I welcome everyone to the second meeting in 2013 of the Justice Sub-Committee on Policing, and I ask everyone to switch off completely their mobile phones and other electronic devices, as they interfere with the broadcasting system even when they are switched to silent. There are no apologies.
Official Report · Committee
Work Programme
Speakers
Showing Christine Grahame only · show everyone- Christine Grahame SNP 33
- Graeme Pearson Lab 15
- John Finnie Ind 10
- Kevin Stewart SNP 5
- Margaret Mitchell Con 5
- Alison McInnes LD 4
Christine Grahame’s contributions
33 contributionsYour point is on the record. We can certainly write to the SPA to indicate our concern that that is not a good start—and there have been faltering starts before that, as well.
The only item on our agenda is consideration of our approach to developing a work programme. We had an initial discussion last week and agreed to hold an evidence session with the Scottish Police Authority and the chief constable. Unfortunately, it was not possible to arrange that session for this week—in fairness, we asked at quite short notice. We therefore have time today—it says in my brief that we have “plenty of time”; I do not know who wrote that—to have a full discussion on the way forward for the sub-committee.The paper from the clerks provides background information on the Police and Fire Reform (Scotland) Act 2012 and highlights current issues relating to police reform, with which you are probably familiar. We can have six meetings before the summer recess, so it would be useful to consider how we want to approach the meetings. There are a couple of options in the paper. For example, we could hold a series of evidence sessions with the main police bodies, to establish particular areas of work to undertake. Alternatively, we could prioritise a couple of issues and invite relevant witnesses to give evidence on those issues.I think that it will be best if I just go round the table asking members to give their views in turn. Of course, you are welcome to give more general views on the sub-committee’s way forward and the types of work you think that it should do. Graeme Pearson, let us start with you, because you are sitting next to me.
I am afraid that there must be a typo there, because paragraph 25 says,“HMICS published its plan for 2013-14 on 8 March”,so the plan has already been published.
That is not your mistake.
That part of the paper was a bit misleading.
I would have said that that is the SPA’s job. It would be our job to see whether the SPA has done it.
I agree, but we do not need to do the SPA’s job for it. Graeme Pearson agrees with me. That is really what the SPA ought to be doing; whether it does it is another matter. We would keep an eye on both—
You are right. I do not dispute that.
Righty-ho.
It is a great list—there is nothing wrong with it. Our first meeting after recess is on 18 April. I suggest that, having gone through the various things on the list, we write to the SPA and the police service of Scotland and ask them to comment on the progress that has been made on all the issues that we have raised. We should do that prior to our next meeting. How long would that give us, given that it includes the recess? It means that we will be able to focus on something. We do not want to have a scattergun effect. Having got those responses, do we want just to discuss them? We could ask the SPA and the police service of Scotland in to speak to their responses.
I am not unhappy about that, although it is still useful to list the areas that we will be addressing. We could ask for a progress report from both of the bodies that I mentioned. DCC Fitzpatrick was very interesting. As local policing seems to be one of the main issues, she could be our first witness. However, we would still have the other paper before us, with the responses, and be able to pick things out of it.
We need to narrow down the issues.
We can do that. That is absolutely fine. We will focus on local policing arrangements, accountability and the local police plans.
I do not think that they would think that for one minute, but you have that on the record anyway. Of course, this is a public meeting, so people can look at the Official Report.Our time is limited, so we must be focused. Our next meeting will be only an hour or so. I would be interested in having a general discussion on visits. As the Justice Committee members know from our prison visits, there is sometimes nothing to beat them—you just get a feel for things. How do members feel about visits? How would we factor them into what is a crowded day and week for members? I want to leave Mondays and Fridays free for constituency business. We cannot start encroaching on that. However, if we were given dispensation not to attend chamber business, we could do a visit in an afternoon. The clerk is giving me one of those looks, but it might be possible for some of us to go on visits then.There was a suggestion that we visit somewhere, although I cannot remember what Kevin Stewart said.
It would be good to get out as part of the process. Do members want the visits to be additional to the regular one-hour meeting that we will have every two weeks, at least initially to see how it flows?
Right—that is grand.
Shall we set something in train right away? What do members suggest?
I will be guided by members.
Would you then support such a visit?
What about the specialist crime division?
Can we have a couple of ideas? I do not know what the business is for the week after recess, but perhaps we could do a visit then.
Let me get this clear. We know the way forward on the other part—we will have the Official Report and we are going to highlight certain issues on which we want to focus, such as local policing and accountability. At our next meeting, we will probably have DCC Rose Fitzpatrick along. She and DCC Iain Livingstone recently gave an extremely interesting presentation, particularly on the specialist crime division. We will also try to visit Gartcosh or forensics during that week. Where are forensics located?
So we will find a place and visit it that week, if we can fix that.
We will do that even if not all members can make it. It will be a fact-finding visit, so we will try to get as many members as possible freed up that day to go on the visit. That is a good idea.
You are never insensitive, Graeme. You are so subtle all the time.
I think that DCC Fitzpatrick will work that out if she comes before us. We are in an odd position with the short scrutiny sessions, so it will be useful to let local government members and the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities know what we are doing. We cannot have them along to respond, but they should listen in and perhaps feed back to us. We should let COSLA and other interested parties know when we call people to give evidence. The Justice Committee can always return if any big issue arises.
I would like to hear what is said and then hear the response. There is no harm in telling COSLA what we are doing and it might feed us some questions. We will do both. I think that that will be fair.
We follow the usual timetable so the papers are normally out on a Monday. We get them on a Monday and we do not sit until the Thursday. I know that that does not sound like a lot of time, but it is what we usually have. Interruption. I am getting my ear bent by the clerk—I love this system—so I can tell you that, if the papers are ready on a Friday, we will make a special effort for you. You might be a slow reader—we do not know.
To make it clear, the visits would be on an afternoon during chamber time. Depending on what we need, they would be an hour or a couple of hours. We do not always have to be in the chamber for every debate but, obviously, we will let the business managers know of our plans; we have a business manager sitting here. We can let the business managers know that if they do not factor in a debate on justice, local government or equal opportunities for that afternoon, that would be quite handy.
Yes.
It is also helpful to go somewhere collectively and come back with the same information and experience and reflect collectively on the visit. We all pick up stuff from our constituencies as we go along, so there is nothing to stop people doing that. I am content with the meeting; we have not done too badly. Not every meeting will be as short; I was aiming for 1.45 pm and it is 1.39 pm, which is not too bad. I will conclude the meeting unless there is anything else.
I do indeed. Thank you very much, Graeme. You always have the last word.Meeting closed at 13:39.
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.