The Secretary of State for Transport’s announcement yesterday on the proposed extension of high-speed rail to Manchester and Leeds is supported by analysis that suggests that £3 billion of economic benefits to Scotland will be delivered after that line is completed in 2033. That is based on figures from High Speed Two (HS2) Ltd. However, our ambition is to have a full high-speed connection that links both Glasgow and Edinburgh with London and other cities throughout the United Kingdom. Our analysis is that a full network will deliver economic benefits worth £24 billion to Scotland.
The HS2 analysis also shows that other areas of Britain will benefit more from HS2 and will benefit sooner. It shows that the West Midlands and the north-west will both see more than twice the economic benefits that will be delivered to Scotland. That is why we are pressing the UK Government for joint work towards Scotland’s inclusion in a full UK high-speed rail network, and we will work with the UK Government to achieve that.
The minister clearly shares the view of the Scottish Chambers of Commerce and our municipal leaders that Scotland cannot afford to be marginalised by its exclusion from this multibillion-pound investment. If Scotland remains part of the UK, Scottish taxpayers will be expected to contribute a proportionate £3 billion-plus in construction costs. Does the minister agree that the UK Government is adding insult to injury through Scotland paying towards increasing the competitiveness of English cities at the expense of our economy? What does he think of the comments by the Tory MP Michael Fabricant yesterday on Radio 4’s “The World at One”? He said:
“This is a long-term project anyway. Eventually HS2—and we do need a new line going from north to south—isn’t going to be completed right up to Scotland until 2050, 2060”.
Keith BrownSNPThe Minister for Transport and Veterans · Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
The last thing that I want to do is act as somebody who can interpret the comments of Michael Fabricant. I will leave that to others who are better qualified than I am.
Kenneth Gibson makes a very good point about the benefits and the cost to Scotland. It will be interesting to see, for example, the treatment of consequentials from the expenditure that the UK Government incurs on the project.
Kenneth Gibson’s other point about the benefits that will accrue is relevant when we think of previous experience. For example, everyone expected that the bulk of the benefits from the line between Madrid and Seville would accrue to Seville but, in fact, they accrued to an even greater extent to the larger and more populous capital. London and England will also benefit greatly from the high-speed link coming all the way to Scotland, and that is what we are trying to achieve.
By 2033, Manchester to London journey times will be almost halved, whereas the improvement from Glasgow might be only 12 per cent—it is not really a case of better together, is it? If HS2 is not to be extended to Scotland in the foreseeable future—like the Tories, the previous UK Government had no such plans—will the minister demand additional resources to upgrade and enhance the Scottish rail network to help to end the growing economic imbalance between the northern half of the UK and the south-east of England?
Keith BrownSNPThe Minister for Transport and Veterans · Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
I have already commented on consequentials, which we will bear in mind. We would, of course, much rather see a commitment from the UK Government to extending the high-speed rail link right through to Scotland, and I do not believe that the door is closed on that. Very positive statements have been made by the Prime Minister and the Secretary of State for Transport, which were perhaps not borne out by last week’s announcement.
We will continue to push the UK Government. We believe that we can work with it to ensure that we get those benefits. That would be the best way to spend the money. We have shown our bona fides in the cabinet secretary’s statement that we will push ahead with the high-speed rail link from Edinburgh to Glasgow. We want the UK Government to come with us so that we can deliver a high-speed rail network that will deliver benefits to the whole of the UK.
Does the minister agree that the construction of the high-speed rail line should start in the south and the north of England at the same time to speed up the network coming to Scotland? Can he explain how on earth making that case would be assisted by breaking up the United Kingdom?
Keith BrownSNPThe Minister for Transport and Veterans · Clackmannanshire and Dunblane
Richard Baker mentioned the north of England, but we have said to the UK Government that we are happy to start at this end now. In constructing the Borders railway, we are not starting at one end and going to the other—we are starting at both ends and trying to push ahead as fast as possible.
We are trying to work constructively with the UK Government. Although we are not content with its position so far, it certainly moves ahead of the position that the Labour Party took. It had no commitment at all to bringing the high-speed rail link to Scotland. At least we have moved on from that position, and I am confident that we can make further progress.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.