1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01299)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Johann Lamont Lab 6
- Alex Salmond SNP 6
- Tricia Marwick 2
The record
14 contributions1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01299)
Meetings to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.
This afternoon, the Scottish Parliament will debate the legacy of Margaret Thatcher. Three months after Margaret Thatcher became Prime Minister, I became a teacher. I was a schoolteacher throughout her time in office. As a teacher, I saw first-hand how our young people had their hopes and aspirations extinguished by the decisions that she made.
I remember the challenge of trying to motivate teenagers who thought that studying was a waste of time because there were no jobs for them anyway. No one in this chamber wants a return to those days. The First Minister pledged that every 16 to 19-year-old in Scotland would have a guaranteed place in education or training. Has he achieved that goal?
I remember the challenge of trying to motivate teenagers who thought that studying was a waste of time because there were no jobs for them anyway. No one in this chamber wants a return to those days. The First Minister pledged that every 16 to 19-year-old in Scotland would have a guaranteed place in education or training. Has he achieved that goal?
The policy for 16 to 19-year-olds has been implemented and is, I suspect, one of a number of reasons why youth unemployment in Scotland has declined in the past year by a third from 25 to 17 per cent. Although that is still far, far too many, it is a substantial achievement. The guarantee for 16 to 19-year-olds, along with the substantial increase in apprenticeships in Scotland, is part of the programme that has led to that success.
I am not sure whether that means that the First Minister has or has not achieved his goal, so I will ask him another question. The First Minister promised that no young person should be left behind—who could disagree with that? How many 16 to 19-year-olds who left school before March this year do not have a place in education or training?
The guarantee for 16 to 19-year-olds is to make the offer to 16 to 19-year-olds—[Interruption.] Labour MSPs should reflect on what is happening elsewhere, in terms of the United Kingdom Government—[Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
What is happening elsewhere is that young people are being forced to work for no wages whatsoever. The guarantee for 16 to 19-year-olds, which is unparalleled across these islands, is a significant part of the offer to young people, which is resulting in substantial success.
The reduction in youth unemployment and the increase in youth employment is a substantial success. Every member in this chamber should recognise it as such and take pride in the fact that the Parliament, through initiatives that we are taking, is making a real difference to one of the great corrosive issues—youth unemployment—that affect our society.
Members can say that there are far too many young people who are still unemployed—of course there are—but not to recognise that a reduction of that extent in a single year has something to do with the initiatives taken by this Parliament, the 60 or 70 per cent increase in apprenticeships in Scotland and the youth training guarantee for 16 to 19-year-olds, is to deny the reality that significant moves made by this Government and this Parliament are resulting in benefits to the young people of Scotland.
The reduction in youth unemployment and the increase in youth employment is a substantial success. Every member in this chamber should recognise it as such and take pride in the fact that the Parliament, through initiatives that we are taking, is making a real difference to one of the great corrosive issues—youth unemployment—that affect our society.
Members can say that there are far too many young people who are still unemployed—of course there are—but not to recognise that a reduction of that extent in a single year has something to do with the initiatives taken by this Parliament, the 60 or 70 per cent increase in apprenticeships in Scotland and the youth training guarantee for 16 to 19-year-olds, is to deny the reality that significant moves made by this Government and this Parliament are resulting in benefits to the young people of Scotland.
First, and depressingly, we know that if the figures had gone in the other direction, the First Minister would not have taken responsibility for bad news.
My second point, which is a serious one—I am thinking again about the young people whom I taught in the 1980s—is that long-term youth unemployment is disproportionately higher in Scotland than it is in the rest of the United Kingdom. That is why the issue of the offer—not the guarantee—to 16 to 19-year-olds is so important. The First Minister does not seem to know the answer to the question I asked. In private, though, he does know because, under freedom of information legislation, we have established that Skills Development Scotland has identified more than 7,000 school leavers who are known to be looking for a job or training but have yet to find a place. However, it is worse than that. SDS has also admitted that it has lost more than 17,000 school leavers: it does not know what 17,000 school leavers are doing or where they are. If we do not know where they are, how do we protect them and prevent them from becoming the long-term unemployed who we know have suffered over the past year?
In that context, what are the First Minister’s pledges worth when a guarantee has now become an offer, and the offer has not been delivered?
My second point, which is a serious one—I am thinking again about the young people whom I taught in the 1980s—is that long-term youth unemployment is disproportionately higher in Scotland than it is in the rest of the United Kingdom. That is why the issue of the offer—not the guarantee—to 16 to 19-year-olds is so important. The First Minister does not seem to know the answer to the question I asked. In private, though, he does know because, under freedom of information legislation, we have established that Skills Development Scotland has identified more than 7,000 school leavers who are known to be looking for a job or training but have yet to find a place. However, it is worse than that. SDS has also admitted that it has lost more than 17,000 school leavers: it does not know what 17,000 school leavers are doing or where they are. If we do not know where they are, how do we protect them and prevent them from becoming the long-term unemployed who we know have suffered over the past year?
In that context, what are the First Minister’s pledges worth when a guarantee has now become an offer, and the offer has not been delivered?
The employment rate for 16 to 24-year-olds in Scotland is now 56.7 per cent. That compares with a UK level of 49.7 per cent. The unemployment rate is 16.1 per cent, which compares with the UK level of 20.6 per cent. The economic inactivity level is 32 per cent, compared with a UK level of 37 per cent. By any standard, that is a substantial success in the most difficult economic climate.
Johann Lamont says that we take the credit for that. I think that, when the number of apprenticeships is hugely increased, and when that offer is made to 16 to 19-year-olds, this Parliament is entitled to take satisfaction in the substantial improvement in the situation that faces young people in Scotland.
I can tell Johann Lamont that, in terms of the destination of people leaving school, which we have measured exactly over the past few years, we know that, in 2011-12, 89.9 per cent of youngsters went to a positive destination. That compares with a figure in 2006-07—not during the recession times—of 86.6 per cent.
We should reflect for a second on what that means. Not only has there been, over the past year, a substantial improvement in young people getting jobs and apprenticeships and getting a good start in life after the recession, but the destinations of our school leavers are more positive for more youngsters than they were in the good times when the Labour Party was in charge in this Parliament, by any measure.
Can Johann Lamont not find it within herself to say, “Look—something really important is happening here. Perhaps we should follow the apprenticeship programme, which is proving to be such a success. Perhaps there is something to be said for this youth guarantee in helping young people who are getting the tough end of life”? Is there not something for this entire Parliament to welcome in the demonstration that, although effective action cannot solve every problem, it has resulted in a substantial improvement that is affecting the lives and welfare of tens of thousands of young people in Scotland?
Johann Lamont says that we take the credit for that. I think that, when the number of apprenticeships is hugely increased, and when that offer is made to 16 to 19-year-olds, this Parliament is entitled to take satisfaction in the substantial improvement in the situation that faces young people in Scotland.
I can tell Johann Lamont that, in terms of the destination of people leaving school, which we have measured exactly over the past few years, we know that, in 2011-12, 89.9 per cent of youngsters went to a positive destination. That compares with a figure in 2006-07—not during the recession times—of 86.6 per cent.
We should reflect for a second on what that means. Not only has there been, over the past year, a substantial improvement in young people getting jobs and apprenticeships and getting a good start in life after the recession, but the destinations of our school leavers are more positive for more youngsters than they were in the good times when the Labour Party was in charge in this Parliament, by any measure.
Can Johann Lamont not find it within herself to say, “Look—something really important is happening here. Perhaps we should follow the apprenticeship programme, which is proving to be such a success. Perhaps there is something to be said for this youth guarantee in helping young people who are getting the tough end of life”? Is there not something for this entire Parliament to welcome in the demonstration that, although effective action cannot solve every problem, it has resulted in a substantial improvement that is affecting the lives and welfare of tens of thousands of young people in Scotland?
It is interesting that, although the First Minister can find lots and lots of figures to trade with me, he cannot answer the question about the 7,000 young people without education or training and the 17,000 people whose whereabouts we do not even know.
One of the lessons that I learned in the 1980s as a schoolteacher was that, when politicians talk to one another and trade figures, they ignore the reality of what is happening to communities throughout Scotland. We cannot allow that to happen again. I ask the First Minister not to trade figures about the bits that he is happy with, but to listen and think about what his own agency is saying, and what is happening to some of our young people. We know that one in every six school leavers is either out of work or out of training, or we do not even know what their status is.
The problem for this Government is that it starts with a slogan, but it cuts careers officers and college places and then denies the truth. The First Minister thinks that politics is about process and good news stories, but it is not. It is about taking hard choices and changing people’s lives. He talks, to bolster his argument, about 25,000 apprenticeships, but he gets to that figure by calling 10,000 people who are already in work for six months apprentices. He cuts college funding—[Interruption.]
One of the lessons that I learned in the 1980s as a schoolteacher was that, when politicians talk to one another and trade figures, they ignore the reality of what is happening to communities throughout Scotland. We cannot allow that to happen again. I ask the First Minister not to trade figures about the bits that he is happy with, but to listen and think about what his own agency is saying, and what is happening to some of our young people. We know that one in every six school leavers is either out of work or out of training, or we do not even know what their status is.
The problem for this Government is that it starts with a slogan, but it cuts careers officers and college places and then denies the truth. The First Minister thinks that politics is about process and good news stories, but it is not. It is about taking hard choices and changing people’s lives. He talks, to bolster his argument, about 25,000 apprenticeships, but he gets to that figure by calling 10,000 people who are already in work for six months apprentices. He cuts college funding—[Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
I am asking the First Minister to think about doing the hard stuff. He cuts college funding, but tells the Parliament that it is going up. Now we know what he knew: that 17,000 school leavers have simply disappeared—and that is according to the Government. Please, in this week of all weeks, will the First Minister learn that lesson, put down the slogans and start doing his job?
I know that Johann Lamont does not like the figures, but she should perhaps reflect on the fact that I just gave her the figure for school leavers reaching positive destinations—something that we have now identified exactly. That shows not just a recovery since the recession, but a situation that is better than when Labour was in power.
During that question, Johann Lamont said something particularly interesting. She tried to suggest that the number of apprenticeships—16,000 to almost 26,000—is not a real figure, because the percentage of people in work for six months is high. The percentage of apprenticeships going to people in work for six months is lower than it was when the Labour Party was in office. In other words, there are more people not in work among the 26,000 now than there were, as a percentage, when the Labour Party was in office. How on earth can that be presented as anything with a semblance of an argument?
It is important to learn lessons. The key lesson that I would learn from the years of Margaret Thatcher is that political parties that go into coalition with the Conservatives in campaigns in Scotland will have exactly the same fate as the Conservative Party. Johann Lamont, in believing that she can campaign hand in glove with better together but that people in Scotland will not draw the obvious conclusion about the direction of her politics, is living in a fantasy land. She and her party will pay the highest price for their joint cabal and campaign with the Conservative Party. That is a certain conclusion that the people of Scotland will draw.
During that question, Johann Lamont said something particularly interesting. She tried to suggest that the number of apprenticeships—16,000 to almost 26,000—is not a real figure, because the percentage of people in work for six months is high. The percentage of apprenticeships going to people in work for six months is lower than it was when the Labour Party was in office. In other words, there are more people not in work among the 26,000 now than there were, as a percentage, when the Labour Party was in office. How on earth can that be presented as anything with a semblance of an argument?
It is important to learn lessons. The key lesson that I would learn from the years of Margaret Thatcher is that political parties that go into coalition with the Conservatives in campaigns in Scotland will have exactly the same fate as the Conservative Party. Johann Lamont, in believing that she can campaign hand in glove with better together but that people in Scotland will not draw the obvious conclusion about the direction of her politics, is living in a fantasy land. She and her party will pay the highest price for their joint cabal and campaign with the Conservative Party. That is a certain conclusion that the people of Scotland will draw.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 18 Apr 2013 →- Child Abuse (Interaction Meeting) Questions · 8
- Local Bus Services Questions · 6
- Flooding (North East Scotland) Questions · 8
- Planning Law Reform (Retail Units) Questions · 5
- Golden Eagles (Protection) Questions · 9
- Pension and Social Welfare Costs (Affordability) Questions · 4
- Oil Test Drilling (Ayrshire Coast) Questions · 4
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 14
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 9
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Public Finances (Assessment) First Minister’s Questions · 8
- Edinburgh to Glasgow Improvement Programme First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Third Sector Early Intervention Fund First Minister’s Questions · 5
- Scotland’s Butchers Members’ business · 13
- Society Debate · 147
- Decision Time Decision time · 1
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.