Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Regeneration

Wednesday 12 June 2013 Local Government and Regeneration Committee About 10:00 Evidence session 266 contributions · 17 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

266 contributions · showing 1–200
Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Item 3 is an oral evidence session on our inquiry into the delivery of regeneration in Scotland. This is the first formal evidence session that we have held in this important inquiry, although the committee has already undertaken fact-finding visits to Aberdeen, Cumbernauld and Glasgow to meet local communities and learn from their experiences of regeneration. We plan to undertake further fact-finding visits after the summer recess and to hear from community representatives at our meeting next week. Today we have two panels of witnesses. The first will look at the importance of the housing sector to regeneration policy. I welcome David Fletcher, assistant director of regeneration, Glasgow Housing Association; Dr Colleen Rowan, membership and policy officer, Glasgow and West of Scotland Forum of Housing Associations; Craig Sanderson, chief executive, Link Group Ltd; Pauline Barbour, policy consultant, Scottish Federation of Housing Associations; and Gavin Corbett, policy adviser, Shelter Scotland. I understand that, for some of you, this is your first time before a parliamentary committee. We do not normally bite, so just relax.Gavin Corbett, would you like to make some opening remarks?

Gavin Corbett Shelter Scotland
link

I am happy to go straight to questions.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Does anybody else want to say anything? It seems that you want to go straight to the questions—I like you guys straight off. I will start the ball rolling.The committee has been doing its rounds and it has been holding an inquiry into public service reform. We have looked quite closely at community planning partnerships, which obviously have a part to play in regeneration. What is your experience of community planning partnerships? Are they working for you or not? If not, what is not right about them? Gavin, I will pick on you again.

Gavin Corbett Shelter Scotland
link

That is fine. I will probably bow to some of my colleagues due to their experience on the ground, but I can give my perception of community planning partnerships in Edinburgh. The purpose of integration between public authorities, the voluntary sector and other partners is important. At neighbourhood level, there is a big gap between what people regard as neighbourhoods and how neighbourhoods typically are characterised in partnerships. I am thinking about where I stay in Edinburgh. In the community planning partnership that I am part of, there are at least 10 or 11 communities at neighbourhood level. That begs the question of how we reinforce the ability of those neighbourhoods, as people understand them, to play a meaningful part in community planning partnerships. We are a long way from getting that right yet, but I am sure that my colleagues can give details of their own experiences.

Pauline Barbour Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

The main point that the SFHA membership would make on that question is that we have found that the community planning partnerships do not often include housing as standard in their membership, and we would really like to see housing at the table because of our involvement with health and social work. Everything has to be there, and housing is an integral part of community planning.

Craig Sanderson Link Group Ltd
link

I agree. Since the demise of Communities Scotland, there has not been a high enough representation of housing interests at community planning partnership level. Communities Scotland used to have a place on all the partnerships, but the housing contribution to the debate is now sometimes missing.We work across about 24 local authority areas. The performance of CPPs is mixed around the country, but we always get comments and feedback from local community members who do not feel that they are a strong enough part of the partnerships. The CPPs seem to be dominated by local authorities and by the other agencies; health agencies and the police tend to have a right to be on CPPs, but there appears to be scope for others to have a place at the top table.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

My experience tells me that some of the work that is done with housing is often done in sub-groups of the community planning partnerships. Is that your experience?

Craig Sanderson Link Group Ltd
link

That is correct.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

At that level, does the system work okay? Is information fed up the chain?

Craig Sanderson Link Group Ltd
link

Sometimes, yes. I could name local authorities that are doing better than others, but I will not—

Craig Sanderson Link Group Ltd
link

No, I will not. Laughter.Housing has to be seen to have a place at the top table, as it is strategically important. There must also be community representation at that level.

Dr Colleen Rowan Glasgow and West of Scotland Forum of Housing Associations
link

I echo the previous comments. The issue of representation and having a seat at the table has been a problem for our members. However, the community planning partnership structure in Glasgow is in the process of changing, and we hope to get a seat above the sub-group level. Our members want that representation, and we feel that it is an arena where we need to be represented. I also reiterate the point about the geographical level at which CPPs operate. Decisions taken at that level often bear no relationship to what people at the micro or neighbourhood level want or feel is needed in their local communities.

David Fletcher Glasgow Housing Association
link

I broadly agree with what my colleagues have said. I know from GHA’s engagement, both at strategic level and at sub-group level in the Glasgow community planning partnership, that a lot depends on how organisations resource their involvement and what they invest. There will be an understandable mix of experience, even across the city, in that regard. We need to guard against any misunderstanding of the language related to community planning. In a past life, I was involved in the Glasgow community planning task force—the forerunner of the community planning structures—when I worked in the Easterhouse area for the Glasgow Alliance. Much of the legislation tried to enshrine ways of working across mainstream partners, including police, social work and the local authority in all its guises, and there were complementary arrangements—at that point, they were still to be fully tested—for engagement with local communities. I think that we have a way to go to crack neighbourhood engagement and to connect better with that strategic way of working across the city.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Are there representatives from regeneration communities in the membership of the bodies that the witnesses represent? If so, at what level are they represented?

David Fletcher Glasgow Housing Association
link

At city level, our chief executive and the chair of the board engage in strategic forums in community planning. Below that, at sub-city level, Glasgow splits into three strategic planning areas. Our respective area directors, who have housing management and regeneration staff within their functions, routinely attend the meetings at that level. You are correct that there is sometimes a plethora of other sub-groups and working groups that present themselves at more of a neighbourhood level. Area housing managers and the like normally participate at that level.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Are there no ordinary punters, if you like, at board level or some kind of other senior discussion level in your organisation?

David Fletcher Glasgow Housing Association
link

In our own organisation?

David Fletcher Glasgow Housing Association
link

Yes. There are tenants at board level and tenant-led area committees.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Do they have a strong voice in your organisation?

David Fletcher Glasgow Housing Association
link

Very much so. We try to reinforce that with some devolvement of moneys directly to tenant members in the area committees in order to support local programmes of activity.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

What about the others in your organisation, Dr Rowan?

Dr Rowan
link

Could you clarify the question?

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

How many ordinary folk from regeneration communities take part at a high level in the organisations that you represent?

Dr Rowan
link

Local people involved in regeneration in communities are represented throughout our member organisations. Very often, they carry out projects and initiatives in conjunction with our members.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Is that at significantly high levels in those organisations?

Dr Rowan
link

Yes.

Craig Sanderson Link Group Ltd
link

Link has a group structure. The parent company currently has three tenants on the board. Our subsidiary company, which performs all the housing management function, has a majority of tenants on its board. A lot of those tenants come from areas in which we are hoping to undertake regeneration activities.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Pauline Barbour, what is the case with your member organisations?

Pauline Barbour Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

A number of members of the SFHA council are tenants. There is certainly quite a mix at board level.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

I do not suppose that the question really applies to Shelter, Gavin Corbett.

Gavin Corbett Shelter Scotland
link

That is right; my organisation is probably a bit different from the others here, in the sense that they represent organisations that work with neighbourhoods as neighbourhoods. Our role is primarily to work with disadvantaged people, most of whom live in disadvantaged areas.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

Good morning. I have a supplementary question that relates to community representation on the GHA board. My historical experience of GHA is that it tended to be very top heavy and top down in relation to communities. When community representatives came forward who were critical—or what GHA might describe as overly critical—of the strategy and direction of GHA, they were refused a hearing and, in some cases, removed from the GHA. Does that practice still exist at GHA? Do you still vet who comes on to the area boards or the GHA board itself?

David Fletcher Glasgow Housing Association
link

No; we do not have that practice. I recognise that the question has been posed in a particular way, but for the avoidance of doubt I confirm that the chair of the GHA board is a tenant member. There are five tenant members on the board just now. In fact, tenant members make up the majority on the board and have done so over the life of GHA. That representation has been reinforced further by the area committee structure, which is also tenant led; tenants form the majority on those committees.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

For the record, you said that five tenants make up the majority of members. Does the board consist of nine people?

David Fletcher Glasgow Housing Association
link

I will double-check that, but I think that that is the case.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I sought that clarification because there is an issue about people who are trying to be representatives for their communities. Experience in the past was that some of those members felt that they were being blocked from going further or from taking up what they saw as their rightful place as elected representatives of their communities. 10:15

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

Good morning, everyone. I will focus on some of the evidence that we received from Dr Rowan that I think reflects the discussion so far. Dr Rowan, you stated in your submission that it is important in“the current economic climate ... to think innovatively and creatively about ... different models of regeneration.”You emphasised“partnership working with communities and the third sector”being very much involved in “local delivery mechanisms” to change the culture of public services and that, in particular, it is not about funding but about different “ways of doing things.” Do you and other panel members have good examples of different ways of doing things for regeneration?

Dr Rowan
link

Yes. I will first give a bit of background for those comments in our written submission. Our members have been doing regeneration in one form or another for the past 30 years, so we have a lot of innovative examples. We work with communities, because it is local people who govern community-controlled housing associations. There are myriad examples of partnership working. One example is the neighbourhood audit work that I described in our submission. The New Gorbals Housing Association and the Govanhill Housing Association have carried out neighbourhood audits in their areas. That work was done in the context of the results of the Christie commission and the upcoming community empowerment and renewal bill in order to look at preventative measures. We had feedback from those organisations about some of the partnership working—the audits were really exercises in mapping the partnership working in those areas. They recorded the organisations and agencies that operate in the areas, and they looked at the close partnership working with the housing associations for specific programmes or initiatives, as well as the more intangible forms of partnership working where—

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

Can you give examples of some of them? I think that that would make the issue come alive.

Dr Rowan
link

Yes. For instance, in the New Gorbals Housing Association area, the local credit union was going to be shut down because of its premises—I do not know the exact story with the premises; perhaps they were condemned—but the housing association gave the credit union new premises, refurbished them and gave the credit union a start-up amount of money. The credit union is now up and running again. The housing association refers people to the credit union, and they work in tandem in that way.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

That is good. I would like examples from other panel members, but I have another question for Dr Rowan first. You referred in your submission to the idea of community anchors. I think that you feel that the consultation paper on the proposed community empowerment and renewal bill missed an opportunity by not referring to community anchors. Can you expand on that point?

Dr Rowan
link

Yes. We were delighted to see community anchors referred to in the document “Achieving A Sustainable Future: Regeneration Strategy”. We feel that not only community-controlled housing associations but other agencies such as local community development trusts have carried out the community anchor role over the past 30 years. That reflects that our organisations are very much rooted in their communities: they have trust relationships with communities; they have assets in communities; and they are self-funded. I think that the definition of community anchor speaks to all that and to the roots of the community-based housing movement. Calling an organisation an anchor shows that it is rooted in its community and that members of the community come to it not just about housing but about health issues and welfare issues, for example.It would be good if the Government backed or acknowledged the community anchor role by stating explicitly that our organisations are community anchors and that the Government can work with us and that we can be a kind of host for other organisations or can initiate partnership working. We are keen to see that kind of recognition from the Government. I do not know how the Government would go about it, but perhaps the recognition could be enshrined in the proposed community empowerment and renewal bill. Pauline Barbour and I have had discussions about the community anchor aspect and how important we think it is for our members.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

That ties in very neatly with a suggestion in another written submission that, rather than all the funding going to CPPs, it might be better to fund directly identified community anchors—organisations that are well placed in the community—to deliver projects.Do other panel members have examples of innovation?

Gavin Corbett Shelter Scotland
link

Yes, there are thousands—I am sure that we could easily spend a full hour giving examples.

Gavin Corbett Shelter Scotland
link

The purpose of the strategy—which I hope will come out in the inquiry—is to assess whether those examples have been transformative and led to lasting change. That is why the strategy is important. Other people might have examples, too. The real problem is not innovation—there is plenty of that—but the lack of sustained change.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

Are you not going on to the outcomes a little? Unless you can say, “Here is an example of what we did and this is what it delivered”, there could be a danger that people are simply talking about strategies at that level and not actually delivering.

Gavin Corbett Shelter Scotland
link

Yes, but equally there have been particular projects that were proven to be successful in their own right and were well received and even internationally applauded, and yet the area itself did not change. The main purpose of regeneration is to transform the area.

Gavin Corbett Shelter Scotland
link

I cannot think of anything off the top of my head. I just want to emphasise that, although it is useful to celebrate innovation, that is not where the challenge lies. We could easily fill a big report with good examples of successful projects and initiatives, and I am sure that the projects that colleagues who are here today have undertaken would be among them. However, the question is whether a project has actually changed things and contributed to change in a whole area.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

You spoke about successful projects. That is interesting, because projects and regeneration areas are often deemed to be successful while the outcomes for people have not been that great. A project may be internationally renowned while making little difference in terms of outcomes. Would you agree that that is often the case?

Gavin Corbett Shelter Scotland
link

Absolutely. We have tended historically to judge outcomes on the number of buildings that are improved or the way in which the investment has been spent. One of the emerging themes, which has been emerging for a while—

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

So we are looking at objects rather than people?

Gavin Corbett Shelter Scotland
link

Yes, absolutely. A key point—which I am sure is a widely held view—is that regeneration is not about places or property but about people, and the way in which we measure it must echo that.We should be looking just as much at how we have built up social capital during the period of regeneration as at how we have revamped X number of buildings or transformed a brownfield site. We are not yet at the stage at which we value social capital improvement as much as physical improvement.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

If you think of any examples and want to give the committee that information afterwards, it would be very helpful.

Pauline Barbour Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

As Gavin Corbett said, there are many examples. One example that I can give the committee straight away is Easthall Park Housing Co-operative, and its approach is echoed throughout the association movement. The housing association is linking up with a local college to provide opportunities for apprenticeships and jobs, and it is working on procurement issues with local contractors. Those are on-the-ground initiatives that work exceptionally well in getting people into employment and further education, and there are a lot of aspects to that work.Associations do the majority of such work in kind; they are not seeking money to do it. Their staff apply to the people and communities fund for money to do a project on behalf of the community, or work with a local project that is on the ball about what is needed in the area. Such initiatives work exceptionally well.Organisations such as Link Group and NG Homes are doing exceptional work and engaging in innovative approaches that could be passed on for other organisations to learn from and use in their own ways for their own areas.

Craig Sanderson Link Group Ltd
link

I submitted a number of examples of things that Link Group has done over the years. If I was to choose one of those, it would be the dental surgery in Kirkshaws in Coatbridge.We were going to build on a site that would accommodate two houses. A qualified dentist who had grown up in the area approached us and said that dental facilities in the area were not very good and that, if we built a surgery for him, he would provide an NHS service for the next 10 years. We went ahead with that. We put in money and we got money from NHS Lanarkshire as well as wider-role funding from the Scottish Government and funding from the Big Lottery Fund and other sources. The dentist opened for business with the aim of getting 1,200 clients within two years, but he had that within two weeks. The day that he opened, a queue of folk snaked its way up the road towards Coatbridge centre. The outcome has been a significant improvement in oral health locally, because many of the people who went to the surgery had not been to a dentist for a long time.

Craig Sanderson Link Group Ltd
link

There are plenty of other examples. We can do such things because we are fortunate to have been in business for quite a long time and we have built up reserves, some of which are free reserves, and we have surpluses. We feel that it is incumbent on us to reinvest those into the business, which is why we get involved in those sorts of things. Not every association can do that, but we think that we have an obligation to do so. Because we are in the fortunate position of being able to do that, we feel that we should do it.

David Fletcher Glasgow Housing Association
link

Like Link, we have invested quite a lot of our investment moneys in supporting community regeneration schemes. Earlier, I briefly mentioned the area committee moneys, which are disbursed and prioritised by local communities to support projects from community garden initiatives to village halls and conservatories for sheltered housing complexes. Those are small-scale projects that are prioritised and significant locally.Alongside that, at city level, we try to consider where we can best use our financial clout and the scale of the organisation to deliver programmes at scale. I will give a couple of examples of that. From humble beginnings in a project in Castlemilk, our community janitors programme has employed more than 1,500 people over the past seven or eight years. That is an employment training initiative with Jobs and Business Glasgow. On the outcomes, the scheme not only helps to respond to neighbourhood concerns about cleanliness, maintenance and estate management for local communities; it builds confidence and capability and has good job outcomes for participants in the programme, who are mainly, but not only, guys.Our modern apprenticeship initiative, which we provide in partnership with Skills Development Scotland, gives a white-collar opportunity, particularly for young people. We are proud of how the programme has grown. The intake for the coming year involves 25 to 30 apprentices in our offices and partner housing association offices across the city and, we hope, beyond that.I will give one other example. Pauline Barbour mentioned the community benefits legislation in the context of the Easthall Park Housing Co-operative. At the time of the stock transfer in Glasgow, there was great expectation that it would be a driver for jobs and training opportunities. We have been successful in designing the appropriate community benefit clauses into procurement practice, in that jobs and training outputs have been delivered and the practice has been shared with projects such as those for the Commonwealth games and the Southern general hospital and with the urban regeneration companies as they came along, including the one in Raploch. That has been a big part of the role that we have tried to take on.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

John Wilson has a supplementary question.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

Mr Sanderson mentioned the Kirkshaws dental surgery and a package of funding for it. Who owns the building?

Craig Sanderson Link Group Ltd
link

We do.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

So the Link Housing Association has taken ownership of the building. What was the financial contribution from Link Housing Association to the creation of the building? I am trying to get to the issue of funding. You mentioned the funding streams, which included Lanarkshire NHS Board funding, wider-role funding and some of your reserves. I just want to find out what housing associations are doing as a package. I am aware of the history of housing associations and the wider access role that they have played, and that moneys have come into them. As a percentage, what was Link’s financial input into the project?

Craig Sanderson Link Group Ltd
link

I cannot tell you that now, but I could submit that information to you.

Stuart McMillan SNP West Scotland
link

Good morning. Mr Fletcher mentioned the housing stock transfers just a moment ago. I have some questions not on any one particular transfer but on transfers in general. With such transfers, do problems or issues with regard to the ownership not of buildings as such but of common areas, pavements and so on arise, and is the issue used as an excuse—I was not going to use that word, but I have done so anyway—when it comes to regenerating a particular area? In short, is there any confusion about ownership of the areas around the buildings, with the local authority saying, “We still own that area,” or, “We don’t own it—you do”?

David Fletcher Glasgow Housing Association
link

We certainly encountered that issue with the common estate and, since the transfer, have deployed a number of strategies to improve joint working and the approach to the estate. In our experience, the footprint of the buildings and the hard-standing areas were transferred while, in the vast majority of cases, the green spaces and common areas outwith the immediate GHA estate remained with the city council. There must be strategic and good local working to ensure that we do not miss out any spaces that need to be maintained.In direct response to your question, I should say that in a number of the environmental budgets and initiatives such as play parks, games courts and the like, we very much took the view that the important issue was community ownership and the community dimension. The question of who owned what was less important; we were happy to invest in land that we did not own and sought to put in place a good maintenance regime, which is delivered either by us or, in most cases, by the council. I am pleased to say that the arrangement is working well.

Craig Sanderson Link Group Ltd
link

Can you repeat the question? I thought that you were directing it only at David Fletcher.

Stuart McMillan SNP West Scotland
link

With housing stock transfers, can issues arise not so much with the buildings—those contractual elements will be easy to deal with—but with the common land, the pavements and so on?

Craig Sanderson Link Group Ltd
link

Yes. We do not have David Fletcher’s experience of stock transfers, but when we merged with what was then called Port Glasgow Housing Association we found that the owners of garages that were relatively removed from the houses did not want to contribute to the overall maintenance costs. Although that happened five or six years ago, we have still not resolved the issue.

David Fletcher Glasgow Housing Association
link

Perhaps as a brief supplementary comment I should set some context. First and foremost, local communities have seen direct and tangible improvements in their housing conditions through stock transfer. However, over time, the focus will understandably move to the wider environment and we have tried to reflect and respond to that in our own priorities, budgets and programmes. I know that you will take evidence from Professor Carol Tannahill from the GoWell programme about the longitudinal research, which has demonstrated—as if there were any doubt about it—the impact of the wider neighbourhood on wellbeing, confidence and people’s place both in the world and in their neighbourhood.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Before I bring in Dr Rowan, I highlight our concern about cases in which general maintenance that should have been carried out over the piece has been billed as regeneration and has received regeneration moneys. Have you done anything like that? Have you had certain areas that you have regularly maintained and other areas where stuff might not have been going on but where you have billed maintenance as regeneration and therefore received regeneration money? Does anyone have any admissions that they wish to make?

David Fletcher Glasgow Housing Association
link

I mentioned the area committee funds. We have tried to use those to respond to communities’ concerns when they think that a particular environment—whether it involves walls or planters—is not appropriate. For example, the environment might have been appropriate when it was designed in the 1960s or the 1970s, but it no longer meets the community’s needs. Such activity could be regarded as local regeneration, but we try, where possible, to make the best use of mainstream budgets.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

That is what I was asking about. Such activity is often billed as regeneration when, in other places, it would have come under general maintenance and would have been funded from mainstream budgets. Are you saying that, in Glasgow, such maintenance issues have, in the main, been dealt with using mainstream budgets rather than regeneration moneys?

David Fletcher Glasgow Housing Association
link

We use both. When we can, we tailor such activity to mainstream budgets.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

We will probably deal with mainstreaming versus regeneration in more depth later. For many years, I have been annoyed by regeneration moneys being used as a cash cow to prevent mainstream funding from being used for certain things.

Dr Rowan
link

I will pick up on what David Fletcher said. The same problems arise further down the line, with the second-stage transfers from GHA to our members. There is a bit of woolliness about who is responsible for some areas, which is to do with ownership and so on.To reiterate what David Fletcher said, most of our members have been quite willing to take on responsibility for common parts and factoring in places where there might not be agreement among owners, or where there is disagreement or animosity in mixed-tenure closes or areas. Our members are mostly happy to take on responsibility for a lot of those common parts, either directly or through their factoring subsidiaries.

Pauline Barbour Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

In conjunction with communities, a lot of associations are doing innovative work on areas that might have been lying waste for a long time. Recently, I heard about an example of that at one of the wider-role meetings—we still call them that. The Shettleston community growing project took a bare patch of land that was owned by the association in the area and where nothing was happening and turned it into an extremely impressive community garden, in a section of which people have their own allotments. The project involves a bit of employment and training. It is quite an interesting little project. I am not saying that it deals with all the issues to do with common land not being attended to, but there are things that a community sees and such proposals come from the community. If a community wants to do something about an area because it is not happy about it, it can turn to the local community housing association—the anchor—and ask it how it can help people to approach some of the issues. That has worked really well, and not just for the Shettleston project—there are a few similar projects around.

Gavin Corbett Shelter Scotland
link

I want to pick up on where Colleen Rowan was going with her response. In some ways, the bigger fault line in policy is not to do with whether stock transfer has taken place. In some ways, the housing revenue account is meant to be self-contained, although stock transfer sharpens that analysis. The issue is more to do with the fact that there is no such thing as a council estate or a housing association estate, and that has been the case for quite a long time. All the estates are mixed tenure.Over the past 10 years in particular, private renting has grown in those estates. That has happened under the radar and has quite often involved accidental landlords. I hear all the time that they are the hardest people to engage in regeneration, and that spills over into the debate about who is responsible for the neighbourhood as a whole. It might be the case that 10, 15 or even 20 per cent of properties are let out privately. That is a major challenge that I do not think that we have even identified yet.

Stuart McMillan SNP West Scotland
link

You must have read my mind because my next area of questioning is going to deal with that. I would like to ask the housing association representatives, in particular, whether they have any examples of extreme difficulties that have been encountered in liaising with the landlords in the areas that they cover.

Craig Sanderson Link Group Ltd
link

I will give an example that is close to Mr Pentland’s heart. In Forgewood in Lanarkshire, we took on responsibility for factoring a large area of mixed-tenure properties. Our ability to maintain that area relied very much on contributions from owner-occupiers, but we did not get those contributions. Much against our wishes and the wishes of Mr Pentland, we eventually had to withdraw that service because we were subsidising it so heavily.

David Fletcher Glasgow Housing Association
link

I do not have any direct examples to offer. On alternative tenures and new housing provision, YourPlace Property Management, which is our large factoring subsidiary within the city, recently encountered some tricky issues with a new estate in north Glasgow where a private developer had responsibility. The developer had been perceived by the existing local communities as shirking from providing its services and not delivering for the community. We are collaborating with the council to broker delivery of a service that is more efficient and, we believe, better value for money than the existing poor and badly presenting service.

Gavin Corbett Shelter Scotland
link

On what we do about such issues, I feel strongly that, at the local level, if the price and condition are right, and if doing so fits into the stock strategy, there is a case for buying back properties. Some properties are so badly managed and in such poor condition that they are acting as a brake on regeneration and our ability to house some of the most vulnerable people.At a national level, we have to look much more at where we are going with private renting. It is a major part of our housing landscape. We need to introduce greater security and stability and some certainty around affordability. That speaks to how national policy feeds into our local initiatives.

Pauline Barbour Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

A number of associations have been approached by people who have bought their properties and want to rent them on, with the association being asked to take on the management of those properties. That is quite interesting. I am not saying that the practice is widespread, but people have come to us to ask for advice on how it could be done. There are appropriate mechanisms that allow a local housing association to manage properties that people have bought and want to rent out.

Anne McTaggart Lab Glasgow
link

On the back of that question, I want to ask about people who have bought their property but are unable to sustain the mortgage. Are you familiar with buying over such properties?

David Fletcher Glasgow Housing Association
link

Such situations are very familiar. We get a number of inquiries—I was going to say every day, but certainly every week. We are participants in the Government’s mortgage to rent initiative. In the past year, we have purchased around 40 properties throughout the city. That is very much in keeping with what Gavin Corbett said. People—sometimes individuals and sometimes, following a bereavement, family members—approach the association, looking for a bit of support. We see that as a growing role for us in the city.

Anne McTaggart Lab Glasgow
link

At the very start of the meeting, David Fletcher mentioned community involvement and the fact that communities are not really participating to their full capacity. How can we best improve the situation?

David Fletcher Glasgow Housing Association
link

I mentioned that in the context of community planning and the strategic structures, below city level but still involving large geographies, in which senior officers often operate. It is about finding a way of engaging at a neighbourhood level. Later, the committee will hear from Dr Peter Matthews, who has put together a paper with examples of different engagement structures that have come and gone over the past couple of decades. It is also about finding a way of supporting organisations such as ours, which operate at the neighbourhood level, or other community-based organisations. There is no single answer. There needs to be a flexible approach to the definition of community anchors. However, housing associations can play a key role in helping to engage more people across the cities and beyond.

Anne McTaggart Lab Glasgow
link

Does it not always seem to be just the same group of people who are on all the committees within the community? How representative of that community are those people?10:45

David Fletcher Glasgow Housing Association
link

The national standards for community engagement strongly recommend guarding against going only to people from a particular walk of life or a particular group of tenants or residents. That is a risk.In our working lives, we have all seen a number of people who wear many hats and who often become exhausted by the community activity that they commit to. We have a responsibility to encourage more people to get involved through different forms of engagement.

Anne McTaggart Lab Glasgow
link

I have a question for the other witnesses about that. How do you encourage new people?

Gavin Corbett Shelter Scotland
link

That question goes right to the heart of what the regeneration strategy is about—building community capacity. We have all touched on the issue of burnout already—it is a big problem.It strikes me that in these areas, there are a lot of people with additional challenges in their lives. We need to find ways to expand the work that we already do with those people. We provide housing support, for example, and Craig Sanderson’s organisation also does a lot on housing support. Can we expand the scope of that work to give people the tools to enable them to become more engaged with their neighbourhood or their community?In other words, we do not need to create separate work; we need to recognise that we work with a lot of people already and ask what skills they need to be able to engage more fully in their neighbourhood, as part of their own development as well as being part of how the neighbourhood might develop.

Pauline Barbour Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

A lot is to do with—I hate to say it—what funding is available when we are trying to encourage people in the community to get involved. As far as I am aware, a separate stream will run parallel to the people and communities fund to help community capacity building.I would be interested to find out a bit more about the development of that stream and what it will mean for communities. It will be a wonderful asset to help people who may not have been involved in such things before grow and develop in their own areas and become a full, participating member of their community.

Craig Sanderson Link Group Ltd
link

Gavin Corbett mentioned our housing support services. At one time, we were probably funding those services to the tune of about a quarter of a million quid a year in order to keep them going.It is essential to employ people to talk to other people and to build up good relationships. You can quickly find out whether somebody is not representative of their community, if you talk to them. In general, we have found that people are genuinely representative, but you have to put the resources in and put the time aside to genuinely engage with people.

Dr Rowan
link

Our members are based in their local community and people see them as being part of their local community. Staff are very often local residents as well, which is important. The relationship of trust that I think I mentioned in our written evidence is key, and it has been built up over years and years.I will give an example of one innovative approach to getting people involved who are not the same old faces. Ardenglen Housing Association in Castlemilk has decided to go down the route of getting them young, if you like. It has set up an initiative called teen zone, with local people filming events for a video blog newsletter. The association is also involved in trying to get those people on to the governance side, passing the baton to them from older committee members. Such approaches will get people involved and keep them as part of the decision-making processes in those organisations.All our members are involved in employment and training initiatives, promoting financial inclusion, providing myriad community services and promoting volunteering in the community. You come into contact with a vast swathe of the community, not just one stripe or strand of it. All those things will continue to happen and approaches will be broadened out to reach different people in the community.

Anne McTaggart Lab Glasgow
link

As a former community worker, that is music to my ears. I really enjoyed hearing about the project that you talked about and the idea of shadow boards, because young people need to learn from others.

Dr Rowan
link

Exactly.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

On the issue of engagement in Glasgow, could Mr Fletcher tell me how many tenants and residents associations there are in Glasgow?

David Fletcher Glasgow Housing Association
link

I would need to check the exact number, but my estimate would be 60 to 70, across the city. Previously, there may have been a larger number. I am happy to submit a written response to your question.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I assure Mr Fletcher that, 15 years ago, there were more than 200 tenants and residents associations in Glasgow—I know because I conducted a survey to find out how many of them were actively engaged with Glasgow City Council at that time. Are the targets or outcomes that are set for housing associations concentrated too much on financial performance and the building or improvement of houses and not enough on the economic impact on the existing residents of the areas that are being affected by the improvements?

Gavin Corbett Shelter Scotland
link

As I said earlier, I do not think that we pay enough attention to outcomes such as building social capital, as opposed to the issues of how much we have spent and how many houses we have improved. You mentioned existing residents. That is an important issue. One of the questions around regeneration is, “How much have we improved place for the people who are there and how much have we improved place by displacing the people who are there, and what will happen to the people who have been displaced?” That is a question that, perhaps, needs to be answered by research. I think that regeneration is successful only if it works for the most disadvantaged people in the most disadvantaged areas. That is a big challenge for the regeneration strategy, and is a long-term aim.

Pauline Barbour Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

As most of us would recognise, it is easier to measure the bricks-and-mortar side of things rather than the social aspect. It is important to highlight that there is a duty on associations to report to tenants on their performance within the charter. I am not saying that that is a panacea or provides a solution to all the problems, but there is a duty on associations to say what they are doing in an area. Tenants have been involved in the development of the charter. That element has been present, but I am sure that more could be done.

Craig Sanderson Link Group Ltd
link

Traditionally, there has perhaps been too great a focus on the numbers of houses that have been built and on the finances of an association. We are experiencing a wee bit of tension—that is perhaps too strong a word—because the Scottish Government is encouraging us to embark on innovative projects and do good things with the money but the regulator is saying that we should not do so much of the wider-action stuff and should focus on keeping our nose clean and building more houses. There is a bit of a dilemma there.As Anne McTaggart knows, I am a big fan of something called social return on investment. We could all be doing more of that sort of thing. That is a process whereby you can prove how much extra social and environmental benefit comes from a pound’s expenditure when, for example, you are building a new house. I think that we could be doing more social impact measurement.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

You said that the Government is encouraging you to use your reserves but that the regulator is saying that you should keep your nose clean and build more housing. Is that right?

Craig Sanderson Link Group Ltd
link

I would not say that the regulator is saying that outright, but it is implying that.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

The regulator is implying that.

Craig Sanderson Link Group Ltd
link

Yes. That might just be our experience, though. Others might want to comment.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

If anyone has any other comments on that, I would be glad to hear them.

Dr Rowan
link

I echo what Craig Sanderson said. That is our members’ perspective, by and large.

David Fletcher Glasgow Housing Association
link

I do not have direct experience of that, but I understand exactly what Craig Sanderson is describing. We have a series of targets that we set annually around what we call our better lives programme, which tends to drive away from a strict focus on finance, buildings and the estate. People-based programmes and employment and training are important. We endorse Craig Sanderson’s comments.On social impact investment, we did a piece of work with Heriot-Watt University a couple of years ago to examine the wider economic outcomes that were generated from the Glasgow Housing Association investment programme, and we need to do more of that.We have other targets around engagement programmes, including bursaries, partnerships with the education department and supporting access to further education colleges and universities. We are particularly trying to reach people who have all the ability but maybe not the same opportunity, and we are taking on an advocacy and champion role to help to connect with them through our services and front-line staff. Hopefully, a large organisation such as ours is able to reach people at some scale.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

Gavin Corbett picked up on the point that I want to raise. In a lot of communities, we carry out regeneration but do not measure the economic benefit of that to the individual household in the community. A lot of displacement has taken place over the years, with a lot of new-build owner-occupied projects progressing in tandem with the housing association work. That skews the overall economic impact for the existing residents, who do not see any real economic improvement in their household incomes despite all the money that we have spent on regeneration projects. There are areas throughout Scotland where, despite our having spent £20 million or £30 million on improving the area, the existing residents have not benefited economically. How do we measure that? Is enough being done to measure the economic impact not only on the area but on the individual households of the people for whom we are supposed to be carrying out regeneration to improve their lives?

Gavin Corbett Shelter Scotland
link

The research would probably need to be longitudinal rather than short term and would take quite an investment. Others may be better placed to comment on how valuable that would be. We would need to be able to trace things over time and follow individual people, not just the area as a whole.You touch on one of the benefits that we might look at. The GHA written submission contains quite a lot of information about the additional benefits for employment, training and apprenticeships. At best, that is what happens with regeneration—we look at how people in an area benefit from activity in the area through using community benefit clauses and so on. However, I do not think that that is universal yet, and there is a long way to go to ensure that people in an area benefit.Particularly when we have a crisis of unemployment among young people, we need to understand that, for young people who are furthest from the labour market and who may be at risk of causing the problems that a lot of communities rightly get distressed about, apprenticeships are too far up the line. We need to introduce people to simple activities such as getting up and ready for work and taking responsibility for themselves. I would like a range of more intermediate projects that would allow young people who are furthest from the labour market, who live in some of the most disadvantaged areas, to gain from the activity that is taking place around them.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

You are saying that some of the moneys that Government directs towards regeneration would be better off in such projects than in the physical projects that we have seen again and again in some places.

Gavin Corbett Shelter Scotland
link

Let us have the physical projects, but we must also consider how they can provide added value by directly engaging some of the people who might otherwise be quite distant from them. It is not a question of either/or; it is about how we can add value to those projects.

David Fletcher Glasgow Housing Association
link

We have embraced the GoWell programme, about which you will hear more from Carol Tannahill and her team. The programme has sought to follow people as they have stayed in their communities or moved. The committee will be aware that it is common in regeneration areas that are going through turbulent change—a lot of rehousing and demolition—that there is churn in the neighbourhood and a turnover of the housing stock. There are many challenges involved in trying to follow an individual on that journey. As Gavin Corbett acknowledges, it involves a significant amount of investment and requires the skills and experience to be able to do that right and follow someone over a decade or possibly more, as the GoWell programme has sought to do. We have sought to invest in that programme and learn lessons from it not at the end of the period but as we go, through interaction with the principal investigators.11:00

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

We are getting quite tight for time now. I will allow a brief supplementary from Stuart McMillan.

Stuart McMillan SNP West Scotland
link

I have a question for Mr Corbett. A number of people have contacted me in the past regarding proposed developments. They are perhaps not happy with one or two of the outcomes, but they genuinely feel that they have been consulted. Is that common or is Mr Corbett aware of less consultation with tenants and residents?

Gavin Corbett Shelter Scotland
link

I suspect that every evaluation of a project will say that there were some things to learn about communication and consultation. Those can always be improved.I am interested in how we consult. Projects such as participative budgeting, which are active forms of engagement rather than passive ones, seem to be particularly successful because they are not just about receiving views but involve an outcome and the distribution of resources. They seem to offer a way to go.

John Pentland Lab Motherwell and Wishaw
link

For the record, I say a big thank you to Mr Sanderson for his support and, indeed, tolerance during the hard negotiations that we had on Forgewood.

Craig Sanderson Link Group Ltd
link

I have never been called tolerant before.

John Pentland Lab Motherwell and Wishaw
link

The witnesses will be more aware than anybody that we now live in a difficult financial climate. Is their role in regeneration restricted because of the significant cut in the cost per unit for houses? I ask them to advise the committee what that means to them and what it has done.

Gavin Corbett Shelter Scotland
link

We are managing to keep the development programme moving forward at some scale in Glasgow. That creates other pressures and tensions but, so far, we have managed to do it successfully and we see our work in Glasgow at this time growing.

Pauline Barbour Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

If the grant levels were raised, associations could do more and could unlock private finance in light of the current lack of bank lending. Albyn Housing Society has discovered that, with £40,000, it can build 25 houses but, with £60,000, it can build 75 houses. If the grant was set at about 65 per cent, that could make a major impact on social housing provision.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

How would more grant money unlock more private finance?

Pauline Barbour Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

It would lever it in.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

We have heard that leverage is much higher now than it has been previously. Is that the case?

Pauline Barbour Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

I would have to check on that, but the example from Albyn Housing Society may be interesting to you because it has done some research into how it could manage with different levels of grant.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

That would be interesting, but we would need more than just the basics. We would need to see the business plan.

Craig Sanderson Link Group Ltd
link

I am on record as saying that, for there to be a long-term future for social housing, the subsidy level has to go back up to the 60 or 65 per cent level that it was at in 2010. Since 2011, it has been brought down to about 40 per cent. We cannot make social housing stack up in the long term at those grant levels.We managed to do it by using some of our land bank and free reserves, but you can sell your organs only once. Our business plan gives us a healthy development programme but, after three years, we will fall off a cliff because our current financial arrangements, which are quite good because they were negotiated before the recession, will run out. As you suggested, future funding may be much more expensive if it comes from the private sector, so we have to compensate for that additional cost of borrowing by maintaining subsidy levels. It is only by building houses that we can continue to create jobs for people.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Has there been any investigation of the use of pension fund moneys?

Craig Sanderson Link Group Ltd
link

Yes.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

How have you got on with that?

Craig Sanderson Link Group Ltd
link

We have looked at that and at bond finance. It is less convenient, if you like. At the moment we borrow from a bank by having what is called a loan facility, so we only have to draw down that money when we need it. If we hit planning delays, for instance, it does not matter. We are increasingly hitting planning delays; if we borrow money through a bond, we have to start repaying that the day we get it. Therefore we lose money if we cannot start on site and finish on time.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Perhaps that will lead to more efficiency.

Dr Rowan
link

I would refer the panel to our submission to the Infrastructure and Capital Investment Committee, which I can submit again. We gave written and then oral evidence last year that outlines our concerns and some of the barriers to reduced investment that our members see.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Again, that would be useful.

John Pentland Lab Motherwell and Wishaw
link

Mr Sanderson, am I right in thinking that you said just now that if the unit cost does not rise in the next three years, some housing associations could fall off a cliff?

Craig Sanderson Link Group Ltd
link

No—I said that the delivery or provision of social housing may be impossible. We are already making more of our development programme available for what is called intermediate, mid-market or, sometimes, affordable rent. However, we feel that the greatest need, especially in regeneration areas, is for housing at social rent levels.

John Pentland Lab Motherwell and Wishaw
link

I have another question that follows up something that was asked earlier.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

If you are going to change the subject, I will bring in Mr Wilson for a supplementary question and then come back to you.

John Wilson SNP Central Scotland
link

I want to ask about the subsidy issue. I have worked alongside housing developments as they took place. Can anyone on the panel comment on whether, when housing associations were being promoted, the wrong model of housing funding strategy was adopted? If we could start again, should we look at a different model? Some of the housing associations were started with almost 95 per cent grant funding, on the basis—as I understand it—that 95 or 98 per cent initial stage grant funding would allow them to become self-sustaining over a period of time. Given the levels of subsidies about which we are talking now—65 per cent, for example—are housing associations not self-sustainable? Will they continue to need high levels of subsidy? We are told that local authorities can deliver a house for a £25,000 Government subsidy, yet the committee has been told today that housing associations need a subsidy of anything up to 65 per cent.

Craig Sanderson Link Group Ltd
link

I will give that question a bash. You have got to be careful that you are comparing apples with apples. The reason that local authorities could build with less subsidy was because they already owned the land. When we are working out the feasibility of a project, we have to include the cost of purchasing the land. That is one reason why local authorities could deliver houses more cheaply. On whether the model was initially flawed, no, I do not think that it was. The success of housing associations of all types, whether they are national, such as Link, or community based or regional—sort of in the middle—has been fantastic. Scotland needs to be proud of that. The level of subsidy that was originally required in the 1990s had more to do with what was needed to keep rents affordable, rather than what was needed to sustain a business. With tenemental rehabilitation in Glasgow, 25 per cent of the cost initially needed to be subsidised because that amount of work could not be done with an affordable rent at the end of it. At least, that is my interpretation. I would say that the model is a good one and should be allowed to continue.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

For clarification, we need councils to tell us how much they pay for land. My experience is that unless the land is in the housing revenue account, which is often not the case, councils have to purchase land. We need to clarify that point.

John Pentland Lab Motherwell and Wishaw
link

We were given GHA’s area committee fund post-evaluation survey, which shows the before and after of a completed project. Is your association’s role in regeneration restricted by the pressures to maintain and improve existing stock and its energy efficiency? Are you using some of the grant moneys to pay for that?

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Can you go through that very briefly? I want to get all the other questioners in, if possible.

David Fletcher Glasgow Housing Association
link

I am not quite sure what grant moneys John Pentland is talking about, and it would not be our philosophy to be restricted. We would see our role as going far beyond the stock. We hope that it has been useful for the committee to see the examples and I hope that it endorses and supports some of my earlier comments about our role as champion or advocate in neighbourhoods in which often no other community structures exist. Where such structures exist, we do our best to work alongside voluntary sector organisations and others.Will you clarify what you meant about energy efficiency?

John Pentland Lab Motherwell and Wishaw
link

Is your time being consumed by bringing up your older stock to the standard that meets energy efficiency targets?

David Fletcher Glasgow Housing Association
link

No; that is not the case. In the early years of GHA’s programme, there was a massive push towards delivery of the investment programme, because much of the stock in the city absolutely needed to be brought up to warm, affordable standards.Investment of £1.2 billion has been made in the vast majority of neighbourhoods, although not yet everywhere—far from it. That will allow for resource, staff time and committee and board time to be invested in neighbourhoods in the period ahead in such things as better lives programmes and more community-based approaches.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Does anybody else want to have a crack at that?

Dr Rowan
link

I echo what David Fletcher said. There are some problems with older tenemental stock in Glasgow, especially with wall insulation. We are trying to access innovative ways and funding to deal with that, in conjunction with the Scottish Government and energy companies. That is an on-going, rolling process, but most of our members’ stock is already at that standard.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

I think that you all indicated that you are in favour of community audits, but perhaps we did not tease out what they should include. There is an opportunity there, given what you have said about single outcome agreements, for example. I am drawing particularly on the Link submission, which indicated that there is not sufficient recognition of regeneration and there is sometimes conflict between the long-term aspirations of housing associations and other registered social landlords and the community, and the political realities, which tend to move the goalposts a lot. The people’s community fund was mentioned, which gave a sizeable amount of funding for regeneration. That has now been withdrawn and a smaller pot of money is divided more widely, which has brought challenges. Will you comment more generally on the political realities of goalposts changing with different funding initiatives?Lastly, when we have gone out to communities, we have come across the issue of procurement. Local authorities tend to look at procurement in a way that is very much officer led, rather than looking at the social benefits that could be incurred by relaxing how procurement works.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Can we have very brief responses, please? Gavin Corbett can have the first crack.

Gavin Corbett Shelter Scotland
link

You mentioned community audits. My heart sinks when I hear the word “audit”; as I indicated earlier, I am much keener on more active forms of understanding communities. My experience is of using things at a small village level, through a rural project. If something is seen as being done to people, it is less useful than if it is more active.The last point was on a wider assessment of procurement. We need to get that right at specification stage. If we wait until we are looking at the tenders that have been submitted, it is too late. We need to specify at an early stage what we want a project to deliver, and then invite and seek interest from organisations that are in that ballpark.11:15

Pauline Barbour Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

Community audits are positive things—after all, it is good for communities to see what others are doing and to learn from their peers—but other panel members will probably have more involvement in their ins and outs and what they entail.I wonder whether I picked up Margaret Mitchell properly. Were you talking about problems with funding streams to get projects going?

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

It is just that things are always moving. For example, the people and communities fund, which seems to have been very good, has been replaced with something that might not be so generous.

Pauline Barbour Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

One example that unfortunately has not worked out so well is the Raploch area, which David Fletcher mentioned. With the cut in the association’s budget and a lack of financial capability and grant funding, the project stalled slightly. The problem is that the community’s expectations are not being met and an association, if it is in the local area, tends to be the first port of call for people wanting to know why these things are not happening and why promises have not been kept. Despite all the good things that associations do with regeneration, such problems and issues still have to be addressed.

Margaret Mitchell Con Central Scotland
link

Are you able to make your case more strongly through the single outcome agreement to ensure that regeneration and how this or that project is achieving it are factored in?

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

I must ask for a brief response.

Pauline Barbour Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

I can find out a bit more and report back to the committee.

Craig Sanderson Link Group Ltd
link

The fund that I was referring to that had been withdrawn was the wider-role fund. At one time, it was worth £12 million a year; it was cut to £6 million and then replaced with the so-called people and communities fund. Wider-role funding was available only to housing associations, while PCF is quite rightly—probably—available to others as well. It just means that there are more mouths to feed with a reduced amount of money.

Dr Rowan
link

The two members of our forum that as I mentioned earlier have carried out community audits—New Gorbals and Govanhill—found them to be very useful indeed. Moreover, they were not done to the community and they were not a matter of simply going round and counting assets. Focus groups were established, local priorities identified and partner agencies in the area spoken to about how they could work together better for the area.

David Fletcher Glasgow Housing Association
link

Like Gavin Corbett, I get a heavy heart when I think about community audits, but I think that they have a role to play. It is tricky, because in the single outcome agreements the leadership on community planning was rested with local authorities, and I think that the audits need to be designed carefully to ensure that they fit. Earlier, we discussed how mainstreaming had been a key driver, and it is tricky to link both things together successfully.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

I have already talked about how in certain areas regeneration moneys have funded things that in other areas would have come from mainstream budgets; indeed, Peter Matthews’s submission highlights the same point. Do you have any examples of regeneration moneys going into projects that should really have been funded from mainstream budgets? As a former chair of a social inclusion partnership, I have many, but I would like to hear from the panellists.

Craig Sanderson Link Group Ltd
link

I do not feel that I can comment on that.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

So you have no examples of projects funded by regeneration moneys rather than mainstream budgets. I believe that Mr Fletcher mentioned the point earlier.

David Fletcher Glasgow Housing Association
link

I agree with your earlier sentiment, convener. In a number of areas, we are responding to community priorities. Having been involved in the social inclusion partnership in Easterhouse for many years, I know that such partnerships often had to take a step forward and draw other mainstream partners to the table to deliver a community project. An example from a couple of years ago that comes to mind was Easterhouse’s cultural campus—as it was known—called The Bridge, which linked the library, the swimming pool and John Wheatley College. The social inclusion partnership used significant resources from its own budget as the lever to create that initiative.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

I just find it very interesting that none of you can cite any examples.Dr Rowan said that organisations with which she had been involved have been community anchors for 30 years. Of course, “community anchors” is one of those buzz phrases that come along from time to time, but if such organisations have been community anchors for many a year do they need to be defined in law?

Dr Rowan
link

They do not necessarily need to be defined in law, but it would not do any harm for them to be acknowledged as community anchors.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

But what happens if an organisation that feels that it is a community anchor is defined as such and another or an individual is not?

Dr Rowan
link

Well, I think that it is—

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

I am sorry—I am just playing devil’s advocate.

Dr Rowan
link

I suppose that that will always happen. However, it would be useful to have a set of criteria that people can see.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Does anyone else want to have a go at that?

Pauline Barbour Scottish Federation of Housing Associations
link

The issue was raised during discussions around the formation of the people and communities fund, and everyone found it difficult to thrash out a definition of community anchor. A set of definitions has been formulated; some associations meet them absolutely and others such as development trusts meet all or most of them. The criteria exist and it is useful to have them.

Gavin Corbett Shelter Scotland
link

I heard the scepticism in your question, convener, and share your sense that the label of “community anchor” can be as much of a dead-weight if the organisation that bears it does not show how it has earned and continues to earn the title. Enshrining it in law would not be helpful because such an approach tends to fossilise things, but the metaphor is useful if it is used as a springboard rather than as a dead-weight.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

I thank the witnesses for their evidence. The session has run on a bit longer than you might have expected, but that probably shows that you were good witnesses.I suspend the meeting for a change of witnesses.11:21 Meeting suspended.

11:27 On resuming—

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

We move on to our second panel. I welcome Professor Carol Tannahill, director of the Glasgow centre for population health and a member of the GoWell project; Dr Peter Matthews, lecturer in the school of the built environment at Heriot-Watt University; and Annette Hastings, senior lecturer in urban studies at the University of Glasgow.I think that one of the previous panellists thought that I was scowling at them, but in fact I am in pain rather than scowling. I point out, because I know that for some of you this is your first visit to the Parliament, that we do not bite.As no one wants to make an opening statement, we will go straight to questions—I love that. I will start with the first question that I asked the previous panel, which is about the role of community planning partnerships in regeneration. What do you think of community planning partnerships in this sphere?

Professor Carol Tannahill GoWell
link

First, the principle of bringing together all the main partners that work in an area in something like a community planning partnership is undoubtedly a very good idea. If community planning partnerships did not exist, we would all want to invent something like them. The principle is therefore very good, but there have been concerns and tensions about the two different roles that community planning partnerships often look to fulfil. The first role is about co-ordinating the resources, strategies and services of players at the level of the local authority. The second role is about the community bit of community planning: community involvement and reflecting the needs and priorities of the different communities that sit within a local authority area.With regard to today’s discussion, we need to recognise that community planning partnerships are often not in a position to have the detailed local knowledge that is required to inform local regeneration decisions. I like to think of it as a chain, with community planning partnerships being one part of that chain and also having a role in keeping the chain well oiled. They have a responsibility for ensuring that there is the necessary community infrastructure for local decisions, but they often do not have that localised knowledge of what is needed in some areas.11:30

Dr Peter Matthews Heriot-Watt University
link

I share those concerns. There is a key challenge in accessing the strategic local authority level in community planning. It is difficult for anybody to engage at that level, and the Local Government in Scotland Act 2003 says that local authorities also have to deliver local community planning. My experience of watching community planning happen at strategic local authority level is that it is very much about the leaders of those organisations coming to talk to one another, just to make sure that they are on the same page at the level of partnership working. It sometimes gets towards deeper partnership working, but much of it is about ensuring, for example, that other organisations know what the health board is doing or what the police are doing.At local level, more depressingly, a lot of the partnerships are just an arena for local community groups to voice their concerns in what can be an unconstructive way, and for different council departments—or even different parts of the same council departments—to come together to find out what the others are doing. That is the sort of partnership working that should not be taking place in community planning, which should move beyond that. The police are seen a lot at local level. I used to see Lothian and Borders Police and Strathclyde Police, before the reorganisation of police services, doing fantastic partnership working at local level, but the local general practitioners’ practices, the local dentists or other partnership organisations that can make a difference in communities are not seen in that way.To echo the point that was made by Gavin Corbett, there is a big question about local arrangements and what constitutes a neighbourhood. A lot of local authorities have resorted to using multimember wards as their basic geography; they are vast and they have cut a lot of former regeneration areas in two.

Annette Hastings University of Glasgow
link

I would not disagree with either of my colleagues; I would add to the list of issues and concerns. At a city-wide or local authority-wide level, and at a more local level, community planning is a useful instrument for understanding the different levels of need for particular services. As a strategic body, the community planning partnership can bring services together, think about the multidimensionality of needs, and assess whether there are different levels of need in different parts of an area for particular services. They are useful as a strategic instrument, and that is at the heart of my submission. They are also a good instrument for tailoring provision appropriately to meet those needs.The other aspect of community planning—keeping communities at the heart of community planning—is harder to deliver, but in an era when we are thinking about more community-led regeneration, it is helpful to have more detailed intelligence about the potential for communities to take the lead and do things for themselves in particular areas.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

Exercises in planning for real have been carried out in many areas. Is that the right way to do things so as to better inform community planning partnerships about what is required in communities, rather than having things done to them, as was said earlier?

Dr Matthews
link

I know of planning for real. It is a copyrighted product, and although I have not been involved in it myself, I know the type of approach that it involves.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

It is copyrighted by Aberdeen City Council, if I remember rightly.

Dr Matthews
link

There is a range of different methods of engaging communities and of allowing communities to come up with their own vision of where they want to be in the future.The charrettes have been quite popular for land use planning in master planning new neighbourhoods successfully with the sustainable communities initiative. I would not say that there is one ideal method, as there is a range of methods. Increasingly, new technologies are changing the methods and how we might think about using different methods to engage with communities and allow a community to vision. However, when we are talking about regenerating communities, it is quite a big ask to expect people who might be struggling to think where their next meal is coming from to vision where their neighbourhood will be in 20 years. We must understand the capability of a community to carry out these visioning exercises.

Kevin Stewart SNP The Convener · Aberdeen Central
link

So, you would like planning for real with some kind of advocacy involved as well.

Dr Matthews
link

Yes.

John Pentland Lab Motherwell and Wishaw
link

Will the panel define the role that the community plays in CPPs? Way back in 2002, when the matter was first discussed, it was advocated that CPPs should be about planning by the community and not just for the community. What is your view on that?

Professor Tannahill
link

I am happy to kick off. My experience is particularly in the Glasgow context. As was mentioned, community planning operates in different ways across the country, so I have a partial view of it. In Glasgow, we have seen a number of different approaches and efforts to enable community involvement in community planning, particularly through the more devolved, sector-based community planning structures.The focus is currently on community council involvement. However, everyone recognises that that is limited and does not go far enough. We need to find new ways of involving the community.Our experience in GoWell, which is not particularly focused on community involvement and community planning, is that people feel that they have an increasing influence over the decisions that affect them. We are seeing progress, over time, in members of the communities that we are studying feeling that they have some say over neighbourhood planning—master planning and so on—and over direct housing allocations and things such as that.The influence is least in the areas that require the most regeneration. There is a gradient across the city in the extent to which people feel that they have influence. People in such areas also feel that they have least influence over the big decisions in the city.The questions that we ask are on a scale, and range from the extent to which people feel that they have some say over issues that affect their home to the extent to which they feel that they have some say over issues that affect their neighbourhood and the extent to which they feel that they can influence decisions that organisations such as the council and the health board make. It is clear that, the further away decisions are from being directly about people and their households, the more the influence that people feel they have decreases.There is a long way to go. As I said in answer to the first question, part of the solution will lie in further development of community planning, but that is not the sole answer for community involvement in decisions.

  1. 10:00 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
  2. 10:00 Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 1
  3. 10:00 Regeneration Evidence session · 266

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.