be addressed. The fact is that where community bodies are properly resourced and the people involved are clear about their purpose and the benefits that can come from the process, the approach to regeneration can be solidified and enhanced.
The message is to keep it simple.
Certainly. The whole field has been through significant change and, in fact, is going through further change as certain budget prospects come to fruition. With the further reductions that we expect in council budgets over the next three to five years, every pound will be a prisoner. As a result, community engagement must be viewed as a priority in the range of activities that we are undertaking and how it takes place and plays its part in meeting the other pressures that we face must be made clear and simple.
How many of your members are involved in community planning partnerships in the 32 areas, either at board level or just below?
Economic development is a priority in every council’s community plan. That is clear and understood and you will see it embedded in all community plans and SOAs. However, our involvement or not in the various partnerships comes down to the priority that the issue is afforded within the range of other pressures that community planning partnerships are dealing with. In some council areas, where the economy is relatively sound and robust, it is perhaps not as much of a priority and there is less of a resource input. However, in the vast majority of council areas, economic development is certainly viewed as a priority and economic development officers are pretty regular attendees at CPP meetings and are expected to account for the actions in their SOAs and their commitments in the community plan.We are strong participants in the community planning process. I would say that some play an active role in shaping and maintaining the community planning process; it is certainly a fundamental plank of the work.
I wonder whether you can give us an indication of your position in Falkirk. Are you on the board of the Falkirk community planning partnership?
No, but over the year I or someone covering our economic remit will attend perhaps half of the CPP’s leadership group meetings; for example, regular reports are sought on our work on the my future’s in Falkirk economic strategy. Given our community planning partnership’s very strong focus on employability and the fact that helping young people into the labour market is seen as a priority, such issues are frequently aired and discussed, with not only the council but other partners reporting on how they support that work.
Where does your engagement with communities fit in with the community planning partnership?
Engagement with communities tends to come through the particular activities that we have under way, whether that is our work in town centres, or the Helix project that I mentioned earlier. That came through an active community engagement process. It tends to be horses for courses. Community engagement is only one aspect of what we do in economic development, because we have a range of other responsibilities. We also connect with the wider community engagement process that the community planning partnership sustains. The CPP has an on-going relationship with the community and community representatives are involved in that partnership. Our economic work in community engagement tends to be more issue specific, be that town centres, employability and so on.11:30
A lot of work is being done in Falkirk and Grangemouth town centres and particularly in Denny town centre. I know those areas well. You engage mainly with the business community in that work. How do you engage with communities? The committee has been trying to get to a definition of communities that refers to the people who live in deprived or low-income communities, because we need to engage them in discussions and decisions on economic development issues. How do you do that in Falkirk?
In Falkirk Council, we use a range of tools in our community engagement activities, particularly in town centres. Our work is not just about engaging with the business community, although we engage actively with it. For example, we have a business panel, and any business in Falkirk is entitled to be part of that.
My question was about engaging with communities, not business communities. I know what work is taking place with the business community in Falkirk. However, I am trying to understand how we engage with the residents around the town centres and with those in other communities that are struggling economically. How do we get them involved in decision-making processes, which in your case are those of Falkirk Council? You referred to engagement officers; are they linked to your economic development unit? If they are linked to another council department, how do you make links with them when you try to engage with, say, those who live in the communities around Denny town centre and who are concerned about town centre issues?
We have officers who are responsible for engaging with the community. They are actively involved in working with communities in each of the town centres. In the past, we have conducted community surveys and held events when a proposal or scheme is being put to the community. We arrange events and involve people in shaping proposals.We encourage input on proposals through individual groups, which include schools. We have active involvement with local primary and secondary schools on plans as they develop. We also work with each of the community councils and keep in regular contact with them about proposals that are coming forward. Our officers are out attending community council meetings regularly and they feed in notes that give an update on what is happening.We can also engage with specific interest groups, whether they be groups of retailers, older people or young people who are bringing forward projects. For example, we have been developing a townscape heritage initiative in Falkirk town centre, which is one of the largest initiatives to have been approved in Scotland. That has been built on very active community involvement through the heritage bodies, the local historical society, the churches and the schools.That strong and active community engagement has produced the first project, which is in the churchyard in the very centre of the town. That is being showcased as an example of best practice on how to involve a community in shaping a design.We build community benefits into projects. We have a community benefits and procurement policy that is applied to any capital investment that is undertaken, so such things are built into the delivery of projects that are under way. We have robust arrangements for community engagement in the development of our projects. That is warts and all—in some circumstances, people are unhappy or unsettled about the proposals that we put to them, and we have to acknowledge and act on the community’s wider concerns.
I welcome your enthusiasm for the community engagement that you have in Falkirk. Is that community engagement replicated throughout the 31 other local authorities? Are all economic development units as high profile in their local authorities as you have said that yours is in Falkirk?
In this meeting
Everything on 25 Sep 2013 →- 09:30 Interests Procedure · 2
- 09:30 Decisions on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 2
- 09:30 Regeneration Committee business · 333
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.