Item 2 is an oral evidence session as part of our inquiry into the delivery of regeneration in Scotland. We have two panels of witnesses today. The first panel is here to discuss the role of European Union and lottery funding in regeneration. I welcome Eric Samuel, senior policy and learning manager with the Big Lottery Fund; Colin McLean, head of the Heritage Lottery Fund Scotland; and David Souter, team leader with the European structural funds programme delivery team at the Scottish Government. Gentlemen, would you like to make brief opening remarks?
Official Report · Committee
Regeneration
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Kevin Stewart SNP 53
- Eric Samuel Big Lottery Fund 32
- Colin McLean Heritage Lottery Fund 30
- David Souter Scottish Government 22
- Stewart Stevenson SNP 21
- Margaret Mitchell Con 19
- Andy Milne SURF - Scotland’s Independent Regeneration Network 16
- Stuart McMillan SNP 15
- Stuart Hashagen Scottish Community Development Centre and Community Health Exchange 15
- Angus Hardie Scottish Community Alliance 14
- Rory Dutton Development Trusts Association Scotland 13
- John Wilson SNP 12
- John Pentland Lab 9
- Anne McTaggart Lab 2
The record
273 contributions · showing 1–200Yes. In a sense, the Heritage Lottery Fund does what it says on the tin: we are primarily a heritage organisation, although our objective is to make a lasting—that is an important word—difference for heritage and for people, both individuals and communities. We are not a regeneration agency per se, although we firmly believe that, as we said in our written submission, a great number of our projects have a great deal of impact on communities and towns and spaces around Scotland.
We write to MSPs to tell you what awards have been made in your constituencies, but I never take it for granted that you know what the Big Lottery Fund does, so I will quickly describe that. We are a United Kingdom organisation, with offices in all four countries of the UK. I am based in the Scotland office in Glasgow. We still do some UK-wide work, but most of our work in Scotland is Scotland focused, as we carry out policy directions that are given to us by Scottish ministers. Twenty-eight pence from each lottery pound goes to good causes, and Big receives 40 per cent of that amount. We are therefore the largest lottery distributor in the UK and Scotland.We operate a wide range of grants programmes, ranging from the very small, offering £300 to £2,000, to the very large, dealing with millions of pounds, and we take a variety of approaches to do that. Our mission is to bring improvements to communities and the lives of people most in need. We do that by investing about £1 million a week in such communities in Scotland.
The Scottish Government is the managing authority for both the European regional development fund and the European social fund in Scotland. We deliver them through two separate programmes: one in the Highlands and Islands and one in the lowlands and uplands. The regeneration focus is largely on the lowlands and uplands programme, for which we have delivered around £84 million of grant against £200 million of expenditure through our urban regeneration programme.The focus of the structural funds programmes changed in the last programme period, and we moved away from the more traditional place-based regeneration interventions that previous structural funds had funded towards having much more focus on employability. That led to our being fairly restricted in what we can do in regeneration, although we have funded quite a mixed bag of projects, including the JESSICA—joint European support for sustainable investment in city areas—regeneration fund, which should provide a revolving source of funding for regeneration as we move forward.
Thank you very much. I will start by asking Mr Samuel and Mr McLean a question. We have had evidence from a number of community groups, not only during this inquiry but in the course of other work that the committee has done, that quite often lottery funding is available for capital works but the groups then find it difficult to cope with on-going revenue costs. Can you comment on that and perhaps give the committee an indication of how you can tackle that in the future? It is all very well having nice new buildings, whether brand new or refurbished, but if you do not have the money to run them after you have established them, that creates even more difficulties and frustration.
In the case of the HLF, that is fair criticism. We are a project funder and so our funding is for capital projects or time-limited activities projects. From all our projects, we expect clear people benefits, which might be training programmes or apprenticeships through our skills programme. All our projects are required to meet our criteria, which suggest that people need to be involved and have a say in what is happening to their heritage in their place, and that people should participate in activities around the projects to build a legacy. However, we do not provide long-term core funding and we have never seen that as our remit. Therefore, that is a perfectly fair criticism.
You say that you do not provide long-term funding, but I wonder about the benefit of spending a lot of money on refurbishing a building or other structure only for that not to be used because there is not enough revenue. Although it is great to save our heritage, it seems a bit daft to put in a huge amount of capital only for a building to go to waste again.
If some of the projects that we funded went to waste, I would completely agree with you, but I am comfortable in saying that, of the more than 3,000 projects that we have funded in Scotland, not a single one has gone to waste. When we assess projects, we are keen to ensure that there is a plan for long-term sustainability. That plan might be about involving volunteers in the long term, having a source of revenue funding from other places or receiving funding from us to cover some of the start-up costs through, for example, new education programmes. For that reason, thus far, none of our buildings projects has failed.
Most of the money that the Big Lottery Fund gives out is revenue funding, whereas capital funding is probably a fairly small element, although it is a major programme. The growing community assets programme, which I look after, is about enabling communities to take over assets. We stress that we want communities eventually to operate those assets on their own and to make them financially viable and sustainable.The programme has been evaluated independently, and from that we know how vital it is to provide money for revenue for such projects. For example, we know that it is important to have a project manager from the start to manage a project, and we will supply funding for that. We supply funding for five years, as well as other support. We have a social enterprise called the Social Investment Business, which provides applicants with support with putting together business plans and financial planning.We are in an interesting time. Like Colin McLean’s organisation, we have funded 127 projects through the first round of the GCA programme and we are now into the second round, but none has failed, although I have to say that we have probably had some near things. The financial climate is proving challenging for some projects. Some projects that we funded in the first round are coming back because of the financial situation and because things are not working out quite as was thought in their plans to make themselves sustainable. The Big Lottery Fund Scotland committee has been supportive of those projects so far, as we feel that we have some responsibility to help them. Revenue funding is available from us, as well as capital funding, to help those projects.
To follow on from the convener’s points, we have received evidence on joint projects between, say, a local authority and volunteers. The evidence from the volunteers was that, because they do not have continuing resources to enable them to use the facility, they find themselves excluded. The reason why those projects are sustainable and do not fail is that the local authority—or whoever the other partner is—picks up the cost. However, that is at the expense of the volunteers, who cannot use the facility because they do not have enough resources to pay for that.Colin McLean and Eric Samuel said that, until now, there have been very few failures but, as the convener said, in future we might see more. On that point, is any advice given or is any transitional funding available to help organisations such as the ones that we have heard about to help them through the process?
In fact, we have just introduced a new programme called exactly that—transitional funding—to help our past grant recipients to look again at their business model and how they run their organisations, so that they can get support to rethink what they do with the resources that are available. That programme has just been launched and I do not think that we have made an award under it yet. However, it is in response to the exact situation that you describe and I hope that through it we can find a way to help the organisations that you mention.
We also had a programme called survive and thrive, which was put in place not just to help growing community asset projects but projects from other investment areas, to help them through this difficult financial climate.
Will you be making that public knowledge—are you doing a promotion about that?
We promote all our programmes.
Good morning. For the record, I should declare that I chair a local organisation that is in receipt of several funding strands from the Big Lottery Fund.I want to follow up Mr Pentland’s question about the assets or community facilities that are developed through funding, particularly from the Big Lottery Fund. The submission from the Big Lottery Fund refers to a project in Newmains in North Lanarkshire and indicates that the local library and housing office will move into the new facility that is being built. Who owns that facility—who ultimately has control and management responsibility for it? One of the issues that this committee tries to examine is where funding from the Big Lottery Fund, the European social fund and other European funding programmes and the Heritage Lottery Fund goes to and whether that funding just supplements existing public services, such as local authority services, rather than being a real benefit to communities. We may go further into the definition of communities and people later on but, before we do that, could you explain what criteria are put in place to ensure that local communities gain an asset and that the funding is not just used by another organisation as a funding stream to supplement its own responsibilities?
The growing community assets programme is quite clear: it is about communities owning assets. We do sometimes face the problem that public bodies do not want to release those assets to community groups. We are not saying that ownership is the be all and end all, or that there is anything wrong with leasing. However, we know from our experience, for example, of operating the Scottish land fund—the lottery funding from 2001 to 2006—the transformational effects that happen when communities take over assets. That is why we are very strict in saying that growing community assets is totally about community ownership. We sometimes receive pleas that we should consider leasing. To be honest, though, our clients tell us that they do not want that. They want overall control of those assets. Therefore we go to great lengths to ensure that the asset is passed to a community group, which is then responsible for that asset and for taking it forward.
I assume that you mean that the community owns and controls the building.
Correct.
In the past, the Big Lottery Fund gave grants for refurbishment or new build if a 25-year lease was obtained.
We never did that.
That is good, because it gives clarification. A popular misconception is that the Big Lottery Fund would give grant funding for community assets if there was a 25-year lease.
We tend to be criticised because we will not do that.
There is still the issue of ownership and control. That ties into Mr Pentland’s question about other agencies and local authority departments stepping in to assist and in effect to bale out some community organisations to allow them to continue to own and control those buildings. 09:45
We are quite clear that it is about community ownership and that the community group should own the asset. That said, if the local authority or any other public body decides to hire some of the rooms or facilities in the asset in order to provide a service, it gives a degree of comfort because the project will get the running costs. We would positively welcome outside agencies buying services from such assets to give them a chance of becoming financially sustainable.
Although I agree entirely with Eric Samuel’s general point, I think that there can be some exceptions. For example, with Maryhill burgh halls in Glasgow, although the community trust ultimately took ownership of the project, we would have been completely happy for Glasgow City Council, which owned the building, to grant a very long lease, as that would have provided some security not only for the building—the heritage asset—but, as we have heard, for the trust, as it would not have had that ownership headache to worry about.Like Eric Samuel, we would be happy for public service bodies to take a tenancy in one of our projects and provide those running it with some secure income. A very good example of that is Garrison house in Millport, where the local health service established a health centre and pharmacy in what started out as a heritage project, providing a sustainable use that secures some income.
What is your definition of a long lease?
Twenty-five years. We have had some 99-year leases.
Going back to a previous question, I wonder whether the panel can define the term “community” for me. I know that Mr McLean referred to people, but it would be good to get more clarification on that. After all, there are so many definitions of community; we have a community planning process, for example, and there are all these moves to put communities at the heart of the policy.Secondly, in its submission, the Big Lottery Fund says that a number of organisations are“involved in regeneration including, for example, the Scottish Government, SURF, DTAS, HIE, SIS and, at a local level, local authorities.”Where is the reference to the communities or the local people who are being asked to deliver on some of these major innovative regeneration projects at a local level?In short, I seek a definition of community and, secondly, I want to know where communities figure in the process at ESF, Heritage Lottery Fund or Big Lottery Fund level.
We do not try to define “community” in that way. For us, a community is a group of people with a tangible or intangible asset from their past that they want to talk to us about doing something with. It does not matter to us whether that group is a local authority, an established trust or a new body; in fact, we have introduced a new range of start-up grants aimed at bodies that are not yet constituted and which do not know quite what to do with the asset in which they are interested. I hope that our definition of community is very inclusive, not exclusive; in our view, it is the group of people who are interested in doing something with this or that tangible or intangible asset.
The quotation that John Wilson highlighted comes from our response to the question,“How can the linkage between the various strategies and policies related to regeneration be improved?”I should make it clear that our growing community assets initiative supports communities, but we did not feel it appropriate to mention it in that particular response.Like the Heritage Lottery Fund, we allow communities to define themselves and are not in the business of telling communities where their boundaries are. However, we insist that applications come from community groups and that the facility must be community owned and managed and, at the application stage, we check that the project has the local community’s support. The group making the application must have a membership of at least 100 people in that community or 10 per cent of the population. I repeat that there is no doubt that GCA is about community ownership.
Mr Souter, can you comment from a European funding perspective?
With European funding, we do not define the term “community”. In fact, we tend to engage with public agencies, mainly because the audit burden that accompanies such funding is heavy and long standing, and the only way in which we can deliver on that and offer some reassurance to the Commission is by engaging through public bodies.We co-funded the Maryhill burgh halls, because it was a good project and it stacked up, so it is not the case that we engage exclusively with the public sector. We go to community groups as well, as long as we have some reassurance that the audit and liability can be carried forward.
I want, fairly concisely, to extract some numbers, in so far as we might be able to get them. In doing so, I start by making a distinction between projects and responsibilities. A project has a beginning, a middle and an end, and the end is the most important part. A responsibility is something that has no defined end. It may end up having an end, but that is a different thing. My questions are asked in that context. What I am interested in—informed, to some extent, by the submission from the Heritage Lottery Fund—is knowing what proportion of the generality of project and responsibility funding comes from you guys and what comes from elsewhere. In other words, what is the balance—broadly? I am not looking for auditable figures.
Our average percentage grant is about 50 per cent, so we have levered in roughly the same amount again. We have spent approximately £600 million in Scotland, so that is £1.2 billion in total. That percentage is climbing, for obvious reasons. The lottery is one of the few major sources of funding around, certainly in heritage. There are few heritage projects proceeding now in which we are not involved, and our percentage intervention rates are climbing. In virtually all our programmes, we can now offer up to 90 per cent and, in some of the smaller ones, we can offer 100 per cent. Does that help you?
Yes, that is a helpful answer to the first of my set of questions. Does Eric Samuel also want to say something?
It depends on which programme investment area is on offer. We can offer up to 100 per cent, but our committee tends to look for some contribution—whether that is a financial contribution or a contribution in kind—particularly where growing community assets is concerned. When we are talking about a community, we like to see some contribution from somewhere in that community to show commitment to the project.
I come to the second of my three strands of questions. What kind of measurable benefit do you expect for every pound that you deploy?
We do not run an analysis like that. We are looking for outcomes from our investment—we think of it as investment—such as the heritage being better managed and people better understanding their heritage, taking more interest in it, taking better care of it in future, enjoying it more and knowing more about it. We do not run a financial model that says that a pound of this has to produce a pound of that.
How, then, do you assess the range of opportunities that you have for spending money and decide which come top of the pile and which will fall below the cut? What is the metric, if it is not a financial metric? In saying that, I am not suggesting that it should be a financial metric.
We now have 15 grant programmes. They are all managed individually, and there is competition at the moment in every one of those. Let us take, for example, heritage grants. Yesterday, I was in London presenting some projects for parks to our board. The competition, as ever, is stiff. There are always more projects than we have resources to support, and our board decided some time ago that, as long as we have managed the applicant’s request during the assessment process so that we think that it is realistic—which does not mean, “What’s the least we can give them?” but, “What is the amount needed to realise the project?”—we will take a decision based on that amount, so someone would not ask for £2 million and receive £1 million from us. We then assess the projects against the outcome framework for that programme, asking whether the heritage will be better managed, and so on—some of the things that I mentioned earlier—and projects compete against one another on that basis. We do not use an arithmetical scoring system.
Is it fair to say that a key part of your decision making is looking at the ability of the sponsors of the project and their responsibility to deliver? In other words, there is no point in supporting a project that cannot convince you that it is going to work.
Yes, I think that that is fair comment.
Let me move on to my final numerical question, if we can get it. For every pound, or unit of benefit—whatever the metric might be—that you expect from projects, how much do you actually get? In other words, I expect to see some failure, because if there is no failure in the system, we are not being ambitious enough and taking enough risks. I just wonder where you see the balance lie.
In our new outcomes framework—for example, under heritage grants, which cover all the standard heritage projects that you will be familiar with, which in our case are those that request more than £100,000—we do not expect our applicants to meet all our outcomes. They pick the outcomes that they think are most suitable to their programme. We think that that is a much healthier way to operate.Whereas in the past we have been very good at examining the detail of what people do, we are now much more interested in what difference that is going to make. The assessment or judgment of one against the other is more difficult for us now. It is a new system, which we launched just last year, and it is proving challenging for our decision makers. When we say that projects fail—and I said earlier that we have had very few that have failed—they are not all being measured against exactly the same thing, because we do not think that it is possible to do that in our sector. Projects are not being measured in exactly the same way.In general, heritage projects are likely to succeed in getting our support if they are involved with something that is at risk or something that the local community believes to be of significance to it. We do not define “heritage” in any way and, if you come to us and say that a thing, tangible or intangible, is important to you, that is enough of a definition of heritage and importance—we do not say, “No, it’s not.”In those terms, it is rather easy for us to see that the projects were all important to the applicants and therefore are delivering benefits back to them.
So the ad hoc definition comes from the project sponsor.
It comes from the applicant.
It comes from the applicant. Where does the post hoc assessment come from?
All through a project’s management, we will work closely with the applicant, making sure that all the invoices are correct—that is the lowest common denominator. At a much more realistic level, we do a great deal of hand holding. We might provide the grantee with a mentor—a project manager to help them to run their project. Projects are difficult to run and we have a lot of experience in doing that. We provide a great deal of support for our recipients.
You make a very interesting point. Years ago, a boss in my department said that if we do not fund some failures, we have failed, because it is all about trying new stuff. I would imagine that Colin McLean thinks the same. We are so tightly controlled by our financial regulations and by audit nowadays that we have to be very careful about what we put money into, so we operate a risk-based approach.
Is the point not that when something fails, you will be judged on when you catch the failure and respond to it, rather than on whether you have failed? Is that not the proper test?
We try to make sure that we do not fund failure to start with, but inevitably some things will fail. As Colin McLean said, we are exactly the same. We try to help our grant holders through that journey.
Are you saying that your absolute focus is to look at a project and say, “This is one that has some defined percentage of potential for failing,” and you will not choose to fund a portfolio of projects with bigger risk? Many of those bigger-risk projects may be ones that deliver bigger benefit.
Again, it varies from programme to programme and investment area to investment area, but generally our assessment process is to try to make sure that we fund successful projects. We owe that to the projects themselves, if nothing else.
Thank you. I have a list of names: Margaret Mitchell, Stuart McMillan, Anne McTaggart and then John Pentland again.
Good morning, gentlemen. I will probe a little more on outcomes and how you assess projects. I want you to bear in mind a comment in written evidence from one of the people whom we will hear from later, which stated:“there was often a marked difference between the outcomes of expensive evaluation programmes paid for by those funding the programme and the perceptions of local people living within communities being regenerated.”I take on board Mr McLean’s comment that the Heritage Lottery Fund provides niche funding that is not necessarily focused on regeneration, although that can certainly be a by-product. It would be helpful if you could all comment on that.
I am happy to say something about evaluation. We expect all our projects to do some self-evaluation and we ask the applicant at the beginning to work with us to define how they will evaluate their own success. We do not very often pay for expensive post-project evaluation exercises, so I think that that criticism probably would not work for us.We are very keen that applicants do their own evaluation because we think that there are lessons to be learned from evaluation for everyone, including the applicants. All projects have associated risk, so there is always something that has to be dealt with along the way, or even after the project has finished. If the applicants do their own evaluation, that is a healthier approach to the science, if I may call it that.10:00
Mr Souter has been quite quiet.
We have a fairly rigorous evaluation process before we agree funding, which involves peer review of any project to ensure that it stacks up. In terms of the impact on local communities, a lot of our investments tend to be quite long term and involve transport, and it is only when other things happen that their impact can truly be evaluated. We can evaluate whether we have met most of the programme indicators that we signed up to, but we cannot really measure whether that has had an impact on the local community within the time period.It is absolutely right that we require that projects evaluate themselves, but if they pay for their own evaluation it will not be overly critical. Therefore, after the closure of the programme, we are required to evaluate the impact of the programme, and it is at that stage that we start to see what the impacts have been rather than the outcomes, which we monitor closely.
You talk about ensuring that a project stacks up. What do you look for?
If it is a capital project, we look for surety that there will be revenue funding behind it and that it will not face difficulties. We tend to look for business space, and to ensure that there is a market for it in the area that will provide the revenue funding. If it is a revenue project, we look for an exit strategy from the European funding and we want to know whether other funding has been identified to take the project forward.
I presume that that would be for the benefit of the local community.
Absolutely—although structural funds tend to be delivered through the large public agencies. We tend to look at how the community planning partnerships have engaged with communities, because that is not something in which we have a role to play.
Do you consult the community on what it thinks about how funds have been used?
That is part of the evaluation of the overall programme. When we develop individual projects, it is the role of the agency that has strategic responsibility for the area and for the policy area to bring forward projects that meet the criteria.
You will forgive me for saying that that is exactly the kind of top-down approach that we have just heard has caused the failure of regeneration in many areas.
I fully agree. It is one of the failures of the current programme that, at the moment, we are requiring people to bring in projects rather than giving more security of funding over a longer period so that organisations can deliver a more strategic, bottom-up approach and engage with communities. We tie up a lot of the community groups and community planning partnerships in bidding rounds and pulling projects together instead of focusing them on delivering outcomes. We need to try to fix that for the new programme period. It is a fault with the current programme.
When an organisation comes along or you have a bid in front of you, what is to prevent your going out and talking to the local community?
I suppose that there is nothing to prevent that. I could say that it is resources or that it is not really our role, but there is nothing to prevent our going out and talking to a community group to evaluate a project.
My question, too, is on funding and agency involvement. What is the current grant funding level for a project? When I worked for a project that received European funding, match funding of 55 per cent had to be found. Is that still the case? It is very difficult for communities to find that level of funding. For a major infrastructure regeneration project, that could be a couple of million pounds.
There are two different intervention rates. The figure tends to average out at about 40 per cent in the Lowlands and uplands, but it can go up to 70 per cent in the Highlands and Islands, simply because the programme is different.I fully recognise the difficulties that small community groups in particular face in building sometimes very complicated funding packages to draw down ERDF and ESF. Since I moved into looking at the European social fund, which involves more local organisations, one of the things that has frustrated me is that we require organisations to spend a disproportionate amount of time building funding packages and drawing funding from the strategic agencies that are responsible for delivering the policy. Part of the thinking for the new programme is that we should try to declutter things, remove that requirement, and lift the audit burden that currently sits with community groups and put it at a level of groups that are better resourced to deal with.
Raising the funding is one thing, but ensuring that you have the right project at the very beginning by engaging with the community would be a marked improvement. I recommend that you consider that.
We evaluate at various levels. We expect projects to self-evaluate, and we will include money in the grant that we give to them to pay the costs of that, but we also provide them with support from a contractor to learn how to evaluate, because we think that it is important for projects to know whether they are succeeding and to have evidence with which they can prove that the project has been successful when it comes to looking for future funding and making a case for it.We also evaluate at programme level. That happens sometimes although not always. However, the growing community assets programme has been independently evaluated over the past five years. In fact, I have just had the final evaluation through. I will pass that to the clerk, because I think that it will be of interest to members of the committee. Households where the projects were located were asked what they thought of them and whether they had made a difference. We go down to the community level with the evaluations.A member of my staff conducted an evaluation of the our place initiative. They spoke to stakeholders and people who were involved in the projects at the local level.
How much is done at the front end before the allocation of funding in talking to the community and teasing out whether it thinks that a project will have value?
We leave the applicants to make that case to us. We question them on that and look for community consultation; for example, what events they have held, and when—whether they were held recently or whether something that was carried out years ago is being relied on. We want up-to-date information about applicants talking to their communities about whether they want to see the project go forward.
Would it involve their having held public meetings?
The applicants could have held a public meeting, carried out a consultation exercise or done anything that can prove that they have the support of the community. We will not support anything through GCA that does not have the support of the local community. We know from evaluating that there is no point in putting money into something that is not supported by the local community.
What can the local community be?
As I said in response to an earlier question, we let the community define itself. We are more interested in hearing about the people who live in the community. GCA is not there to fund communities of interest; it is there to fund communities. We want to see the people who live in the community supporting the projects.
link
Good morning, gentlemen. My first question is to Mr Souter. Can you provide some information, please, on the level of European funds that have been invested in regeneration over the past five years and how much it is intended will be invested in each of the next five years?
I can give figures for this programme period. We have delivered £84 million in grants in 13 local authority areas that are targeted under our urban regeneration priority, and that has unlocked expenditure of about £200 million.The complication with setting out what the plans are for the next five years is that, as you will probably be aware, we are coming to the end of the present structural funds period; the new period starts next year. We are in consultation on the shape of the new programme and the delivery arrangements for it.Scotland will receive something in the order of €700 million over the next six or seven years. There is no thematic criterion of urban regeneration in the new programmes; the European Commission has set out what the 11 themes will be and urban regeneration is not one of them, although some of the activity indicators would lend themselves to a wider, more holistic definition of regeneration that would include low-carbon interventions at local level and skills development. The best guess is that about €200 million will be available in the social inclusion and employability envelope, but we do not have precise figures for how that will play out for what could be termed as regeneration.
link
At last week’s meeting, I raised the point that, when it comes to regeneration, there will not be a one-size-fits-all strategy for Scotland as a whole, given the country’s demographics and the differences between urban and rural communities. That said, when we consider that the various funding arrangements that are in place include the ERDF, the European social fund, the rural development programme and the maritime and fisheries programme, do you think that there are too many types of funding opportunity? Is the landscape too crowded?
Within the European funding streams, there is a big push from the Commission to get more effective outcomes across all four funds. The proposals that are out for consultation would see us draw together the ERDF, the ESF, the maritime funding and the rural funding into three thematic Scottish funds. The idea is that that would hide the wiring for project sponsors. If a project sponsor comes forward with a good idea, it should not matter whether the funding comes from a maritime fund, a rural fund, the ESF or the ERDF; it should just be funded as a good idea.We want to take that a stage further. I think that there are too many funding streams, not only in those four funds, but generally. We have a situation in which project sponsors are building funding packages and then bringing them to European funding streams. We would like to work with the strategic delivery agencies to look at what their plans are for the next five or six years and to align the European structural funds much more closely with the sources of match funding, so that community and other groups can have better and easier access to the funds overall. As well as offering those groups the advantage of a one-stop shop for European funding, that approach would pass on the quite significant audit burden to agencies that are probably better able and better resourced to deal with it over the next 10 or 13 years, or however long the auditable life of the programme is.
link
Would the other witnesses like to add to that?
Are you referring to your earlier question about figures, or would you like me to comment on everything that you asked about?
link
I would like you to comment on all of it, but the second question in particular.
Okay. The first question is not easy to answer, because we fund in rounds. For example, we spent £160 million in the first round of what we call investing in communities, which ran from 2006 until 2010. Our current funding round runs from 2010 until 2015. Over that period, we have an indicative budget of £242.5 million, but I probably cannot specify how much of it is for regeneration because of the variety of the programmes. Some of the programmes, such as the growing community assets programme, are very much aimed at that, but a lot of the programmes are revenue programmes that may do some regeneration, although that is not their point.
link
I am sorry to butt in, but I would like to pose one quick question. Have you seen an uplift in the funds that are available to the Big Lottery Fund since the Olympic games finished?10:15
I am not sure what link you are making there, but we have certainly seen an uplift because of increased ticket sales. The other problem that we face is that our budgets can fluctuate according to a number of factors, one of which is ticket sales.You asked whether there are too many programmes. That is something that we are very conscious of, not least because of the operating costs of the programmes, which we are trying to drive down. We try to help in that we operate something called a single front door. It is not a physical door, but access to a team of staff in the office. Basically, our customers do not have to know what they are applying for. They can phone the number and speak to staff, and behind the scenes we will arrange the best programme for them to go to. We try to help them in that way.
I will give you a range of figures. In the past five years, we have committed £105 million to heritage projects in Scotland. On a generous estimate, we would say that because there are people benefits from all of them, they have all had some impact on regeneration. If we take the tightest definition, through our specific town centre regeneration programme—the townscape heritage initiative—we have committed roughly £15 million in that period. That is the range, and the true figure will lie somewhere in between.On whether the landscape is too crowded, like Eric Samuel’s organisation, we have one team in Edinburgh, and three of the 17 staff members are devoted to development work, which involves providing advice to applicants. The advice that we give to all prospective applicants is, “Get in touch with us, speak to us, and we’ll plug you in to one of our programmes.” The range of programmes is a reflection of the consultation that we did with our usual stakeholders and the general public in devising our new strategic framework.
link
Thank you. I have a final question for Mr Souter and then one for Mr Samuel.On the European funding that is managed by the Scottish Government and any auditing that has taken place, has the Government been happy or content with the outcomes thus far? Have any projects not achieved as big an economic impact as was hoped for? Has the Government been happy with the outcomes that have transpired from the investment that has been made?
In general terms, when programmes are measured against the outcomes that we signed up to at the start, we are content that we have delivered.A few projects have not delivered as we expected. Probably the most obvious example is one that I mentioned earlier—the JESSICA investment fund that was specifically to create a revolving line of debt finance to unlock capital investment. When we designed the JESSICA fund, the intention was that it would fund projects that were happening in areas that needed regeneration. The shift in the market over the past four or five years has meant that those projects are simply not happening, and we have had to shift the focus of the investment to projects that, five years ago, would have been considered for bank finance. That is not necessarily a criticism of the JESSICA instrument, because it demonstrates that it is flexible enough to deal with different market conditions, but a frustration of mine is that it is not doing what I thought it was going to do at the start and unlocking investments in communities. I hope that, by the time the money starts to be repaid and comes back in, the market will have picked up and we will be able to have a revolving line of credit that can go out. That is probably the project in which I am most disappointed.However, in general terms, most projects are where we expected them to be. We monitor projects closely and they are required to submit information regularly. Inevitably, because we have 500 projects, some will be more successful than others, but in general terms we are reasonably comfortable that the money is being spent well.I think that we could have done better if we had been more strategic in the delivery arrangements and if we had aligned the funding streams a bit more. That is a lesson learned from the current programme period that is informing us for the new one.
link
My final question—
Before we leave you, Mr Souter, I have a question. You said that you could probably have dealt with some of the funding streams a little better. Do some of the difficulties that sometimes exist result from having overcomplicated programmes and policies?
The programmes are certainly overcomplicated. How we have separated out the different European funding strands in our current programme does not give us the best result. Being more joined up and more strategic about those strands would give us better results.
What do you mean by being more strategic? What do you suggest?
That is about joining up the strands at a higher level. We spend a lot of time and a lot of money on administering the different funding streams from Europe on agriculture, fisheries, the ESF and the European regional development fund. We spend a lot of resource on delivering them.We also spend a lot of resource on meeting the audit burden that goes along with that administration and on all the compliance arrangements. It would be better if we could simplify the whole process and use that resource on ensuring that things are being done more effectively rather than on the bureaucracy of the streams.
Are those audit and compliance regulations laid down by Europe or has someone here decided to put that burden on us?
It is very easy for managing authorities to always blame the Commission. Options were available to us earlier in the programme period for simplified cost methodologies that would have removed an awful lot of the audit problems that were faced. However, the appetite to make those changes was not there at the start of the programme.
You mention “simplified cost methodologies”—not only do the folk out there get annoyed by such phrases, but we get somewhat frustrated by them too.
Sorry.
Are you saying that, at the beginning of the programmes, somebody decided to overcomplicate the administration, the audit and the compliance of the funds?
No. I will define a simplified cost: it is a unit cost for an outcome—for example, if somebody trains 1,000 plumbers, we will pay them X amount for every one of those plumbers.We have developed the funds and we deliver them in a way that is based on full cost recovery. Basically, whatever expenditure is defrayed in training those 1,000 plumbers, all the paperwork has to be kept for it and people have to hold that paperwork for 10 years by the time the auditors come in. That is what we audit.Earlier in the programme period, we had the option to sign up to the unit cost methodology, whereby a price is fixed and people are paid for that. The Commission’s thinking on that came pretty late in the programme period—it came midway through it. It was felt at the time that it would not be possible to introduce that option midway through a programme period.
So because we have done it one way, we will continue doing it that way—is that it?
The issue is more that that is how projects have been funded up to now and it was unreasonable to move the goalposts midway through the programme period. However, we will have to use all the options on the simplified cost and the unit cost to deliver the programmes in the future, because we simply cannot continue with the full cost recovery approach, with all the bus tickets and all the receipts.
I might seek further clarification later on some of your points. I am sorry for having interrupted Stuart McMillan, but it was important to get that point clear.
link
Mr Samuel, the answer to question 6 in your submission touches on the state aid regulations. Will you explain your concerns about them, please?
The issue seems to be arising more and more nowadays. In our case, it stems from when we try to get projects to think about how they will become financially viable towards the end of their grant, as I explained earlier. One obvious way in which they can do that is by engaging in fairly low-level, low-key trading activity. However, the word “trading” triggers all sorts of problems as far as state aid is concerned. It can also cause us problems when funding also comes from another organisation. We might take one view of state aid and another funder could take an opposite view of state aid—that happens and creates problems. It has been a particular issue for the Scottish land fund as far as forestry projects are concerned. In fact, I will go to a meeting about that after this meeting.I have to give credit to our legal people, because they encourage us to push the envelope a bit on state aid. However, we have to be very careful. It would be all very well for us to say to a project, “We’re giving you money, but it could be liable to challenge under state aid regulations,” and wash our hands of it, but we do not think that that would be a responsible attitude, so we try to investigate the issue before we give a project money. If a grant is challenged and found to be contravening regulations, the project loses out, because it has to hand back the money and will be fined. We therefore have a responsibility to be clear on the issue.We try to push the envelope—I am not saying that we break the law; please do not take my comments in that way—as far as we can to help the groups concerned. As I said in our submission, we hope that the committee agrees that our approach is the best one for communities out there.
link
Have you spoken to similar organisations in other EU member states about the issue?
No, we have not spoken to organisations in other EU member states, but we are obviously in contact with other Scottish organisations and, as we are a UK organisation, we look at the matter across the board in the UK.
link
Have you raised your concerns with representatives in the European Parliament and with the relevant EU commissioner?
No, we have not, although we could probably do that. My personal opinion—I am not saying that this is the Big Lottery Fund’s opinion—is that it might be better if the matter was taken forward at a level higher than the Big Lottery Fund.
Stewart Stevenson has a brief supplementary question.
My question is on a slightly different subject, convener.
In that case, I will add Mr Stevenson to the end of my list.
My question, which is for Mr Samuel, is on the our place programme, which the Big Lottery Fund’s submission mentions. That programme appears to be excellent and it appears to meet the needs of communities as they have been expressed to us. Is the intention to roll it out across Scotland? It currently operates in only five areas.
That is a very new approach for us. We think that the programme has been successful, but we want time to assess that. Having said that, we are sufficiently confident in it that, although we will not roll it out across Scotland, we will do the same thing again in seven other neighbourhoods.We are in the middle of working through data but, as you can imagine, selecting the areas is not an easy task, because of the various interests that are involved. The programme is a long-term one and its operating cost is quite expensive. As I said, we are always being looked at to see what our operating costs are and to ensure that we are not spending too much on management and administration rather than on getting the grants out there, so we need to be very careful in how we take programmes forward. However, we have been sufficiently impressed by the our place programme to try it again in seven other areas. I hope that we will make announcements about that very soon.
As I was aware of who was going to be on the panel, I did a search to see how lottery funds are helping towards regeneration in my constituency, Motherwell and Wishaw. Anyone who knows Motherwell and Wishaw will be well aware that the area has significant regeneration needs. I was a wee bit alarmed to find out that, although there was funding historically, there has recently been a lack of spending in the area, particularly from the Heritage Lottery Fund. My question is about the criteria. Do you target funding at areas that are in most need?10:30
Yes. In each five-year planning period, we choose a small number of local authority areas, which we call development priorities. They are chosen according to two factors. The main one is spend, measured on a per capita basis. The other one is a deprivation measure. At the moment, our three priority areas are Dumfries and Galloway, West Lothian and West Dunbartonshire. I do not think that your area has ever been so low on our league table that it has been in the reckoning for being a development priority area, so there must be other areas of Scotland where we have been spending less.The development team—our front-of-house help team—focuses its efforts in those areas to encourage communities and others to think about heritage and about projects that they might propose to us. We can fairly say that, in our past five-year period, we had a considerable excess in those areas. It is not every local authority that we find that easy to work with but, in the main, that has been a good strategy.
I, too, looked at the figures for your constituency. The Garrion People’s Housing Co-operative got about £850,000 from us for a GCA project. I looked at the projects that I thought would be tied in with regeneration. Your area has probably done pretty well as far as GCA is concerned. There could always be more, but GCA depends a lot on the assets that are available in the community and what the community wants to proceed with.As a lottery distributor, we generally take a similar approach to that of the Heritage Lottery Fund, in that we monitor where the money is going and we look at whether people are getting what they think should be their share. That is where the our place programme came from—we saw that there were cold spots. Similarly to the Heritage Lottery Fund, we send out our outreach team to drum up business and generate support through us or from the third sector interface. Furthermore, local authorities have funding officers who can help communities to think about the projects that they would like to pursue and to put applications together.
It is good to see that Eric Samuel does his research, too.
It does not always work, but I try.
You referred to the Garrion People’s Housing Co-operative. We raised a question earlier about how a community finds itself in a situation because it does not have a business plan, and there is every chance that support could be removed.What percentage of your grants go to the most deprived areas? Do they get less, more or the average?
Because we prioritise our priority areas against two measures—one is low spend and the other is deprivation—we focus our efforts on deprived communities. Our spend in those areas tends to start from a low point, and we put in as much effort as we can to raise that.In the past five years, we have been successful in some of those areas and less successful in others. A main influencer is the local authority’s capacity and interest to use the Heritage Lottery Fund as a tool for whatever purpose. Generally, the deprived communities that have done less well get a lot of attention from us, but none of our funds is defined by place—they are all open to all parts of Scotland, with the tiny exception of the townscape heritage initiative, which is focused on designated conservation areas.
In the past, the explanation for low allocations has been that the number of applications was too low. What are you doing to address that?
Our development team is working in the areas concerned to encourage people to think about heritage and to bring applications to us. As I mentioned earlier, we now have a suite of programmes, some of which are aimed precisely at community groups that are struggling to develop ideas. We have start-up grants, transition funding and the our heritage programme, which can deliver projects with funds of up to £100,000 from us. We have a range of small, medium-sized and large programmes that we think meet everyone’s needs. They have been designed in response to comments that we have received.
My questions are for all three members of the panel. What funding bids have been made on an annual basis or in the funding rounds for the Big Lottery Fund? How far have they exceeded the money that has been available from each of the organisations?
Averaged across all our programmes, the success rate, if we might call it that, has been in recent years approximately 50 per cent—we have received twice as many bids by value as we have the resources to support them.
I am sorry, convener, but I obviously did not do my research thoroughly enough. I cannot give those figures now, but I will supply them to the committee.
The European social fund and the European regional development fund are 100 per cent targeted on regeneration areas for certain priorities. All the funding from the European social fund has been absorbed, and we are sitting at about 90 per cent commitment for the ERDF programme. Last week, we launched a call for new ERDF bids; we expect that to be significantly oversubscribed.
I understand that all three sets of funds will be heavily oversubscribed. Local authorities are establishing a number of arm’s-length organisations. They have indicated that they will make bids to the Big Lottery Fund, the Heritage Lottery Fund and other funds to supplement the regeneration of existing facilities. How do you view bids, particularly those made by arm’s-length organisations for mainstream public services that were delivered previously by a local authority?
The biggest risk probably comes from the sports and leisure arms that have been set up, which will probably be eligible to apply to us for funding. However, as far as the Big Lottery Fund is concerned, sportscotland funds sports so, fortunately—if that is the right expression to use—it is highly unlikely that we would have a programme that such bodies could apply to. They could come to the growing community assets programme for funding, but sports facilities have not been a high priority for that investment area.The issue has not been a big problem for us so far, but I very much take your point that it could increasingly become so in the future. I cannot give you any satisfaction because, as I said, such bodies will probably be eligible, so we will have to be alert to that.
In the culture and heritage world, arm’s-length bodies are common—virtually every authority has one or is in the process of establishing one. They are most certainly eligible to apply to us. Every local authority can also apply, but that makes no difference to the eligibility status of arm’s-length organisations as far as we are concerned.We have funded a number of projects with culture and leisure trusts that have been entirely successful. However, we need to bear it in mind that we do not provide core revenue funding so, in that sense, we are not substituting for the local authority‘s day-to-day activities.
I can think of no reason why arm’s-length organisations would be ineligible. However, in looking at the organisations that have been set up, I see no fit with current or future programmes. That might change as the trend develops, but the activity in which they are engaged would not be eligible for ERDF or ESF funding.
I asked those questions to compare what are in effect public bodies with local communities. There is major competition for funding streams and particularly for Big Lottery funding. The issue is how organisations make a like-for-like comparison between funding of a genuinely community-led project and funding of other projects.In the Big Lottery Fund’s submission, we read about the Helix project in Grangemouth, for which £25 million was awarded to Scottish Canals, Falkirk Council and the Central Scotland Forest Trust. Where is the community engagement in that process? Where is the community purpose in delivering that level of funding for a project when we clearly view regeneration as the regeneration of particular areas that suffer from deprivation? How does that fit into the overall programme?I understand the purpose of the ESF, what its aims are and where resources are targeted. However, how do we ensure that the scarce resources that are made available through the Heritage Lottery Fund and the Big Lottery Fund are being directed in the right direction to the maximum benefit of the communities that live in deprivation?
I said at the start that we have various investment areas and programmes. To echo what Colin McLean said, the Big Lottery Fund can fund the public sector and the private sector as long as the grants that we give are earmarked and we keep careful control so that the money does not go into profits.We operate various programmes; the living landmarks programme aimed to do large-scale regeneration. As I have explained, of the programmes that I look after at the Big Lottery Fund, growing community assets is all about communities. I have said that our mission is to improve the lives of the most deprived communities.We have various programmes that operate at different levels. Living landmarks was a UK programme. I am not saying that it was not our problem, because we were part of that. It is great that we got a big programme such as that in Scotland and as part of a UK-wide programme. However, most of the funding that the Big Lottery Fund Scotland distributes in Scotland is based at community level. Under the growing community assets programme, only community organisations can apply for an award.
We support heritage projects. Our single largest grant in Scotland, which was £21.5 million, was to provide the new Riverside museum in Glasgow. That asset is owned and was built by Glasgow City Council. The project was managed and run by Glasgow Life—a separate, arm’s-length organisation that has some community representation on it. I do not think that another project has involved such a range of community consultation on the shape of the project and the opportunity for the local community to tell its stories through the project. That has been a good model for involving the community in a major capital project whose total cost was £80-something million. The community had a serious hand in influencing its content.
I call Stewart Stevenson.
My question is sort of a concluding one, convener. I do not know whether I am last.
No, you are not.
I think that the witnesses can answer my questions quite briefly. In the light of what we have heard, I will probe a bit the governance of your organisations and particularly the role of non-executives and board members. What is emerging, quite reasonably, is that the assessment is judgment based and relates to outcomes. Therefore, you must have the right people with the right experience and understanding to get the quality of judgment.Are you satisfied that the people who are coming forward to help you to do that job are sufficiently diverse? My use of the term “diverse” is broad brush; I am not talking purely about equalities. Do they have the necessary range of abilities? Are things getting better or worse? How important is the input of non-executives to the success or otherwise of your organisations? That question does not particularly apply to David Souter.
We have three tiers of decision makers. On applications for up to £100,000, I am the decision maker. The committee for Scotland decides on requests for up to £2 million. It is open to anyone to apply to be on the committee and a diverse range of interests is represented, although there tends to be a heritage component in virtually every committee member. We have one or two people who have been involved in planning and regeneration; someone who has been involved in tourism; someone who ran an urban regeneration company; and people who are familiar with our natural heritage—that tends to be the background. The decision making for requests for more than £2 million is done by our board of trustees, who are appointed by the Prime Minister. They have a range of interests in business and heritage.
My question was about not who the people are but whether you are content that you are getting the support that you need. I am inviting you not to criticise incumbents but to look ahead to the future.
We are content. In the small world in which we operate in Scotland, it is quite difficult to recruit committee members, but we have never had fewer applications than we have had places, so there is always a process of choice. We have good representation. As officers, we are happy that we have good support from our non-execs.10:45
Likewise, our Scotland committee members are ministerial appointments, so the question might be better put to the Scottish ministers. Are they happy with the people who apply? Some of our committee members leave office each year, so there is a turnover, and I understand that we have a good application rate for the vacancies. Speaking personally, I think that the committee has a good geographic spread that involves people from throughout Scotland, and other demographics are pretty well covered.
John Pentland wants to ask a question.
Is this the last question, convener?
No.
It is not the last question. Do you have a position on the increase in the price of a lottery ticket from £1 to £2?
That is a bit of an unfair question.
My thinking behind that has two aspects. First, could that increase have an impact on the future of regeneration? Secondly, Colin McLean said that 28p of every £1 goes to good causes. If the ticket price is increased to £2, will that become 56p?
My answer to your first question is that I do not have a view on that—that is the answer that you would expect from me. We are told that Camelot expects the price increase to raise additional revenue. That is the end of our statement on the matter.
Does Mr Samuel have anything to add?
No. I do not think that I can add anything.
I have a final question. Mr McLean mentioned townscape heritage initiatives, on which quite a lot of money has been spent in various parts of the country. Do you look at the practicalities of the changes that are made? I am thinking particularly about changes to utilities or a lack of change to utilities, which might mean that we invest quite a lot of money in an area but see no real improvement in utilities. That might lead quite quickly to the area being dug up again, which causes a lot of grief after the investment has been made.
By “utilities” do you mean the services that run beneath roads?
I mean gas, electricity and water.
Sadly, that is beyond my control. Our townscape heritage initiatives are all in designated conservation areas. Through its planning powers, the local authority can impose a number of constraints on how utility companies can behave, but we all know that that is far from perfect. It is a source of frustration for all of us if we invest in a conservation area—in our case, to improve its appearance and heritage—and then see it damaged by the utilities. However, I am afraid that that is outwith my control.
Should you discuss that before funding is allocated? I hate to see good money being spent on something that, to be frank, gets damaged quite quickly.
The areas first need to be designated conservation areas, and we are keen to encourage local authorities to use what in my time as a planner were called their article 4 powers to restrict permitted development. However, some of the utility companies’ activities are beyond the planning controls. Other than through our discussing such matters with the local authorities and ensuring that they exercise the controls that they have, I feel that what you ask about is a little beyond us.
I will offer an observation. The Scottish road works commissioner—I do not remember whether that is her exact title—has just levied her maximum possible fine of some £50,000 in relation to inappropriate digging up. There is a structure in Scotland through which to seek to control such works. It is quite widely admired internationally, although it is capable of improvement.
Regeneration is obviously a long-term process in many cases. Can we hear about your long-term strategies and how you intend to improve on what you are doing?
I mentioned that part of our strategy for the next programme period is to try to align the rural funding, the fisheries funding, the ESF and the ERDF. As I said, regeneration is not a specific thematic objective of the new programme, but a lot of activities in the programme could meet the wider definition of regeneration.The trick for us over the next year between now and the start of the new programme will be to identify the niche for structural funds instead of trying, as at the moment, to spread them across a lot of different activities. By identifying that, we can decide whether the funds are more appropriate to certain activities and less appropriate to others and we can start to declutter the landscape.
How will communities be involved in that long-term strategy? Groups tell us all the time that funding can be sporadic and that there can be a short-term outlook. Another frustration of mine is that we give money to something only to see it fail quite quickly, before it has had the opportunity to become self-sustaining.
If we can get the funds aligned correctly, one advantage will be an ability to give a long-term assurance that funding will be available for three or four years, with a review built in at that stage. Ideally, the programmes that we start with on day 1 will develop but not necessarily change over the period and we will be able to give partners that longer-term security.As for the benefits to communities, one of the advantages of working or leveraging funds through community planning partnerships is that community groups can directly access that funding instead of being required to build funding packages and then come to us.
You are being very optimistic if you think that that is happening. I urge you to look at the committee’s report on public service reform and see what we think about community planning partnerships.
As I have indicated, the current funding round will end in 2015. Before we launch a funding round, we always conduct a huge consultation exercise. In the previous one, which took place in 2010, our clients—or, if you like, our customers—told us that they wanted more consistency and, as you have suggested, they did not want us to chop and change the money that is available and what it is used for.Obviously, the position will all depend on what people tell us in the consultation, but I would expect a regeneration programme such as growing community assets to continue. We will learn the lessons from the five-year evaluation that has just finished, as I have said. Of course, aside from those lessons, the evaluation contains a lot of useful stuff for communities that are thinking about taking on such projects and we will ensure that that is disseminated as widely as possible.I think that there will also be consistency with growing community assets because of the proposed community empowerment and renewal bill and the land reform review group’s work on the same subject. Given that, it would make no sense whatever for us to take a funding source such as GCA away from the investment portfolio.
My response has two parts; the first relates to the Heritage Lottery Fund and the second goes a little wider than that.A strategic framework that we devised after a lot of consultation with our usual customers and the public has come up with the objective of making a lasting difference for heritage and people. We are allergic to the idea of funding projects that we might need to look at again in X years’ time, and the sustainability of our investments is a very big factor in our decision making. All our projects must have a people element—whether that be through running a range of activities; being involved in deciding what the project should be; deciding what should happen to the heritage assets in an area and how they should be run, managed or conserved; participating in training exercises; or running education programmes—and we think that heritage projects that involve people in that way are the best means of leaving a lasting legacy.In a wider sense, we are working through the Scottish lottery distributors forum with our colleagues in the Big Lottery Fund, Creative Scotland and sportscotland to define an area of Scotland where we plan to work together in a pilot project to see what we can do for that place. You will have to excuse me—we have not quite finished the process, so I cannot tell you where that area is or whether it will be a local authority area or more tightly defined. I hope that that pilot will teach us something about how we can work best with communities for the future.
Thank you very much for your evidence. I suspend for five minutes to allow a changeover of witnesses.10:54 Meeting suspended.
10:59 On resuming—
We move on to our second panel of witnesses, to discuss the role of community groups and the third sector in regeneration. I welcome Rory Dutton, development officer for the north with the Development Trusts Association Scotland; Angus Hardie, chief executive of the Scottish Community Alliance; Stuart Hashagen, senior community development adviser with the Scottish Community Development Centre and the community health exchange; and Andy Milne, chief executive of SURF-Scotland’s Independent Regeneration Network. Gentlemen, you are very welcome. Would you like to make any opening remarks?
I shall say a few words about the Scottish Community Development Centre. We have been established for about 20 years in two different organisational forms. We are here to promote and support community development across Scotland, and we see that as involving advising on policy areas, practice development and working directly with communities up and down Scotland.The things with which we have been associated include the training programme for the social inclusion partnerships, when we had them. We worked to co-ordinate the development of the national standards for community engagement and the VOICE—visioning outcomes in community engagement—programme, which is an online version of much the same thing. The community health exchange, which supports the network of community health organisations across Scotland, is based with us, as is the Scottish co-production network, which tries to encourage co-produced solutions to community problems with the national health service and other bodies.We also run two or three programmes directly in communities, one of which, health issues in the community, is a training programme for local community activists. Another programme, which is funded by the Big Lottery Fund, is called ACE—achieving community empowerment—and is a capacity building programme for a number of smaller community organisations. The other thing that I should mention is that we developed and have spent a lot of time with LEAP—learning, evaluation and planning—which is an outcome-focused planning and evaluation framework for all forms of participatory community activities. That gives you an idea of the range of things that we are involved in.
The Development Trusts Association Scotland, as the committee is probably aware, is the independent charitable membership body for community development trusts across Scotland. We have about 200 member development trusts. We are run by volunteers from our member development trusts and we have been around for about 10 years. Our role is very much to support community anchor organisations and to help them establish and develop projects and, in the long term, become more financially and organisationally sustainable. We also deliver a contract for the Scottish Government on asset transfer from local authorities to community groups.I should add that our director, Ian Cooke, apologises, as he is not available to attend today’s meeting.
Thank you for the opportunity to be here today and to speak. I have taken the liberty of circulating a bit of material, because there is a lot to be said about regeneration and I want to be brief.On the sheet entitled “Regeneration and Degeneration”, I have tried to illustrate in a diagram some of the measures that have been brought forward over the past 40 years or so to encourage more community regeneration. In the middle column, I talk about some of the degeneration factors. SURF tries to support all the organisations that are involved in the broad field of regeneration from the private and public sectors, such as housing associations, community groups and voluntary and heritage organisations, but in my view we do not talk often enough about the factors that cause degeneration in the first place, and there is an issue of scale between the two things that it might be worth the committee considering. In the green column, I have tried to indicate some of the big stuff in the background that, in SURF’s view, we do not normally directly link well enough with our aspirations to deliver regeneration in communities. Although there are some important smaller funds in the left-hand column, in the right-hand column members will see that there are substantial resources that SURF believes could, if intelligently and properly applied, make a much larger impact than they currently do in successful attempts to regenerate communities.I have also included in the pack a piece on our alliance for action programme, which SURF is undertaking to try to link up national resources with local initiatives, projects, knowledge and assets. That is a testing programme that the Scottish Government is supporting over the next two years, and I will say more about it later if members are interested. Lastly, there is a brochure from last year’s SURF awards—something that we do every year. All the information is online on the SURF website, which highlights more than 100 short-listed projects over six years. In that, you will see the range of work that SURF does to support regeneration around sustainable places, creativity, community-led regeneration, employment and infrastructure.I hope to try to answer some of the committee’s questions on ways in which it might be more possible to connect some of the big resources at hand with the very local challenges, assets and priorities that we have in community regeneration.
Any points that I would like to make at this stage are contained in the written evidence that I submitted, so I am happy to leave it there and take questions from the committee.
I will begin the questions. You heard some of the earlier questioning on funding and how some community groups find it difficult to deal with on-going revenue funding. They get the capital from one source or another, but the revenue funding often is not there. In your experience from the many roles that you undertake, is that situation normal or unusual? How can we help people to come up with business plans to ensure that the original investment can be sustained? Are we doing enough to ensure that we are capacity building, so that folks who take on voluntary roles, which can be a great burden, can do so with confidence and the necessary advice?
The short answer is yes, it is an issue for community organisations to maintain the revenue to keep the services that they offer going. As we have heard, most of the funding programmes are short term and time limited. Given that most situations in disadvantaged communities are not going to go away overnight, the community organisations that deal with those situations would do much better if they had a longer-term and continued funding stream, provided that they are doing the kind of work that is important in communities, such as alleviating poverty, addressing disadvantage and improving health. Because funding criteria change, because funding is unpredictable—often a lot of staff time is spent on applying for funding, rather than delivering services—and, as was mentioned earlier, because funding bodies like to invest in new ideas that may carry some risk, community organisations have to be innovative to achieve funding. There are many barriers to achieving the situation that, for most communities, would be ideal—namely, a longer-term stream of funding that they could use in the best possible way.
Do you think that those difficulties act as a demotivator for some who want to get involved in their community?
I am not sure. I think that most people get involved because they are angry or concerned about a local community issue, so that is the driver. When they get to the point at which they need funding to achieve the outcomes that they want, they discover the challenges. Most people get fired up to meet those challenges, but nevertheless there comes a point at which people might feel that they are never going to get funding and so they might lose motivation and energy.
Absolutely. Also, the issue is not just about revenue funding; it is about funding to create and establish the community vehicles that will take forward regeneration. In the more disadvantaged areas, where community anchor organisations or groups are not established, we find that more than just revenue funding is needed. Support and funding are needed to get those organisations up and running in the first place.I certainly agree that core funding is critical. It takes a lot of time to develop income streams and many anchor organisations are working hard to do so. Any business takes a long time to develop; there is a long period when core funding is absolutely essential while an organisation is trying to deliver for the community and also trying to develop income streams. We have seen that, when a voluntary group that is struggling gets core funding, it makes a big difference. A good example of that is Highlands and Islands Enterprise’s community account management programme, which involves LEADER funding. We are told that the recent evaluation of that has been extremely positive.Core funding is needed. The issue is not just about projects, although it is great to have the project funding that we talked about earlier, because a bit of core cost can be built in to cover that overhead, if you like. However, groups must consult their communities to find out what is really needed and to get appropriate developments. That work must be covered, as well as the work that is involved in finding out about all the funding, making applications, progressing initiatives, building partnerships and so on.
One thing that we have found as we have gone around the country, not only for this inquiry, is that a bit of seedcorn money can sometimes make a huge difference and that what is required is not a huge amount of resource, whether money or people, but a kick-start.Mr Dutton referred to the LEADER programme. Again, we have heard in places where we have been quite a lot of criticism of that programme and the amount of hoops that groups have to go through to access even very small amounts of money from it and other sources. What is your experience of that?
For the programme to which I referred, all the hoops are largely handled by the intermediary, which is Highlands and Islands Enterprise, and community groups simply employ development officers. The groups do not have the degree of administration that is involved in applying directly for LEADER funding, because an intermediary applies on their behalf. However, there is a big demand on community groups that are involved in LEADER-funded projects. The biggest issue with LEADER is to do with cash flow, because groups have to spend money and then seek reimbursement. That is a huge issue for organisations that have no capital reserves or regular incoming cash flow.
Rather than being overreliant on intermediaries, would it not be best to get rid of some of the hoops and declutter the processes that folk have to go through?
Yes, absolutely. We hope that the people and communities fund will provide core funding for community anchor organisations. In some local areas, community benefit funds come from things such as wind farms, and organisations can get funding for development officers. The problem is that a lot of the funding is for only one, two or three years. Regeneration is a long-term process that requires an organisation continually to develop and build on successive initiatives. There must be that continuum, which all the different funding programmes must key into.
Rory Dutton’s point about sustainability and sustained effort is important. If we look at the SURF awards booklet and at what has been allocated over the years, we can see that a lot of it is for the Highlands and Islands area. SURF is concerned with not only urban areas but the whole of Scotland. I would say that one reason for those successes is the sustained and settled approach that Highlands and Islands Enterprise has delivered in its area by connecting up people, place, economy, transport, technology and regeneration in a way that does not seem to have been possible in the denser urban setting in Scotland in which programmes, regimes and branding turn over every three or four years. I suggest that that is simply a reflection of the greater political temperature in the centre of Scotland as opposed to the more rural Highlands and Islands area. However, the issue of sustainability is key.We might want to ask what we are trying to achieve. There was a question earlier about addressing need, which is important. Ultimately, regeneration is about trying to address poverty and inequality. However, for the areas with the greatest difficulties, it may not always be possible to bring forward organisations that are already well equipped, well networked and well resourced to take on responsibilities. In the first place, we look for participation, which can take place in many forms—that is what we need to support. We must not assume that people will want to start by owning, running or managing an asset. We need to support people to be more actively involved in their community and grow capacity to make intelligent decisions as to what are assets and what are, in fact, liabilities. Sustainability is important, but so is not making assumptions that the endgame is community ownership.11:15
It is interesting that you used the term “regime”, Mr Milne. Do you use that terminology because you believe that too much is being done from the top down rather than from the bottom up?
Actually, to a degree, I think that not enough is being done from the top down. If we consider the right-hand column in my “Regeneration and Degeneration” paper, we see that the Scottish Government probably does not think enough about how its decisions on procurement, infrastructure and service targeting are most effectively engaged in so that they will benefit the communities that are in greatest need.There is a danger in shifting that major macroeconomic and social responsibility on to already fragile communities with a lack of capacity and, frankly, on to people who are trying to pay their bills and hold their families and communities together. To ask them to solve the macro problems that Governments at national, European and international levels have created and failed to address over decades seems to be a bit of an ask.We need to sort out the right level of intervention. Given my professional background, I am very much in favour of community-led regeneration and community ownership. However, I do not believe that they will deliver what we need to be delivered in the absence of effective action from the top through the allocation of much more substantial resources.
I think that we will come back to that issue in greater depth.
The absence of revenue support is the issue that we hear about most from communities, I think. We heard from the earlier panel of funders that a view just seems to have invaded the funders’ world that revenue is much harder to come by.Last week, when I was at a project in Rutherglen, we were reminiscing about the good old days of urban aid. With urban aid, it was possible to get revenue funding for five years, or seven years if an organisation was lucky and got extensions. With seven years’ revenue funding, an organisation really could do something. However, with a year’s funding, a body might just be getting to grips with the job and then it is in trouble. We have to rethink our attitude towards revenue funding and the balance between revenue and capital. We have constant debates on that with the Big Lottery Fund and others.Another aspect is about capacity and whether the most disadvantaged communities get their fair share of what is available. It is not just about the need to go in and build capacity, because we have been working on capacity building for a long time and in some regards it does not seem to work—or it does not seem to change the balance of who gets the cash when it is out there.Rory Dutton made an interesting point. There are ways of building capacity by investing directly in communities, which has been worked on for quite a while in the Highlands and Islands. Eric Samuel spoke about the our place approach, which seems encouraging, as it is about targeting communities that have missed out and saying that we will work with them until we can come up with a project that will gain traction in the community. We have to rethink our approach to building capacity in the communities that appear to need it the most.
One thing that a lot of other folk have talked about is education and investment in education in deprived communities. Should we be looking at that much more than is currently the case?
Do you mean in terms of mainstream education?
Yes.
I used to work in schools, and my experience of education, just over Arthur’s Seat in Craigmillar, was that the schools got a fair amount of the additional resources that were available from the council. However, the issue was more complex than what was going on in the school, and the project that I was working with was trying to make links between the home and the school and to raise the value of education within the home.
Was that the community schools formula?
Actually, it was a precursor of that. It was called the instep project, but it melded into the new community schools idea. The thing that surprised me when I was working in the schools, given that Craigmillar is one of the areas that had a lot of regeneration focus, was that the schools largely saw themselves as outwith that discussion on regeneration. It was a strange disconnect, because although that was the biggest physical and financial resource going into those communities, it did not seem to blend with the other money that was going in in the name of regeneration, capacity building or whatever. I always thought that that was anomalous.
That is an interesting but not unsurprising point.
Although it is a subject of some controversy, particularly in secondary schools, the curriculum for excellence regime is opening up interesting avenues in terms of how young people think about themselves as citizens and about their participation and creativity, and I see some hope in that.To take up Angus Hardie’s point, schools are often the centre of communities. They are where people meet to pick up their kids and chat about how things are, what is working and not working, problems with traffic and jobs and so on. They are hugely underused resources as community anchors and, over the years, as you will know, convener, there have been many efforts to create community schools that genuinely interact with the forces around them. There is tremendous potential both in the education process and in the schools as buildings and functioning hubs in communities, and we could do much more to link in with that.As Angus Hardie said, the ability of young people to have a positive educational experience and a positive general experience in their school is greatly affected by external financial, social and economic factors. We are doing some work at the moment with Children in Scotland to look specifically at the impact of those factors on the ability of headteachers in primary schools not just to sustain positive educational outcomes but to use that as the basis for greater interaction in the community. You are right, convener, to put your finger not just on the process of education but on the physical realisation of that process, in the form of schools, as being key to the potential for regeneration in some of the most disadvantaged areas where other so-called anchor organisations and other forms of capacity are currently missing.
I will take a question from Margaret Mitchell. We have been mentioning education and she is about to see some teachers.
It is not a related point, gentlemen. I thank you all for your submissions. My question is a general one. The committee has received evidence of successful individual community projects but, despite that, the statistics show that there is not a general improvement in deprived areas. From reading your submissions, I know that you all have ideas and suggestions about that, so I would like to go along the panel and find out why you think the situation is as it is and what can be done about it.
I absolutely agree that there are many examples of successful community initiatives. In fact, it is probably true to say that the wider world does not necessarily know how much has happened in many communities. There is probably a lack of public relations, marketing and communication of the positive gains that have been made, and that is an issue.Having said that, I come back to what Andy Milne said earlier when he asked what expectations there are for community projects to resolve big issues of poverty, disadvantage and lack of achievement. My view is that they are part of the mix, but are not the whole picture. It is important that communities can take action on issues of particular concern to them, but that alone will not change the deprivation statistics.I was at a meeting with members of a housing association last night and, although this is not firmly established evidence, it was suggested that the deprivation statistics for the areas where the association works appear to have become better over the period when the association has been playing a wider role in the local community regeneration strategy. That is hard to substantiate as lots of other things are going on, but the statistics seem to be better than they were—and that is in a very disadvantaged part of Glasgow.
You mention that“CPPs are seen ... as inter-agency planning vehicles instead of facilitators and enablers of neighbourhood work.”You suggest that, if CPPs were to“prioritise supporting engagement and capacity building”,they would be much more effective.
Absolutely. I mentioned the national standards for community engagement, which the then Scottish Executive commissioned. That was specifically to address the requirement in the Local Government in Scotland Act 2003 that local authorities should engage with community groups in setting up community planning. We came up with an interesting and agreed definition of community engagement, which meant that there should be a debate between public bodies and communities about what the needs, issues and opportunities are. Plans should then be set to achieve change through partnership between the various bodies.My view is that we need partnerships. We cannot leave everything to community organisations, and we cannot leave it all to government either. There needs to be an evolution of effective partnership work between communities and the people who provide services and support to them.
In this meeting
Everything on 26 Jun 2013 →- 09:30 Decision on Taking Business in Private Procedure · 1
- 09:30 Regeneration Evidence session · 273
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.