Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Regeneration

Wednesday 11 September 2013 Local Government and Regeneration Committee About 09:30 Committee business 341 contributions · 24 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

341 contributions · showing 1–200
Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Good morning, and welcome to the 23rd meeting in 2013 of the Local Government and Regeneration Committee. I ask everyone to ensure that all mobile phones and other electronic devices are switched off.This is our colleague Margaret Mitchell’s last meeting before she moves to her new role on the Justice Committee. I am sure that we all hope that she enjoys it. On the committee’s behalf, I thank Margaret for all her efforts—her input has been appreciated by most members, most of the time. Laughter. I realise that she takes the job of scrutiny to heart and is very assiduous in that regard.You will be a real loss to this committee, but we wish you all the best in your new role.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Item 1 is evidence on regeneration. We have three panels of witnesses representing local authorities and the enterprise agencies. They have submitted written evidence, which members have in their papers.I welcome the first panel. Councillor Mairi Evans is convener of the infrastructure committee and Alan McKeown is strategic director for communities at Angus Council. Councillor Chris Thompson is chair of the enterprise services committee and Jim McCaffer is head of regeneration services at South Lanarkshire Council. Councillor Lawrence O’Neill is vice-convener of the housing, environment and economic development committee and Jim McAloon is head of regeneration and economic development at West Dunbartonshire Council.Do any of you have brief opening statements?

Councillor Lawrence O’Neill West Dunbartonshire Council
link

I apologise on behalf of West Dunbartonshire Council because our convener is, unfortunately, unable to attend due to there being a committee meeting this afternoon; we hope that it will have a positive regeneration outcome for West Dunbartonshire.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Very good. You are welcome, Councillor O’Neill.

Councillor O’Neill
link

Thank you.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

I will ask the first question. Can you give us an idea of the size of funding for, specifically, regeneration activity? Beyond that, can you indicate what proportion of those moneys is used for community organisations and community-led regeneration? Councillor O’Neill—do you want to start?

Councillor O’Neill
link

In West Dunbartonshire we have been setting the budget over the past year or so, and we have now embarked on a 10-year capital regeneration investment that is worth somewhere in the region of £133 million. We are building new care homes and schools, and are investing £85 million in housing to meet the Scottish housing quality standards. There has been quite a turnaround in the region. Under the previous council administration, we were potentially going for a partial stock transfer, but under the new administration, from May 2012, we changed that course. The officers have now come round to that, and will be delivering fully to the Scottish housing quality standards in spending £85 million on 10,000 or so houses. We have also embarked on building two new care homes with provision for, I think, 90 beds each.We will take on board suggestions from the community in particular about how we can move forward. A lot of our budgeting work, certainly for the capital programmes, has involved asking communities what they would like. We will continue to involve them throughout the process.A lot of money has been put aside, which often worries me with regard to budgets. We have many challenges in West Dunbartonshire, such as the fact that Clydebank is an old industrial town, the question how to make West Dunbartonshire attractive to regeneration and the question how we can provide an infrastructure that helps regeneration to progress in our communities.Like most authorities, we face massive challenges with unemployment—in particular, youth unemployment. We have set aside £2.83 million from the council’s resources and we are working alongside the Department for Work and Pensions and Skills Development Scotland. We set the ambition of bringing in 1,000 jobs in 1,000 days in administration and are way ahead of what we had hoped to achieve—we are at 66 per cent of our target.We face many challenges and we are putting in a huge amount of money. As one of the council tax payers of West Dunbartonshire, that does not quite give me sleepless nights, although it might. We are heading in the right direction.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Feel free to bring in Mr McAloon to answer my next questions. What is the “huge amount of money” that has been allocated to regeneration? I reiterate that I would really like to know what proportion of that money is going into community projects and community-led regeneration.

Jim McAloon West Dunbartonshire Council
link

I would be happy to provide the committee with the overall figure. I endorse what Councillor O’Neill said. Through the community planning partnership, the council has listened to the community. For example, we recently ring fenced money for a social enterprise challenge fund. That provides an opportunity to encourage communities to set up enterprises to support themselves.This year, we are looking to support three social enterprises, and the nine applicants will be assessed later this week. Each successful start-up enterprise will be supported with £15,000 in its first year, and will have business gateway support. There will also be support through the money that we have set aside for employing people, which Councillor O’Neill mentioned and which is additional to Scottish Enterprise and Skills Development Scotland support. That £2.83 million has been supplemented by a further £300,000 from the council.Councillor O’Neill mentioned that we are at 66 per cent of the target to achieve 1,000 jobs in 1,000 days. The council has made a fantastic effort on its own; we have taken on more than 175 modern apprentices this year alone, and 100 per cent of those youngsters have gained jobs at the end, through the council.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

The committee is really interested in getting the detail on the specific budgets and the proportions. It would be useful if those figures could be sent to us.

Councillor Chris Thompson South Lanarkshire Council
link

Our figure for regeneration funding is £9 million. That must be looked at in the wider context. We see regeneration as an integral part of the work that we do. The decisions that we make on housing, schools, purchasing through the council and employability are all linked. That involves working together with our partners through the community planning partnership.We have regeneration areas in not only built-up areas, but rural areas. Like our colleagues, we face some very testing issues. We made significant progress up to 2009-10, but that will—unfortunately—slip back because of the changes that the United Kingdom Government has made. There are mismatches between the UK Government’s policies and what some of the rest of us are trying to do. Those mismatches include the work programme—which, to be frank with you, is of no use in a regeneration area—and, of course, changes to benefits, which again affect regeneration areas very dramatically. If you do not mind, convener, I will ask Jim McCaffer to give more details in a few minutes.

Councillor Thompson
link

Clyde Gateway is an urban regeneration company of which I am a founder member. We are working with that organisation in what is one of the most deprived areas of South Lanarkshire and Glasgow, with highly contaminated land and some of the worst figures in the country for long-term unemployment, poor education standards and so on. Those are the sorts of things that we see.We in South Lanarkshire have a regeneration strategy that goes back a very long time and we have a poverty strategy that also goes back a considerable time. There are no quick fixes for such situations. If we want to regenerate such areas—I think that we all do—we have to be in it for the long term, which means consistent investment over 20 to 25 years. Regeneration is about changing the economic situation for many people who live in the area, and it is not just about putting up buildings and decontaminating land, but about changing lives; it is about getting people back to work, getting them economically active and improving their health, their education and their ambitions. That is a big, big ask, but if we continue to invest, I think that in years to come, whoever is sitting at this table then will see that that investment was very worth while.Regeneration is a central part of the council’s policy. It is supported by all the political parties in the council and by the independent councillors. We all have the same view: we need to tackle the worst areas, we need to invest in them over a long period, we need to measure how we are getting on, and we need to work with the Government and other agencies to ensure that money goes where it is most needed.

Jim McCaffer South Lanarkshire Council
link

Councillor Thompson mentioned the £9 million of support that the council gives to regeneration activity in South Lanarkshire. As other authorities will testify, that money is then used to lever in money—from Europe, from the Scottish Government, from the Big Lottery Fund and from other sources.We spend about £9 million per annum on employability programmes. My West Dunbartonshire Council colleagues mentioned the outcomes in relation to West Dunbartonshire. We try to support about 5,000 people per year through those programmes. We also spend about £1 million on business support programmes.Councillor Thompson mentioned poverty: we have a specific tackling poverty fund of about £5 million that helps health improvement programmes, family support programmes and employability programmes. Through the LEADER programme we spend about £500,000 a year in our rural area. We also support the Clyde Gateway initiative directly with funds of just under £1 million per annum and we spend about £5 million per annum on capital works.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Do you have at your fingertips the proportion of that money that is spent on community-led projects?

Jim McCaffer South Lanarkshire Council
link

I do not. Clearly the LEADER programme, which is about rural development, Is very much about bottom-up, grass-roots initiatives, so all of those resources would be included, as well as the bulk of the tackling poverty funds that involve working with local communities. All of that £5 million budget is linked closely to community needs.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Further detail on that would be extremely useful for the committee during the course of its deliberations.

Councillor Thompson
link

May I come back in on that point?

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Do so very briefly, Mr Thompson, please.

Councillor Thompson
link

To add to what Jim McCaffer said, we have a community planning partnership board that the community sits on with our partners. We fully involve the community in decisions that are made and recommended to the community planning partnership.We recently started new initiatives in the worst 5 per cent of areas in order to ensure that we are building the capacity of those communities to make their contributions. The difficulty for us is that in many of those areas it can be very difficult for people to get involved as volunteers, so we are, with our partners, spending a lot of time in those areas building that capacity to contribute, to be involved in decisions and to make a real difference to what we are doing. That work is on-going. I am sure that Jim McCaffer will be glad to supply information to you, as well.09:45

Councillor Mairi Evans Angus Council
link

To be honest, I find it quite hard to quantify the amount. We probably have a similar capital spend to other authorities of similar size, but it is hard to put a figure on how much we spend on regeneration, including the whole social aspect, because the money is, obviously, divided among various projects across social work and education, especially when we take into account work such as early years intervention, if we are discussing regeneration in its broadest context.We do a lot of our work through the community planning partnerships. We have a community grants scheme, which helps community groups with various activities. The scheme probably has a budget of about £160,000. We work well with community groups, particularly in the area that I am from, which is Brechin, where we have a very strong group.There is a lot of community planning and community activity, but rather than such groups seeking money from the council or our allocating a budget to help them, our approach is to try to help them to access money elsewhere, if you see what I mean, for all their different activities. In that way, they are trying to plan for what Brechin’s future will look like 10 or 20 years down the line. We just help to facilitate the process and provide support through community planning.As I said, I find the economic and social regeneration aspect a little hard to quantify, if you are looking for hard figures.

Alan McKeown Angus Council
link

We will bring together the figures in the same way that colleagues have said they will and break them down into various aspects, including our capital spend from various big projects. As Councillor Evans highlighted, Angus Council has shifted from a budget-led approach to an outcomes-led approach. We try to use money flexibly so that we see added value and connections with, for example, building new schools or working with our colleagues in the national health service around hubs. We work through community planning to tie such developments in with the provision of sustainable economic regeneration jobs during the building process, and with sustainable employment during the lifetime of the projects.Getting into some of those things means getting out of some of our other estate; we are wrestling with those issues. A key issue that we are wrestling with is community asset transfer, which involves valuing assets against the rules around best value, which the council has to achieve for general fund assets, and balancing that with what communities feel they can afford to pay and what they want to do with the assets. There is a positive shift from a budget-led approach to an outcomes-led approach.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Am I right that what you are saying is that you ensure that mainstream budgets are used to help regeneration?

Alan McKeown Angus Council
link

Yes.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Does the same go for the other authorities? I would like yes or no answers.Witnesses: Yes.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

You are bending the spend to get the most out of it. We will probably return to that aspect shortly.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

I will focus on capital spend in my questions, which I address to all the witnesses.The first contribution was from Councillor O’Neill, who gave us a very impressive list of projects. If the council had no regeneration department and no regeneration project, which of those projects would not proceed?

Councillor O’Neill
link

I do not know whether at this point we should defer to the officer.

Jim McAloon West Dunbartonshire Council
link

That is a very difficult question to answer, particularly for an officer.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Perhaps you could depoliticise the question for Mr McAloon.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

I know, but officers are always wary of such questions. You should maybe ask what priorities would still stand.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

No. That is not what I mean at all, convener, if I may say so.I have heard a list of projects. However, if the council was doing no regeneration, I think that you would do every one of the projects anyway, because you still need new schools, new accommodation for the elderly and so on. I want to tease out what capital spending is happening only because you are doing regeneration. I start from a position of not being clear. It is easier when it comes to revenue, but on capital spending I am not clear. I will go round the table, if the convener permits that.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Do you want to try again, Mr McAloon?

Jim McAloon West Dunbartonshire Council
link

One of our key projects is a new civic building. That project has absolutely been driven by the need to make a difference in the local area and it links in with the review of town centres that has just been completed. Town centres have to be about much more than the retail experience; they have to be attractive centres that the community wants to use.Through the Scottish Futures Trust, we have worked with all the public agencies on their asset strategies. We are still only part of the way through that process, but we have already identified a partnership of need, which relates to police presence. We have also carried out an assessment of the economic impact on council staff spend in an area. All that work points to the fact that the town that would benefit most is Dumbarton.The council could put a new civic headquarters anywhere, but we are trying to link the project to the regeneration needs of Dumbarton. We are also linking that with the new building for Our Lady and St Patrick’s high school, which is another regeneration project. We are currently considering the location of the school. If a walkway bridge was put in place, the daily flow of traffic into the town centre would multiply tenfold. Those are a couple of examples of projects that are being driven by the regeneration requirements of the town. They are aimed at increasing footfall and increasing the need for the community to come into the town centre. Our belief is that that will uplift the existing retail experience and will encourage new retail to come in.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

What I am hearing you say—you can agree or disagree—is that you are using communities’ needs in order to prioritise spending that you might normally, for quite proper policy reasons, take forward in any event in areas where the regeneration impact will be greatest. Of course you will not always achieve that, but that is essentially the aim.Witnesses indicated agreement.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

I see heads nodding, so I will move on to questions for Councillor Thompson and his team. You said that regeneration is integrated into everything that you do, so I suspect that you are in the same position. Remember that I am focusing on capital expenditure.

Councillor Thompson
link

We have a capital budget of £5 million to £6 million for regeneration. Let me address your question. It is always good to get a question from a lawyer, because they are usually pretty testing.

Councillor Thompson
link

Are you not? I thought that you were

Councillor Thompson
link

That is worse.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

I count things. You have just insulted at least one member of the committee.

Councillor Thompson
link

I apologise for that, Stewart.If we did not have a regeneration department and budget, we would need to go back and look at our capital plans. Remember that I told you that the council’s policy is to concentrate our funding in the most deprived areas. We are replacing every single primary and secondary school in South Lanarkshire on the basis of the condition of the schools. If we could not put money into regeneration, we would need to make a decision on what would be started first. In many of the areas in which we are involved in regeneration, the problems in the schools are very great, so we would invest there first. We would do the same in respect of housing; fortunately, we are not in that position.Such decisions would be political and are not things that I would ask Jim McCaffer about, but things that my colleagues of all parties and I would need to sit down and look at. The situation is not going to change unless politicians make qualitative decisions about putting money into such areas over a long period of time. I hope that those figures add up for the mathematician.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

That is helpful. Councillor Evans, your official specifically highlighted the building of new schools. Would those schools be built if you had no regeneration strategy? A lot of things get bad regeneration, and I am starting from the position of having some deep scepticism about that. I am absolutely here to be persuaded, however.

Councillor Evans
link

To be honest, Angus Council does not have to pretend not to have a regeneration budget or a regeneration committee, because we do not have those things. As with the majority of capital budgets, the money is assigned to the greatest need. We have two big school projects going on in Brechin and Forfar, both of which are community hubs, but they would not have been possible otherwise—they were not planned for. It was through the Government that we were able to go ahead with them.We have in the budget some money assigned for regeneration, but that is purely through other projects for which we have had to make bids. If it had not been for money from the townscape heritage initiative, we would not have been able to regenerate the centre of Brechin, and if it had not been for the conservation area regeneration scheme, we would not have been able to go ahead with the work in Kirriemuir either—we were successful in obtaining funding for that. Those things were not in the capital plan and were not budgeted for, but we have had to make allowances for them because we were successful in bidding for those funds.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Thank you, Mr Stevenson—the non-lawyer. We now turn to a lawyer—Margaret Mitchell.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

I was just thinking that it was as well that you did not call our mathematician a banker, but I remember that he is a former banker.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

He would deny that as well. Let’s not go there. Laughter.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

Can I tease out a little bit about community-led regeneration? You talked about encouraging communities and including them in the process. To what extent have the CPPs in your areas supported community-led regeneration?

Councillor O’Neill
link

There is an emerging process around the proposed community empowerment and renewal bill, and in West Dunbartonshire we have developed a new framework for community engagement. We have a citizens panel, which we are trying to augment, and we have public reassurance initiatives.Like most of the panel, we always struggle to connect with young people and get them actively involved. We do not want to always go down the line where it is the same older folk—I am probably getting into that age frame—who show up and put in a huge amount of effort across a swathe of different committees and communities. How do we involve our young people in that and how do we engage them through social media and so on? We are looking at how we use our citizens panel, and at best practice nationally, to try to involve young people. They are our young communities of today, but they will be our older communities in the future.We have a community participation committee in West Dunbartonshire and we have brought many members of communities on to that from a number of relevant community structures. We have brought them all together to influence the agenda that we, as politicians, deliver. We are also looking at new community involvement. We have six distinct wards, so we have broken them into six distinct neighbourhoods and we are looking at involving the community more in that.An issue that we have—certainly in relation to the proposed community empowerment and renewal bill—is how we can engage effectively with communities and whether the legitimate point of contact would be a community council or another organisation. An issue not only in West Dunbartonshire but beyond is how active and effective our community councils are. A lot of work is being put in, and we encourage as many people as possible in West Dunbartonshire to be part of their community councils. Some people who have come to my surgeries have been involved in their community council since its inception, when the Local Government (Scotland) Act 1973 came into force.By all means, we wish to harness people’s experience and knowledge, but we also need to freshen them up and hear from other folk about what could be done. We are looking at a wide swathe of measures that can and will be taken, with community involvement throughout.10:00

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

If a local organisation or a group of people had an idea for what they thought would be a good community initiative, how could they get that to you? How would the council be made aware of that?

Councillor O’Neill
link

You have just teed that up for me, Margaret. As part of our disposal strategy, a number of community facilities are probably going to be closed and demolished. In Duntocher, within my ward of Kilpatrick, a whole collective of local folk said that they did not want to lose their community facility, so they came together and formed a steering committee. With the assistance of Provost McAllister and lots of officers within the council, including community learning development officers, education lets officers and regeneration officers, they looked at the feasibility of their taking over the running of the facility in the village of Duntocher. I am delighted to say that, only a few months ago, the facility was handed over to the community, which has taken ownership of it and responsibility for it. That has not come without its challenges, but they have all stepped up to the mark and want to have the facility. Without that, the councillors or council officers would probably have decided just to close the building, as it was companiesting too much and was not delivering. It is now bright and shiny, and it is being used daily.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

To go back to my original question, given everything that you are doing to engage with the community, you would not necessarily see CPPs as being the main driver for community-led regeneration.

Councillor O’Neill
link

No. They definitely play a major part, but I would not say that they are the main driver.

Councillor Thompson
link

In South Lanarkshire, the community groups are involved throughout the whole process of making decisions, right up to the CPP. The thinking is that we should be doing things not for people, but with people. We do that in a number of ways, including through the community capacity building that we are doing in the worst 5 per cent of areas; the regeneration partnership that I mentioned earlier where the decisions on many of these things are made—the voluntary organisations and local communities sit on that; the LEADER programme in rural areas, which they also sit on to make decisions; and Voluntary Action South Lanarkshire—VASLAN—on which they are also represented. Those groups are all around the table and can put their views and wishes directly to the CPP. Also, let us not forget Clyde Gateway, the urban regeneration company.The important thing for us is that we continue to build capacity in those areas. We are doing that by setting up action groups, youth groups and community-led projects such as that which Councillor O’Neill mentioned. Certain things in communities will attract people to come along. Sometimes it is an environmental project aimed at cleaning up spaces or creating a garden, or it could be about youth unemployment. It is about homing in on the things that the communities see as important and then bringing the strength of the CPP to bear in order to do something about them.We regularly provide drop-in advice centres in some of the community hubs, whereby we sit down with people in the community who want advice on how to do things and what the next steps are. We have officers who advise them on exactly the steps that they need to take, and those officers then feed back to the council.Part of capacity building is about encouraging people to get involved and to come up with projects that they think should go forward. The challenge for us is to find a way to fund projects and put them into a programme. We are currently getting a good response from communities, but I stress that we need to build capacity to ensure that communities have the knowledge and skills that they need if they are to take things to the next step. Someone talked about attracting outside funding, which is important.It is about giving people back a bit of confidence and ownership of the community in which they live. The council’s role, as I see it, is to try to serve communities’ needs and to support and help them.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

That sounds good. Let me give you a practical example of such support. Many communities would dearly love to hire and use assets that councils own, but sometimes they are not given access to buildings after hours or even during the day—perhaps for health and safety reasons—or the charges are prohibitive. Will you comment on that?

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Councillor Thompson, will you be brief? We have a lot to get through.

Councillor Thompson
link

We are keen to work with communities. We have a community asset transfer scheme, to try to help people who want to take over an asset—

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

I was not talking about taking over an asset. I was talking about assets that local authorities own and run, which have spare capacity that people are often not able to use.

Councillor Thompson
link

We are only too happy to work with people on that. If you know of examples, please flag them up to us and we will look at them carefully. If there is spare capacity and we can find a way of ensuring that the community can benefit, we will do that.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

Okay, thank you. Did Councillor Evans want to respond to my question on CPPs?

Councillor Evans
link

What you talked about is exactly what we are doing. We have vacant buildings throughout Angus that we are letting community groups use. If a building is vacant or on the market, we are not doing anything with it. What is the point of having it sit there doing nothing, when people could put the space to good use? It is about working with community groups to see what they need and whether we can facilitate things.My party is in administration now but was in opposition in the previous term. It seemed to me that there was a massive breakdown between what was happening in the strategic-level community planning partnership and what was happening with local community planning on the ground. There was a big disconnect there and it seemed that community planning was only as good as the local officer—if a ward had a good one they made a big difference, but if it had a bad one nothing happened and we heard nothing but complaints. I could not have told you what the strategic-level CPP discussed or what were the outcomes of its discussions. It is only as I get more involved now that I can see what is happening. We are working on how we tie what people need at the most local level with planning at the strategic level, so that we bring everything together.You will probably hear me say more than once that Brechin is our flagship example of how community planning works. Regeneration in the town pretty much kicked off with the townscape heritage initiative, which had funding of £3 million. The town centre was run down, but with the funding we were able to give the whole place a new lease of life.At first, people in Brechin had to be dragged along kicking and screaming—they could not see the purpose of what was happening. However, we brought in retail experts from Merchant City in Glasgow, who helped to bring our retailers together to think about how they could improve the town. Things have snowballed from there. People have set up events throughout the year, and the work has completely changed the way in which Brechiners think about their town. Instead of moaning about the place, people are saying that Brechin has a lot to offer and that there is much to get excited about.The work was supported by community planning all the way along. As it happened, our community council reformed, so we had a new group of positive-thinking people there. The work of the local partnership, the community council and the retailers group, with support from local community planning, has completely changed Brechin. We hope to build on the experience and spread the approach across Angus.

Alan McKeown Angus Council
link

There is a point to be made about wider community planning and some of the frictions between national agendas—on the disposal of NHS land through the disposals book, for example—and how they do or do not contribute to strategic alignment.We might decide that we would like to do something with old hospital sites, for example, by developing housing sites to meet a wider regeneration objective or building a centre of excellence for training. However, the NHS holds a big swathe of land and its disposal strategy is centralised, which means that our local NHS partners do not have much of an influence. That gap is an issue not only for Angus Council but in other areas, and the committee may want to explore whether we can achieve proper structural alignment if we do not follow through on some of those disposal strategies and other rules.When I worked for the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities and community planning was just beginning, that was one of the key goals. If we get the NHS, local government, police, fire and the voluntary sector all strategically aligned, including on budgets, we have a chance for success.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

That is very useful, Mr McKeown. I will not go around the table on that, because we would probably hear about a lot of local aspects, but, if any of you want to send us information about where such difficulties have arisen, that would be very helpful.

Richard Baker Lab North East Scotland
link

I am interested in how we maximise investment in regeneration and the policy changes that can be made to incentivise it.South Lanarkshire Council’s submission refers specifically to the “challenges” in procurement processes at present. Procurement is one area in which council spend can be used to maximise investment in regeneration, also levering in private partners.What could be done specifically in that regard? I direct my question to Councillor Thompson, as I have referred to his submission. What is being achieved through procurement at present, and what more could be achieved?The submission also refers to the forthcoming procurement bill and the existing challenges. What sort of changes are needed to ensure that we can maximise investment in regeneration through council procurement?

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

I ask you all to give brief answers from now on, because we have a huge number of questions to get through.

Councillor Thompson
link

I think that you have been speaking to the leader of the council about brief answers again, convener.A number of provisions could be considered for inclusion in the procurement bill, on aspects such as living wages, taking on apprentices and recruiting in the areas of highest deprivation.Our strategy has been more than reasonably successful, but we have worked on it for 10 years through the supplier development programme. The Government procurement department is now considering a national roll-out of the supplier development programme as part of a wider piece of work, and I congratulate it on doing so.Far more could be done, and if we take the spend and tie our employability, regeneration and economic development strategies into our procurement strategy, we will get far bigger hits for our buck. It is important that we do that.If you are caught for time, convener, we can produce a submission on that for the committee. As I said, the strategy has been a 10-year piece of work that has often involved winning the hearts and minds of procurement professionals.

Richard Baker Lab North East Scotland
link

I will be brief, convener, because we are short of time.Councillor Thompson, are you confident that those goals will be achieved through the forthcoming procurement bill? Is there the necessary dialogue between local authorities and the Scottish Government regarding that legislation—which is due to be introduced in the near future—to ensure that the new legislative framework will be in place to help to achieve the goals that you have set out?

Councillor Thompson
link

I certainly hope so. The Government is listening to what we are saying and is doing its absolute best, but we must remember that we have to balance what we do against European legislation. We have to push the boundaries as far as we can, and there are some very good models south of the border—particularly in areas of London—that we can look at in that respect.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Councillor Thompson, you mentioned the council’s procurement department. Some of us recently visited the Clyde Gateway project, which seems to have dealt with certain procurement issues that others have felt to be an impediment. That is my impression from what was said to us. What co-operation is there between South Lanarkshire Council’s procurement department—as you referred to it—and the procurement work that is going on at Clyde Gateway?10:15

Councillor Thompson
link

It is not just about Clyde Gateway but the council’s whole process. The procurement department has been given specific instructions by the chief executive and the elected members that it is necessary to bring on local suppliers. If we need to build our capacity, we will do that using our economic development budget. The suppliers must use our work programmes. We can put some of that in legislation, but some of it we cannot. We have worked very closely with Clyde Gateway on how it procures, and its model is very similar to the one that we use. We are very supportive of Clyde Gateway. We believe that there is a way forward in the procurement area and that it is one that we cannot miss, because it is very important.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Okay. Does anyone else want to talk about procurement? I hope that you will all become involved in the consultation on the bill, because that is extremely important.

Stuart McMillan SNP West Scotland
link

I have a question for each of the local authorities. The first question is to Angus Council. You stated in your written submission:“Regeneration policy in Scotland needs to anticipate and respond to changing patterns of behaviour”.You then went on to highlight the issue of“behavioural change in terms of smoking, obesity, alcohol etc.”Is the local authority undertaking any particular actions to help facilitate such change?

Councillor Evans
link

Absolutely. I talked earlier about it being hard to pinpoint budgets and identify spending, but we are trying to take massive steps in the direction of tackling obesity and poverty. We are doing that through a lot of early intervention projects, but it is done in conjunction with community planning and working with the third sector. For example, Voluntary Action Angus is a key partner. We are looking at the most deprived areas in Angus and working together to tackle the issues there.

Stuart McMillan SNP West Scotland
link

Would it be possible to send the committee more detailed information on that?

Councillor Evans
link

Absolutely.

Stuart McMillan SNP West Scotland
link

Thank you. My next question is for South Lanarkshire Council. Councillor Thompson, on the first page of your written submission, in answer to question 1, you referred to the“EU structural programme 2014-2020”and went on to say:“If programmes such as these are developed increasingly looking at areas of opportunity then there is the potential for regeneration projects and jobs to move to relatively wealthy and successful areas.”I suggest that that ties in with what is said in the Scottish Enterprise written submission. We will hear later in the meeting from a representative from Scottish Enterprise, but its submission states:“Clear priorities are not only important for maximising the impact of public sector spend. They also send a strong message to the private sector about where public investment is most likely to enhance the conditions for the private sector, making the returns on investment sufficiently attractive.”As I said, I think that the two statements that I have quoted are similar. Do you think that there is possibly too much investment for the larger, more affluent areas compared with that for areas of deprivation?

Councillor Thompson
link

It is important to get a balance. I am interested to see that Scottish Enterprise and South Lanarkshire Council take the same view on the issue, which just goes to show that partnership does work.We must be very careful, though, about having layers of policies within departments and the creation of silos. We must be very clear about exactly what we are doing, whether at the level of the council, Scottish Enterprise or the Scottish Government. We must get the balance of investment right. Clyde Gateway is a good example of where a lot of public money is going in, but we must persuade the private sector to come in and must give it the confidence that it can invest its money in the same way. Even with the best will in the world, the public sector cannot do it all. Our job should be to stimulate investment and get work started, and then hope that we can get the private sector to take it from there. That is not an easy ask in the current economic situation, but we are beginning to see some of that in Clyde Gateway and in other areas. However, we must balance how and where we spend our money and ensure that we attract private-sector funding to come in on the back of that.

Stuart McMillan SNP West Scotland
link

Thank you. My next question is for Councillor O’Neill. You referred earlier to the meeting that will take place this afternoon regarding the potential benefit for a regeneration project that is to do with a school.I am not going to ask a political question, but I have a technical question. I am led to believe that, if the decision goes ahead, there may be a joint procurement arrangement for schools between West Dunbartonshire Council and another authority.

Councillor O’Neill
link

It is East Renfrewshire Council. We are about three months behind East Renfrewshire Council in the procurement process and we would save on costs. West Dunbartonshire Council receives 66 per cent of its funding from the Scottish Government and we come up with the other capital moneys. We are working on a joint procurement model with East Renfrewshire Council so that the work and the drawings will be done at the same time. Because we are slightly behind in the process, there is some benefit for us as we will learn from East Renfrewshire Council’s mistakes and, we hope, avoid making them. The decision on what will happen at particular sites will be made by an education committee this afternoon.

Stuart McMillan SNP West Scotland
link

Would there be potential financial implications if there were any further slippage in the procurement and in moving ahead with the programme?

Councillor O’Neill
link

It is contained just now. If there is an officer recommendation for a particular site but there is a groundswell of opinion within the community against a particular bit of greenbelt being used—

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

We are getting too much into local policy decision making, as far as I am concerned.

Councillor O’Neill
link

I appreciate that. As it stands just now, there will be no slippage and we will not fall behind.

Anne McTaggart Lab Glasgow
link

According to what we have heard this morning, the establishment and measurement of regeneration outcomes has been quite varied. Would you welcome an approach that was based on people’s wellbeing?

Councillor Evans
link

Absolutely. We are working more towards an outcomes-based approach anyway through our community planning, so we would welcome that. The funding tends to be diverted to shorter-term projects that are easier to slice at budget time. A lot of the time, we cannot see whether a project could have a positive impact 10 years down the line because we do not get the chance to assess it properly. Therefore, I would welcome such an approach.

Councillor Thompson
link

We conduct a residents survey that includes that issue. We have done that in 2007, 2009 and 2011, and the next one is due at some point this year. The background to your question is right—we need to measure what we are doing to see the outcomes that we are getting from it. We need to measure what is happening out in the communities, and the best way to do that is to ask the people who live there.

Councillor O’Neill
link

We see regeneration very much in terms of community wellbeing. If we do not have jobs, regeneration and people interacting socially, we will not have healthy and safe communities. We look at the whole mix of regeneration and all the benefits that come from it. If people have jobs, they feel better about themselves, about their children and so on. It is not rocket science. Regeneration will have a domino effect if the community is at the heart of it.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

Good morning. Convener, I apologise for starting with a local question—I will try to generalise it in the context of the issues that have been raised today.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

Councillor O’Neill, you talked about community asset transfer in Duntocher and said that the facility is being used daily now that it is run by the community. Why do you think the facility was not used daily when it was under the control of the council? What is different now that means that it is used more frequently by the community?

Councillor O’Neill
link

I hesitate to make a political point, but I do not think that we were using our assets appropriately. A cost implication was undoubtedly involved; previous administrations were trying to reduce budgets.My colleague from Brechin talked about communities using facilities that had not been used. As the vice-convener of my council’s housing, environment and economic development committee, I strive to look at such things. We reduced some charges for community facilities in West Dunbartonshire and brought some into line with each other—we had a number of pricing regimes that went back even to regional council days. Probably about 95 per cent of charges in West Dunbartonshire were reduced.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

The situation shows that communities can operate facilities successfully, which leads to the argument about community asset transfer being of benefit to communities.Councillor Thompson, you made great play of the schools improvement programme. According to written information, that programme of upgrading and new builds is almost complete. You said that you had worked with local contractors to create local jobs and local apprenticeships. How successful has that programme been? What long-term monitoring will be done to ensure that people who are employed on those contracts gain meaningful employment in the future?

Councillor Thompson
link

The approach has been very successful. The contractors use our employability scheme to do their recruitment. We support many people with job subsidies and training. The recent figures show that more than 90 per cent of the people involved are still in full-time employment a year after they have finished participating in the scheme. The approach is very good.We are talking about people who go through our skills academy in construction from 14 to 16 and people right up through the process. Probably 100 people have got jobs through that process. That is over and above the adults who have taken part in other schemes and got jobs with job subsidies.Our scheme has been successful. The good news for us is that the contractors like it. They find it useful, it reduces their costs and it gives them community ownership of what is happening. The scheme is working, but it is not a cheap option.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

My final question is to Councillor Evans. You referred to the revamping of community councils in Angus and you talked about engaging with “positive-thinking people”. How do you engage with people who do not think positively and who might criticise the local authority’s regeneration strategies and policies? I will not put that question to the other witnesses, although it might apply to them. How do you tackle people who question what is being done—particularly if they have been around for many decades and have seen things being done to rather than with them?

Councillor Evans
link

There are a lot of elected members in this room, so I am sure that we are all used to meeting people who do not think positively about us, let alone other things. As I said, the physical regeneration that we had sparked a sea change in people. The general feeling was that everybody was fed up with how things had been. There was a lot of negative thinking at the start. People complained that not an awful lot seemed to be happening, and then they complained when the scaffolding went up. It was only when the results were seen that the general attitude changed.As more and more people started to talk about our city in a positive way, things snowballed and there was a big sweep towards change. You will always get negative people no matter what you do. Some people will always criticise certain policies, whatever we try to do. Only when they see the effects do they change their opinion. It is a matter of being consistent until people see the final results.10:30

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I had those three brief questions, but I want finally to raise an issue that people might want to reflect on. Engaging with people at the start of the process might assist in taking them in the direction of travel that you are aiming for, rather than have them fight against it. One big issue is that many communities feel that they are getting things done to them rather than with them. That is why you might get negative thinking at the start of the process.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Thank you, Mr Wilson.I want to make a brief point. Having been out and about, we have seen cross-boundary co-operation in relation to Clyde Gateway, which involves two local authorities and a lot of other partner agencies. How do you deal with regeneration schemes that cross local authority boundaries? Councillor Evans, I know your neck of the woods and I think that you represent Edzell—although, of course, Edzell air base is in Aberdeenshire. How do you ensure that you co-operate with other local authorities to create the right climate for regeneration in cross-border areas, as has happened with Clyde Gateway?

Councillor Evans
link

It is quite hard, because on the other side we have a border with a city where the needs are quite different. Aberdeenshire is a place that we could work with more closely, but I do not think that the relationship is 100 per cent there in respect of regeneration. Regeneration feels quite localised at the moment. I do not know whether Mr McKeown has a different opinion.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

I understand that. I will come to Councillor O’Neill next to ask about West Dunbartonshire. There are areas where the effects of regeneration—or lack thereof—are felt across local authority boundaries. What I am trying to establish is how we ensure that there is discussion between local authorities, as there has been in relation to Clyde Gateway, so that communities on the boundaries do not miss out on regeneration prospects.

Alan McKeown Angus Council
link

From our perspective, it is about the regional planning approach, which in Angus is the TAYplan approach. We start off with strategic planning discussions between officials and elected members. That is helping us ensure that we bridge any gap between Dundee and Angus.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

You have opened another can of worms. You are obviously involved in TAYplan, but Edzell air base is included in the Aberdeen city and shire plan. How do you ensure that there is co-operation in that regard?

Alan McKeown Angus Council
link

We met the chief executive of Aberdeenshire Council as we walked into this meeting, and we have agreed to catch up and have a conversation about shared services and regeneration activities. At one level, it is as simple as having and using good personal relationships and then bringing in elected members to talk to each other. That world is opening up much more now than it ever has in the past. We have to create those opportunities and make them work for us. At one level, it is as simple as that.

Councillor O’Neill
link

Given our position, we do a lot of work with Argyll and Bute Council and Stirling Council as our three boundaries meet. We also work with the Loch Lomond and Trossachs National Park Authority. As well as being the vice-convener of the regeneration committee, I am the convener of the planning and licensing committee. I sit on the Clyde Valley joint community planning group, our local development planning group. We also have the Clyde waterfront strategic planning group. We do lots of joint work. Most recently, in relation to the marine accident investigation branch, a boat sank on Loch Lomond. I appreciate that we are short of time, convener. The boat was unregulated—

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Councillor O’Neill, I think that we are drifting off the subject of regeneration and the cross-border co-operation aspect.

Councillor O’Neill
link

Okay. There is the Clyde Valley community planning partnership and the joint development group, and I am vice-convener of the Clyde and Loch Lomond flood prevention group, which is working with the Scottish Environment Protection Agency and local authorities that are adversely affected by flooding.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Councillor Thompson, you mentioned Clyde Gateway. Do you want to say anything else?

Councillor Thompson
link

We have a good relationship with our old friends in North Lanarkshire, particularly on regeneration and what we call routes to inclusion. We sit down together regularly to think about where people are and where they are going. The initiative is politically led, and below the political leadership there is an officer group. We look at business development and business gateway, which has some fit in that regard, and we look at tourism, which is important in the rural area and also fits with the regeneration agenda. We, too, are involved in the Clyde Valley CPP. Work is politically led, as it was on Clyde Gateway and as it is in Glasgow. The politicians meet to talk about our shared values, and officers advise us.Partnership with other local authorities is working well, as is partnership with Scottish Enterprise—someone from Scottish Enterprise is sitting behind me and would probably give me a skelp if I did not say that—and with Skills Development Scotland and the national health service. We do not always get what we want and we do not always agree, but we share problems, argue out a common way forward and then stick to it.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Thank you all for your evidence. I hope that we will get feedback on some of the points that were made.10:36 Meeting suspended.

10:38 On resuming—

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

I welcome our second panel: Rachael McCormack is director of strengthening communities at Highlands and Islands Enterprise; Councillor Thomas Prag is chair of the planning, environment and development committee at Highland Council; and Andy McCann is economy and regeneration manager at Highland Council. Does anyone want to make brief opening remarks?

Councillor Thomas Prag Highland Council
link

I have no intention of making a long opening statement, because I am sure that members have lots of questions, but it might be helpful if I remind members that although people tend to think of the Highlands as being rural we have areas of significant urban deprivation.I also want to draw members’ attention to something that we said in our submission, on how to work with communities and whether work should be public sector led or community led. We tend towards a middle path—in other words, it could be either.That is really all that needs saying. The committee will no doubt grill us with difficult questions.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Thank you for that. I am sure that most of us are aware that not all of Highland is rural. Many of us will have visited the great city of Inverness and some of the other urban areas of your authority. In terms of tourism, a lot of us have been here, there and everywhere. However, that point is useful, because we sometimes see local authorities as being either urban or rural, so thank you for that.Highland Council and Highlands and Islands Enterprise are represented here, and I imagine that many of your regeneration budgets are joint budgets. Perhaps you could tell us about that co-operation and say how much you are spending on regeneration activity and what proportion of that budget is spent on community-led regeneration.Councillor Prag, do you want to go first?

Councillor Prag
link

Yes, but I am going to rely on my colleagues quite a bit.

Councillor Prag
link

I heard that question being asked before and I wished that I had had it beforehand because we could have done the homework for you. The difficulty, in many cases, is in identifying what is in the regeneration budget. Frankly, so much of what we do is about communities and regeneration anyway, but it is the additional bits that we need to consider.We can point to such things as a community challenge fund that we have introduced—it is a relatively small fund for us—which is encouraging communities to come to us with ideas about where they can perhaps provide services better, and to work with us. That has produced some interesting ideas. We have a preventative spend budget as well. Those are two relatively small things that I can immediately identify. Mr McCann can probably give you a list of some of the sums—he has had a chance to think about it.

Andy McCann Highland Council
link

Good morning. One thing that we are keen to point out is the Highland LEADER programme, which we have been active in. That is a £16.5 million programme in Highland. It is European cash and it is matched with some Scottish Government funding, but £5 million of match funding has also come in from the council. Some 350 projects have been funded through that. External funding has come in, but the council has also identified spend.The council also has £1 million of discretionary spend for each of the wards, and it is active at the community level in supporting community projects. Another example is our employability budget, where we are spending just under £2.5 million, and we have the European social fund funding on top of that. As part of that, just under £0.5 million is directed to deprived area funds to support community projects, which is linked to employability.As Councillor Prag said, we have a wide range of activity. We are happy to pull together some further details for you if you wish.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

As you said, the LEADER money is mainly European. You also mentioned the European social fund money. How much European money do you have to play with, as it were?

Andy McCann Highland Council
link

As I said, the LEADER programme is a £16.5 million programme. It includes LEADER and convergence funding. We recently pulled down £1 million of ESF funding for employability activity, and we have also just pulled down £80,000 from the Scottish Government for a particular employment initiative that has come along. The council has also pulled down money from other, wider funds including the European regional development fund and the European fisheries fund, which again supports community activity. That is just under £0.5 million.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Okay. It would be useful for us to get our heads round that.

Rachael McCormack Highlands and Islands Enterprise
link

Highlands and Islands Enterprise and our predecessor organisation, the Highlands and Islands Development Board, have been in establishment for a period spanning five decades. Back in the 1960s, the HIDB was given a remit of social and economic development, and now HIE has that remit. That distinctive characteristic of our organisation means that we interlace and combine approaches to social development and economic development.The answer to the question of how much we spend on regeneration depends on how we define regeneration, but it would probably be all of it, given that the focus of Highlands and Islands Enterprise’s work is to support communities, businesses and social enterprises in the Highlands and Islands region to grow, be ambitious and reach their aspirations.10:45

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

Good morning. Can we tease out how, in practice, Highlands and Islands Enterprise and Highland Council co-ordinate their regeneration strategy and activity, given all the funding that you have mentioned and the shared aims, to ensure that there is no duplication and that there is value for money?

Rachael McCormack Highlands and Islands Enterprise
link

For the benefit of the committee, I clarify that HIE’s relationship is with all the local authorities in the region, one of which is Highland Council. We also work with colleagues in Moray, Shetland, Orkney, Innse Gall and Argyll and Bute. In addition, we have a little bit of crossover with North Ayrshire. I hope that I have not missed anybody.Therefore, we work with a range of local authority partners. At a strategic level, senior colleagues on the HIE executive sit on the boards of each of the community planning partnerships in our area, and that is an extremely valuable mechanism for strategic alignment.I can see that there is a hunger for some figures and I will use our community account management programme as an example. I can share with the committee the figures for the contribution that HIE makes—as that is the mechanism for collaboration—and the contributions that all the local authority partners and a number of other partners make, principally to support community-led regeneration, if that is of interest, convener.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Yes, go ahead, Ms McCormack.

Rachael McCormack Highlands and Islands Enterprise
link

For a number of years, HIE has supported community-led regeneration in a very specific way, which we term community account management, whereby we work with a whole community in a particular location when the community identifies and establishes itself. We provide support, resources and some access to finance, but we also bring other agencies together around the community so that it can benefit directly from specific support.The communities have a long-term relationship with HIE staff. We have expertise within our community assets team and our community growth committee’s policies team. We also have strengthening communities teams within each of our eight area teams, so wherever a community is in the Highlands and Islands region, it is not very far away from an area office or a local office with HIE staff who have a community-led regeneration focus.I will give the figures and financials for the account management process. We have done an interim review—it is a rolling programme—and from when the account management process started properly in 2009, there has been a cumulative investment of £4.6 million, of which HIE funding was just over £2.7 million and LEADER funding, via the local authority LEADER local action groups, was £1.8 million. In addition, Shetland Islands Council and Orkney Islands Council made further contributions. One of the national parks and a number of other agencies have given contributions in kind. The process is something of an exemplar of multi-agency working and of adopting a partnership approach to locally led community regeneration.I tend to distance myself from the phrase “bottom-up”, because I do not agree with it as a principle and I do not think that it is right. I think that “community led” is a much more accurate description of what community-led development and regeneration are, because the starting point is the community coming together around a common need, a shared aim or a desire to do something—sometimes because there is a threat of something happening that they do not want to happen. We support them to become constituted and give them some initial grant moneys to allow them to spread their wings a little bit and to determine for themselves what they want to do and the trajectory that they want to go on.We support them to do far-reaching community engagement. When I say far-reaching, we would look for 60, 70 or 80 per cent representation, if that is at all possible. I was at a presentation from the Machrihanish air base community company recently, at which its representatives talked about 70 or 80 per cent representation, with thousands of people in their community participating in the early-stage consultation. That is very significant. The difference is that it is community led as opposed to agency led.We support an assets audit—an inventory of what is available to a community and what a community might want to do differently—and then a prioritisation exercise, which leads to what we term a growth plan, which is basically a shared development plan. It is important that we give direction to help communities to identify those things that will increase their resilience in the long term. If they want to do two different things and one of them has an income stream associated with it going forward, that would be the most likely one that we would guide the community towards putting its resource in. That is because grant dependency is not a position that our communities want to be in and is not sustainable in terms of the current public sector purse either.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

Is it through that interim review to which you referred and through account management that you have the checks and balances to ensure that you are not duplicating anything that is already being done in Highland Council or in one of the various councils that you mentioned HIE works with? It is a lot to keep a handle on.

Rachael McCormack Highlands and Islands Enterprise
link

It certainly is. I am fortunate in having an extremely capable staff and a range of colleagues who work directly with partner agencies. It is not all for HIE to deliver—absolutely not. It is community led. HIE provides an umbrella—a framework, if you like—but we are reliant on colleagues and share that responsibility for delivery with them. That includes colleagues such as the colleagues who are here from Highland Council, our other local authority partners and our health authority partners—it is a multi-agency list.The community account relationship is the responsibility of HIE in as much as we provide the staff resource that has the long-term relationship and brings the expertise. We do not provide core support to organisations but we are there if they need us. We are there for the good times when development is going strongly; we are there for the bad times; and we are there for the long haul.In talking to communities, we hear that it is that relationship that is most important to them—not the finance. They always say that the finance is nice, but if you asked them to say what is most important, it is the relationship with our expert staff, who bring a huge amount of experience and can expedite significant change in communities for the benefit of the whole, inclusive community, not just the community anchor organisation with which we work.

Councillor Prag
link

That is all right, I am used to being called lots of things. For such a short name, it can be difficult.At the top level, if you are talking about how we work together, I go back long enough in the area—long before I was involved with the council—to be able to remember when the relationship, frankly, was not all that good. In fact, it was competitive, which was even worse. That was before all of our times, I am delighted to say.What exists at the moment is, first, the single outcome agreement, which has been very helpful in focusing minds and in focusing us on what the outcomes need to be and who is responsible for them. That is working much better for us now. We also have things such as the Highland economic forum. It has all kinds of bodies on it, but we do not just meet as a talking shop. We have targets and we ask, “Who is going to do that?” I chair it, as it happens. HIE is part of that, as are many other appropriate organisations.We also have a joint economic recovery plan. The economy and what to do about it has been top of the council’s programme for this session. We partly developed the plan but some of the detail is now being taken on by HIE. We are working together on that and we had a meeting a few weeks ago about where bits of that are going.Mr McCann can probably give you a more practical example from the work done on the Nigg energy park and its redevelopment. That was a classic example of a project for which partnership working was the only way to deliver it.

Andy McCann Highland Council
link

I am tempted to say that working together is just something that we do; it is how we work in Highland Council. We do not necessarily think of having to make the connections, because they are already there and we work together in an operational sense.Just to pick up on something that was said, there is the strategic side of it, with the single outcome agreement, but we are currently doing another thing through the Highland community planning partnership. A cross-agency working group is sitting down with the agencies to look at how we are all working together on community development. That is not just about duplication or addressing the issue with HIE; it is about looking at what NHS Highland is doing—through its district partnerships or on health inequalities—and trying to make the connections across the range of agencies, not just with HIE.To pick up again on the operational aspect, we made joint investments in Nigg. There were a lot of issues about state aid, so we had to work closely there with the officers on practical details to ensure that there was no problem. For the Highland LEADER programme, HIE and other partners were integral to putting together the programme’s design, strategy and operational delivery on the ground. Partnership working is built into our systems and working practices.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

Are there checks and balances to ensure that there is no duplication of funding by councils and HIE? Do you ensure that there is no wastage at all and that value for money is a priority?

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Who wants to tackle that one?

Andy McCann Highland Council
link

On checks and balances, it is about understanding individual projects and the finances through the operational mechanisms that are used. For example, the Nigg operational mechanism had to be very clear and detailed because of the particular investment issues there, state aid issues and so forth. The operational mechanism for individual projects, such as the Highland LEADER programme, identifies the funding clearly and up front. If agencies are looking for particular outcomes, that is captured in the projects’ outcomes.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Ms McCormack, you were keen to answer that question, too.

Rachael McCormack Highlands and Islands Enterprise
link

I echo Andy McCann’s point. I can give a couple of examples, without going into detail here, from the course of the past two days. An issue arose, but before we or anyone else steamed in to sort it out, the first port of call was a phone call at director-to-director level. Then we would encourage colleagues from the respective teams to have detailed dialogue. Secondly, on the way into Edinburgh last night, I pulled into the car park at Wickes because Stuart Black was on the phone wanting a chat about something where there is a mutual crossover and we need to collaborate. I do not think that I could make up that kind of example.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

I want to pursue an issue that I pursued with the previous panel, the essence of which relates particularly to capital expenditure. If we were not engaged in regeneration, what would we not do? To turn that on its head and put it positively, what are we doing in capital expenditure that we are doing only because we are focusing on regeneration?

Councillor Prag
link

That is a very good question. I am glad that, as I listened to it, I had a little time to think about it. By the way, the mathematician in my family was my father, not me.It is really hard to pin down an answer to your question, because regeneration funding advances things in some cases, or makes us do things better. Lots of work is being done in the city of Inverness. For example, a big bit of flood defence work is being done to prevent the river from flowing into the city. We are funding that, but the Scottish Government is largely funding it. However, we can also do bits on top of that work because we can access other bits of funding to make it that much better and regenerate that part of the city at the same time. That shows why it is quite difficult to answer your question.Schools were mentioned earlier. There are areas in which a new school might have to be built, but if we have access to different funding and the community thinks and works together, we can add something to that school. I cannot give you specifics in answer to your question, because there is not a neat line. I know that that is not comfortable for a mathematician, but the position is very grey.

Andy McCann Highland Council
link

We referred in our written evidence to a particular project in which the council was investing in a school. The council was aware that the community was keen to have community facilities in the school, but the council’s capital programme was not able to provide them. The council used part of its capital to provide the space, but it was through community development activity that the community got together and did the fit-out. The community is now involved in the management of the facility.It is not necessarily about generating extra capital; it is about how capital is used to create opportunities. In the example that I gave, the community became active, and the asset that has been created is not just a council asset but very much a community one.11:00

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

Are you saying that as a matter of policy you use capital expenditure in a way that maximises the building of community capacity?

Andy McCann Highland Council
link

When there is the opportunity to do that, that is certainly what happens in Highland Council.

Councillor Prag
link

I have not thought about it in that way, but I think that we instinctively do that. In other words, I do not think that there is a written policy, but we would immediately make the most of our capital from a community point of view. Perhaps I have misunderstood the question.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

Are you suggesting that regeneration is so ingrained in everyone that you do not need to speak of it? I am slightly sceptical about that.

Councillor Prag
link

We can always find things to talk about. Is regeneration ingrained? I think that it is. Let me give you an example. We have a lot of small towns and city centres, as everywhere else does. A report about regenerating town centres was produced recently for the Scottish Government, but we had already been thinking about how our city centres need to be different kinds of places. We had organised a seminar for our members about the issue, so that they could think about it—so regeneration is embedded in our thinking.May I give you another example? We have known for a while that we want to do something about Academy Street, in Inverness, but we really need regeneration funds for that. Anyone who knows Inverness will know that the street is a thoroughfare and a problem, which is crying out for significant help, not just to improve some of the buildings but, in my view, to create a shared space where vehicles and people mingle more. That is the kind of thing that we might want to do. We do not have the capital resources to do everything, but we might put something towards regeneration of that part of the city—I am not sure that that has answered your question.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

I might go back to buying my shoes in Inverness if you closed down the bank that replaced the best shoe shop in the Highlands. But there we are.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

We are getting parochial again. Ms McCormack, do you want to add anything?

Rachael McCormack Highlands and Islands Enterprise
link

Mr Stevenson made an interesting challenge about our perspective. When we look at capital investment, we probably do not describe what we are doing in terms of regeneration objectives. The objectives that we seek in relation to community-led development are to do with demographic change, positive economic activity, increased social participation, services and amenities that are managed for and by the community and positive changes in environment and land management. We look for a qualitative measure of overall community confidence.I gave figures on HIE investment of more than £2 million to deliver some of the capital projects that communities sought. We invested a total of £4.5 million over two or three years, and that levered in other moneys—£6.60 for every £1. There was a creative use of capital with a view to maintaining a focus on what you might call regeneration but what we would describe as a series of linked outcomes that are beneficial for our communities.Perhaps another way of answering Mr Stevenson’s question is to say that we have confidence in our communities, to the extent that we are very comfortable with placing in their hands some of our most significant chunks of capital, for community-led investment. In South Uist, for example, Stòras Uibhist and Sealladh na Beinne Mòire are taking forward a £10 million harbour development, to which HIE has contributed more than £5 million. We have put money into the hands of a community landlord to take forward a community-led regeneration project that will be demonstrably transformational for that part of our region.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Will you clarify one point? You said that an investment of £1 levered in £6.60. Is that right?

Rachael McCormack Highlands and Islands Enterprise
link

In terms of community investment secured during the period that we looked at, although a number of those communities had support from Highlands and Islands Enterprise over the preceding period. We did an interim snapshot evaluation to examine what the spending and productivity had been during that period, and we found some fairly significant results. I would be happy to share that with the committee, if that would be of interest.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

That would be of great interest to the committee, thank you.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

HIE and HIDB have been around for five decades. What impact has that had on communities, particularly with regard to social development issues? Has it given communities in the Highlands and elsewhere a grasp of what can be achieved if they are actively involved in regeneration?

Rachael McCormack Highlands and Islands Enterprise
link

Most communities would agree that it has given them massive confidence—that is an appropriate descriptor. I think that the longevity of the relationship—which I will probably mention as many times as possible when I am before the committee—is fundamental, as are the expertise and guidance of staff who understand communities.Sometimes, people come to us cold and say, “Can you deliver X, Y and Z?”, “Can you get the community to participate?” and “Can you give us the results of the interim phase within four months?” We say, “No, we can’t.” We are honest about that. We are involved in the process of demonstrable and genuine community-led development. It is possible to produce something quick and dirty in that sort of timeframe, but the longevity of the relationship allows communities to build their capacity and their confidence and identify the things that are important to them. There might be some things that are pressing, but there will be other things that are under the surface, and having a little bit of time and support to be able to identify them brings huge benefits. Confidence is a significant outcome.Taking a step back, I point out that 500,000 acres of land in Scotland are owned by communities. In the past decade, HIE has supported the purchase of 320,000 acres by communities, so those communities are now living on land that they own. For example, two thirds of the population of the Outer Hebrides now live on land that they own, manage and develop. North Harris Trust took ownership of its estate 10 years ago. The population of those 62,000 acres of north Harris had declined by half in the preceding five decades, but the population is now returning. The trust has a competent and capable team of staff and represents an ambitious community. It has taken forward a range of development projects. It has built and let eight social housing units. It is considering turbine projects, as well as setting up industrial units for light industry, which will increase the economic opportunities in the area.I could go on, because the achievements of that community in the past 10 years have been absolutely phenomenal. The experience has been truly transformational, and came about as a result of investment by the community, HIE and a range of partner agencies.

Councillor Prag
link

She would say that, wouldn’t she?

Rachael McCormack Highlands and Islands Enterprise
link

And she does.

Councillor Prag
link

I am really glad that she did so as comprehensively as she did. However, I can speak as someone who is outside HIE. I have been involved in the Highlands since 1976, and will be for the rest of my life. Back then, confidence was pretty low. Population flows were still negative, particularly among the young people. That has changed. The reason for that is the issue of confidence. I notice, as I walk around and talk to people, that people are confident. They are still living in fragile areas, of course, so why are they confident? I think that it is because of the local knowledge and local understanding of HIE. People trust it and, therefore, are willing to work with it.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

The point that I was trying to come to is that the good practice over those five decades has allowed communities to engage fully in the process and to feel valued within the process.Councillor Prag, in your opening remarks, you made reference to the fact that there is urban deprivation as well as rural deprivation in the Highlands and you mentioned a particular street in Inverness that you would like to see being regenerated. How do you deal with the competing pressures in relation to regeneration and value for money that exist in deciding between a development in, say, the city of Inverness and regeneration that is aimed at dealing with the problems of deprivation in Wick, Thurso or Durness?

Councillor Prag
link

The nice simple answer is that that is challenging but they both matter, and they both matter to each other. For a big authority such as Highland Council, that is sometimes quite a tricky balance. We have councillors in Caithness who would always argue that we are not doing enough for Wick. Wick is quite a good example. It is an area that is not in the best of health, if I can put it that way—I walked round it recently—but it has potential, because of offshore wind and so on in the harbour area. We have done some work on that, as has HIE.How do we balance that against development in Inverness? We find the resources to do both—we do not do one or the other. We have to do both. However, it is also a city region, so Inverness has to be looked after as part of the region. We cannot just suddenly say, “Inverness is okay, so we’ll leave it. We won’t bother with it.” The rest of the Highlands is linked to it—Inverness is the heart.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

You mentioned that you had been involved in the Highlands since 1976 and you talked about depopulation in some of its rural areas. In some areas, that has been successfully turned around, but not in all areas. You mentioned Wick and the issues that it faces. How do you see Highland Council skewing its funding, particularly its capital expenditure, in the future to assist communities along the northern coast to fully engage economically with some of the opportunities that are currently available to them?

Councillor Prag
link

The answer is that we are already doing a lot. I am sorry, as this is going to sound like a love-in, but we do that together. Yesterday, there was a meeting of the Caithness and north Sutherland regeneration partnership, which I could not go to. That is a classic example of a partnership. It involves organisations such as HIE, Highland Council and the local chambers of commerce. A lot of work is being done there because of the Dounreay rundown. The plus with that is that we know the phasing and how it will work. The Caithness and north Sutherland regeneration partnership is heavily involved in that, and we work with it on that.Wick has different issues. It is a bit further away. I have forgotten your question; I think that it was about how we prioritise—

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

How do you engage with those communities to ensure that the council, when it can, drives some of the capital investment that could take place to assist them?

Councillor Prag
link

I will give you an example. We are producing new local plans for those areas. In Wick and Thurso, we held charrettes—I do not know whether you have come across them.

Councillor Prag
link

It is a dreadful word but a very good process and one that involves the local community. Communities have joined us and our planning colleagues in drafting their own plan, which is now being discussed and consulted on.I wrote down a few notes before I came to the meeting. Serendipity plays a big part, but serendipity needs a hand and that is where we get involved. In Wick’s case, it will probably be activity to do with offshore developments and the harbour that will help to spark off a lot of that. We can do whatever we like—we could put money into pedestrianisation and all the rest of it, but if the business is not there and the community’s heart is not in it, it will do nothing other than tidy up the street a bit. It needs to lead to the opening of new shops and new activity. If there is business that is likely to come into Wick, we need to help to ensure that that happens.Wick airport was recently renamed Wick John o’ Groats airport. That was a simple marketing exercise. It may sound silly, but that is the kind of thing that begins to change how a place feels about itself. John o’ Groats is now a very lovely place to visit. I ask any members who have been there in the past to please go again—it has been regenerated, through the involvement of partners such as Highland Council and HIE.11:15

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I am tempted to talk about the John o’ Groats signpost, but I will avoid that debate.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

I thought you might want to talk about Old Pulteney, but we will not go there either.We have heard a lot about difficulties with state aid. How have you overcome such barriers in some of the big projects that you have mentioned?

Councillor Prag
link

We thought that the topic might come up, so we nominated Rachael McCormack to discuss it.

Rachael McCormack Highlands and Islands Enterprise
link

I was telling colleagues about a question that came from the floor during the Development Trusts Association Scotland conference, which took place a week last Monday. I was surrounded by esteemed colleagues when a state aid question came up, and everybody looked at me, so I am quite happy to take your question.The provisions in the state aid legislation give us quite a lot of opportunity to support communities—and social enterprises and businesses—which is an important starting point. State aid is exactly what it says: aid from the state that allows things to happen that perhaps would not otherwise happen.There are a number of ways in which we can support communities through what is sometimes considered to be a bit of a minefield or a bumpy patch of legislation. The reality is that the legislation exists, so we must navigate a path through it. Along the path that HIE has trodden over time, we have evolved and developed a clear position statement—partly as a response to questions and demands from communities—regarding the issues arising from state aid.In doing so, we have worked with the Scottish Government state aid unit and a number of colleagues from the Big Lottery and others to consider the ways in which we can reach a much more transparent—and shared—position on state aid. One of the biggest frustrations for communities is the variation. When a project comes to me, I might deem it to be eligible for state aid and treat it in a particular way, whereas if it lands on the desk of the Big Lottery or a Government department, they might take a slightly different perspective on the issue. Regularising the systems and having a conversation about shared views on state aid so that we can send a message to communities will be a significant step forward as we progress the issue.That would be consistent with the approach that HIE has evolved, which involves looking at every project individually to produce a bespoke response, and considering opportunities for maximising the mechanisms that exist—not just de minimis, but where there are approved schemes in place.As an agency that deals a lot in the arena of state aid, which other agencies do not necessarily do, we can bring to the table expertise and knowledge about those schemes. We can share that with others, and say, “Here is an opportunity for a scheme that does not eat into or erode”—for that is how communities view it—“the de minimis three-year rolling window.”

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

It would be good if your knowledge could be shared across the country. You are the first person who has ever attempted to answer that question by beginning with positives—that is really good, and I thank you for it.We would be interested to hear more about your approach, and if you could write to the clerks to tell us how you have overcome some of the barriers that are often perceived to exist, it would be very useful for the committee.

Rachael McCormack Highlands and Islands Enterprise
link

I would be happy to do so.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

Picking up on what has just been said about state aid, the issue with regard to regeneration and a wide range of other areas, as I understand it, arises when public money is adjudged under state aid rules to distort competition. I am seeing heads nodding, which confirms my understanding of an issue that we all wrestle with.I am interested to know how we can minimise that. What common myths about constraints under state aid rules does HIE in particular encounter? During our inquiries in this area and in other areas, we find that people feel themselves constrained when, in reality, no such constraint operates. That is the view to which we are probably leading ourselves.

Rachael McCormack Highlands and Islands Enterprise
link

I think that that is for me again.

Councillor Prag
link

Yes, I think so.

Rachael McCormack Highlands and Islands Enterprise
link

I mentioned the group that we put together with the Big Lottery Fund and the Scottish Government’s state aid unit. That culminated in our internal business improvement and audit team, within which we have a remarkable individual, Mr Melvyn Waumsley, who is the state aid guru—we defer to him, although we now have significant knowledge on the issue across the organisation—producing a position statement paper. That has a focus on community enterprise, as that is where some of the issues have emerged in the recent past. The paper has been seen by our board, so it is a matter of public record, and I am happy to share it with the committee. We are in the process of talking to colleagues in other organisations about how we align much more closely and make common and shared decisions on state aid.One of the biggest issues that I face is the duck and cover response. Actually, the state aid rules present an opportunity, and I do not say that lightly. I have certainly learned a lot in the past 18 months about the state aid legislation, but I genuinely feel that there is an opportunity to reorientate and reposition on what has become a bit of a negative issue. If I can give a project only several hundred thousand pounds of state aid, surely we need to look at that as a good thing and not as a self-limiting thing. If we look at the situation as an opportunity, that allows us to move into different territory. That might involve public intervention. Recognising that state intervention is what it is, how do we invent the new, different and innovative approaches, routes or channels that mean that a project that we want to do can secure funding?A good example is a recent Scottish land fund award to a woodland project. State aid was an issue, because forestry is a primary activity and as a result the intervention rate is limited under the legislation to 20 per cent. The project involved a £1.5 million forest acquisition. We split it up and looked at the standing timber and the land, and the community was able to bring a commercial partner to the table with a significant sum of money, which enabled the bit of public sector money that was available to achieve the delivery of the whole project. That community can now proceed with the creation of woodland crofts, employment sites and a host of other things, because it identified that private sector partner to bring to the party. The situation has created an environment of innovation. That is where we have an opportunity with state aid, rather than a duck and cover response from me.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Briefly, please, Mr Stevenson.

Stewart Stevenson SNP Banffshire and Buchan Coast
link

Given that we are pretty clear that there is huge hidden self-constraint on the issue, which of necessity you cannot measure easily, I encourage HIE to be as public as possible in deconstructing those hidden constraints to which many people feel themselves subject, using the evidence base that you have. That would be extremely helpful.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

We would also love to see HIE’s position paper, if that is at all possible.

Rachael McCormack Highlands and Islands Enterprise
link

I am sure that it can be shared.

Stuart McMillan SNP West Scotland
link

Thank you, convener, although Stewart Stevenson just stole the question that I was going to pose. However, I have another one. Earlier, we heard about community involvement at Machrihanish and that about 70 per cent of the population had taken part in the wider community involvement operation.

Rachael McCormack Highlands and Islands Enterprise
link

To clarify that for the avoidance of doubt, that figure relates to the vote to go ahead with land ownership, rather than simply community involvement.

Stuart McMillan SNP West Scotland
link

Okay. Over the past decade or so, have there been any marked differences between urban and rural areas in relation to community involvement in schemes?

Councillor Prag
link

Your question goes to the heart of where communities work and where they do not. I have both in my ward, so I recognise that quite well. In some ways, the rural communities work an awful lot better—positively, as somebody said earlier—although not all of them, as one of them has more problems. They more naturally have something to hold them together, as people tend to know one another better. That is much harder to achieve in most urban areas.It comes back to a point that we make in our written submission, if I can drift off the question for a moment. Some communities are very good at leading stuff and coming forward with ideas because they have the right kind of people within them. Let us take the example of community broadband. There are areas where there are people with expertise who are able to put together schemes and come forward with ideas for funding and how the schemes can be progressed. There are other remote communities that, through no fault of their own, happen not to have the right kind of people. Should we leave them to wait and say, “Well, they’re not coming forward with anything”? We have no direct involvement with that but, in our view, our role is to support a community that does not naturally have that leadership or expertise. We should not lead from the top down, but we should not ignore the community just because it is not coming up with ideas itself. It is fashionable at the moment to say that the community must come forward. I totally agree with that, but some communities are not awfully good at that and in those communities it is our job, I think, to help things to happen.That is not a direct answer to your question, but it is an interesting issue that we feel strongly about. We must find the right approach for different communities, and that will sometimes mean our getting more involved.

Andy McCann Highland Council
link

It is an interesting question. How do we engage communities and get a community that has not been active to become active? Do we create the conditions for that? If so, what are those conditions?In certain parts of Highland where there were active groups, all that we had to do was provide cash, which became the catalyst for more activity taking place. However, in other areas and in small towns, our work with other groups has been much slower as people have been slower to get involved. Because of the Highlands geography, we have 11 local area partnerships. We recognised the opportunity provided by the LEADER programme and decided to give those partnerships an allocation of funding so that they knew that, if they put together a development plan and did the preliminary work, they would be guaranteed funding. That was the catalyst for those groups to come together. They were slower than communities in other areas to establish the projects and pull down the funding, but after two or three years they started to gain momentum. We had created the conditions for that. Indeed, in our expression of interest in the new LEADER programme, we said that it would be great if the funding allowed us to have an urban fund for Inverness so that we could try to do something similar there and offer that encouragement.

Rachael McCormack Highlands and Islands Enterprise
link

Early stage community organisation interventions are really important in creating the capacity for communities to be able to go on and think bigger things. For the best part of a decade, our assets team has provided access to expertise and a little bit of resource. As I mentioned earlier, that allows a group to be autonomous and make some decisions. We do not put whistles-and-bells caveats on how the money should be spent; we encourage the community to think about their trajectory, their governance and their constitution. Once they have gone through some of those early stage development processes, we encourage them to think about how they engage with a wider community.HIE would not today get involved in consulting community partners and residents, and I am not sure that we have got involved in that in the past. The dialogue is much more meaningful if it is led by the community, even if there is no strongly constituted community group—that is illustrated in Machrihanish, which is why I cited that example. There is more responsiveness and uptake if people think that they are all in it together, and there is a sentiment that things will happen if communities collaborate. Community land ownership in the Highlands and Islands region, as well as asset ownership—over 150 assets have been acquired by communities in the HIE region with HIE support over the past decade—shows other communities very visibly that they can do that. There is, therefore, a rationale and a purpose behind a community’s getting involved. People feel that they are not on a hiding to nothing because the same thing has been done in other places and they can have confidence that they can do it in their communities.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Thank you for your evidence, which has been very useful. I suspend the meeting for approximately 10 minutes for a comfort break.11:30 Meeting suspended.

11:40 On resuming—

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

I welcome our third and final panel of witnesses. Aubrey Fawcett is corporate director of environment, regeneration and resources and Stuart Jamieson is head of regeneration and planning at Inverclyde Council, and Allan McQuade is business infrastructure director at Scottish Enterprise. For this panel, we are also joined by Duncan McNeil MSP, whom I welcome to the meeting. I invite him to declare any interests that are relevant to the committee.

Duncan McNeil Lab Greenock and Inverclyde
link

I am not aware that I have any interests that I am required to declare to the committee, but I refer members to my declaration in the register of members’ interests.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Thank you. I will take your questions at the end, after I have given committee members an opportunity to put their questions.As members are aware, we have invited witnesses from all the urban regeneration companies in Scotland to give oral evidence as part of our inquiry; we will hear from other URCs at our meeting on 25 September. I start by asking our witnesses whether they would like to make an opening statement.

Allan McQuade Scottish Enterprise
link

No—we have no opening statement.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

I will start the questioning. Gentlemen, what were the original objectives of Riverside Inverclyde? What progress has been made to date in achieving those objectives? Who wants to start?

Aubrey Fawcett Inverclyde Council
link

I will kick off. We shared a paper with the committee, which I think has been circulated. I refer members to the start of that paper, which goes into detail on the objectives. Let me just get the right paper in front of me.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

Convener, for clarification, is Mr Fawcett referring to the paper that we received in confidence?

Aubrey Fawcett Inverclyde Council
link

That is correct.

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.