Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Subordinate Legislation

Wednesday 6 September 2000 Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee Subordinate legislation 42 contributions · 10 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

42 contributions
John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

Item 5 is subordinate legislation. The first item will be the Education (Student Loans) Amendment (Scotland) Regulations 2000, for which we will be joined by Gillian Thompson. Before we discuss the two statutory instruments, the clerk will give us an update on the Subordinate Legislation Committee's deliberations.

Simon Watkins Clerk Team Leader
link

The Subordinate Legislation Committee met yesterday and has not yet formally reported on the first instrument. However, it highlighted a couple of technical considerations, one of which is that the instrument breaks the rule about the timing between when an instrument is laid and when it comes into force. That issue is being raised with the Executive. The second issue is that there have apparently been amendments to the Local Government Act 1963, which is referred to, relating to the Metropolitan police district. One or two technical issues arise. Until the Subordinate Legislation Committee formally reports to us, we cannot formally report to the Parliament, but it is possible for members to ask questions and come to a view about the instrument, which can then be confirmed at a later meeting.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

I ask Gillian Thompson whether there any points that she wants to make and to reflect on the points raised by the Subordinate Legislation Committee.

Gillian Thompson Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

I saw those points this morning and can certainly comment on the amendment that was made in 1974, if the committee would find that helpful, although we will obviously also respond in the normal way.

Gillian Thompson Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

The committee is correct in assuming that regulation 3 in the amended regulations is intended to take the position back to that set out in 1963, but as amended in 1974. I am sorry if that is not clear from the regulation.There is a reference to the amendment in the footnote. We were attempting to bring the description of the Metropolitan police district back to that as in 1974. Otherwise, it would have been changed by the 1999 legislation, which was not what we wanted to achieve.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

Do members want to raise any points on the regulations? As the clerks have indicated, we cannot formally report to Parliament on this until we receive the report of the Subordinate Legislation Committee. A discussion of the regulations will be on our agenda at the next formal meeting of the committee.I thank Gillian Thompson for coming along.The second item of subordinate legislation is the Education and Training (Scotland) Regulations 2000 (SSI 2000/292). This instrument relates to the regulations associated with the introduction of the Education and Training (Scotland) Act 2000, which was approved by Parliament prior to the summer recess. We have again been joined for this item by David Stewart and Allan Wilson, who have frequent appearances at the committee behind them, to discuss the regulations. I offer you the chance to update us on the actions that ministers have taken in drawing up the regulations, in the light of the parliamentary debates that we have had on the subject.

David Stewart Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

Following the latter stages of the Education and Training (Scotland) Bill, ministers wrote again to you with a revision of the regulations in the light of the commitments made in the debate on the matter. Thereafter, we worked through a final version of the regulations—the one you now have here—which looks different from the previous illustrative draft. It is designed to carry out the commitments that were given. Most of the changes are stylistic and technical, but the instrument reflects the original legislative commitments.

Mr Allan Wilson Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

The only other point that I would add is that, like Gillian Thompson before us, we understand that the Subordinate Legislation Committee examined

these regulations yesterday. It raised a couple of points. Would you like a response on those at this stage?

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

I will invite the clerk to go through them, then I will come back to you.

Simon Watkins Clerk Team Leader
link

The first point relates to regulation 7(4), which concerns the sub-delegation of some of the rules governing the introduction of individual learning accounts to the Scottish ministers. It is a question of to what extent sub-delegation is sensible. The second point relates to regulation 7(5), which restricts the number of grants that can be issued. The committee has raised an issue about the vires of that regulation.

Mr Wilson
link

We will make the formal reply on those points within the next day or two. On the point about regulation 7(4)—the minister's powers to determine additional grants—we understand that the power is to be found in section 1(2)(b) of the Education and Training (Scotland) Act 2000 where it states that ministers may determine the amount and how it is paid. That is the basis of that part of the regulation.Regulation 7(5) deals with limiting to 100,000 grants of £150. Under section 1(1) of the Education and Training (Scotland) Act 2000"Ministers may make regulations authorising grants to be paid".It is at their discretion whether to limit the number of grants and to set what the amounts would be.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

On the latter point, you are effectively saying that under the first section of the act, ministers have the power to determine that.

Mr Wilson
link

That is what we understand.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

If ministers wish to exceed that as the scheme rolls out, what is the mechanism for doing so? Do ministers have to lay further regulations? If we reach 100,000 individual learning accounts, do ministers have to prepare a further set of regulations to approve the one hundred thousand and first account?

Mr Wilson
link

Yes. As there is specific reference in the regulation to 100,000, we would have to amend it if there were going to be 100,001.

Margo MacDonald SNP Lothians
link

Do the regulations state at which point that application would have to be made by the minister?

Mr Wilson
link

No. The policy intention all along—as published in the consultation documents and as discussed during its progress through Parliament—was that there would be 100,000 accounts. There is no intention to change that policy. If there were any intention to change it, the regulations would need to be amended. It would depend on the amount of time required to get that regulation through.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

Henry McLeish's letter to the convener dated 4 July stated that the minister would shortly agree the arrangements for evaluating the two discretionary fund pilots and that a full report would be issued on the outcome. Can you tell us when we might be in receipt of the reports on the pilots?

Mr Wilson
link

We expect the report to be available round about June or July next year. The final arrangements for the evaluation have yet to be settled. We must ensure that the information is available in time for the review of the regulations, to which ministers are already committed. They have said that they will review the regulations within a year.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

With regard to the 20 per cent and 80 per cent rules on further support, do you feel that problems of definition might thwart the full potential of implementation of the individual learning accounts scheme, because of the thresholds being somewhat arbitrary?

Mr Wilson
link

We must gain from our experience on this as time goes by. It has been clear from the beginning that it will be difficult to define which specific courses are in or out in certain areas. Some are clearly in and others are clearly out, but many will be in that shadowy area. Part of the overall monitoring will identify whether, if those occur regularly, something can be done about them quickly or whether we must tackle it again later on in the year.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

You may be aware that I have written to the minister about this. Following a visit to Sabhal Mòr Ostaig this summer, it occurred to me, in discussions with senior personnel at Sabhal Mòr Ostaig, that there is terrific opportunity for those involved in service and tourism—perhaps even Parliament staff—to benefit from short courses there. Communication is one of the criteria that entitles people to the 80 per cent assistance. Will you confirm that Gaelic courses would qualify for the full 80 per cent support at Sabhal Mòr Ostaig?

Mr Wilson
link

I would not expect Gaelic courses to qualify for the 80 per cent support. I would expect language courses of that type to qualify for the full 20 per cent, or indeed the £150, which in many cases will be higher. When the definitions of the 80 per cent were considered, they were in three main areas. One was basic information technology skills, another was basic literacy and the third was basic numeracy. We have worked on that basis and have identified that small list of half a dozen or so courses.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

But not basic literacy in Gaelic.

Mr Wilson
link

That is correct.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

Now that Mr Ewing has had his week of intensive Gaelic training at Sabhal Mòr Ostaig, we are the wiser for it.

Allan Wilson Lab Cunninghame North
link

The minister's letter referred to local enterprise companies preparing local marketing strategies to reach those who might not otherwise be interested in the lifelong learning process. Is there a national marketing strategy that will drive the local enterprise companies' development of their local marketing strategies?

David Stewart Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

As was discussed during the progress of the bill, the Scottish University for Industry will take the lead on the national marketing of its own direct services and on awareness raising about individual learning accounts and local enterprise companies will do the local marketing. Scottish Enterprise, Highlands and Islands Enterprise and SUFI have been working together on that national strategy. The individual local strategies have been discussed with the Scottish UFI to ensure that the two things fit together.

David Stewart Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

A national strategy has been prepared by SUFI for the local enterprise companies and SUFI to work to.

Elaine Thomson Lab Aberdeen North
link

When will the marketing programme be rolled out? When do the regulations become operative? I thought that, after 1 September, people would be able to apply for individual learning accounts.

David Stewart Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

It has gone live from 1 September; people can apply for ILAs. Indeed, a number of people who were getting ILAs through the field testing process have already got their accounts. Several thousand accounts are therefore already in existence. My colleague Allan Wilson will say a little about the local marketing that is already under way. The main push on national marketing will follow the launch of the Scottish UFI next month. That will cover joint marketing of learndirect services and the money that is available through ILAs.

Mr Wilson
link

Much of the local marketing is already in hand, because we were able to roll out the field testing of ILAs throughout Scotland. That information has already gone out to LECs, employers and the main learning providers. Even in the few days that the programme has been going, the telephone line to SUFI has been extremely busy with inquiries. The message is clearly getting through, but we do not yet know whether it is getting through to the right people. We will find out about that through the monitoring that we are undertaking as part of our overall evaluation.

Mr Wilson
link

It is mainly advertised in a range of booklets and packs that have been made available. A number of posters have also been produced, which are being displayed in locations that the local marketing people consider appropriate. We have been talking to our colleagues in the Department for Education and Employment about what further promotion might be undertaken. It is possible, although we have not agreed the details yet, that there may be some limited radio marketing as well.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

I am a wee bit surprised to hear about the sequence of events that you have described: the local marketing preceding the national marketing. Parliamentary debates left me with the impression that we had to get the bill through in such a hurry because everything was going live so quickly and the regulations would simply enforce what was going to happen. I am quite bewildered by the time scale that you are now talking about.

David Stewart Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

The time scale relates to the fact that the ILAs were going to go live in the rest of the UK at the same time. Tax relief for vocational training was going to end on 31 August, so the new system had to be ready for 1 September for those who would otherwise have been able to use that type of relief to be able to take advantage of ILAs. Those are the two reasons for the change. Local marketing has taken the lead because, throughout the period during which the bill was discussed, we were piloting and field testing ILAs with local enterprise companies. There has been a lot of local marketing. All the learning providers in Scotland have received packs about ILAs, as have employers, so people coming forward for courses can be told about them. The bit that has not gone out live in headlights at this stage is the television and national newspaper advertising, which will go live with the SUFI marketing in October to get both messages across together. At that point, the telephone number, which is widely known among those in the know, will be better promoted in all the media and will gain a high level of awareness.

Elaine Thomson Lab Aberdeen North
link

Will there be a website for local and national marketing?

Mr Wilson
link

Yes. There is already a lot of information about ILAs on the Scottish University for Industry website. We are continually reviewing that information and it will be updated.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

I think that we have exhausted that subject. There are no issues arising from the regulations that we need to draw to the attention of Parliament, although there are some technical issues that have been highlighted by the Subordinate Legislation Committee. We must wait for those issues to be formally resolved before we can sign off the regulations. However, as we have no issues to report to Parliament as a result of today's deliberations, we shall give the regulations the nod when the Subordinate Legislation Committee clears up its issues.Thank you for your evidence.

Meeting continued in private until 13:04.

  1. Scottish Parliament Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee Wednesday 6 September 2000 (Morning) Committee business · 2
  2. Exam Results Committee business · 24
  3. The New Economy Committee business · 156
  4. Subordinate Legislation Subordinate legislation · 42

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.