Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 12 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Budget Process

Wednesday 5 April 2000 Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee Committee business 113 contributions · 14 speakers

Speakers

Choose an MSP to read only their contributions

The record

113 contributions
John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

Item 1 is the budget process. Members will be familiar with the Public Finance and Accountability (Scotland) Act 2000, which provides an important place for committees in the consideration of departmental budgets as part of the Executive's overall budget. Late last week, we were circulated with extracts relating to enterprise and lifelong learning of the proposed budget document that will be issued by the Minister for Finance. We have also received documents on local government and European funds because they touch on some issues that relate to the policy area in which the committee is interested. The officials who are here to give evidence will respond to points about the enterprise and lifelong learning department material only.I invite Stephen Woodhouse from the finance team of the enterprise and lifelong learning department to introduce his colleagues and to make any appropriate introductory remarks.

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

Thank you, convener.I am Stephen Woodhouse; I am a finance team leader with responsibility for enterprise and lifelong learning. To my left is Colin Reeves, who is head of the further and adult education division. Next to him is Wilson Malone, who is head of the investment assistance division.On my right is David Wilson, who is head of the enterprise network and tourism division and Graeme Dickson, who is head of the higher education, science and student support division.The document before the committee is an extract from a departmental report that shows the proposed budget for enterprise and lifelong learning. The figures are based on the comprehensive spending review of a couple of years ago. They have been adjusted for the decisions that were made following the publication of the Executive's programme for government document. There have also been some subsequent technical adjustments between programmes.The figures break down the expenditure to what we consider to be meaningful and discrete chunks, such as expenditure on Scottish Enterprise, further education, the Scottish Higher Education Funding Council and so on. We have included more detail to facilitate understanding of the figures.The budget document that was approved by Parliament contains information that is not included in the tables in the document. The document includes only information on expenditure that is within the departmental expenditure limit. Some cash sums are not included, in particular student loans.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

Thank you.Our discussion this morning will be on points of fact and detail. We will leave officials to indicate whether it is appropriate for them to respond to questions on policy issues.On the documents that we have been shown, page 37 indicates that the budget for 2000-01 is £2.001 billion. The table on the following page indicates a total of £1.88 billion. Can you explain the difference between the figures?

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

That is because the copy you have is a printer's proof—the first figure that you mention is wrong.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

The figure should be £1.88 billion—that clears up the issue of the missing millions.You said that the figures in table 3.1 take account of decisions based on the comprehensive spending review. What account do the figures take of decisions that have been made by the Executive in the past few months on, for example, student finance?

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

The figures do not include any adjustments that are based on decisions relating to the advice of the Cubie committee.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

Are there any other aspects of policy change since the start of the parliamentary year that are not spelt out in the balance of expenditure that is indicated?

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

Yes. The recent announcement by Mr McLeish on additional money for tourism—£5 million for Ossian—is not included. That will be included in a supplementary report later in the year.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

Are you in a position to tell the committee how the Executive will decide where the money will come from that will be required to implement the Cubie committee recommendations and the tourism strategy? How will the committee be advised of any proposed changes to the expenditure proposals that have been set out by the Executive in the document before us?

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

We will put advice to ministers on where the money to fund Cubie might come from. Ultimately, the decision will be for ministers and I imagine that Mr McLeish will report to the committee on how that decision was made.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

What is the likely time scale for that? To put that in a wider context, the information that we have does not take into account the changes to public expenditure that were announced by the Chancellor of the Exchequer in his budget a few weeks ago. Reallocations will also be required to take account of the circumstances that you mentioned regarding Cubie and tourism. When are the figures likely to become clear?

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

Ministers have yet to decide how to deal with the proposals that arose from the budget. I hope that that will happen in the next couple of months.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

Okay. I will broaden the questioning out to other members.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

Thank you, convener.My question concerns the presentation of the figures. Am I right in saying that—apart from one table at the end—the papers show the figures in cash terms, rather than real terms?

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

They show the figures in cash terms, with the exception of student loans; that figure is shown in resource accounting terms.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

So the figures do not take account of the effect of inflation?

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

To the extent that—. Yes.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

Could the figures be presented in real terms, showing the effect of inflation?

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

At level III?

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

Yes; we could do that.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

That would be helpful in allowing us to make a comparison of the real value of money, year on year, on each budget line. That is much appreciated.

Elaine Thomson Lab Aberdeen North
link

A set of objectives is shown alongside each table. I assume that those are your key performance indicators.Stephen Woodhouse indicated agreement.

Elaine Thomson Lab Aberdeen North
link

Are those objectives, or KPIs, new or on-going? Do you—or will you—report your progress against those objectives somewhere?

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

They are a mixture of old and new. Some come from the programme for government; others existed beforehand. The majority will be reported elsewhere, in more detail. For example, the Scottish Tourist Board will report its objectives in its annual report. Similarly, Scottish Enterprise will include its performance in its annual report, as will the Scottish Higher Education Funding Council.

Nick Johnston Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

On table 3.11, page 45, what has happened to the £36 million that is shown as unallocated in 1999-2000? Has it been subsumed in the figures for the next years, or is it in a pot elsewhere, which we can access?

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

Most of it has been subsumed in meeting commitments in the current financial year and the following year. Table 3.11 shows that the amount that is unallocated for 2001-02 is £1.1 million.That money is being used to meet rising commitments. We are trying to carry it forward into each future year, so that it can be used—

Nick Johnston Con Mid Scotland and Fife
link

So the real amount of money that has come out of the Scottish budget in 2000-01 and 2001-02 is reduced by £36 million, because that sum was unallocated reserves from prior years?

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

It has been reallocated into those future years. Yes.

Allan Wilson Lab Cunninghame North
link

That was one of my questions. The other relates to level III, table 3.10, and regional selective assistance. There seems to be a planned reduction of £10 million; that is reversed in the second projected year, which shows a planned increase to £84 million. The explanatory note says that RSA is "demand led". Does the 2001 figure reflect a lack of demand? As I believe RSA should be extended and probably increased, I would be interested to learn whether that figure reflects lack of demand or a policy change.What proportion of the value of RSA grants is made in support of inward investment projects as opposed to indigenous investment? Is that proportion liable to change?

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

The figure is lower for 2000-01 because we had money for the Hyundai project; we moved that money to the following year because we did not think that we would need it this year.Wilson Malone can probably answer your other questions.

Wilson Malone Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

Indigenous firms typically account for 80 per cent of RSA offers that we issue and about 40 per cent of the spend. To put it the other way round, inward investors get about 60 per cent of the spend. You could characterise that differently by saying that big projects account for 60 per cent of spend and that, largely, inward investors have the big projects.I do not foresee a significant change in that proportion.

Allan Wilson Lab Cunninghame North
link

I take that point, but would a significant increase in allocations to inward investment have an adverse effect on your ability to meet indigenous companies' demand for RSA?

Wilson Malone Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

Yes, in theory, but that has never happened. We have always managed to meet our obligations to both.

Annabel Goldie Con West of Scotland
link

I am looking at the funding of Scottish higher education and trying to reconcile tables 3.3 and 3.19. Apart from the fact that the latter is in real terms, there seems to be quite a disparity in the baseline figures. Is there a straightforward explanation for that?

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

Are you looking at the difference for 2001 between £609.4 million and the real-terms figure of £581.5 million?

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

I assume that that is the impact of inflation. Is that right?

Graeme Dickson Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

I think that it is because of inflation. Both tables show £531.9 million for 1998-99, but for 1999-2000 it looks as if the effect of inflation has been taken into account in table 3.19 but not in table 3.3.

Annabel Goldie Con West of Scotland
link

So is inflation the explanation for the disparity? I am looking at 2001-02. In table 3.3 we have £641.6 million, but in real terms—in table 3.19—the figure drops to £597.2 million. I am sorry; I am a novice at these things, and I find it—

Graeme Dickson Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

I am sorry too; this is the first time we have seen the figures, so it is difficult to talk about them without doing some mental arithmetic.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

The difference between cash terms and real terms—if my anorak mind is correct—should be simply the effect of inflation. If it is not, there may be wider issues.

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

Yes. The base year is 1998-99, so by the time we get to 2001-02, the effect of inflation is that much greater and it would deflate the numbers—

Annabel Goldie Con West of Scotland
link

So there is a cumulative component in the figures?

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

Yes.

Annabel Goldie Con West of Scotland
link

What rate is inflation worked out at? Do you project an out-turn rate for inflation?

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

We have gross domestic product deflators, which the Treasury provides. We apply them to each year.

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

I am happy to go back and check the figures.

Annabel Goldie Con West of Scotland
link

I would be grateful if you would. My next question concerns the fact that what is set down in the document is not what actually reaches our higher education institutions. I have already raised that point with the First Minister in the chamber. Is there any dialogue between the department and the Scottish Higher Education Funding Council about the final release of funds?

Graeme Dickson Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

We provide the funding council with a guidance letter and a grant offer letter every year. SHEFC's grant for financial year 2000-01 is £609 million, as shown in the table. It is up to the council to decide how the grant is allocated to individual institutions, because under the Further and Higher Education (Scotland) Act 1992 the Executive is prevented from directing the council toward any individual institution or course.In this year's grant offer letter, specific initiatives were included for part-time fees, funding for research infrastructure, commercialising research and decommissioning the former reactor owned by Glasgow, Edinburgh and Strathclyde universities. That adds up to about £10 million. Apart from that, it is up to the council to decide how it disperses the remaining money to the universities.

Annabel Goldie Con West of Scotland
link

Is it within the domain of your department to engage in dialogue with higher education institutions and listen to their representations about the council's final allocation? That may not be on a pleading-hard-cases basis; if money is being top-sliced by SHEFC for whatever reason, all higher education institutions have to make pre-emptive bids at short notice.

Graeme Dickson Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

Yes, in this case we have done, and not just at official level. The university principals made the same point to Henry McLeish.

George Lyon LD Argyll and Bute
link

You will be required to pay student tuition fees for this coming year and the next number of years. Is that built in to the figures that we have in front of us? If so, how much will it cost in years 1, 2 and 3?

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

Table 3.2 shows a breakdown of expenditure by the Student Awards Agency for Scotland. The first line shows a combined figure for awards and fees. It does not take account of the changes following the Cubie report. I do not have to hand a split showing fees, but we can provide that for the committee.

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

Yes.

George Lyon LD Argyll and Bute
link

Are the fees paid directly to the Student Awards Agency, which then pays the universities?

Graeme Dickson Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

The addition to the Student Awards Agency that will be needed for 2000-01 is between £20 million and £27 million. The agency will pay the money directly to institutions on behalf of each student, irrespective of family income.

Annabel Goldie Con West of Scotland
link

In the interests of propriety, I should have stated that I am a member of the court of the University of Strathclyde, which is a declarable interest.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

We are beginning to get the message on that point.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfries
link

Like Annabel, I was confused by some of the figures for higher education. I do not find this report terribly useful. There is not enough detail and explanation in it. I presume that this is just a public document and wonder whether a more detailed analysis will be provided for the committee—it is difficult to get the necessary information. For example, I would be interested to know what is spent on science and research in Scotland; there is no way to find that information in this document.I am also interested in the rationale behind some of the judgments that have been made. For example, is the fact that, in real terms, funding for higher education is going down this financial year but will increase substantially the following year due to student numbers falling and being projected to be higher the following year? What is the rationale behind that? I also note that, in Highlands and Islands Enterprise, a decreasing sum is being allocated to developing skills. It seems a little odd, given our commitment to lifelong learning, that we are investing less in developing skills. The report is a bit confusing and provides insufficient information to let us analyse the situation.

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

Mr Dickson, would you like to deal with the point on higher education?

Graeme Dickson Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

Yes. One of the reasons the figures show a downturn in real terms this year is that the cash increase is understated. The main reason for that is that the figures for 1999-2000 include a specific allocation that was given to fund the new University of Edinburgh medical school buildings at Edinburgh royal infirmary and the Western general hospital. There will also be allocations for the next two years, but they are not shown in the forward plans because the money comes from the health department and is then transferred to the funding council. Until the building contractors for the new institutions have run their profile and worked out how much of the share is from the medical schools, the transfer cannot be made. That is one of the reasons. There is probably about another £10 million to go into the higher education budget this year. Other additions are not shown in a table that is based on such broad categories. For example, it does not take account of Open University funding in Scotland from this year and the change in designation of Bell College of Technology, which will move from one sector to another.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfries
link

So, to get to the point, this document is for public consumption. Will a more detailed breakdown be made available to the committee?

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

I think that we can provide a breakdown to the next level down, which I hope will answer some of your concerns.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

I understand that we will return to this matter later in the year, when some of the implications of the Cubie committee and the tourism budget will become clear. We will raise with ministers some of the points that Elaine Murray has made.

Marilyn Livingstone Lab Kirkcaldy
link

How much of the further education budget is ring-fenced? Last year, there was some ring-fencing for social inclusion. What are the targets for quantitative, as well as qualitative, measures? There was a change last year. Can you provide that information now, or will you provide it later?

Colin Reeves Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

The question is how much of the further education budget is ring-fenced for specific purposes. Mr McLeish issued the main letter of guidance to the funding council on 29 March. As with higher education, the council is given a large sum of money but a few items are ring-fenced for specific initiatives or purposes. It is essentially for the funding council to decide the breakdown between the money which—

Marilyn Livingstone Lab Kirkcaldy
link

I was asking a specific question. Last year there was an allocation for social inclusion to encourage colleges to recruit students who come from disadvantaged groups. What is that allocation this year?

Colin Reeves Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

I can provide that information to the committee later.

Elaine Thomson Lab Aberdeen North
link

I would like to ask one further question about objectives. Gender impact analysis was discussed at the Finance Committee yesterday. Is gender one of the criteria that you use to monitor objectives? None of your objectives mentions gender.

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

Some of the funding councils' more detailed objectives may use gender as a criterion, but I do not know.

Graeme Dickson Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

In higher education, student intake is broken down across socio-economic groups and by gender to measure improvements in the balance in socio-economic groups. The gender balance in higher education is already about 50-50.

Elaine Thomson Lab Aberdeen North
link

One of the objectives is to assist new business starts; the objective is 100,000 new businesses across Scotland by 2009. From what you have said, no data on gender is held on that. Would such data be of value?

David Wilson Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

That is one of the programme for Government targets. As far as I am aware, it is not being monitored or audited in terms of the gender of the director of the company. We can take back that suggestion.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

How is that number being monitored?

David Wilson Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

An overall assessment of the programme for government targets is going on. We will continue to monitor all the targets so that we have the statistical sources and information to ensure that we can monitor them over time. A similar exercise has been done for the social justice milestones.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

Is that framework in place?

David Wilson Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

It is in place for new businesses, about which there is good information. The information on each target varies; we have good information on some and are improving information on others. We have fairly good information on new businesses.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

Is there a framework that provides for monitoring all the indicators in the programme for government since that programme was published, for example—in respect of enterprise and lifelong learning—the number of modern apprenticeships, new exporters, or new starts in training?

David Wilson Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

Yes. That has been put in place.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

Could there be a year one report on the programme for government by September this year—one year after the programme was published—which would show the original target and progress towards it for each of those indicators?

David Wilson Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

I am not aware that any commitment has been made to do that. An exercise is under way to assess and monitor each target, as you would expect.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

Could you look at page 46 and the level II real-terms table—table 3.19—which includes figures for the estimated budgets for Scottish Enterprise and Highlands and Islands Enterprise. The budget for Scottish Enterprise for 1999-2000 is £368 million; that figure will rise to £402 million by 2001-2002, which represents an increase of 9 per cent over the two-year period. The figure for HIE falls from £64 million to £61.6 million, which represents a cut of 4 per cent. Can you explain that disparity of treatment?

David Wilson Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

The principal reason, which I mentioned earlier, was the Hyundai project. In effect, money was reallocated from 1999-2000 into 2001-2002. If you look along the line, you will see that the Scottish Enterprise budget has varied significantly. If you make the same comparison between 1998-1999 and 2001-2002, the Scottish Enterprise budget has gone up to some extent, but the difference is not as marked.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

Were those budget figures fixed before the announcement of redundancies at Barmac?

David Wilson Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

Yes.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

Will they be reviewed?

David Wilson Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

As you are probably aware, Highlands and Islands Enterprise has made representation to the department for additional funds; that is being considered.

Elaine Murray Lab Dumfries
link

Table 3.9 on page 43 is about tourism. You said earlier that the new money that has been announced for tourism is not included in the table; I appreciate that, but it would appear that the allocation for promotion and development of tourism is on the decrease, whereas the allocation for administration of tourism is on the increase. Is there an explanation for that—for example, is it connected with the development of Project Ossian?

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

Staffing for the development of Project Ossian is part of the reason. The change is primarily a reallocation; some staff who supported promotion and development activities have been moved into administration.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

If members have no further comments, I will make some concluding points.The 1999-2000 estimated outturn in real terms is shown on page 46. When does that figure become concrete?

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

It should be pretty concrete now. It is based on the appropriation accounts, which were published last August.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

That is the estimated figure.

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

I beg your pardon. The figures will become concrete in August.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

Before we take our next stab at the budget, which will happen once we know the impact of the Chancellor of the Exchequer's budget and the decisions on Cubie and tourism, will we have the 1999-2000 outturn figures?

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

Those figures do not become final, formally, until the National Audit Office sign them off. There should be almost-final drafts before that.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

I do not understand where table 3.11 fits into the department's total budget. I can see where every other budget line fits into table 3.1, but I cannot get table 3.11 to fit into that table. Perhaps I have found another printer's proof error.

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

It is another printer's proof error.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

So the other line in table 3.1 should tie in with table 3.11. Okay.In table 3.11, for the Scottish renewables obligation, the outturn figure for 1998-1999 is shown as £6.6 million. If my recollection of that budget line is correct, it has been £12.9 million per annum in cash terms since time immemorial. Why has it been £12.9 million for each of the three succeeding years, with an outturn figure of £6.6 million? Was that ever discussed?

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

It was. I think that there has been a third renewables order—at least that has been proposed, if it has not happened—so we have retained the provision to deal with the outcome of that order.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

The unallocated figure of £35.9 million, which we talked about earlier, is a figure within the 1999-2000 budget, for which there was no departmental home at the outset of the year. You are now budgeting much more up to the ceiling. Is it a contingency?

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

No. That figure arose partly from money not spent on Hyundai and partly from a large regional RSA claim that was expected to come in, but did not. We were able to carry the money forward to allow for those claims coming in in future years, or to meet other commitments.

Fergus Ewing SNP Inverness East, Nairn and Lochaber
link

The money not spent on Hyundai has been mentioned twice, in relation to the unallocated figure and the Scottish Enterprise figure. What was the total allocation for Hyundai? How much has been spent?

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

I will have to come back to you on that; I do not have the information with me.

Stephen Woodhouse Scottish Executive Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Department
link

Yes.

John Swinney SNP The Convener · North Tayside
link

We have to find out where Hyundai fits into the equation, because it is having an impact on our deliberations. It would be useful to have a note that set out exactly what has happened with the Hyundai allocation. We need to know its impact on the budget lines; it either has an impact on a number of budget lines, in which case we will have to consider how they add up, or it has an impact on only one budget line. We need to know the assumptions that have been made in reallocating money to future provision. That would get to the heart of some of our concerns.I thank the witnesses for their attendance. We will reconsider those issues in due course.

  1. Scottish Parliament Enterprise and Lifelong Learning Committee Wednesday 5 April 2000 (Morning) Committee business · 2
  2. Budget Process Committee business · 113
  3. Local Economic Development Committee business · 79

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.