1. On this day, when we are all thinking of the soldiers’ lives that have been lost abroad, and the families who are grieving at the loss of those brave men, I ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01332)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Johann Lamont Lab 7
- Alex Salmond SNP 7
- Tricia Marwick 4
The record
18 contributions1. On this day, when we are all thinking of the soldiers’ lives that have been lost abroad, and the families who are grieving at the loss of those brave men, I ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01332)
Johann Lamont rightly reflects on the loss this week of three Scottish soldiers. I know that the whole Parliament will want to pay tribute to Corporal William Savage, Fusilier Samuel Flint and Private Robert Hetherington, of the Royal Regiment of Scotland, who died while serving in operations in Afghanistan.
We must also hope that the other six brave personnel who were injured in the explosion make a speedy and full recovery from their injuries. The incident demonstrates once again the dangers that are faced by our armed forces, who deserve our deepest gratitude for the job that they do in the most difficult and trying circumstances.
In this chamber, different views are, rightly, often expressed on the wisdom of military interventions in a variety of places in the world, but there is not, and never has been, any division whatever, in any party in this Parliament, about the respect in which we hold our armed forces for the sacrifices that they make.
No words, of course, can bring comfort to the families of soldiers at a time like this, but the thoughts and sympathies of everyone in Scotland on hearing this dreadful news will be with them as they cope in these dreadful times.
We must also hope that the other six brave personnel who were injured in the explosion make a speedy and full recovery from their injuries. The incident demonstrates once again the dangers that are faced by our armed forces, who deserve our deepest gratitude for the job that they do in the most difficult and trying circumstances.
In this chamber, different views are, rightly, often expressed on the wisdom of military interventions in a variety of places in the world, but there is not, and never has been, any division whatever, in any party in this Parliament, about the respect in which we hold our armed forces for the sacrifices that they make.
No words, of course, can bring comfort to the families of soldiers at a time like this, but the thoughts and sympathies of everyone in Scotland on hearing this dreadful news will be with them as they cope in these dreadful times.
I thank the First Minister for what he said. He speaks for all of us in sending our sympathies and condolences to the families, and our very good wishes to those who are injured.
After the past 10 days, is not it the case that the First Minister’s plans on currency and Scottish pensions are in exactly the same condition as his receipts for his half-a-million-pounds trip to the Ryder cup—completely and utterly shredded?
After the past 10 days, is not it the case that the First Minister’s plans on currency and Scottish pensions are in exactly the same condition as his receipts for his half-a-million-pounds trip to the Ryder cup—completely and utterly shredded?
The Scottish Government has put forward the policy that we believe is in the best interests of Scotland and, indeed, the rest of the United Kingdom. I have to say that the Labour party’s arguing that it has any consistency or credibility in its currency policy does not bear examination.
I suppose on the question of currency, with so many supporters advising—[Interruption.]
I suppose on the question of currency, with so many supporters advising—[Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
Given that so many supporters advise that the policy that is advocated by the Scottish Government is correct, I would, on balance, agree with Alistair Darling, who said on 10 January on “Newsnight Scotland” that
“Of course it would be desirable to have a currency union ... of course a currency union is logical”.
Therefore I can say to the Parliament, for the only time in this First Minister’s question time, and probably others: I agree, on this subject, with Alistair Darling.
“Of course it would be desirable to have a currency union ... of course a currency union is logical”.
Therefore I can say to the Parliament, for the only time in this First Minister’s question time, and probably others: I agree, on this subject, with Alistair Darling.
I am not sure that it was worth the First Minister’s while to hunt through his folder to find that line. Also, for the First Minister to talk about consistency and the currency in one sentence is bizarre for the rest of us.
The First Minister said this week that he will bet his career and his house on a yes vote in the referendum. Is not that wonderful? Who else shares his confidence? Hands up those on the front bench who will bet their career and their house on a yes vote. [Interruption.]
The First Minister said this week that he will bet his career and his house on a yes vote in the referendum. Is not that wonderful? Who else shares his confidence? Hands up those on the front bench who will bet their career and their house on a yes vote. [Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
There are obviously no takers there. Let us try the back benchers. Which members behind the front bench—who have no career, but have a house—would bet their houses on a yes vote? Will they put their hands up? No? How about hands up those who support a separate Scottish currency? Maybe they do that only in private, when the First Minister is not watching.
Of course, the First Minister’s macho acclamation of his willingness to risk all, to show how much he believes in himself, is not the point. Is not it the case that the First Minister’s career and the First Minister’s house do not matter, and that what does matter is that he is taking a gamble with everyone’s house and everyone’s job, with a currency plan that he has evidently not thought through?
Of course, the First Minister’s macho acclamation of his willingness to risk all, to show how much he believes in himself, is not the point. Is not it the case that the First Minister’s career and the First Minister’s house do not matter, and that what does matter is that he is taking a gamble with everyone’s house and everyone’s job, with a currency plan that he has evidently not thought through?
That worked about as well for Johann Lamont as it did for Ed Miliband previously, when he tried it in the House of Commons.
The big risk in Scottish politics is the risk to the Labour Party in the gamble that it is taking in campaigning hand in hand and shoulder to shoulder with the Conservative Party in the better together campaign. Therefore, we should ask ourselves whether, in the better together campaign, Labour policy has been totally subsumed by the Conservative Party. [Interruption.] I think that means “Yes.”
I have been looking at the policy positions of the better together parties at the previous general election. The only party that said “never” to the euro was the Conservative Party. The Labour Party’s 2010 manifesto said that there would be
“no membership ... without ... a referendum.”
The Liberal Democrats said that they
“believe that it is in Britain’s long-term interest to be part of the euro.”
Therefore, I think that it is fairly reasonable for Johann Lamont to accept the Scottish Government policy in favour of a sterling area and the substantial support that that has. What is interesting is the suggestion that the better together campaign has a singly policy. It has three policies—one for every party in it. The danger for the Labour Party in campaigning hand in hand with the Conservative Party is that it is gambling its future with the Scottish people.
The big risk in Scottish politics is the risk to the Labour Party in the gamble that it is taking in campaigning hand in hand and shoulder to shoulder with the Conservative Party in the better together campaign. Therefore, we should ask ourselves whether, in the better together campaign, Labour policy has been totally subsumed by the Conservative Party. [Interruption.] I think that means “Yes.”
I have been looking at the policy positions of the better together parties at the previous general election. The only party that said “never” to the euro was the Conservative Party. The Labour Party’s 2010 manifesto said that there would be
“no membership ... without ... a referendum.”
The Liberal Democrats said that they
“believe that it is in Britain’s long-term interest to be part of the euro.”
Therefore, I think that it is fairly reasonable for Johann Lamont to accept the Scottish Government policy in favour of a sterling area and the substantial support that that has. What is interesting is the suggestion that the better together campaign has a singly policy. It has three policies—one for every party in it. The danger for the Labour Party in campaigning hand in hand with the Conservative Party is that it is gambling its future with the Scottish people.
Meanwhile, back in the real world, all the people who thought that perhaps the First Minister had a case will now realise that he has no case whatever. The First Minister says that we will keep the pound; the chair of the yes campaign says that we should have a separate Scottish currency and then prepare to join the euro. To put it most kindly, that is a complete shambles.
The First Minister said that the previous Chancellor of the Exchequer was responsible for the Royal Bank of Scotland nearly going under—the bank that the First Minister used to work for—[Interruption.] I am sorry; I thought that the SNP knew that he used to work for the RBS. Never mind. He now claims that the current chancellor has no control over the Bank of England. You simply could not make it up. The people of Scotland deserve honesty and clarity. This is not about the First Minister’s bravado and gambling, or about a smart soundbite for him; this is about people’s jobs, homes, mortgages, pensions and savings.
Members: Same old, same old.
The First Minister said that the previous Chancellor of the Exchequer was responsible for the Royal Bank of Scotland nearly going under—the bank that the First Minister used to work for—[Interruption.] I am sorry; I thought that the SNP knew that he used to work for the RBS. Never mind. He now claims that the current chancellor has no control over the Bank of England. You simply could not make it up. The people of Scotland deserve honesty and clarity. This is not about the First Minister’s bravado and gambling, or about a smart soundbite for him; this is about people’s jobs, homes, mortgages, pensions and savings.
Members: Same old, same old.
It may be “same old, same old” to the SNP back benchers, but this is about people’s jobs, homes, mortgages, pensions and savings. That is not “Same old, same old”, apart from for the group of separatists; it is about the real world. For the sake of clarity, will the First Minister now rule out a separate Scottish currency?
I have news for Johann Lamont. What got the Royal Bank of Scotland, Northern Rock and many other financial institutions into trouble was not the Bank of England’s control of interest rates but, partly, the Financial Services Authority’s lack of regulation of the banking system. [Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
Which mastermind was, as Chancellor of the Exchequer, in control of the FSA during that period? It was the same person who is now in control of the no campaign in Scotland—Alistair Darling.
Perhaps we should have a glance at the reports into the near collapse of the banking system and look at the roles of Gordon Brown, Ed Balls and Tony Blair, and the responsibility that they have been allocated in terms of their attitude and their lack of control and vigilance over the financial system.
We have put forward the Government’s viewpoint—which is supported by more Nobel laureates than you can shake a stick at, and by former members of the monetary policy committee of the Bank of England—that it would be in the interests of Scotland and the rest of the UK to share sterling.
Let me quote another expert. This time it is Simon Lee, from the University of Hull, who on Radio Scotland this week, said:
“For England and the rest of the UK, there would be major advantages of having Scotland remaining as part of a continuing monetary Union and monetary stability pact.”
That serious analysis puts forward the view that it is in the interests of Scotland and the rest of the UK. Perhaps that is why, when the current Chancellor of the Exchequer and the Chief Secretary to the Treasury came up to Scotland last week, at no point in all their interviews, and despite the bluff and bluster, did they say no. They know that the policy is in the interests of Scotland and the rest of the UK.
Perhaps we should have a glance at the reports into the near collapse of the banking system and look at the roles of Gordon Brown, Ed Balls and Tony Blair, and the responsibility that they have been allocated in terms of their attitude and their lack of control and vigilance over the financial system.
We have put forward the Government’s viewpoint—which is supported by more Nobel laureates than you can shake a stick at, and by former members of the monetary policy committee of the Bank of England—that it would be in the interests of Scotland and the rest of the UK to share sterling.
Let me quote another expert. This time it is Simon Lee, from the University of Hull, who on Radio Scotland this week, said:
“For England and the rest of the UK, there would be major advantages of having Scotland remaining as part of a continuing monetary Union and monetary stability pact.”
That serious analysis puts forward the view that it is in the interests of Scotland and the rest of the UK. Perhaps that is why, when the current Chancellor of the Exchequer and the Chief Secretary to the Treasury came up to Scotland last week, at no point in all their interviews, and despite the bluff and bluster, did they say no. They know that the policy is in the interests of Scotland and the rest of the UK.
I think that there were more squirrels there than you could shake a stick at. One would think that the First Minister had never argued for lighter-touch regulation of the banking system and that he had never written that letter to Fred Goodwin, saying “Go on yourself—that’s absolutely brilliant!” before he departed the Royal Bank of Scotland.
However, one thing that we note from that response is that the First Minister did not answer the question. The fact is that although he is trying to break up Britain, the only things that are breaking up are his arguments and campaign. The currency union between the Czech Republic and Slovakia lasted just six weeks—if only the First Minister could hold on to a policy position for that long.
Seriously—Scotland is on pause while he punts his fantasy arguments. Only one thing is consistent: we cannot trust the First Minister on anything. On apprenticeships, he took 10,000 people who were already in jobs and called them apprentices. [Interruption.] We all know it. He said that he had abolished hidden waiting lists when he had fiddled them, and then he told us that he was increasing college spending when he was slashing it. Is not it the most accurate answer ever given to any Parliament anywhere that we cannot trust a word that the First Minister says?
However, one thing that we note from that response is that the First Minister did not answer the question. The fact is that although he is trying to break up Britain, the only things that are breaking up are his arguments and campaign. The currency union between the Czech Republic and Slovakia lasted just six weeks—if only the First Minister could hold on to a policy position for that long.
Seriously—Scotland is on pause while he punts his fantasy arguments. Only one thing is consistent: we cannot trust the First Minister on anything. On apprenticeships, he took 10,000 people who were already in jobs and called them apprentices. [Interruption.] We all know it. He said that he had abolished hidden waiting lists when he had fiddled them, and then he told us that he was increasing college spending when he was slashing it. Is not it the most accurate answer ever given to any Parliament anywhere that we cannot trust a word that the First Minister says?
I was fascinated by the argument that the Scottish National Party does not have consistency on policy. If I remember correctly, Johann Lamont’s latest policy on devolution for Scotland did not last six hours at the Labour Party conference.
Not for the first time, I point out to Johann Lamont that the more than 60 per cent increase in apprenticeships and the decline in youth unemployment from 25 to 16 per cent over the past year or so should be claimed as a substantial success. Her argument that that takes into account people who were already in work is nullified by the fact that there is a lower percentage of new apprentices going to people in work than when the Labour Party was in power with a reduced number of apprentices.
Now that I have explained it for—I think—the third time, perhaps Johann Lamont will not ask the question again, because it is clearly without any foundation whatever. The success that we are having with apprentices is a good thing for Scotland, as is the success that we are having in getting young people into work.
In her general line of attacking the Government’s record, Johann Lamont is doing nothing differently from her three predecessors, who did exactly the same thing. It is no different from Labour’s negativity and approach to the last election—I see Iain Gray sitting on the back benches—when it rubbished and diminished everything about Scotland’s potential, which is exactly Labour’s attitude to the question of currency. This is the country with the stronger budgetary position and a surplus in its balance of trade; the idea that we should be beholden to a country that is in a worse fiscal position and which has a deficit in its balance of trade is simply incredible.
The Labour Party’s negativity and its running down of Scotland is precisely the reason why, exactly two years ago, the people of Scotland passed their verdict on it, which is why its members are sitting on the Opposition benches in such diminished numbers. [Applause.]
Not for the first time, I point out to Johann Lamont that the more than 60 per cent increase in apprenticeships and the decline in youth unemployment from 25 to 16 per cent over the past year or so should be claimed as a substantial success. Her argument that that takes into account people who were already in work is nullified by the fact that there is a lower percentage of new apprentices going to people in work than when the Labour Party was in power with a reduced number of apprentices.
Now that I have explained it for—I think—the third time, perhaps Johann Lamont will not ask the question again, because it is clearly without any foundation whatever. The success that we are having with apprentices is a good thing for Scotland, as is the success that we are having in getting young people into work.
In her general line of attacking the Government’s record, Johann Lamont is doing nothing differently from her three predecessors, who did exactly the same thing. It is no different from Labour’s negativity and approach to the last election—I see Iain Gray sitting on the back benches—when it rubbished and diminished everything about Scotland’s potential, which is exactly Labour’s attitude to the question of currency. This is the country with the stronger budgetary position and a surplus in its balance of trade; the idea that we should be beholden to a country that is in a worse fiscal position and which has a deficit in its balance of trade is simply incredible.
The Labour Party’s negativity and its running down of Scotland is precisely the reason why, exactly two years ago, the people of Scotland passed their verdict on it, which is why its members are sitting on the Opposition benches in such diminished numbers. [Applause.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 2 May 2013 →- Tourism (Air Passenger Duty) Questions · 6
- Social Housing (Regulations) Questions · 4
- Business Improvement Districts Questions · 4
- Equality Questions · 6
- Independence Referendum (Spending Limits) Questions · 4
- Manufacturing (Support) Questions · 7
- Modern Languages (Primary Schools) Questions · 4
- Gaelic Questions · 4
- Life Sciences (Technology Innovation Centres) Questions · 5
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 18
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Proceeds of Crime (Communities) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Pensions Regulations First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Modern Languages (Secondary Schools) First Minister’s Questions · 5
- Blacklisting Members’ business · 33
- Motion of Condolence Procedure · 6
- Community Justice System Debate · 37
- Decision Time Decision time · 8
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.