Good morning, colleagues, and welcome to the first meeting in 2013 of the Referendum (Scotland) Bill Committee. I ask everyone to switch off mobile phones and so on. We have received apologies from Annabel Goldie, who is replaced today by John Lamont, and from Linda Fabiani, whose substitute is Bill Kidd. There are no other apologies.Item 1 on our agenda is our work programme, which gives the committee the opportunity to consider the timetable for the scrutiny of the forthcoming draft referendum franchise (Scotland) bill and draft referendum (Scotland) bill. The clerk’s paper sets out a potential timetable for both bills.It is not mentioned in the paper, but of course both bills will need to go before the Subordinate Legislation Committee if there is any secondary legislation in them and before the Finance Committee for its consideration. Those committees will need to peer in and fit around whatever we agree to be our timetable.The back of the clerk’s paper contains timetables that show in two separate columns how things could work for the franchise bill and the referendum bill. There are two options for the referendum bill that depend on the approach we want to take.The purpose of today’s meeting is to invite members’ comments on the two options and which one they prefer. We do not have to come to a decision today, but it would be helpful guidance for the clerks if they had an idea where the committee stands.I will hand over to you, folks. Who would like to kick off the discussion?
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Bruce Crawford only · show everyone- Bruce Crawford SNP 6
- Tavish Scott LD 3
- James Kelly Lab 2
- Rob Gibson SNP 2
- Annabelle Ewing SNP 2
- Patrick Harvie Green 1
- Stewart Maxwell SNP 1
- John Lamont Con 1
- Stuart McMillan SNP 1
- Patricia Ferguson Lab 1
Bruce Crawford’s contributions
6 contributionsThe only thing that the committee would need to do is to seek the Parliamentary Bureau’s approval to slip the timescales back. There would be a requirement on us to do that, but it is a technical possibility.
I realise that there are diverging views, but we will try to get a way forward that everyone can agree with. I tend to the optimistic perspective in life, and I look for a positive outcome; I try to look on everything that I do in that light.James Kelly makes a reasonable point in that the paragraph from the Deputy First Minister does not really give any detail on why the October deadline is required. There might be issues, particularly to do with the Gould recommendations, and it might be that, for technical reasons, certain things need to be done by a certain date, but we do not know that. Gould certainly requires all legislation to be in place six months before the poll, but I do not know at this stage—none of us knows—how much secondary legislation will be involved in the referendum bill.We should ask the Deputy First Minister for more information on why the October deadline is important and wait for that response before we nail our colours to the mast on the timetable option for the referendum bill. If we are convinced after the Deputy First Minister replies that there is a good rationale for the date, I suggest on the basis of what I have heard, and to help the clerks with their planning, that we go for option 1 rather than option 2. Is that reasonable?10:15
I am entirely relaxed about the option that we use. My suggestion was just based on the views that I heard.
It is good to hear people’s initial views—that is what we are doing today. Let us agree on the franchise bill timetable. We can write to the Deputy First Minister to find out the parameters in which the Government is working and whether there are technical reasons for the October deadline. When we have that response, we can look at the timetable for the referendum bill. If we are told that there are no particular reasons for the deadline of the end of October, it will be a bit easier to decide the timetable. Is doing things in that order reasonable?Members indicated agreement.
We agreed at a previous meeting that we would go into private for item 2 today. Any members who are not supposed to be here for that and any members of the public can now go.10:18 Meeting continued in private until 10:33.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.