I pay tribute to the work of our clerk, Mark MacPherson. His organisational skills and general good humour made the visit extremely smooth and effortless. I also thank Allan Wilson for bringing me back to the purpose of the inquiry when I began to stray into the more interesting areas of Greenock life.We spent two days in Renfrewshire, which was a pleasure and extremely illuminating. We met providers of business support, such as the local enterprise company, the local authorities, the chambers of commerce and the enterprise trust. We also talked to consumers—the chambers of commerce are both providers and consumers—and businesses that had had contact with the local enterprise company and the local authorities. We visited National Semiconductor, although it is not particularly involved in business support. Our meetings gave us an overview of the way in which various agencies in an area can pull together in times of economic distress to make a concerted effort to bring people back into work. We also visited the Renfrewshire Education Business Partnership.I have tried, with Mark MacPherson's help, to summarise the visit in four parts. I will begin with the providers of services. All the organisations felt that a national economic strategy was urgently required and would help in the delivery of services. However, they emphasised that any national strategy must be flexible enough to support regional variations in requirements and must include schools and colleges. Most organisations recognised that consumers of services were interested not in strategies, but in the services available.On partnerships, organisations recognised that consumers of services could be confused by the range of services and service providers available—they had paid attention to our interim report on that matter. However, they felt that partnership was the way forward and that there was little point in reinventing the wheel. The chambers of commerce shared that view. Organisations admitted that closer working would be required to reduce duplication and overlap. Closer working would cover a wide range of issues, focusing particularly on agreeing shared objectives, goals and strategies, and on sharing information—databases of property, for example—best practice and benchmarking. Some of those initiatives would be more beneficial if the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities was also involved. We particularly noted that the local authority economic development agencies did not seem to have any part to play in promoting best practice, although COSLA is developing a model. The establishment of an integrated business centre, which is a particular factor in Inverclyde, was seen as an important step forward. It will house all LEC and local authority providers, providing a single gateway to assistance and support. The current business shop set-up is seen as useful, although ultimately it is only a signpost facility. Organisations recognise that the barriers that need to be overcome are the existing culture as well as features of accountability, control and funding. It is fair to note at this point that it became apparent that the integrated business centre was being pushed far more by the local authorities and the chambers of commerce than by the LEC. Some organisations have found that the LEC does not have people with the necessary experience to assist in all cases, particularly in relation to small business. On the availability of support, organisations recognise that the focus is on business start-up but believe that there may be a shortfall in the availability of continued support. Our attention was drawn to the withdrawal of support from organisations that had been in business for perhaps 18 months; in many cases, that left the organisations on their own. Some of those organisations are supposed to be referred to the local enterprise trust at 18 months, but that does not seem to be happening—support seems to stop short in some cases.There were some indications that the marketing of services and assistance could be improved. It was suggested that use should be made of companies that had benefited from the support available to promote services. We had a long discussion on the effectiveness of economic development services. Some organisations were concerned about the way in which service delivery could be measured—should targets be set and, if so, how would they be agreed? Targets would need to be sufficiently flexible to support local differences. We concluded that perhaps headline or framework performance indicators would be appropriate. Again, we gained the impression from the local authorities that COSLA was already doing some work on that. It will be interesting to draw out from COSLA the stage at which that work is. We found that the enterprise trust in Greenock was almost moribund. It is quite sad to note that, of the £90,000—in round figures—that it receives from the LEC, £55,000 is spent on its own administration, with only £35,000 being passed on to local businesses. I would not want to extrapolate from our experience with that enterprise trust that all enterprise trusts are the same. The Lanarkshire model was mentioned as an example in which the trusts are, in fact, business shops. However, that is not the case in Renfrewshire. We took somewhere in the region of 40 pages of notes, which I am distilling for the committee in this verbal report. Mark MacPherson has all the evidence and notes and I have papers to which members can refer, should specific detail be required. Although the chambers of commerce had no criticism of the LEC or the local authorities, admitting that the local economic forum was useful and that the integrated business centre was a good idea, they felt that the general structure of local development services would benefit from some reorganisation and reallocation of responsibility. They felt that they had an important role to play in providing businesses with a direct link to the top. To that end, they proposed to the committee that they be provided with a statutory responsibility in local economic strategy. They recognise that there is a cost involved in that proposal and I am not quite sure how much we would want to get involved in promoting that approach.The chambers of commerce were keen to emphasise that any changes should focus on making the current structure work better—again, the message that we should not reinvent the wheel came through strongly. Whatever the outcome of the various reviews and inquiries, the chambers of commerce felt that they had a key role to play, as they had close links with local businesses and already established forums, such as networking evenings or lunches. Perhaps it is no surprise that they made a strong pitch for their own organisations. The problems that the chambers of commerce identified in the current structure were the same as those identified by others—confusion, duplication, overlap, lack of expertise, lack of continued support and slow response times. They also identified the LEC's focus on specific areas as a problem—the LEC seems to be interested only in high growth, e-commerce and manufacturing. The chambers emphasised that the consumers of services are interested not in strategies, but in the end product. Many of the consumers of services—the businesses—complained that they did not know whom to approach, what services were provided or which services they could access. Most felt that a single gateway would be helpful. They were not previously aware of the integrated business centre, although they thought that it seemed to be a step in the right direction. We were advised that the integrated business centre was not due to open until April, although in practice it might not open until July. We may be in the early marketing stages of that enterprise. Consumers received various levels of support. Some had received extensive help from service providers, in the form of both advice and funding, particularly where an account manager system was used. Others felt that they had been pointed in the right direction by business shops and the first business initiative. However, some companies felt that the funding support was insufficient—the example that was given was of a company trying to break into export markets. Some felt that the continued support was not enough, as the focus was on business start-ups, with support falling off after 18 months or two years. Several consumers felt that the service providers lacked expertise and relevant experience. Some also felt that there was a lack of continuity—especially if the individual with whom they had been dealing left the service provider—and that the question of sharing expertise in other areas should be investigated. The turnover of staff in LECs and enterprise trusts may be a valid question for the committee to consider.Some consumers felt that there was far too much bureaucracy and control, which was thought to be discouraging and unhelpful. Some businesses believed that bureaucracy could result in both delays to assistance and missed opportunities. It was also suggested that, where a company's business was spread over several geographical areas, the company would have to deal with more than one provider, with the services offered in one area differing from those offered in another. Some companies suggested that providers focused too much on specific types of company—such as manufacturing, e-commerce and start-ups—often at the expense of others. I think that there is a gap in the provision of services for some types of businesses that could provide more employment. However, there are problems with transferring staff from one enterprise to another. In particular, retail businesses felt that the LEC was not terribly relevant to them. National Semiconductor represents a good example of various organisations in an area working together in a difficult situation. It is a prime example of partnerships working effectively, involving all the key players in sharing goals and objectives and in liaising to produce an overall strategy. I suggest that all members of the committee have a look at the further information that is available on that point. The work that had been done was particularly impressive. I was surprised at the way in which the work force was organised. There was a lot of short-time working—as short as three or four weeks in some cases. I was extremely impressed by Renfrewshire Education Business Partnership. It is well organised and demonstrates effective networking, particularly in its work with schools. Funding is provided by the LEC and private business in a ratio of 1:2. The funding from the LEC has been well used in levering private sector funds. The partnership's prime concern is to have access to information from the Executive. We were provided with extensive briefing packs, which we will make available to any member who wants to see them. In any inquiry, one does not always stick to the straight and narrow, however much one tries. There are a few things that I would like to mention to the committee; although they are not directly relevant to the inquiry, they are of general interest for economic development. Funding for economic development can be viewed as a soft target or as a non-statutory requirement for local authorities. Assurance of funding is crucial for effective forward planning. Not surprisingly, that view was expressed by the local authority development departments. I was impressed by one of them, which had been very proactive and had done some good work in Renfrewshire. The aspirations and attitudes of people entering or thinking of entering business are key. That is particularly true in cases where company owners are capable of expanding but have a comfortable lifestyle and so no incentive to take on further responsibility. That was conveyed by both service providers and consumers. The committee might want to consider what incentives are needed to encourage companies that have grown to a certain size to grow further. Should we provide incentives for companies to grow further? Some businesses seem to get to the size at which they are comfortable and no longer want to evolve. Location and infrastructure seem to be major factors. Accommodation and property were mentioned several times during our visit; there seems to be a lack of certain types of property in Renfrewshire. One business in the process of starting up had had superb help from the first business initiative, from the business shop and from the local economic development company. However, the main stumbling block had been with the installation of telephone lines by British Telecommunications; that had delayed the business for four months, which I found staggering. We received supplementary submissions from Renfrewshire Council, which provided examples of business support in action, and from the Paisley and District Chamber of Commerce, which had a proposal for a completely new structure. We also received copies of slides and an information pack from the Renfrewshire Education Business Partnership, and details of co-operation between National Semiconductors and Renfrewshire Enterprise. We have a copy of a letter from North Tyneside Council. It has been pointed out that we have not at any stage of this inquiry made comparative studies of similar situations in England and Wales—that might be worth considering. All in all, I found the visit very useful. I did not know Renfrewshire well, but now I feel that I know it a little better. Some of its problems are peculiar—if I stress anything in this report, it is that local problems definitely need local solutions and that there is no point trying to impose something from the centre when local people are already working well together.