1. For the last time in 2012, I ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01073)
Official Report · Chamber
Engagements
First Minister’s Question Time
Speakers
Choose an MSP to read only their contributions- Johann Lamont Lab 10
- Tricia Marwick 8
- Alex Salmond SNP 6
- John Swinney SNP 1
The record
25 contributions1. For the last time in 2012, I ask the First Minister what engagements he has planned for the rest of the day. (S4F-01073)
I am delighted to announce that I will be speaking to the Minister for Energy, Enterprise and Tourism, Fergus Ewing, who is at Nigg to announce that the Scottish company the Global Energy Group is to increase its workforce at the Nigg energy park by 50 per cent, which is 400 new jobs. The applications for those jobs will start today, which makes fantastic news for the re-industrialisation of the Cromarty area and is a great Christmas present for the Highlands of Scotland.
We on this side of the chamber always welcome good news in relation to opportunities for people to work. [Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
Over the past year, the First Minister has told us that he had legal advice on the European Union, when he had not; that college funding was going up, when he was cutting it; and that we would have a seat on the monetary policy committee of the Bank of England, when he had not even spoken to it. Which one of those answers was the most exact ever given to any Parliament anywhere? [Laughter.]
That is a bundle of laughs at Christmas, is it not? The ancient Mayan civilisation predicted that the end of the world will come tomorrow; Johann Lamont comes here and predicts it every single week. [Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
The First Minister has obviously not been attending the same First Minister’s question time as I have for the past year. [Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
I am, of course, ever an optimist about the First Minister’s reflecting at some point on the gap between what he says and what he does.
However, I think that we can all agree that this has been a tough year for everyone—money has been tight almost everywhere. Some of us might ask “What could we do with half a million pounds? Maybe 60 nurses or 40 teachers?” However, in Alex Salmond’s world, half a million pounds gets you five days watching golf in Chicago. What was the First Minister’s preferred foreign investment opportunity visit of the year? Was it his half a million pound trip to the Ryder cup or his trip to the pictures in California?
However, I think that we can all agree that this has been a tough year for everyone—money has been tight almost everywhere. Some of us might ask “What could we do with half a million pounds? Maybe 60 nurses or 40 teachers?” However, in Alex Salmond’s world, half a million pounds gets you five days watching golf in Chicago. What was the First Minister’s preferred foreign investment opportunity visit of the year? Was it his half a million pound trip to the Ryder cup or his trip to the pictures in California?
Promotion of Scotland is of huge importance. [Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
If I remember correctly, there were three direct jobs announcements as a result of the Scottish Enterprise and Scottish Government mission to Chicago. I know that Johann Lamont welcomes, as she has just told us, all those new jobs for Scotland.
It is worth reflecting that something that we should be cheered about at Christmas is that an Ernst & Young survey once again shows that Scotland is the top location for inward investment in these islands. Given that, and given that we even exceeded London this year, we must be doing something right in terms of promotion of Scotland abroad. So, perhaps—in the spirit of Christmas and unity that I know Johann Lamont is aspiring to—she will welcome if not the success of the Government, then the success of Scottish Enterprise and Scottish Development International in bringing those valuable new jobs to Scotland.
It is worth reflecting that something that we should be cheered about at Christmas is that an Ernst & Young survey once again shows that Scotland is the top location for inward investment in these islands. Given that, and given that we even exceeded London this year, we must be doing something right in terms of promotion of Scotland abroad. So, perhaps—in the spirit of Christmas and unity that I know Johann Lamont is aspiring to—she will welcome if not the success of the Government, then the success of Scottish Enterprise and Scottish Development International in bringing those valuable new jobs to Scotland.
I am not sure that the First Minister’s half a million pound trip to the Ryder cup was what brought those jobs to Scotland. If we were concerned about bringing jobs, perhaps we would not be attacking the very colleges that create the skills and, therefore, the opportunities for people.
Of course, the First Minister has moved this year—I am not talking about his proposed flit from Bute house to St Andrew’s tower. We may recall that when David Cameron called for talks on the referendum, the First Minister said that it was
“an extraordinary attempt to bully and intimidate Scotland”.
Then he signed the timetable and said that it was an “historic” moment. Who has been the First Minister’s favourite visitor to Edinburgh this year: is it David Cameron, or is it Rupert Murdoch coming round for a Tunnock’s teacake? Does he now regret not getting the Dalai Lama round for a caramel wafer?
Of course, the First Minister has moved this year—I am not talking about his proposed flit from Bute house to St Andrew’s tower. We may recall that when David Cameron called for talks on the referendum, the First Minister said that it was
“an extraordinary attempt to bully and intimidate Scotland”.
Then he signed the timetable and said that it was an “historic” moment. Who has been the First Minister’s favourite visitor to Edinburgh this year: is it David Cameron, or is it Rupert Murdoch coming round for a Tunnock’s teacake? Does he now regret not getting the Dalai Lama round for a caramel wafer?
I think that what would be a fundamental attack on Scotland’s colleges would be the imposition of tuition fees on the 26,000 students in our colleges who currently do not pay tuition fees.
I think that it was unwise of Johann Lamont to cite David Cameron. I have been looking at Prime Minister’s question time from yesterday. David Cameron attacked Ed Miliband for having
“the same old something-for-nothing culture that got us in this mess in the first place”—[Official Report, House of Commons, 19 December 2012; Vol 555, c 844.]
which directly reflects the “something for nothing” speech of Johann Lamont. After one year in office as the Labour Party leader in Scotland, she receives the ultimate accolade: she is quoted by the Tory Prime Minister, in support, in the House of Commons. What a disgrace.
I think that it was unwise of Johann Lamont to cite David Cameron. I have been looking at Prime Minister’s question time from yesterday. David Cameron attacked Ed Miliband for having
“the same old something-for-nothing culture that got us in this mess in the first place”—[Official Report, House of Commons, 19 December 2012; Vol 555, c 844.]
which directly reflects the “something for nothing” speech of Johann Lamont. After one year in office as the Labour Party leader in Scotland, she receives the ultimate accolade: she is quoted by the Tory Prime Minister, in support, in the House of Commons. What a disgrace.
Of course, the First Minister’s problem is that John Swinney wanted to have that debate. That is why he asked Campbell Christie to commission a report. That report said that we need to deal with competing demands.
The reality is that the price—which the First Minister denied—of his education choices is cuts in college places and our schools having a growing gap between the rich and the poor. He knows that; perhaps in the new year he will want to confront the reality of it.
However, we are now in the Christmas spirit. [Interruption.]
The reality is that the price—which the First Minister denied—of his education choices is cuts in college places and our schools having a growing gap between the rich and the poor. He knows that; perhaps in the new year he will want to confront the reality of it.
However, we are now in the Christmas spirit. [Interruption.]
John Swinney
SNP The Cabinet Secretary for Finance, Employment and Sustainable Growth · Perthshire North
link
“It says here.”
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order. Mr Swinney!
What I say does not need to be written down, because it is in my very heart. It is in my very heart, First Minister, because we are, of course, approaching Christmas. After such a historic year of success,
“in terms of the debate”—[Laughter.]—
I presume that the First Minister will want to hand out Christmas presents to his successful team. Perhaps there will be a congratulatory abacus and spell-checker for Mike Russell, a talking doll for John Swinney, so that he can learn what “dialogue” actually means, or even a shovel for Nicola Sturgeon so that she is always shovel-ready to clean up the First Minister’s next bit of mess. [Interruption.]
“in terms of the debate”—[Laughter.]—
I presume that the First Minister will want to hand out Christmas presents to his successful team. Perhaps there will be a congratulatory abacus and spell-checker for Mike Russell, a talking doll for John Swinney, so that he can learn what “dialogue” actually means, or even a shovel for Nicola Sturgeon so that she is always shovel-ready to clean up the First Minister’s next bit of mess. [Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
May I wish everyone in the chamber and everyone in the country a happy Christmas and a peaceful and more prosperous new year. [Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
In the First Minister’s case, may I wish him as good a year next year as he has had this year. [Interruption.]
Tricia Marwick
The Presiding Officer · Mid Fife and Glenrothes
link
Order.
I notice that Johann Lamont only becomes cheerful and gets in the Christmas spirit when she moves away from Paul Sinclair’s script and speaks from the heart. I advise much more of that over the next year.
Let us, however, celebrate something else today: let us celebrate the Universities and Colleges Admissions Service figures that have been released, which show a 1 per cent increase in students going to Scottish universities, compared with the 26,000 decline in English students going to English universities. Let us consider that both the college and the university funding positions in Scotland are hugely greater than those south of the border.
What part of the argument for imposing tuition fees on university students and on 26,000 college students would actually increase the numbers of students going to university or college? Cannot we look at the catastrophe south of the border and hope that all parties will maintain the commitment that they made in the chamber—by a huge majority—not to have up-front or back-end tuition fees in Scotland?
Just to check—in the Christmas spirit—that my memory was not playing tricks, I consulted the Scottish Labour website this very day. I advise members to consult it quickly, because it might be down by Christmas. It says—there is a picture of Johann Lamont—
“No up-front or back-end tuition fees for Scottish students”.
On the web, there are pictures of Jenny Marra, Lewis Macdonald and Richard Baker all signing the pledge against tuition fees. It bears a remarkable resemblance to the pledge that Nick Clegg signed before his party nosedived.
As we approach the coming year, let us hope that Johann Lamont will not relish the fact that she is cited by David Cameron in the new Tory-Labour alliance in Scotland, and that she will return to not just the roots of the Labour Party and the Scottish National Party but the Scottish tradition of free education, so that we can say with confidence to the students of Scotland—not just next year but for all time—that free education will be part of the Scottish tradition. That way we can pave a future for the people of Scotland—not just for Christmas, but for all time.
Let us, however, celebrate something else today: let us celebrate the Universities and Colleges Admissions Service figures that have been released, which show a 1 per cent increase in students going to Scottish universities, compared with the 26,000 decline in English students going to English universities. Let us consider that both the college and the university funding positions in Scotland are hugely greater than those south of the border.
What part of the argument for imposing tuition fees on university students and on 26,000 college students would actually increase the numbers of students going to university or college? Cannot we look at the catastrophe south of the border and hope that all parties will maintain the commitment that they made in the chamber—by a huge majority—not to have up-front or back-end tuition fees in Scotland?
Just to check—in the Christmas spirit—that my memory was not playing tricks, I consulted the Scottish Labour website this very day. I advise members to consult it quickly, because it might be down by Christmas. It says—there is a picture of Johann Lamont—
“No up-front or back-end tuition fees for Scottish students”.
On the web, there are pictures of Jenny Marra, Lewis Macdonald and Richard Baker all signing the pledge against tuition fees. It bears a remarkable resemblance to the pledge that Nick Clegg signed before his party nosedived.
As we approach the coming year, let us hope that Johann Lamont will not relish the fact that she is cited by David Cameron in the new Tory-Labour alliance in Scotland, and that she will return to not just the roots of the Labour Party and the Scottish National Party but the Scottish tradition of free education, so that we can say with confidence to the students of Scotland—not just next year but for all time—that free education will be part of the Scottish tradition. That way we can pave a future for the people of Scotland—not just for Christmas, but for all time.
Motions, questions and votes
Linked from this item of the Official ReportIn this meeting
Everything on 20 Dec 2012 →- General Question Time Questions · 2
- Highlands and Islands Superfast Broadband Pilot Questions · 4
- National Grid Connection (Renewables Installations) Questions · 4
- Disclosure Scotland Questions · 4
- Affordable Housing (Barnett Consequentials) Questions · 4
- Remploy (Discussions with United Kingdom Government) Questions · 4
- Third Don Crossing (Discussions with Aberdeen City Council) Questions · 6
- Domestic Abuse Courts Questions · 6
- RAF Leuchars (Multi-role Brigade Proposals) Questions · 4
- BBC Scotland (Job Losses) Questions · 6
- Engagements First Minister’s Questions · 25
- Secretary of State for Scotland (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 17
- Cabinet (Meetings) First Minister’s Questions · 6
- Alcohol (Minimum Unit Pricing) First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Homelessness First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Festive Season Industrial Action First Minister’s Questions · 4
- Clydesdale Bank Job Losses Members’ business · 10
- Waiting Times Audit Report Statement · 43
- Draft Budget 2013-14 Debate · 117
- Decision Time Decision time · 2
The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.