Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 17 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 7 February 2013 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 12 contributions · 2 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

12 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link


1. To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day.

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Today we have the fantastic news that the Lanarkshire life sciences facility BioCity Scotland, together with the Scottish universities life sciences alliance and the University of Dundee, has won a £100 million drug discovery contract. That means 40 highly skilled jobs in Newhouse immediately, with the promise of many more developments to come. That puts Scotland at the very centre of European drug discovery, and I know that that will be welcomed by the whole Parliament.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
Indeed.

Yesterday morning, the First Minister visited the technology company Clyde Space in Glasgow, where he said:

“This is one small satellite for Clyde and a giant leap for their extraterrestrial export business”.

In the afternoon, his back benchers applauded a £24 million cut in college budgets. Does the First Minister feel that he and his party are in touch with real Scots?

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
Scotland needs jobs. Last year, the Scottish Government said that it would spend £353 million on shovel-ready capital projects. In reality, it spent just £20 million. Of the £119 million that it said it would spend on new schools, it has spent nothing—not one coin. On Monday, however, the Deputy First Minister said that, within 15 months of the referendum, we could be like Namibia or Togo. Does the First Minister feel that he is in touch with the real priorities of Scots?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
The direct capital budget, from which shovel-ready projects are funded, is being cut by 26 per cent by the Westminster Government. The Westminster Government’s defence of that is that it is better than the 35 per cent cut that was the projected cut of Alistair Darling, the man who wanted to implement cuts that would be “deeper and tougher” than those of Margaret Thatcher.

The great advantage of direct capital spending by Government is that it can be spent on shovel-ready projects and can be spent quickly. The fact that Johann Lamont does not know the difference between direct Government spending and the non-profit distribution trust is a signal feature of the Labour Party’s inability to understand the basics of public finance. NPD funding is project based—we have to build a project and we have to gather in the finance. The great virtue of NPD is that it is a lot cheaper than the private finance initiative. We introduced the NPD programme because we did not want ever again to see the Scottish people pay out billions of pounds over the following 30 years on PFI projects, resulting in payments of many times their capital value. The fact that even the Conservative Party now admits that PFI was a ghastly mistake exposes the better together campaign as two right-wing parties competing over which one can be the more extreme.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
Even I, in my least charitable moments, did not imagine that the First Minister planned not to spend any money through the NPD programme on schools. It is not that I do not understand the project; it is that the First Minister said that the Government would spend the £119 million but has not spent one coin. The jobs have not come. The complacency is astonishing.

I ask the First Minister to come back with us to the real world. This morning, we spoke to Anne Fisher, a 50-year-old mother of three who has cancer. She lives in Greenock. If she lived in England, she would be receiving drugs that could prolong her life. However, because she lives in Scotland, she does not get that treatment. The Government’s delayed drugs review will be too late for Anne. Her case, sadly, is not an isolated one.

While Anne Fisher fights for treatment, the former health secretary Nicola Sturgeon had time this week to publish the words of Abraham Lincoln on, apparently, a written constitution. Does the First Minister believe that he and his Government are in touch with the real needs of people such as Anne Fisher?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
The whole area of access to drug treatments is an extremely serious issue and should be treated as such in the chamber. The Labour Party will remember that it agreed with us on not going down the road of a cancer drugs fund, and many of the cancer charities agreed with us on that aspect. Labour also welcomed the health secretary’s recent announcement on the introduction of the rare conditions medicine fund.

It should be accepted that, in trying to deal with these extraordinarily difficult issues, we are trying to find the best possible system that allows our people to have access to the best possible treatment. The idea that these issues are easy to deal with—as if they could be waved away—is extraordinary, given that they are one of the great challenges facing health services across the world. We believe that the combination that we have tried to arrive at in Scotland, where we have the Scottish Medicines Consortium, the newly introduced rare conditions medicine fund and individual patient treatment requests, is the best possible system that we can have at present, as we move to the new drug-pricing system.

I hope that, whatever view people across the chamber take, they will recognise that this Government, like all parties in the chamber, is trying to deal with that issue in the best possible way to help the greatest number of people.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
I can assure the First Minister that I take this issue extremely seriously. What I ask the Government to do is to listen to what people are saying and to act. It has taken newspaper headlines to get Alex Neil to act, and I think that that is a problem. Even now what the First Minister says does not address Anne Fisher’s problems, so I ask him to look again.

Whatever the First Minister is doing, he is certainly not addressing the real needs of Scots. He would rather play games, imagining where he might be in three years’ time, than face the reality of today. While he pretends, the needs of Scots seeking jobs are ignored, patients such as Anne Fisher go untreated and students miss out on a college education—all while the First Minister prepares the seating plan for our independence ball. The First Minister even seems to have given up on trying to make the case for independence and is instead trying to persuade Scots that they have already voted for it. When will the First Minister start addressing the real needs of Scots rather than continue his own game of let’s pretend?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
First, I remind Johann Lamont that the Labour Party voted with the Government not to establish a cancer drugs fund. Secondly, Alex Neil as health secretary took the advice that was coming forward in setting up the rare conditions medicine fund. Thirdly, the Routledge review is looking at this very issue to ensure that we have the best possible system in Scotland. That indicates to me that we are taking these things extremely seriously, as every member should.

This Government’s commitment to the national health service is, in my view, beyond argument. We are the party that in two successive elections promised to increase funding to the national health service; Johann Lamont leads a party that in two successive elections would not give that commitment. Therefore, on the national health service, which like all public services is under great pressure at present, it should be remembered that it is because of this Government’s success in being re-elected that the national health service revenue budget is increasing in real terms. There has been no guarantee on that from anyone else.

The difficulty for the Labour Party in making political points about the national health service was well exemplified only yesterday by the extraordinary and dreadful revelations about Mid Staffordshire NHS Foundation Trust. Those things occurred not when Margaret Thatcher was Prime Minister or under the Tory-Liberal coalition but under Labour’s watch.

According to page 19 of the inquiry report,

“Management thinking during the period under review was dominated by financial pressures and achieving”

Foundation Trust

“status, to the detriment of quality of care”.

I submit to Johann Lamont that this Government’s decision to have a properly integrated national health service, instead of one that competes internally and is on the road to privatisation—which was started by the Labour Party south of the border—is vindicated by events in both Scotland and England.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
The First Minister accuses me of making a political point and then goes on to do precisely that in complacent defence of what is happening in the national health service. All I ask is that he understands that the people of this country are not talking about constitutional platforms—they want a First Minister who will address the needs of women such as Anne Fisher now.

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
The fact that in the House of Commons I voted against foundation hospitals and the Labour Party voted for them is something that is worthy of political debate.

Johann Lamont says that she does not like constitutional politics, and she worries that the SNP’s attention is devoted to constitutional politics. I have been doing a bit of analysis on the questions that Johann Lamont has asked me. What is the number 1 subject that she has asked me about at First Minister’s questions? Is it the economy, the health service or education? No—it is Scottish independence.

The woman who accuses this Government of being obsessed by independence comes along here and invariably asks about Scottish independence. Johann Lamont asks about Scottish independence because the Labour record on everything else is so lamentable. I enjoy her asking about Scottish independence because it is only by accessing the resources—human and material—of this nation that we can put to rights not only the public services but the economy of this country.

  1. Railway Network (Access for Disabled People) Questions · 10
  2. Credit Unions Questions · 9
  3. Gaelic-medium Schools Questions · 4
  4. Consumer Focus (Abolition) Questions · 4
  5. Scottish Local Authorities Remuneration Committee Questions · 6
  6. Green Deal Questions · 4
  7. Transport System (Integration) Questions · 6
  8. Year of Natural Scotland Questions · 8
  9. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 12
  10. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 16
  11. Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  12. Fishing Fleet (Mackerel Quota) First Minister’s Questions · 6
  13. Victims Surcharge on Offenders First Minister’s Questions · 7
  14. Hospital-acquired Infections First Minister’s Questions · 8
  15. Retail Sector Members’ business · 7
  16. Local Government Finance (Scotland) Order 2013 [Draft] Debate · 65
  17. Debt Arrangement Scheme Debate · 33
  18. Parliamentary Bureau Motion Business motions · 2
  19. Decision Time Decision time · 9

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.