Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 18 Nov 2026

Official Report · Chamber

Engagements

First Minister’s Question Time

Thursday 10 January 2013 Meeting of the Parliament First Minister’s Questions 12 contributions · 3 speakers Watch on Scottish Parliament TV

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

12 contributions
Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link


1. I wish everyone all the best in 2013.

To ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01090)

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Presiding Officer, with your permission I would like to pay tribute to Jimmy Halliday, the former chairman of the Scottish National Party, who sadly passed away last Thursday.

Jimmy Halliday led the SNP in the 1950s, when we had two candidates in the general election, and in his career he laid the foundations for the subsequent expansion of the party and the success that we have enjoyed more recently. His funeral is taking place in around an hour’s time, in Dundee. Although many of us cannot be there in person, I am sure that all members on these benches—indeed, members across the chamber—will wish to send our thoughts and condolences to Jimmy’s wife, Olive, and the wider family.

Later today I have meetings to take forward the Government’s programme for Scotland.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
I thank the First Minister for that and of course we, too, would wish to send condolences to Jimmy Halliday’s family.

In the first week after summer recess, the First Minister moved his deputy, Nicola Sturgeon, from health and put her in charge of the referendum and economic recovery. Four months later, it is becoming increasing clear why she was so keen to move on: a children’s ward threatened with closure at St John’s in Livingston, Borders general put at risk, surgery provision cut at Perth royal infirmary, the scandal of hidden waiting lists at NHS Lothian and beyond, and people with terminal illnesses being denied life-prolonging drugs that are available in other parts of the country.

Nicola Sturgeon proclaims herself “the yes minister”. Can we start calling Alex Neil the clean-up-the-mess minister?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
That is a cheery start to the new year. As I remember it, when Nicola Sturgeon, the Deputy First Minister, moved, many voices across the chamber were saying how excellent she had been as the health secretary—even Jackie Baillie moved herself to say so. I admit that that was in contrast to what had been said before, but nonetheless that was the general tenor, so I do not accept Johann Lamont’s revisionist view of Nicola Sturgeon’s term as health secretary.

Let us look at some of the great successes of the health service. This Government has protected the front-line national health service budget and delivered record £11.6 billion resources, which would not have been guaranteed if we had had the misfortune of the Labour Party in office. We put patients and their safety first, which is why I suspect that the thing that really matters—public confidence and patient confidence in the NHS in Scotland—is at a very high level indeed.

I could also mention that, as I understand it, this party seems almost to be alone in this chamber in wanting to maintain an NHS that is free at the point of need. [Interruption.] As I understand it, prescription charges are part of the Labour cuts commission. That is perhaps another reason why the SNP Government’s record on the health service is so warmly supported by the Scottish people.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
Perhaps the First Minister might not have been so fulsome in his praise of Nicola Sturgeon when she moved if he had realised what we are hearing now about what is happening in the health service. There is a real-terms cut and whatever the First Minister says about free prescriptions, we know that that service is under phenomenal pressure. His denial of that is a denial of his responsibility as the First Minister of this country.

No matter what gloss the First Minister wants to put on it, on November 7, the Auditor General for Scotland, Caroline Gardner, put our health service on “amber warning.” When I challenged the First Minister about that, he said that the

“national health service is performing in outstanding fashion”.—[Official Report, 8 November 2012; c 13224.]

However, the Audit Scotland report highlighted Nicola Sturgeon’s real legacy to the health service: a £1 billion repair backlog, health boards having to borrow to keep services up and running—[Interruption.] That is what the Auditor General said, not what I said. There have also been thousands of staffing cuts, which have left us with fewer nurses than we had when the SNP came to power.

Given the new revelations on a daily basis about the mess that Nicola Sturgeon has left the Scottish health service in, does the First Minister still think that the Auditor General is wrong?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I think that Johann Lamont is wrong, not the Auditor General. She is wrong in a range of ways but I notice in particular that she has now revised her previous claim, which she made on 4 September last year, that there were fewer staff in the health service than there were when I became First Minister. That is what she said in the Official Report on 4 September. In fact, in June 2012, there were 130,363 full-time equivalents in the health service compared with 127,000 in September 2006. There are actually more staff in the health service than there were when the Scottish National Party took office, which is probably why Johann Lamont has not sought to repeat that claim. No doubt we will get a correction some time.

Let us assume that it will be difficult to convince Jackie Baillie, who said that Scotland was the centre of hospital-acquired infections just when such infections were dramatically declining in Scotland, and others on the Labour benches of the excellence of the work of the people in the national health service. I think that, instead of that invalidation of their work, what really matters is the satisfaction rate among the people, which has been recorded not by the Government but in the Scottish household survey. According to the survey, 88 per cent of people—up from 81 per cent in 2007—were satisfied with their local health services. That satisfaction ratio is not just at a high level but significantly higher than when the SNP took office. I somehow think that the verdict of the people of Scotland is somewhat more impartial than the verdict of the Labour Party benches; after all, was it not the verdict of the people of Scotland that has this Government in office and the Labour Party in opposition?

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
First of all, the First Minister says that he thinks that I am wrong. I work on the assumption that the First Minister thinks that I am wrong; the problem for him is that the Auditor General is saying something very serious and he is saying that that is wrong. Staff across Scotland are raising concerns about the pressures that they are under in the national health service. This is not an attack on staff, who are doing a phenomenal job; the charge is that this Government is not supporting them, which is making their job more difficult.

It seems that every week we get another damning report on the health service. In 2008, Nicola Sturgeon said that she had

“made tackling health inequalities”

her

“top priority”.

However, the Auditor General, Caroline Gardner, told the Public Audit Committee that, in terms of life expectancy,

“the gap is still increasing.”—[Official Report, Public Audit Committee, 19 December 2012; c 1050.]

The chief medical officer, Dr Harry Burns, has also acknowledged the lack of progress in tackling health inequalities under this Government. Now we are told that we are having a rethink of the approach to health inequalities. Is that an admission that Nicola Sturgeon and the SNP have completely failed to deliver their top health target?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
Health inequalities are a huge issue for the Scottish people. The reason that Harry Burns made that point—

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
I heard the comment that the SNP had done nothing. As Harry Burns indicated, the SNP made the tackling of health inequalities and facing up to that situation, which incidentally has been with us for a generation or more in Scotland, one of the Government’s top priorities.

I say gently to the Labour Party that a range of measures is directed towards improving the health of the Scottish people, one—and only one—of the most important of which relates to our attitude to alcohol. Our attempt to introduce minimum pricing would have a significant effect on improving the health of the Scottish people. If the Labour Party had shown rather more enthusiasm for it, its claims about the national health service might have slightly more credibility.

Members across the chamber would do well to remember that certain things such as health inequalities in Scotland and the whole approach to having a national health service free at the point of need should unite people in this chamber and should be joint objectives for it.

Nicola Sturgeon made the issue a key objective of Government policy and we will continue to pursue it. We know the task that has to be done and we know the measures—we also know that no measures will yield immediate short-term gains. However, the issue unites the Scottish Parliament because it is of huge importance to the Scottish people.

Johann Lamont Lab Glasgow Pollok
link
The problem for the First Minister is that saying it does not make it so. The difficulty for the First Minister is that we understand the challenge of health inequalities. We understand the challenge of inequality across our communities. The challenge in government is to test what the Government does and what it spends against the outcomes. When I said that, the First Minister said, “No, we will not have that debate at all.”

The fact is that Nicola Sturgeon was health secretary for five years. In the 127 days since she left office, her successor has had to deal with review after review. He has had to deal with a review into the full extent of the hidden waiting lists in health boards across the country, although Nicola Sturgeon had told us that NHS Lothian was an isolated case. He has had to deal with a review of access to groundbreaking drugs for people who are terminally ill, because under Nicola Sturgeon we went from being the best in the United Kingdom to the worst on that issue. He has had to deal with a review of health inequalities and the resuscitation of a task force, five years after Nicola Sturgeon made the issue her top priority.

How many reviews do we need? How many independent reports do we need before the First Minister realises that his Government is failing to deliver for the health of the people of Scotland?

Alex Salmond SNP The First Minister · Aberdeenshire East
link
There is a range of corrections that I could make. I point out that it was Nicola Sturgeon who established the review into waiting lists across Scotland. Of course, the fact that we were prepared to establish the review and do something about the issue puts us in stark contrast with the Labour Party, given that hidden waiting lists were institutionalised in Labour Party policy.

Johann Lamont talked about the difference between saying something and doing something. We said that we would protect the health service budget and we have done that. We have delivered in full on the manifesto commitment to pass on the Barnett consequentials arising from the United Kingdom 2010 comprehensive spending review, which means that there will be a record £11.6 billion resource budget for Scotland in 2014-15. We are doing exactly what we said that we would do.

In sharp contrast, the Labour Party would not give a commitment to protect the health service budget. In the famous interview on “Newsnight”, Iain Gray refused to say that the health service budget would be ring fenced in Scotland. We said that that would be a key priority of public spending in Scotland and we delivered that. We did exactly what we said in the election that we would do. That is why the Scottish people trust this party with the national health service and our other vital public services in Scotland.

Motions, questions and votes

Linked from this item of the Official Report
  1. Fuel Poverty (Public Health Implications) Questions · 4
  2. Scottish Court Service (Meetings) Questions · 9
  3. National Health Service Boards (Meetings) Questions · 6
  4. Prisons (Child-friendly Visiting Times) Questions · 7
  5. Grassroots Football Questions · 6
  6. NHS Fife (Meetings) Questions · 4
  7. Scottish Literature (Promotion in Schools, Colleges and Universities) Questions · 4
  8. Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 12
  9. Prime Minister (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 11
  10. Child Benefit First Minister’s Questions · 4
  11. “Scotland’s place in the Renewable Energy World” First Minister’s Questions · 4
  12. Police Service of Scotland First Minister’s Questions · 10
  13. Tourism (CNN Poll) First Minister’s Questions · 8
  14. Mergers and Acquisitions Members’ business · 8
  15. Youth Employment Debate · 96
  16. Parliamentary Bureau Motions Business motions · 2
  17. Decision Time Decision time · 9

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.