Parliament Workbench
Data: Official Report to 19 Nov 2026

Official Report · Committee

Additional Support for Learning

Tuesday 15 May 2012 Education and Culture Committee About 10:00 Evidence session 118 contributions · 12 speakers

Speakers

Showing Stewart Maxwell only · show everyone

Stewart Maxwell’s contributions

18 contributions
Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Good morning and welcome to the 15th meeting in 2012 of the Education and Culture Committee. I remind members and people in the public gallery that mobile phones should be switched off at all times. We have received apologies from Liz Smith, who is unable to be with us this morning.Our only item of business today is to take evidence on additional support for learning. The Scottish Government recently published its first annual report on progress that is being made in implementing the Education (Additional Support for Learning) (Scotland) Act 2004, as amended. Our discussion will focus on the main issues that arise from that report.The committee recently considered a petition from Enable Scotland—a member of which is among the witnesses today—that calls for better training for teachers and support staff on additional support. The committee agreed that some of the main themes that arise from that petition should also be discussed today.I welcome to the committee John Butcher, who is representing the Association of Directors of Education in Scotland, additional support for learning network—which is quite a title; Alan Jones, who is chair of the Scottish Division of Educational Psychology; Linda Whitmore, who is development officer for children and young people at Enable Scotland; and Kristina Woolnough from the National Parent Forum of Scotland. Good morning to you all.I want to get straight to the questions, so I invite Marco Biagi to start us off.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

I certainly agree with you about jargon. It does not help that we all talk about ASL, IEPs, CSPs and BLTs. That was a joke, by the way.There is a serious point to be made here. Although people around the table may understand some of the phrases—perhaps not all of them—the fact remains that parents, in the main, do not. Mr Findlay has made a telling point.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

The assumption is that, since November 2010, children who are identified as looked after have all been assessed as having need of additional support for learning unless otherwise indicated, but only around four in 10 are recorded as receiving such support. Why is there a disparity between the assumption of 100 per cent—which, of course, would not be the case—and the actual figure of 40 per cent, given the very poor recorded outcomes for looked-after children?

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

There is no argument about that. That is not the question. The assumption should be that, since November 2010, all children who are identified as looked after will have additional support for learning needs unless otherwise identified.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

There may well be. Given that that is the case, why are only about 40 per cent recorded as getting that additional support? That may be the correct figure, but it seems low given what we know about the educational outcomes for looked-after children.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

We might be talking at cross purposes here, but I will bring in Neil Findlay at this point.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Kristina Woolnough mentioned young people who were—in her words—going to secondary school “illiterate”, so I want to bring in Clare Adamson to ask about early intervention.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Are there any contrary views, or does anyone want to make additional comments?

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Clare Adamson has a brief—and I emphasise the word “brief”—supplementary question.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

I am not trying to inhibit your questioning, Clare. On you go.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

Thank you. You mentioned staff training, which I know that Neil Bibby wants to ask about.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

I am aware of the time, so I want to move on, unless Alan Jones has a very critical point.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

John Butcher wants to come in, but I ask him to make his point very brief.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

I am very aware of the time, but I will let in Neil Findlay.

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

I have a final quick question, to which I ask for quick responses. I will start with John Butcher, because he finished on a point about improvement. If you could do one thing to improve the legislation, what would it be?

Stewart Maxwell SNP The Convener · West Scotland
link

I thank you all for your contributions. I am sure that the evidence has been fascinating for the whole committee.I said before the meeting started that we might write to the Government immediately after the meeting or after the Cabinet Secretary for Education and Lifelong Learning has given evidence. I do not know whether members’ views on that are clearer now. My view is that clear issues in the evidence that we heard include the need for clearer guidelines, which came up strongly, as well as training and variation across the country. That may cover most of the issues, unless members have other points on which they want us to write to the Government. We can ask the cabinet secretary about those matters when he appears before us.Meeting closed at 11:50.

The type of each item (debate, statement, questions, members’ business and so on) and the times shown are worked out by this site from headings, the chair’s opening words and the Official Report’s running timestamps. They are not the Parliament’s own classification. Text: the Scottish Parliament Official Report.