Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 25 April 2013 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 10 contributions · 2 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

10 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link


1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01315)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I thank Johann Lamont for the way in which she has expressed sympathy to Brian Adam’s family and friends.

Later today, we will carry forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
If Scotland votes yes in the referendum, the first budget for an independent Scotland will be set in 2016. Who would the First Minister prefer to sign it off—Ed Balls, George Osborne or Angela Merkel?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I must not pick the Cabinet in advance, and I must not say in advance of the Scottish people, but if the Scottish people back the Scottish National Party, given the way that things stand just now, that first budget will be set by John Swinney.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
We all know that that is not true, given what has been said in the past week. Despite the fact that the Government has deployed the First Minister, the Deputy First Minister and, indeed, John Swinney himself, it has been unable to answer the very simple question about the implications for Scotland of being in a sterling zone.

I agree with the First Minister that George Osborne is a slippery, untrustworthy man; I just do not understand why he thinks that that will change after the referendum. I agree that George Osborne’s fiscal and monetary policies are wrong for Scotland and for the whole United Kingdom, but it is Osborne with whom the First Minister will do the deal if he wins the referendum.

That is the difference between Alex Salmond and me. I want to get rid of the Tories and keep the union; he wants to get rid of the union and keep the Tories in charge of the economy.

Can the First Minister explain to me—and perhaps some of his colleagues—why that would be independence?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I point out that somewhere in that question Johann Lamont seemed to concede the first elections to an independent Scottish Parliament. If that is the case, I am absolutely delighted.

The arguments for a sterling area were set out in enormous detail by the fiscal commission some weeks ago. We can point out on the basis of last year’s figures—for example, the £4 billion relative surplus that Scotland had compared with the United Kingdom Treasury—the ample room for manoeuvre. Would that we had the ability now to generate the income that Scotland generated and use it to benefit the people of Scotland. That is the sort of flexibility over taxation and spending that Scotland would have as an independent country.

Johann Lamont is in an unfortunate position in that, even when she proposes an increase in flexibility over fiscal policy by control of income tax, the members of Parliament at Westminster whom she is meant to control describe it as being “dead in the water” and it does not even get discussed at the Scottish Labour conference. Perhaps it is not surprising that she is apparently conceding the first elections to an independent Scottish Parliament. The Labour Party should try harder to unite with its own MPs instead of uniting with George Osborne—that “slippery character”—in the better together campaign.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
Well, that felt like an infestation of squirrels, I have to say. We now seem to be in a position where we no longer cry freedom, we cry flexibility—whatever that might mean. The First Minister has yet to answer a simple question about the implications of his choice, with no plan B for the currency. John Swinney told the BBC that Scotland might leave the United Kingdom without paying any debts at all. It seems that while there are some who say that an independent Scotland might end up like Greece, John Swinney wants us to start off like Greece, by defaulting on our debts.

Four weeks ago, I asked the First Minister what his plan B was if we could not agree on a currency union. Like George Osborne, he said that there was no plan B. So, is his strategy to say, “Let us into a currency union or we won’t pay our debts”? If that fails, would not Salmond’s Scotland start off life as an international pariah without a currency?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Our position, as set out in the fiscal commission’s report, is that Scotland is entitled to a proportionate share of the assets of the United Kingdom and of the liabilities of the United Kingdom. That is the responsible position that we have put forward. As Mervyn King said before the committees of the House of Commons, the Bank of England is not just a bank of London; it is the bank of Scotland and the rest of the UK. What John Swinney was pointing out, and it is a realistic point to make, is that if George Osborne says that all of the monetary assets belong to him and the London Government, then by definition—as night follows day if one pursues that argument—so do the liabilities. People may have noticed that George Osborne and Alistair Darling between them have piled up an enormous number of liabilities over the past few years.

Johann Lamont criticises the Conservative Party. Can I just say to her that it is kind of difficult to do that when she is in alliance with the Conservative Party? She cannot say that she does not like what George Osborne is doing to Scotland, then campaign shoulder to shoulder with him in the better together campaign. We are in the remarkable position of having Alistair Darling, the leader of the better together campaign, saying—he said it on Saturday—that we must not believe a single thing that George Osborne says and that nothing that he says has any credibility. George Osborne says about Alistair Darling that anything that he said has no credibility and that politically he is a “dead man walking”. So two people who do not believe in each other’s credibility are the ones who are saying to Scotland what we cannot do.

However, we can be an independent country with control over our resources and taxation, and that will make Scotland much better off than the better together campaign would ever manage.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
The First Minister talks about credibility, but he changes his position on the currency more times than I change my shoes. The only consistent thing about his position on the currency is that it is not consistent—he does not say the same thing from one week to another. In addition, the First Minister talks about building up liabilities. Yes, we remember how those liabilities were built up: saving the Royal Bank of Scotland, the bank that the First Minister used to work for.

If the First Minister has no plan B, his position boils down simply to this: “Please, gonnae please, let us be in a currency union,” with no credibility about what he would take into the negotiation.

It is clear from the First Minister’s last response that he does not understand why this matters. He thinks that it is a bit of a game or a bit of a knockabout, but it matters to families worrying about what currency their wages will be paid in and how they will put food on the table. It matters to pensioners, who are entitled to know how their pensions will be paid. It matters to the person who has saved all their life and who now wonders what those savings will be worth if there is a yes vote. It matters to anyone who is paying off a mortgage, anyone with a job and anyone with a business.

What currency we have is a most basic question, and it is astonishing that the First Minister has been unable to answer it. But let us pause. What the First Minister is saying is that he wants a divorce but to keep the joint bank account. Is he not gambling with Scotland’s future on the basis of good will from neighbours we would just have rejected?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
When we published the report of the fiscal commission working group, which is an extensive document, we put forward in enormous detail why we think it is in Scotland’s interests to have a sterling area after independence and why it is overwhelmingly in the interests of the rest of the United Kingdom. There are a whole range of points about trade flows between Scotland and the rest of the United Kingdom, but probably the most substantial point is the Scottish resources—£58 billion—that would bankroll the sterling area. What on earth would happen to sterling if that was outside the sterling area? Therefore, we are dependent not on good will or munificence, just the obvious, overwhelming economic self-interest of the rest of the United Kingdom. That is perhaps why, when the chancellor was asked four times on “Newsnight” whether he was ruling it out, he refused to do so. Almost simultaneously, Danny Alexander was asked four times on the other programme, and he refused to rule it out.

Johann Lamont says that she does not know the SNP’s position, and I have just set out what the SNP’s position is. What is Labour’s position? Never mind Alistair Darling. On “Newsnight” on 30 May 2012, Ken Macintosh said to Gordon Brewer:

“Remember the five tests for joining the euro?”

Gordon Brewer said:

“Yes, is that still Labour’s—do you still have five tests?”

Ken Macintosh said:

“Five tests to join the Euro? Certainly.”

Maybe Johann Lamont should bring her own finance spokesman into line, never mind the MPs at Westminster.

Then, of course, we have independent adjudication of these matters, so let us turn to David Blanchflower, former member of the monetary policy committee, who was appointed by a Labour Government. This week, he said that there are

“no major obstacles at all to a currency union if both sides acted with an open mind.”

He said that the UK Government has

“just made it up: it’s political more than economic”.

He added:

“It’s certainly pretty likely, given how disastrous George Osborne has been, that if Scotland had had their own fiscal policy, they would’ve done better”.

He also said:

“Osborne lecturing the Scots on economics is like a freshman who failed Economics 101 giving the keynote address to the American Economic Association.”

I agree with David Blanchflower, the eminent economist whom the Labour Party appointed to the monetary policy committee.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Repeat Prescription Charges Questions · 6
  2. Prisoners (Throughcare and Support) Questions · 6
  3. Independence Referendum (Campaign Funding) Questions · 6
  4. Youth Unemployment Questions · 7
  5. Cod Recovery Plan Questions · 6
  6. NHS Lothian (Readmission Rates) Questions · 4
  7. Cattle and Sheep Farmers Questions · 4
  8. First Minister’s Question Time First Minister’s Questions · 3
  9. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 10
  10. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 15
  11. Nurses First Minister’s Questions · 4
  12. Scottish Banknotes First Minister’s Questions · 6
  13. Courts (Scientific Evidence) First Minister’s Questions · 4
  14. Energy (Tariff Comparison Rate) First Minister’s Questions · 5
  15. Workers Memorial Day Members’ business · 19
  16. Land and Buildings Transaction Tax (Scotland) Bill: Stage 1 Bill debate · 78
  17. Decision Time Decision time · 1

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.