To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01832)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Johann Lamont Lab 7
- Alex Salmond SNP 5
- Tricia Marwick 5
- John Swinney SNP 1
The record
18 contributionsEngagements to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
We have just voted on a budget of scarce resources. Every pound and every penny should be accounted for and explained. The First Minister’s trip to the Ryder cup cost in excess of £468,000. VisitScotland has accounted for how it spent £414,000 of the total figure but, despite a series of freedom of information requests and missed deadlines, the Scottish Government has failed to account for £54,000 of that total. Will the First Minister please account for that spending now?
Johann Lamont has partially answered her own question. The Scottish Government spend was not £460,000 but £50,000. The freedom of information request will be answered as soon as possible. [Interruption.] It will and why should it not be? In my mind, the spending on the trip to Chicago was about the investment decisions that have brought jobs to Scotland, the variety of activities that promoted our country and the huge importance of the estimated £100 million benefit from having the Ryder cup in our country—all that justifies our substantial effort to promote this country.
As we go into this year of the Commonwealth games, homecoming and the Ryder cup—as the attention of the world is centred on Scotland—can we not just agree that it is the duty and obligation of the Scottish Government and every public authority to maximise the benefit from those events?
The Scottish Government has spent £1 million of taxpayers’ cash on a record 14 special advisers and still the First Minister cannot come up with an answer to a simple question.
My mother used to say that every penny should be a prisoner because it came from the sweat of your father’s brow. The First Minister should be as cautious with public spending and the public purse. It is entirely reasonable to ask what has happened to that £54,000. VisitScotland has admitted to spending almost £1,000 on a pianist, more than £1,100 on flying in chefs from Gleneagles and more than £1,700 on ties.
It has been reported that the First Minister chose not to stay in the hotel where the rest of the delegation stayed, but in the more exclusive Peninsula hotel, further away from the course. Suites at that hotel cost more than $2,000 a night. Will the First Minister confirm that he stayed in that hotel, explain why he wanted to stay in a more upmarket hotel than the rest of the delegation and what that cost?
From memory, 17 people were in the Scottish Government delegation, including a range of officials from Scottish Enterprise and the Scottish Government’s industry department. I correct Johann Lamont: the visit was not just about the two days of the Ryder cup; rather, it stretched over the range of events in Chicago to attract investment to Scotland. The investment to Scotland that was announced on that trip was worth tens of millions of pounds and brought jobs to many areas of Scotland.
On special advisers, Johann Lamont mentioned the figure of £1 million. Our spending record on special advisers is incomparably better than that of the previous Labour-Liberal Administration. From memory—I am open to correction—the number of special advisers for the whole of the Scottish Government is also, I think, less than the number of individual special advisers to the Deputy Prime Minister.
The figure of £1 million sticks in my memory because I think that that was the expenditure by Jack McConnell’s Administration during Scotland week. That spending could well have been justified. However, it is so interesting that we have managed to bring as many jobs by rightfully promoting Scotland in the United States without ever hitting that £1 million figure, spent by an Administration of which Johann Lamont was a minister.
Why do we not focus on how we promote this country, get the advantage of promoting Scotland on the world stage, embrace 2014 as a great year for Scotland and say that that promotion—whether it is by VisitScotland or the Scottish Government—is of immense value in bringing jobs and livelihoods to the people of Scotland? [Applause.]
Order.
It is possible to do all that this year and answer simple questions about the money that the First Minister has spent.
I have to say that that answer plumbs the depths in finding anything to talk about except a simple question about a hotel bill. That £54,000 is more than twice what the average person earns in a year, but the First Minister cannot account for how he spent that much money in just a week.
When The Daily Telegraph asked the Scottish Government to account—[Interruption.]
Order. [Interruption.] Mr Wheelhouse—order!
I am not sure whether we have quite got to the point of journalists not being allowed to ask questions but, if we have, we are in a very serious place.
When The Daily Telegraph asked the Scottish Government to account for the whole half a million pounds spent on the Ryder cup, the Government said at first that it could not. Then it said that it could. Then VisitScotland accounted for what it spent. Then the Government told The Daily Telegraph that it would give details on 10 January. Now, two weeks after that deadline and two months after VisitScotland responded, the First Minister still cannot give an answer. I ask him again: how did he spend his cut of the half a million pounds spent on a trip to the golf? [Interruption.]
Order.
And Johann Lamont talked about plumbing the depths. I know that The Daily Telegraph is becoming the house journal of the Labour Party in Scotland, but—
For the third time, let us correct a few things. On the half a million pounds thing, it is obviously not the case because, as Johann Lamont rightly says, VisitScotland did not admit but spelled out what it had spent on promoting Scotland. The promotion of Scotland at the Ryder cup was an important aspect of what we have to do to realise the estimated £100 million of benefit.
In terms of defending VisitScotland, one aspect of what was done was that, at the Ryder cup, a film promoting Scotland as a tourist destination was shown to a live television audience of many hundreds of millions. Johann Lamont should consider what would have happened if VisitScotland had had to buy that sort of publicity.
When it comes to the Scottish Government spend, I have also pointed out that it ain’t me who spent it, but 17 people in the Scottish Government delegation.
A range of investments, generating jobs and investment, was announced while we were in Chicago. Incidentally, that is one of the reasons why foreign direct investment—FDI—projects into Scotland are up 49 per cent in the most recent figures, just as the better together campaign was predicting a collapse.
Why do we not keep our eye on how we can promote our country and celebrate the opportunities that we have this year and how many jobs we can generate for the people of Scotland?
As I have put the emphasis on jobs and employment, perhaps for once in First Minister’s questions—though perhaps not in light of the job figures yesterday—Johann Lamont will get round to asking me about the economy, unemployment and generating jobs for the people of Scotland. [Applause.]
Order.
I welcome the unemployment figures—I genuinely do. I just want an explanation of the figures that I have given and of how the Government spent £54,000. The First Minister has still not explained it.
The First Minister talks about VisitScotland. It has done its job: it has explained how it spent its money. We ask him to follow its example. We know that he went to extraordinary lengths to stop the public finding out that he spent £250 of their money on a pair of Chinese checked trousers when he forgot his tartan trews, but this is more serious.
What do we know? We know that the First Minister spent half a million pounds on a trip to the Ryder cup and that he reportedly upgraded himself—at our expense—to stay in a hotel that is frequented by Beyoncé, Brad Pitt and Justin Bieber.
This is First Minister’s question time.
This is the question.
For those who do not know the Peninsula Chicago, it is
“for those who love to spoil themselves with a luxurious five-star experience, without losing that comfortable home-away-from-home feel.”
The First Minister has to explain how he spent the money. He should understand that, in the real world, the people of Scotland will be disgusted at how he treats himself at their expense. Will he now at least have the decency to explain to them how he spent, in just one week, the £54,000 of taxpayers’ money that he still has not accounted for?
There were—if my memory serves me—17 people in the Scottish Government delegation. The expenditure of £50,000 was on that delegation—flights and accommodation for 17 people.
This is an improvement, because the last time Johann Lamont mentioned the issue, she had me spending the entire £500,000, so I should be eternally grateful that we have now boiled that down to £50,000. I ask her to go one step further and to accept that there were 17 people in the Scottish Government delegation. More important, I ask her to accept that key announcements were made for jobs across Scotland, that key promotion was carried out for many Scottish companies—including the oil and gas round-table discussion, which has also resulted in jobs coming to Scotland—and that there was great promotion of our country. I am talking not just about the Scottish Government’s efforts over that week, but VisitScotland’s efforts at the Ryder cup itself. I was proud to note on the television coverage that the saltire flew so prominently at the Ryder cup in Chicago. That is an essential part of preparing for the great success that we are going to have at Gleneagles.
I am proud of the work that VisitScotland does in increasing tourism, the results of which we are now seeing, and I am proud of the work that Scottish Development International does in bringing jobs to Scotland. That is one of the reasons why we have had a record increase in employment in Scotland and why unemployment in Scotland is 6.4 per cent. This Government is in office because we focus on the things that matter to the people of Scotland—that is, jobs and growth—not the ridiculous frippery that we get from Johann Lamont. [Interruption.]
Order.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 23 Jan 2014 →- Widening Access to Further and Higher Education Questions · 4
- East Ayrshire Council (Learning and Teaching) Questions · 4
- Defibrillators Questions · 6
- Traffic Wardens Questions · 8
- Scottish Welfare Fund Questions · 4
- Chemical Restraints (Care Homes) Questions · 4
- South Scotland Bus Routes Questions · 4
- Help to Buy (Scotland) Scheme (Islands) Questions · 5
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 18
- Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Renewable Energy (Pentland Firth) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Community Land Purchases First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Economic Strategy (Inequality) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Airlines Discriminating Against Disabled People Members’ business · 17
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.